Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Brian Cowen, Prime Minister of Ireland, on the future of the Lisbon Treaty following the negative referendum vote by the Irish, in Dublin on July 21, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

21 July 2008 · Dublin, Ireland

Context
Sarkozy and Cowen held a joint press conference in Dublin on July 21, 2008, to address Ireland's rejection of the Lisbon Treaty in the June 12 referendum.
Main themes
Lisbon Treaty crisis, Irish referendum rejection, EU institutional reform, French EU Council Presidency, Ireland-France bilateral relations, path forward for 27 member states, EU enlargement and ratification, Europe delivering results for citizens, WTO negotiations and farmers, consultation and trust-building
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,499
81st percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
59
86th percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.89
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
1.94
5th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

180 sentences in 29 paragraphs

MR. BRIAN COWEN - Ladies and gentlemen,

First of all, I would like to say that I am delighted to welcome Mr. SARKOZY to Ireland. Not only for his first visit as French President, but also as President of the European Council. We hope that in a less frantic moment, he can return with his family to enjoy our country, to stay longer in our country. I would also like to say that France and Ireland have very close relations at the governmental level, excellent relations but also through the hundreds of thousands of contacts between the Irish and the French throughout the year.

We had a very useful meeting today on several topics and also on the priorities of the French Presidency. The central point of our discussions today has, of course, been the situation arising from the result of the vote on June 12 on the Lisbon Treaty. The President has clearly indicated that he came among us to listen and to better understand why the Irish people voted no.

I explained that we have currently begun a process of analysis and consultations which, we hope, will lead to a better understanding of the concerns that underlie the result of this referendum. This is essential to work towards a resolution of the difficulties but in a way that is satisfactory for each of the 27 member countries of the Union. I also emphasize that the vote of the Irish people must be respected. President SARKOZY, for his part, stressed the importance that he and our European partners attach to the implementation of the reforms contained in the Lisbon Treaty.

The Union must focus on the issues that are important to our populations. The Union, certainly, finds itself in a difficult deadlock but we are determined to manage it. We are looking towards October and the European Council during which I will be able to share my assessment. I will remain in very close contact and we will also engage in September to prepare for this process of the October European Council.

THE PRESIDENT - Mr. Prime Minister, dear Brian, I would like to say how happy I was to make my first trip as President of the European Council to Ireland, to have a long working meeting with the Irish Prime Minister. I told him how much Europe needs Ireland and how much we trust him to explain the reasons for the no and to find ways and means with the Irish people to get out of the situation we find ourselves in.

I was very pleased with the multiple contacts I was able to have with Bernard KOUCHNER with representatives of all political parties whether they voted yes or no, with representatives of trade unions, employers, youth associations, and civil society. I sensed a very strong attachment to Europe on the part of the Irish. I explained that I would fight for us to move forward as 27, without leaving anyone behind, to find a solution together as 27. Everyone presented me with their analysis of the difficulties. The Prime Minister of Ireland will present a report to the European Council in October on the situation and his vision of Ireland's situation in relation to Europe. Until then, we will multiply working meetings. I will have the pleasure of receiving Prime Minister COWEN in Paris in September. Our ministers will work together, our staff as well. We do not have a miracle solution and above all we do not want to impose it. We want the Irish people to feel respected in their choice but we must also take into account the fact that with Italy, soon, 24 countries will have ratified the Lisbon Treaty.

I am convinced that with a little time, and Ireland needs time, we will find the solution to give Europeans the democratic institutions they need. And above all, I perceived this among all my interlocutors and notably with the Prime Minister, the desire for a Europe that delivers results. I was very happy to meet Irish farmers who told me how concerned they were about the negotiations on the WTO and how much they were counting on us to help them. And so this Europe focused on the daily lives of people that delivers results must now be our priority.

So, in summary, there is a passion for Europe here and not a rejection of Europe. There is a desire to find solutions. For that, time is needed. And then, there is a willingness from France, which holds the Presidency, to bring the 27 together in unity to build a Europe that guarantees results. In summary, I do not regret my trip here and I want to reiterate to Brian my friendship, my trust, and my support to get out of the situation we find ourselves in.

QUESTION - Mr. SARKOZY, do you persist in vetoing the enlargement of the European Union until we have a resolution of the Lisbon Treaty? Because we cannot advance amendments, modifications to this Treaty given, as you were told today, that it is a long-term problem. Not only for the French Presidency or even the Swedish one, in 18 months we may not have resolved this issue.

THE PRESIDENT - Sir, first of all, that is not my opinion. Like your Prime Minister, I am bound by the Treaties. The Nice Treaty provides for a Europe of 27. It is not me, it is the Nice Treaty. And for there to be a future enlargement, we must have moved to Lisbon. However, in the current state of affairs, it is either Nice or Lisbon, because a vast majority of member states are not ready for a new institutional conference. But all this gives us time because the French Presidency will continue to open chapters and I hope all chapters of discussion with Croatia and in the best case, Croatia's accession would not be expected until the end of 2010, beginning of 2011. I still hope that in three years, we will have found the solution to get out of the institutional deadlock we find ourselves in. So there is no opposition between this position on Lisbon and Nice and the need for future enlargement.

