Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the reform of local authorities, in Paris on October 22, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

22 October 2008 · Launch of the Committee for the Reform of Local Authorities · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the newly established Committee for the Reform of Local Authorities in Paris on October 22, 2008, outlining the urgency of restructuring France's local government.
Main themes
Reform of local authorities, decentralization, local taxation, competency entanglement, local finances, administrative simplification, intercommunal cooperation, fiscal responsibility, territorial organization, public expenditure control
Duration
~15 min
53rd percentile
Words
1,852
53rd percentile
Sentences
89
57th percentile
Readability
35
26th percentile
Grade
13.3
60th percentile
Syntax
2.99
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
71st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 75%75%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

89 sentences in 49 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Committee for the Reform of Local Authorities,

Prime Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Just a few minutes ago, the Council of Ministers adopted the decree establishing the Committee for the Reform of Local Authorities.

I attach particular importance to this reform.

For 20 years, we have deepened decentralization, transferred many competencies, created new levels of administration, but we have given little thought to the deep structures of our local organization, changed almost nothing in local taxation, and allowed local finances to drift. This situation can no longer continue.

The task is of great difficulty, but no one can contest either the imperative necessity or the manifest urgency.

That is why I thank each member of the Committee for agreeing to participate in this work. These thanks are particularly directed, as everyone will understand, to the President of the Committee, Mr. Edouard Balladur, who bears a heavy responsibility, and to the political figures who do not belong to the presidential majority but who have placed the general interest above their party affiliations and have agreed to join us.

What is at stake?

The decentralization decided by François Mitterrand and implemented by Pierre Mauroy, whose presence on the Committee deeply pleases me, was a true revolution in our country. The daily lives of our fellow citizens have been significantly changed and improved. The centralizing tradition of our country has, for the first time, been challenged, to the greater good of democracy, the dynamism of local life, and the consideration of the diversity of our territories.

This legal revolution, which took place without even modifying the Constitution at the time, but also cultural, has not been questioned by a single government. On the contrary, all governments have sought to deepen it, from the 1992 law on the territorial administration of the Republic to the constitutional reform of 2003, including the law of February 4, 1995, on the orientation for the planning and development of the territory, dear Edouard Balladur, or the law on the strengthening and simplification of intercommunal cooperation of 1999. And it is a fact that throughout this period, decentralization has been endorsed by the French people.

Today, the French have a more nuanced view of our local organization. They continue to criticize Jacobin centralization, they persist in perceiving the state administration as too distant, insufficiently close to their concerns. But they are also increasingly critical of decentralization and the organization of local authorities.

They first find that the number of levels of local authorities is excessive. They are exasperated by the increase in local taxation and the rising costs of local authority operations. They criticize the entanglement of competencies, their multiple redundancies, and regret the absence of clear responsibilities.

The truth is that we all share these diagnostic elements.

We all know that our local authorities are too numerous and too small, that the real success of intercommunal cooperation has not put an end to the particularly high number of municipalities.

We all regret the confusion of competencies, the waste, and the dysfunctions that result from it.

We all believe that local taxation has become archaic and unjust, that the professional tax harms the economic attractiveness of France. But we are powerless to substitute it with another financing system that is dynamic, responsible, and virtuous, guaranteeing the financial autonomy of local authorities. The financing of local authorities does not sufficiently distinguish between state grants and local taxes. Today, the state accounts for a quarter of local taxation. The fiscal responsibility of local authorities is profoundly blurred.

Finally, we all know that restoring our financial balances is impossible without controlling local finances. Between 2000 and 2006, every year, 48,000 jobs were created in all local authorities, excluding transfers of competencies and personnel. In 2007, the increase in local authority expenditures amounted to 14 billion euros. All of this is not reasonable. Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen, it is time to face these issues.

The exercise is not easy, and everyone in this room knows it.

Conservatisms and special interests are numerous; the fear of change is real.

The French have ambivalent, if not contradictory, views on the subject. They regret the waste caused by too many administrative levels, but they are attached to their municipality, their department, their region, as they often are to their "country," these "countries" that sometimes correspond so deeply to the divisions of the Ancien Régime.

They want our public policies to be closer to the ground, to take more account of local specificities. But they are also strongly attached to the principle of equality, which has led us, for several years, to transfer to local authorities management competencies much more than real public policies.

In fact, the provisions of the constitutional law of 2003 concerning local authorities, which allow for local experiments, mergers of authorities, and the designation of lead entities, have remained almost unimplemented. In this regard, you will need to question this gap between the expectations placed in this text and its concrete achievements.

