Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, before the European Parliament, on the actions of the French Presidency of the Council of the European Union, notably the management of the Russo-Georgian conflict, the response to the international financial crisis, the energy-climate package, immigration policy, and community institutions, in Strasbourg on October 21, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

21 October 2008 · Statement before the European Parliament on the actions of the French Presidency of the Council of the European Union · European Parliament

Context
Sarkozy addressed the European Parliament in Strasbourg on October 21, 2008, reporting on France's EU Council Presidency actions including the Georgia conflict and financial crisis.
Main themes
French EU Council Presidency, Russo-Georgian conflict, international financial crisis, European unity, energy-climate package, immigration policy, EU institutional reform, European diplomacy, ceasefire mediation, Cold War prevention, EU-Russia relations, multilateralism
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,714
83rd percentile
Sentences
202
89th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 33%32%
  • Geopolitical 28%27%
  • Institutional 26%26%
  • Environmental 7%6%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

202 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

It is an honor for me to come once again before the European Parliament to report on the actions of the Council Presidency at such an important moment for Europe. If you will allow me, I will try to speak very freely, as is fitting in this chamber which is the heart of the democratic Europe we want.

What have we tried to build? First, the Presidency wanted the European institutions to be united in all the crises we have had to manage. I wanted the European Parliament to be involved at every moment of the major events we have experienced. I want to thank the presidents of your political groups, from all sides, who have engaged in dialogue and unity with the Council Presidency. I also wanted us to work hand in hand with the Commission, and particularly its President, because regardless of the divergences or differences among all those who sit here, everyone knows that division among the institutions of Europe weakens Europe, and that the duty of those who hold responsibilities is to work hand in hand. We will advance Europe if the European Parliament, the Commission, and the Council find a consensus on the major issues to make the voice of Europe heard.

This Europe, we wanted it to be united - which has not been simple - to have independent thinking - because the world needs the thinking of Europe - and to be proactive. If Europe has things to say, it should not just say them, it should act. First, we faced war with the disproportionate reaction of the Russians in the context of the Georgian conflict. Words have meaning. I use the word disproportionate because it is disproportionate to intervene as the Russians did in Georgia. But I use the word reaction because if this reaction was disproportionate, it is because there was inappropriate action beforehand. Europe must be just and should not hesitate to step outside ideological frameworks to carry a message of peace.

On August 8, the crisis broke out. On August 12, with Bernard KOUCHNER, we were in Moscow to obtain a ceasefire. I do not say that it was perfect; I simply say that in four days, Europe achieved a ceasefire. And at the beginning of September, Europe secured a commitment for a withdrawal to the lines before the start of the crisis on August 8. In two months, Europe achieved the end of a war and the withdrawal of occupying troops. There were several theses. Some said - and they had reasons to say so - that dialogue was useless and that the response to military action should be military: madness! Europe witnessed the fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of the Cold War. Europe must not be complicit in a new Cold War, suffered solely due to a lack of composure.

This was a problem we overcame with our American allies, who thought that the trip to Moscow was not timely. Nevertheless, we worked hand in hand with our American allies. They had a position that was not the same as ours. We tried to build collaboration rather than opposition. And frankly, given the state of the world today, I do not think it needs a crisis between Europe and Russia. That would be irresponsible. We can therefore defend our ideas on respect for sovereignty, on respect for the integrity of Georgia, on human rights, on the differences we have with those who lead Russia. But it would have been irresponsible to create the conditions for a confrontation that we do not need. Discussions have begun in Geneva on the future status of those Georgian territories known as South Ossetia and Abkhazia. I am told they are starting with difficulty. Who could imagine otherwise? But the important thing is that they have started. I must say, moreover, that President MEDVEDEV has honored the commitments he made before the Presidency of the Commission and the Presidency of the European Council when we went to Moscow at the beginning of September.