QUESTION - Last week, President SARKOZY said that the Irish must re-vote. Were you surprised by this statement, shocked, or did you think: "after all, he may be right because at the end of the year, if we are the only ones who said no, we will be in an uncomfortable position."

MR. BRIAN COWEN - I would first like to say that I respect the views of all representatives of all nations within the European Union, who are affected by the current situation just as we are. The great genius of the European Union is that this Union works together to find solutions to these problems. The vote of the Irish people is respected. The consequences, we as political leaders, give us the energy to find ways to resolve these problems rather than letting them stagnate. It is the democratic obligation. The Irish government, for its part, has made no decision regarding a second referendum, because we are in a process of reflection, a process of evaluation that is necessary in the days following this referendum. But it is clear that I will work on this with the Presidency of the European Union as a member, as an engaged member of a country that has always demonstrated its pro-European sentiments, a country that wants to remain at the heart of Europe. I must discuss with my colleagues and with the Presidency which has a broader agenda to act on behalf of the 26 members during its Presidency, to see how, together, we can move forward in concert, to make progress once I have evaluated, observed, analyzed the concerns of the Irish people. We have a national consultation process, but it is only underway. We need to see how to address some of these concerns. This is the current process as Mr. President said. We are not here to find a solution, we are here to make a statement of mutual solidarity to find a solution, but a solution that will be satisfactory for all member states. That is how the Union has always worked and will continue to work, and Ireland will take part in this process.

QUESTION - Mr. SARKOZY, do you maintain your comments made last week, that Ireland must hold a second referendum? After your day today, do you understand the anger that these words have provoked?

THE PRESIDENT - I never said that Ireland had to call a new referendum! I said that at some point, the Irish must give their opinion. I did not talk about a referendum, I did not describe the question and I did not interfere in the Irish political debate. No one can be angry when you tell a people: "sooner or later, on a question to be determined, according to a schedule to be negotiated, we will ask for your opinion." In a democracy, that is the least we can do. So, if that makes you angry, it is because there is a really tense atmosphere. But there cannot be a tense atmosphere between Ireland and France. First because we are friends, because we have common interests and because if there is someone who can understand a country that says no, it is perhaps the President of another country that said no. So, there is no misunderstanding, there is no problem. The Prime Minister told me, as did each of the representatives I met, you need time. You need to give that time and, at the same time, I explained to the Prime Minister, as to other partners, that we have European elections in June 2009 and that we need to know at that time a few months in advance, whether we are organizing them on the basis of the Nice Treaty or the Lisbon Treaty.

Everyone has their red lines, everyone has their difficulties, but believe me, there is a willingness between the Presidency of the Union and the Irish government to work hand in hand to find a solution.

I would like to tell you that I was passionate about all the discussions I had. It was extremely enriching and we will continue our work. Starting in September, we will prepare for the European Council meeting in October.

But what did we expect from the President of the Union? That I let things happen? That we do not take care of it? That we leave the Irish on their island? The Irish have asked questions: "will we be able to remain neutral? Will we be able to keep our taxation? Will we be able to keep our legislation on abortion?" But these questions, if the President of the current Council does not come to debate, to hear, to listen, to provide answers, then how are we going to advance the European debate in Ireland?

I am fully aware that it is the Irish who must decide. But, as President of the current Council, I must also take into account the lives of the other 26. We make Europe, Sir, as 27, not alone. I have known this situation of isolation with France and the Netherlands. That is why we came, Bernard KOUCHNER and I, to see our Irish friends with much friendship, much understanding, without the desire to interfere, but a desire to help. It has been too long that in Europe, we let things happen and the difficulties. That is not how we find solutions.

Really, I do not regret this trip, I told Brian. There are a lot of people who told me: "but you should not go, give it time, it is too complicated." Of course, as always in politics, when it is too complicated, you take the door and leave. I think that the role of a statesman is to face the situation, to help the Prime Minister and the government to find solutions. I believe in Europe and there are many Irish citizens who believe in Europe. What do they expect from us? From Brian as from me? That we discuss to find a solution. How can we find a solution if we do not discuss, if we do not come? So, coming to Ireland would be interference and not coming would be indifference. So what do you prefer, you the Irish press, interference or indifference? I believe that coming is being a friend and for the difficulty, perhaps I can help Brian since I have known this difficulty in my country. That is exactly what I did. I do not claim to be right, but I came as a friend to see a friendly country with which we share common convictions and interests and we will find solutions. We need a little time, but we are taking care of it. I preferred this approach rather than waiting for the October Council, for Brian to come with his report without us having talked about it. That is not Europe. Europe is helping each other, not complicating matters, regardless of the political color of governments.

I work with the Irish Prime Minister, whom the Irish have chosen. I think he works with me in the same spirit.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you have evidently shaken the Irish, did they not push back against you? Was this visit useful, productive? Can you draw a lesson from it?

