Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, Mr. Thabo Mbeki, President of South Africa, and Mr. José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, on Euro-South African relations, the political situation in Zimbabwe, and negotiations within the WTO, in Bordeaux on July 25, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

25 July 2008 · Joint press conference on Euro-South African relations, the political situation in Zimbabwe, and negotiations within the WTO · Bordeaux, France

Context
Sarkozy, Mbeki, and Barroso held a joint press conference in Bordeaux on July 25, 2008, following the first EU-South Africa heads-of-state summit.
Main themes
EU-South Africa strategic partnership, Zimbabwe political crisis and mediation, WTO negotiations, food security and aid, climate change, Sudan and International Criminal Court, migration flows, bilateral relations, peace and democracy
Duration
~29 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,518
82nd percentile
Sentences
157
82nd percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
3.10
61st percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

157 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I would like to express how happy I am, as President of the European Council, to welcome today in Bordeaux President Thabo MBEKI, for whom I have great friendship, for the first summit at the level of Heads of State between the European Union and South Africa.

I am also very pleased to welcome my friend President BARROSO, since naturally the Presidency of the Union must be conducted in partnership with the Commission. I would like to acknowledge Commissioner Louis MICHEL, Minister Bernard KOUCHNER, and then the South African Ministers, Minister Jean-Louis BORLOO and Minister Alain JOYANDET.

South Africa is a great partner of the European Union. We have many common interests, we have significant convergences on most major issues. I want to first tell President MBEKI how committed Europe is to the fight against climate change to preserve the balances of the planet and that we have been able to observe great convergences between South Africa and the European Union. It is now South Africa and the European Union that, together, will fight and work for the balances of the planet. There are total convergences of view.

We have discussed the pressing issues of the moment. I am thinking of the question of Zimbabwe. I believe I can say—referring you to the statement that was prepared by the ministers, and I especially thank Bernard KOUCHNER—that there is an agreement to support the courageous mediation of President MBEKI. To give him a little time, and since we have recorded some progress that we welcome. But, as President of the Council, I must also express the horror that the images of violence following the first round elections last March have caused. And so, there is great European vigilance even if there is strong support from Europe for the mediation led by President MBEKI.

We also talked about Sudan and, by mutual agreement, I believe I can say that South Africa and the European Union call on Sudanese President BECHIR to take the necessary gestures and efforts so that the international community understands that he has received the message addressed to him by the International Criminal Court. I mean from the Attorney General.

I would also like to say that we discussed the issues of the WTO and we noted a great convergence of views. We talked about food issues and President BARROSO presented the Commission's proposal: an additional one billion euros in food aid. France supports this proposal with a willingness to redirect this aid towards everything related to agriculture and food production. I will therefore not comment on the statement you have at your disposal, but I believe I can say that, in a new form of summit, more informal, with fewer people, we have made significant progress in the strategic partnership between South Africa and the European Union. In any case, dear Thabo, for Jose Manuel and for me, at least for me as President of the Council and the first European summit I have to lead with a third country, it was an opportunity, a joy, and a chance to be able to do it with the President of South Africa.

MR. THABO MBEKI - Thank you very much, Mr. President. First of all, I would like to thank you for holding this first meeting, this first summit of the European Union - South Africa strategic partnership.

Yes, I completely agree with you, Mr. President. We have covered very major issues, very important within the framework of this partnership to try, indeed, to have common responses. I am delighted to hear you say that indeed the European Commission, under the presidency of Mr. BARROSO, has taken this initiative to make available one billion euros to help us combat this food crisis that we are experiencing, and we are very grateful for that. This is really about food that has a direct impact on the daily lives of our peoples. I hope everyone will applaud and support and rejoice in this great initiative that has been taken by the European Commission on such a crucial issue.