Europe has made peace. Europe has secured the withdrawal of an occupying army and Europe has sought international discussions. It seems to me that it has been a long time since Europe played such a role in a conflict of this nature. I naturally see all the ambiguities, all the shortcomings, all the compromises that had to be made. But in good conscience, I believe that we have achieved the maximum of what was possible and above all, Mr. President of the European Parliament, if Europe had not made the voice of dialogue and the voice of reason heard, who would have done it? When we left with Bernard KOUCHNER on August 12 for Moscow and Tbilisi, the Russians were 40 km from Tbilisi, and the objective was to overthrow Mr. SAKASHVILI's regime. That was the reality. We were a hair's breadth from catastrophe, but thanks to Europe, a determined Europe, that catastrophe did not occur, even if, of course, the road will be long for tensions to ease in that region of the world.

The second issue: the crisis. The incredible, unbelievable systemic financial crisis that began - let’s be clear - on September 15, not on August 7, 2007. On August 7, 2007, a serious, concerning crisis began, but - dare I say - a normal one. On September 15, 2008, we entered another crisis. What happened on September 15, 2008? It was the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers. And the stunned world discovered on September 15, 2008, that a bank could go bankrupt. It is not for us - and it is not for me - to judge what the American government did or did not do. I simply state, and I affirm, that on September 15, 2008, the serious crisis became a systemic crisis with the collapse of the American financial system, then the European financial system, and gradually other stock markets and financial systems. At that moment, what did we try to do? There was the Paulson I plan, which did not work. It is not criticism to say this; it is to describe a reality. And at that moment, with the President of the Commission, we tried to build a common European response, first in the eurozone. Mr. President, you mentioned it: whether one is for or against, it remains that in the zone, we have the same central bank, the same currency, thus a shared duty of unity.

Obtaining a common position was not simple. We first proposed a meeting of the four European countries that are members of the G8. It is no insult to anyone to say that the influence, for example, of the United Kingdom on the global financial system is greater than that of other countries among the 27. I thought that if we could get the English, Germans, Italians, and French to agree, it would not be against the other Europeans but in service of the other Europeans. Of course, there were different analyses, and who could blame us for that? Because in the early days of the crisis, we did not immediately know what the right response was to a crisis never seen in history, at least in the 20th century.

I thought after bringing together the four: it would be appropriate to gather the countries of the Eurogroup plus Slovakia, which will join us. And that week allowed us, together, to find the solution that consisted of allowing banks to do their job again: lending. But we found ourselves in a situation where banks were no longer lending to each other, had no money to lend, and the whole system was collapsing: nationalized banks in the United Kingdom, banks going bankrupt in Belgium, a system outside Europe but so close to Europe, in Iceland, that was collapsing, very bad news in Switzerland, and gradually, contagion, Germany, France, everyone was caught up in it. We succeeded, in the Eurogroup, in agreeing on a gigantic plan, 1,800 billion euros, to allow our financial institutions to do their work and to reassure European savers and entrepreneurs.

Then, we went to the European Council, which adopted the same strategy, and from that moment on, we were able to calm the markets in Europe. A pleasant surprise: the Paulson II plan arrived, and everyone could see that this Paulson II plan is largely inspired by the European plan. There is no glory to be taken from it. There is simply a need to reflect: the crisis is global, the response can only be global. The clocks of the United States and Europe must mark the same time.

But all of this is crisis management, Mr. President. It is nothing more than crisis management. It is not more. If we had not done it, what would have happened? But we still need to provide real answers. How could all this have been possible? How to prevent this from happening again? Does Europe have ideas to defend? A policy to propose? And it is in this context that, on behalf of Europe, at the United Nations General Assembly in early September, I proposed that we hold an international summit to lay the foundations for a new Bretton Woods, referencing what happened in the aftermath of the world war - the second - to establish a new global financial system. This idea is progressing. What should be Europe's objective in the context of this summit? Europe must advocate for a refoundation of global capitalism. What has happened is a betrayal of the values of capitalism. It is not a challenge to the market economy. No rules, the reward of speculators at the expense of entrepreneurs... We must advocate for a new regulation. Europe must propose these ideas, and it will.

First, that no bank benefiting from state money can work with tax havens. That no financial institution, Mr. President, can operate without being subject to financial regulation. That traders see their compensation system calculated and organized in a way that does not encourage reckless risk-taking, as we have seen. That the accounting rules of our banks do not reflect the severity of the crisis, but rather allow for its management. That the monetary system be rethought between fixed exchange rates. We have tried everything in the world. Can the rest of the world continue to bear the deficits of the world's leading power without having a say? The answer is clearly no. It is also pointless to designate a culprit. It is simply necessary to find the voices and means to ensure that this does not happen again.