THE PRESIDENT - Have you seen the stature of the Irish Prime Minister? He is not a man to be pushed around. And look at me, have I been bullied? First of all, you know, I want to say to Brian, he is a courageous man and I was very happy with his invitation. Madam, I did not invite myself to Ireland, that is not my style. I came because I was invited by the Prime Minister. I was very pleased that all the political, union, and associative leaders were present at the French Embassy for the meeting with Bernard KOUCHNER. Do you really believe that if they were hurt or if they had the desire to be unpleasant with us, they would all have come to participate in a one-and-a-half-hour meeting? Ireland is a great hospitable country that knows perfectly well when someone wants to help it. So really, I am ending this trip with a lot of optimism. And if, in addition, I have good news coming from France, I will say that it is the Irish who bring good luck.

QUESTION - Mr. President, I want to verify something with you. If I understood correctly what you are saying, Ireland has received clarifications on the deadline by which this process must be completed?

THE PRESIDENT - I want to tell the Irish press as well as the people of Ireland that we do not have a ready-made solution to a complex problem like this. Psychology matters. We are currently listing with the Irish Prime Minister all the issues that have been debated and that have caused problems, and already that is real work. We are prioritizing them based on the proposal of the Irish Prime Minister. After that, we will try to see how we can provide answers to all these questions, but it is not simply a political issue; there are also legal questions. Our best specialists need to be able to work on this, and that takes time. There is no deadline; there is simply an appointment in June 2009. At some point, the 27, including Ireland, will have to decide whether to organize these elections based on the Nice Treaty or the Lisbon Treaty, and then we will work tirelessly to try to find a solution, a method. That is exactly where we stand.

QUESTION - I have two questions. Mr. COWEN, do you agree in principle to a deadline in June 2009? Mr. President, the Congress in France has just voted for institutional reform with a majority vote. I imagine you are satisfied, so what is your feeling first, and when can this reform be implemented?

MR. BRIAN COWEN - We have parliamentary elections in June 2009, and we need to provide some clarity regarding the modalities of this election. One of the issues we need to address is that the Lisbon Treaty has not been ratified based on the Irish vote. This is one of the many considerations that we must weigh ourselves, as well as the Presidency, but it is also important to emphasize that we will work together. There is no one-size-fits-all solution, and as I said immediately after the vote, we need to see together how to move this situation forward. It is not easy, but just because we say it is not easy does not mean it is impossible, because we all want a result, a common result. It is a union of 27 countries. France and Ireland, with different traditions, security, and defense, still work very closely together. This question of a one-size-fits-all approach for Europe at all times, for all countries, dilutes the idea that there is accommodation, an adjustment for different cultures. We mutually respect our different traditions. We are working closely today in very dangerous parts of the world, in Chad with an Irish general. It is the Franco-Irish contingents that contribute the most to this mission that we are pursuing entirely in accordance with our policy on law and international humanitarian law. These efforts to portray the European Union as a solution and that we must force people to accept a solution is not at all how Europe works, and that has not been our experience. When there have been disputes like this in the past, we have found solutions, and it is our duty to find them today, and that is where the argument must advance and progress. I want to emphasize this point because a lot has been said in our own debate, but here is an example of the solidarity, cooperation that can exist among members of the same Union who have different traditions. This is a very important point in the deadlock where we must confront our differences.

THE PRESIDENT - With the permission of the Irish Prime Minister, it is not my habit to comment on events in France from abroad, but given the importance of what has just taken place in France and your presence, I would like to say a few words to express first my joy that the most important constitutional reform that has been undertaken since 1962 has been adopted with just over a three-fifths majority. The French must know that to amend the Constitution, it is not enough to have a majority; you need a three-fifths majority. It is not easy. Many observers doubted our ability to achieve it, but tonight, I want to say that it is not one camp that has won against another; tonight, it is French democracy that has won. During my presidential campaign, I promised an exemplary democracy. Thanks to this reform, Parliament will have more powers. It will be able to control half of its agenda. Thanks to this reform, French citizens will be able to benefit from the exception of constitutionality, defending their rights before the Constitutional Council. Thanks to this reform, the appointment powers of the President of the Republic will be framed by a Parliament that can give its opinion, block an appointment it does not consider fair, and require public hearings. This is an extremely important reform, and I want to thank all those who, attached to change, democracy, and the modernization of our institutions, have lent their voice. I want to first thank the parliamentary majority for demonstrating remarkable cohesion. I want to thank the centrists for understanding that this reform corresponded to what they have been calling for for years. I want to thank the left radicals and left-wing personalities who supported this reform, and I want to tell the French that once again, the camp of movement, change, and modernity has triumphed over the camp of immobility, rigidity, and sectarianism.

This reform was not mine; this reform is that of French democracy, and now we must learn in France to vote for reforms not because someone proposes them or because of what we think of the person proposing them, but for the content and honesty of this reform. So this is a victory for French democracy. Believe me, I am deeply pleased about this, and I find encouragement to continue with the government of François FILLON the implementation of the essential reforms that France needs to be an exemplary country in Europe. This is very good news. There will now be more parliamentary democracy in our country. Many have been waiting for this for a long time; it is now done. I am happy to be the President of the Republic who has contributed to this. Thank you.