Mr. President, we also appreciate all the other issues addressed and the way we have approached them, which are very important. It is not just about the bilateral relations between the European Union and South Africa, which are doing very well, but other issues such as climate change, migration flows, food security, and the other issues you mentioned, Mr. President: Zimbabwe, Sudan, etc. And I am certain that this summit will have once again proven the importance and usefulness of this type of dialogue between the European Union and ourselves. Indeed, I hope that it will allow us to better coordinate our actions with you in order to be able to react and respond to issues that are common concerns for the European Union, its members, and ourselves, and that have a direct impact on the fundamental issues of peace, democracy, and development.

Thank you, Mr. President, wholeheartedly to you and to President BARROSO for this excellent meeting.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - First, I would also like to express the pleasure I had in participating in this summit. This is the first summit at this level between the European Union and South Africa, even though we have greatly developed the excellent relations between the European Union and South Africa. But this summit, thanks to the fact that there was someone like Nicolas SARKOZY on the European side and someone like Thabo MBEKI on the South African side, was really very interesting because we were able to focus, as President SARKOZY said, in an informal way on the major political issues. We were also able, thanks to the work of our collaborators, of all our teams, and I would particularly like to pay tribute to the work, on the Commission's side, of Louis MICHEL, but also of the French Foreign Minister, Bernard KOUCHNER. We were able to focus on the truly strategic issues between Europe and South Africa.

The truth is that this summit is historic because it marks a historic turning point in the development of our relations. We are moving from a partnership based on our agreement, on trade, development, and cooperation to a partnership that we call strategic. What does strategic mean? It means, first of all, our recognition of South Africa as a key player in Africa but also on the global stage, on issues related to climate change, trade, foreign policy, to name just three examples. Its voice is very heard, and we want to work hand in hand with South Africa. It also means that we want to strengthen our political cooperation beyond trade, economic, and development issues. Because we share values, values such as freedom, democracy, human rights, and respect for the rule of law. That is what the strategic nature of our relationship means. If I may make a personal remark, I can tell you that I first met Thabo MBEKI when he was in opposition, in his country still during the time of apartheid, in the late 1980s, and now I see him as President of South Africa. That is why I cannot be pessimistic about Africa. It is true that there is Zimbabwe, it is true that there is Sudan with Darfur, but Africa, which not so long ago experienced the apartheid regime, is progressing today, thanks to the leadership of men like MBEKI and others, and that is why we, Europeans, want to strengthen this relationship with Africa. We now see Africa not just in the traditional relationship of cooperation for development but as a partner in the major global issues where sometimes certain African leaders like President MBEKI are closer to us than others in some developed countries. For example, in terms of climate change, we were able today to work along this line with South Africa and also on the major trade issues, on the problem of how to respond to this need, to this urgency in agricultural and global matters, and I am very grateful to President SARKOZY, as President of the Council, for the support that he and France are providing to the Commission's proposal for this facility of one billion euros. This is a concrete proof of our solidarity for developing countries, for structural aid to agriculture in these countries, particularly in Africa. And I also want to highlight the great support of President MBEKI. So this is a very fruitful summit with a strong political character, which has really been reflected in these conclusions. I invite you, of course, to read the conclusions. Something new, something new between us, the European Union and South Africa as a major partner in Africa with whom we want to work to address the major challenges.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you, José Manuel. I would like to clarify that there is something very new in the agreement, which is a complete identity of view between South Africa and Europe on the issue of immigration. You know that it is South Africa that is responsible for coordinating for the African Union the entire issue of managing the African diaspora. We have, with José Manuel BARROSO, explained the European pact on immigration. We have noted a more complete identity between South Africa, the coordinator for the African Union on these issues, and the European Union. We will continue to work together. This is a whole new way of conceiving the management of migration flows, not in opposition from one continent to another but rather in complementarity, in partnership between Europe and Africa.

Ladies and Gentlemen, we are open to your questions.

QUESTION - I would like to know if the identity of view you referred to a few minutes ago also applies to the situation in Zimbabwe?