And then, there are many other things to say, but I would especially like Europe to take a look at the global governance of the 21st century. Let us not be surprised that it does not work: we are in the 21st century and we have the institutions of the 20th. The President of the United States and the representatives of Europe have therefore proposed holding several summits starting in mid-November, which will focus on new regulation, new global governance. I hope that Europe can debate this. I will have the opportunity to propose to my partners, heads of state and government, a meeting to prepare for these summits. This question of the refoundation of our capitalism and our international system is a subject for the European Parliament that must debate it, that must carry these ideas. And Europe must speak with one voice to have a chance to be heard.

Who will participate in this summit? There are many schools of thought. The simplest is the G8, which is indisputable, with naturally the Russians, to which we should add the G5, which is also indisputable, which will allow us to associate China and India, in particular, with this essential debate. This will be the entire purpose, with President BARROSO, of the trip we are making to China to convince the Asian powers to participate in this refoundation.

Mr. President, there has been a third subject during this Presidency, which is extremely difficult, that of the future of the energy-climate package. I am fully aware that your assembly and some of your groups are divided on the way forward. Allow me to express my conviction and the policy I intend to propose. The ambitious energy-climate package is based on the conviction that the world is heading for catastrophe if it continues to produce under the same conditions. I do not see a single argument that could suggest that the world is better off environmentally because of the financial crisis. When we decided to embark on the energy-climate package, we did so aware of our responsibilities towards our children and the future of the planet. It is a structural policy. It is a historic policy. It would be disastrous to abandon this policy on the grounds that the financial crisis has occurred.

It would be dramatic and it would be irresponsible. Why irresponsible? Because Europe would send the signal that it is not determined to make the efforts it has promised in this area. And if Europe does not make these efforts, our chances of convincing the rest of the world that we need to preserve the planet's balances are nil. It would therefore not simply be Europe's resignation for itself, but a resignation in the face of the environmental challenge for the whole world. Because if Europe is not exemplary, it will not be heard, respected, or listened to. If Europe does not do this work, no one will do it for us. We will then have missed the appointment with history.

What does it mean to not be at the appointment? In my view, it means two things. The first is to go back on the "3 x 20" targets. And the second is to go back on the timeline, that is to say, the end of the year. And I obviously have no intention - in fact, I do not have the power or the will - to call into question anything regarding co-decision. But in this matter, we fought with President Barroso at the European Council to impose respect for the targets and to impose respect for the timeline. It was not easy.

We therefore have a few weeks to convince a number of our partners whose concerns I understand. One does not create the conditions for compromise without trying to understand what the one who disagrees with you is saying. There are certain economies that are 95% reliant on coal. We cannot ask them for things that would bring them to their knees when the difficulties are already immense. We will therefore need to find ways and means of flexibility, while respecting the two red lines that I proposed to the Council: respect for the targets, respect for the timeline.

I will have the opportunity, Mr. President, to explain this in more detail, but I do not want to abuse your patience.

A word on the fourth topic, the immigration pact, to say that I believe it is a fine example of European democracy: despite the initial differences, everyone was able to agree on a chosen immigration policy, coordinated with the countries of emigration so that we draw the consequences of Schengen, which concerns three-quarters of European countries. It is reasonable that countries that do not need visas to move from one to another establish a common framework of thought for a European immigration policy.

Two points remain and I will be finished.

The first is that the financial crisis is leading us to an economic crisis. This economic crisis is here. It is pointless to predict it since we are living it. I want to say, personally, knowing perfectly the disagreements between certain countries, that I cannot imagine being told that in the face of the financial crisis, a unified European response was needed and that in the face of the economic crisis, a similar unified European response is not needed.

A word on what unified means. Unified does not mean the same response. For the financial crisis, we proposed a toolbox, a roadmap, harmonization, coordination. I think that for economic policy, we will need the same thing. This does not mean that we will all do the same thing. But it does mean that we have at least the obligation to talk about it, the obligation to inform ourselves, and on certain subjects, the obligation to consult each other.