I myself have had the opportunity, on several occasions, to point out that France was not a blank slate, that our local organization reflects a long history, and that it is neither desirable nor even conceivable to sweep it away with a wave of the hand.

However, we can no longer continue to act as if our local administration posed no problems, as if France could, alone in Europe, maintain such a complex, entangled organization, which does not truly correspond to the spirit of decentralization, which is one of local freedom and responsibility.

The issue is not to decide on new transfers of competencies from the state to local authorities. Many transfers have been decided in recent years; it is now important to implement and evaluate them.

The issue is to reflect on the structures. In this context, essential questions must be addressed:

- the clarification of competencies, between local authorities of course, but also between the state and local authorities;

- the simplification of structures, at the communal and intercommunal level, as well as at the level of departments and regions;

- the financial resources of local authorities, and in particular the possible fiscal specialization of the different levels of authorities to ensure real accountability of each actor;

- the size of our authorities, in the context of increasing European competition, as well as the question of large metropolises, dear to Pierre Mauroy and Gérard Longuet;

- the diversification of solutions according to territories, I am thinking in particular of Île-de-France; you know the value I attach to the development of the capital region;

- finally, the question of local elected officials and the gap between the responsibilities they assume and the rewards, not only financial, that they derive from it, in a context where, unfortunately, there are fewer and fewer men and women willing to engage in the service of the community.

The sensitivity and complexity of these questions, the necessity to propose innovative, proactive, and bold solutions, required the establishment of a high-level Committee for reflection and proposals, composed in a pluralistic manner, with personalities of different experiences and profiles.

That is why I decided, Mr. President, to create this Committee. That is why I wanted to entrust you with its presidency. That is why I paid careful attention with you to its composition.

Alongside parliamentarians, I wanted the reflection to involve senior officials, jurists, and intellectuals, because the questions posed to your committee are both political and technical, engage the organization of the state itself, and delve into the historical and sociological roots of our country.

The Committee will naturally conduct hearings, particularly those of associations of elected officials. It will be assisted in its work by the major central directorates of the state, particularly the DGCL, the budget directorate, the tax legislation directorate, and the services of the Secretary of State for Overseas.

Parliamentarians have organized themselves to contribute as closely as possible to your reflection. Often local elected officials themselves, this contribution will be useful and valuable to the work of the Committee. It is all the more crucial since a good part of the proposals formulated by the Committee will need the approval of the national representation to be implemented - in the National Assembly, of course, as well as in the Senate, particularly in light of its role in ensuring the representation of local authorities, and I do not forget that it will be up to it, under Article 39 of the Constitution, to examine in the first instance some of the texts that may be adopted at the end of this work.

In no case is the proliferation of reflections a danger.

Provided, however, that these reflections support the work of the Committee, and do not compete with it, and that the debates within the Committee are truly open and free, otherwise the search for a synthesis beneficial to all would be impossible.

Allow me to insist: the French, our businesses, our local civil servants as well as our state civil servants, our country as a whole, expect a profound reform of our local organization. They want the structures to be simplified, the competencies to be clarified, the responsibilities to be identified, and local expenditures to be controlled.

This is a question of efficiency, but also of democracy. This requires that citizens know what their elected officials are truly accountable for, both financially and in terms of public policies. Your mission is to place the citizen and the local taxpayer at the heart of concerns.

Such a reform cannot succeed if good faith, objective analysis of the facts, the will to reform, and a keen sense of the general interest do not prevail over special interests. It is in this spirit that I ask each member of your Committee to work. And I consider myself, for my part, as the guarantor of the deep desire for reform expressed by the French.

Mr. President, on July 23, 2008, France adopted a deeply revised Constitution. The role you played in this reform was major.

It is time to extend to our local organization the principles that presided over the reform of July 23: those of exemplary democracy, an irreproachable Republic, a public life marked by clarity and responsibility, and governed by the general interest.

The financial crisis we are experiencing should not delay reforms in any way. On the contrary, it should accelerate them. More than ever, we must modernize our country. We need ambitious and innovative responses. I want to believe that the country is ready for it. I am convinced that the evolution of minds, both in public opinion and among elected officials, regardless of the political family to which they belong, can help us achieve this.

Each in our place, we will strive, I say this without emphasis, to be at the rendezvous of history and to meet the expectations of our fellow citizens. I have no doubt, Mr. President of the Committee for the Reform of Local Authorities, that you will show us the way, as you have always done.