MR. THABO MBEKI - We all agreed that it is important for the political parties in Zimbabwe to move forward and that this should happen urgently to reach an agreement among them, facing the issues of forming an inclusive government, with a common program to allow Zimbabwe to move forward. So, I believe everyone in the world wants this to happen quickly. We agree that this is an urgent issue, and that is the attitude taken by the parties. You will remember that in the memorandum of agreements that was signed a few days ago, they gave themselves two weeks to conclude their negotiations. The negotiators are all in South Africa at the moment, and they have been working for several days now to conclude this agreement. That is where we stand, and I am very grateful for the support that has been expressed by President SARKOZY as President of the European Council. I am also grateful for the support of the Commission, but they urgently ask us, which we understand very well, to advance this process as quickly as possible.

THE PRESIDENT - Just a word to clarify that on the position of Mr. BARROSO, mine, and that of Mr. KOUCHNER, there should be no ambiguity. We have three points of agreement. First, what has happened is unacceptable. We must return to the fundamentals, Sir. What has happened is unacceptable and is not accepted. And I have not heard a contrary judgment from Mr. MBEKI, quite the contrary. Secondly, Mr. MBEKI's mediation must be supported because there are no other possible avenues in the immediate future, and everyone in Europe agrees on that. The third point of agreement is that we need to give a little time, but not too much time. I believe I am being perfectly honest in recalling that in Africa there are positions of some that are a bit purer, and in Europe, there are positions of some that are a bit harder. We had to find a compromise with that. A fourth point of agreement is that Europe does not want to interfere, but at the same time, Europe does not accept a number of images and behaviors. And so we support President MBEKI in this mediation. There you go, I believe I have been as clear as possible, with, of course, all the uncertainties and difficulties. There are still three million Zimbabweans who are no longer in Zimbabwe, which is a problem for the entire region because they cannot stay at home. That is exactly what has been said. It is a step forward, including compared to what we discussed at the G8 in Hokkaido.

QUESTION - Was your message to European leaders that at this stage Zimbabwe needs more carrots and sticks given the tightening of sanctions this week?

MR. THABO MBEKI - No, we did not talk about that at all. What is very important, from our point of view, is that the Zimbabweans must now reach an agreement and do so quickly. It is necessary from all points of view. And, in this context, therefore, I am really very grateful for the support that the European Union is providing to the mediation process, and we continue to rely on this support.

QUESTION - Mr. President, I would simply like to know how you respond to the criticisms from Morgan TSVANGIRAI regarding your position, which he describes as somewhat biased - I quote - your pro-MUGABE position according to him. Secondly, President SARKOZY has just said that you need to give time for the crisis in Zimbabwe to resolve itself, but not too much time. How long do you think President MUGABE will remain in power in Zimbabwe? Is it a matter of months, a matter of years?

QUESTION - Regarding the WTO agreement, South Africa has a non-concession position regarding customs duties, whereas the European Union has a contrary position. Would you be willing to support South Africa's position in this regard, knowing that it seeks to protect its emerging industries?

Mr. THABO MBEKI - The question of what will happen in Zimbabwe regarding governance is a question that must be decided by the Zimbabweans themselves. They have agreed to form an inclusive government. So, one of the questions they are currently negotiating is how to constitute this inclusive government. This is a question they are currently discussing, and it is they who will make the decisions about who does what, who steps down when, who holds which position. This is not something decided by the mediator; it is something that will come from negotiations among the Zimbabweans themselves. That is the first thing. The second thing is that we have been working for 16 months now as a facilitating mediator. We have worked with all parties for 16 months, and this includes Mr. TSVANGIRAI and the MDC that he leads. No one has ever withdrawn, and even now, as I said, all negotiators are in South Africa following the signing of the memorandum of agreements. All of them, and this includes the negotiators from Mr. TSVANGIRAI's party. So, whatever he may have said, it has not impacted this process that we have been working on for 16 months; no one has withdrawn, and no one has ever taken a position that has had a negative effect on the negotiation process. So, we will continue on this path.