There are several avenues. Allow me to mention one idea. Stock markets are at historically low levels. I would not want European citizens, in a few months, to wake up discovering that European companies belong to non-European capital, which would have bought at the lowest stock prices, at bargain prices, taking ownership, and then European citizens would ask: what have you done? I ask that each of us reflect on the opportunity there might be to create, in each of our countries, sovereign funds and perhaps these national sovereign funds could, from time to time, coordinate to provide an industrial response to the crisis?

I also want to add that I have looked with great interest at the American plan for the automobile industry. 25 billion dollars at unbeatable interest rates to save the three American car manufacturers from bankruptcy. I would like us to pause for a moment on this subject in Europe. We are asking our manufacturers, and we are right, to now build clean cars, to completely change their production apparatus. In this regard, thanks to the ecological bonus, now 50% of the cars sold in my country are clean cars. Can we leave the European automobile industry in a situation of serious distortion of competition with its American competitors without raising the question of European sectoral policy to defend the European industry? This does not mean that we need to call into question the single market. This does not mean that we need to call into question the principle of competition. This does not mean that we need to call into question the principle of state aid. This means that Europe must provide a united response and a response that must not be naive, in the face of competition from other major regions of the world. Our duty is that in Europe, we can continue to build planes, boats, trains, and cars because Europe needs a powerful industry. On this policy, the Presidency will fight.

Finally, the last point: the institutions. Institutions are not the only European issue; we were wrong to focus too exclusively on this question. But institutions are an issue. I want to express my conviction that the crisis calls for reform of European institutions. The crisis calls for Europe to be able to provide a response as powerful and as rapid as any other global entity, as the United States was able to do in the face of the tragedy represented by the financial crisis.

I am one of those who believe that it would be a very serious mistake not to reform our institutions. Very serious, because to follow such complicated issues as Georgia, Russia, the financial crisis, the economic crisis, it does not seem very reasonable to have a rotating presidency every six months. Allow me to say that frankly, if we love Europe and if we want Europe to speak with one voice, it does not seem reasonable to consider that this should change every six months.

So we will have, with President Barroso, to build a roadmap for December, to see how we can respond to the Irish question. I fully intend, before leaving the Presidency of the Council, to propose this roadmap and to indicate consensually the ways and means to get out of it.

I want to add one last thing: it is not possible for the eurozone to continue without a clearly identified economic government. We can no longer continue like this. I want to pay tribute to the action of the ECB, I want to express my conviction that the ECB must be independent, but for the action of the ECB to find its full measure, it must be able to discuss with an economic government. That was the spirit of the treaty. The spirit of the treaty is dialogue, democracy, and mutual independence. And in my mind, the true economic government of the Eurogroup is a Eurogroup that meets at the level of heads of state and government. And what was my astonishment when I requested this meeting to find that it was the first time since the creation of the Euro that it took place. Frankly: we create a currency, we establish a central bank, we have a unique monetary policy, and we do not have an economic government worthy of the name.

The effort that consisted, Mr. Commissioner Almunia, in electing a President, finance ministers - I participated in the decision, I was myself finance minister at the time - is a salutary effort and I want to pay tribute to the action of Jean-Claude Juncker. But I want to say one thing: when the crisis takes on the proportions we know, the mere meeting of finance ministers is not commensurate with the gravity of the crisis. And when it was necessary to mobilize the sums we mobilized, it was necessary to mobilize not the treasurers but the heads of state and government, who alone have the democratic legitimacy to make such heavy decisions.

Ladies and gentlemen, there would be many other things to say. I would simply like to conclude by saying that for the world, we need a Europe that speaks with a strong voice.

This rests on your shoulders.

This rests on the shoulders of the Commission.

This rests on the shoulders of the Council, and I want to tell you all how useful it has been for the Presidency to feel, beyond the differences, the solidarity of a European Parliament that had analyzed the seriousness of the crisis from the very beginning and that was ready - and may you be honored for it - to put aside our differences in sensitivity to create the conditions for the unity of Europe. I wanted to say this because I believe it very deeply.

Thank you.