THE PRESIDENT - As far as I am concerned, I will not speak to Mr. Mugabe because I have a very harsh judgment on what he has done, but one cannot blame President MBEKI for being a mediator and speaking with the parties. I think it is honest to say that. Regarding South Africa's position and the WTO, first, South Africa is not speaking only for itself; it is also speaking, as you know, on behalf of NAMA, and therefore, sometimes it can express a somewhat tougher position. Not because it is its position as South Africa, but because it speaks on behalf of ten other countries. I argued before the President of the Commission that one of the positions of Europe is to help Africa more than other parts of the world that need it less. I will tell you very simply, Europe can perfectly understand that within the framework of a WTO agreement, efforts should be made to help the emerging South African industry to develop and protect itself, let’s be clear. But we cannot be asked to do the same thing with, for example, China, which has remarkable industrial success and is already one of the most industrially developed countries in the world. We cannot be told in the context of WTO negotiations: "What you are willing to do in terms of concessions towards a large African country like South Africa, you should do towards a magnificent, fantastic country like China, which does not need to be helped like a small developing country." That is exactly what we are saying. This is one of the reasons, I explained to Mr. BARROSO and Mr. MBEKI, why I absolutely do not believe in the G5 and G8 organization, and do not let anyone tell us: "Because there is a G5, we must have the same position for everyone." I believe I have defended this idea loyally. Moreover, on behalf of the European Union, we want to do more for Africa than for other countries in the world. Not simply because we are neighbors of Africa, but because Africa needs it more than other countries in the world. You understand that if there are other emerging countries that have exceptional successes that we applaud, we cannot be told: "You have this exceptional success, and at the same time, we want to treat you as if you were at the very beginning of the success cycle." Therefore, South Africa must have, it seems to me, a much more understanding European position within the framework of WTO negotiations. It already has since Mr. BARROSO and I, I believe I can say, are absolutely working hand in hand, and it is not because we say this about South Africa that we must say it about other parts of the world and other countries. I cited one example; I could cite others, and our position is the same on EPAs. We want a privileged situation for Africa because we want the development of Africa, particularly South Africa. But do not ask us to treat all parts of the world the same way. My answer is very sincere and unambiguous.

QUESTION - On civil servants...

THE PRESIDENT - But that is exactly what is already being done, and moreover, President MBEKI, as President of South Africa, I believe, is not far from this position.

Mr. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - I can only add to what President SARKOZY has said that already, in the latest version now being negotiated in Geneva, there is already explicit recognition of certain specificities for South Africa. This is exactly what President SARKOZY said, and moreover, the European Union, that is to say, the Commission, which as you know negotiates on behalf of the European Union, has strongly supported the recognition of this specificity of South Africa within the framework of these negotiations. Moreover, I myself had also said this to President MBEKI in Hokkaido at that G8 plus 5 meeting.

QUESTION - A question for President MBEKI. Mr. President, you spoke of an agreement you reached with the Europeans on the Zimbabwe issue. Do you think that at least the sanctions against Zimbabwe should be suspended? My second question concerns the idea of a United Nations mediator to participate in the mediation process. Do you agree with that as well? Do you think that the African Union and the United Nations can assist you in your mediation efforts with Zimbabwe?

Mr. THABO MBEKI - Regarding your second question, we actually recognize that the international community is very much interested and necessarily concerned about what is happening in Zimbabwe. Yes, we have taken the initiative for this mediation, but we could indeed form a reference group. It would not be a mediator or negotiator but people who could frame us, help us. We have asked the Secretary-General of the United Nations to appoint someone to this reference group, which he has done. We have asked the Presidency of the African Union Commission to join us, which has been done. We have asked the President of the SADC Commission on Security and International Affairs, chaired by President DOS SANTOS, to send someone, which he has done. We have there a representative of the Secretary-General of the United Nations, of the African Union's foreign affairs commission, and of the SADC political commission, which had initially asked us to undertake this mediation task. So, these are people who will work with the mediators in order to develop a joint strategy if we get there within the framework of this reference group. They are not mediators as such, but they work with the mediator. That is why I call this group a reference group to assist the mediator in his mediation efforts. In relation to your first question, no, we have not asked the European Union to do anything regarding sanctions. Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - And moreover, we were not authorized. We imposed sanctions.

Thank you.