Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mrs. Angela Merkel, Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, on the Eurozone crisis, in Brussels on October 23, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

23 October 2011 · Press conference on the Eurozone crisis following the European Council · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy and Merkel held a joint press conference at the European Council in Brussels on October 23, 2011, amid urgent negotiations over the eurozone debt crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone debt crisis, Franco-German cooperation, bank recapitalization, EFSF strengthening, Greece rescue program, budgetary discipline, economic growth and jobs, treaty modifications, youth unemployment, European banking supervision, IMF and institutions involvement
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,242
78th percentile
Sentences
149
80th percentile
Readability
55
78th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

149 sentences in 49 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, we have concluded the European Council, a meeting of the 27 heads of state or government. We have worked on the growth strategy, and I would like to emphasize that all measures for budgetary consolidation, everything we are doing in terms of stabilizing the euro to overcome the debt crisis, is closely linked to the question of how Europe can achieve economic growth to create jobs. That is why youth unemployment, encouraging research, and innovation were very important themes that we worked on.

During lunch, and still with all 27, we discussed what should be decided by Wednesday. We will now have a meeting of the 17 euro area member states to prepare the decisions for Wednesday. Today, the 17 will not make any decisions but will undertake very important preparations.

I am pleased that by the end of the week we have made progress with the finance ministers: the recapitalization of banks. The situation has shown that the finance ministers have largely agreed on the basis, notably, of the proposals for European banking supervision. All of this will be the subject of a comprehensive decision. That is why there will be another ECOFIN ministers' meeting on Wednesday, but there is a very broad agreement.

What is now needed is to prepare the necessary decisions that remain to be made, namely, on the one hand, strengthening the EFSF to meet its requirements, then protecting the member countries of the euro, and finally working on a new program for Greece. On the other hand, during dinner, we will return to this in more depth with the euro area countries and determine how we can have stricter budgetary discipline in the future. We have said that treaty modifications cannot be ruled out, and Hermann VAN ROMPUY will report on this to the Council of 27.

In the coming hours, we will discuss how the different member countries of Europe are pursuing their reforms, because trust will not simply result from a firewall, trust will not simply result from a new program for Greece; trust will result from the fact that everyone has done their job. What I would like to say, and that is why we are both here before you, together, is that we have had a lot of technical preparatory work that was not completed, which is still not completed. That is why it was necessary to have a second stage of this Council on Wednesday, a second stage in relation to this euro area meeting today. This technical work is progressing at an intensive pace, and France and Germany will have contributed significantly, and we will ensure that the decisions to be made can be made on Wednesday. It must be done with great care and precision regarding the details, and at the same time, we must show the greatest determination. The euro is our common currency; it is our prosperity. The euro is an integral part of Europe. And that is why we are fully aware of our responsibility.

THE PRESIDENT -- Thank you, Angela. You understand well that if Chancellor MERKEL and I spend so much time in meetings together, on the phone, in contact with all our partners, it is because it is crucial, in the face of this unprecedented financial crisis confronting the euro, that France and Germany speak with one voice and assert the will for a common policy. This is absolutely the foundation of everything, and the determination of the Chancellor and myself is absolutely total to provide common, ambitious, sustainable responses to all the issues we face.

I would like to say that the issues are of considerable technical complexity. They are complex because they require a lot of money. They are complex because they involve other partners, notably private partners with whom we must find an agreement on a voluntary basis. They are complex because they involve the 17 countries of the euro area. And they are complex because all institutions, the independent central bank, the Commission, the IMF, the Presidency of the Council, and all participating states must express a common will.

There have been hours and hours of discussions. Work is progressing well on banks, on the Fund, and the possibilities for using this Fund. The hypotheses are narrowing, and a fairly broad agreement is taking shape. On the question of Greece, things are progressing.

We have not yet reached a conclusion; we have until Wednesday, but it must be understood that all decisions will be made at the same time. In addition, with the Chancellor, we have met with the President of the Italian Council. We will also meet with the Greek Prime Minister because it is a set of measures that must be taken. But the countries concerned must also be aware of their responsibilities and the new decisions they will have to make.

So, ladies and gentlemen, that has been our schedule up to now, and there are still long hours of discussions ahead, but we are aware of the particular responsibilities that weigh on the shoulders of Germany and France.

Our will is that an agreement is found on Wednesday that calms the financial crisis, which will allow us, together, to prepare with Germany for the G20 where other decisions must be made to regulate globalization and to allow the world to find its way back to global growth.

QUESTION -- A question for both of you. It has been two years now that you have been in charge trying to resolve the eurozone crisis. For two years, we have heard you say that you will find common, ambitious, sustainable responses. And each time, you fail. Each time, the crisis becomes more serious. Ireland, Portugal, Spain, Italy. So how can we still believe you today when you announce that you will find solutions that will resolve the crisis?

THE PRESIDENT -- Allow me to express my complete disagreement with your analysis, and I take into account the provocation of a spectator in the face of the responsibility of the actors. It is undoubtedly easier to comment than to act, and you would not be the first in this situation. But I cannot let you say that things have failed.

Ireland was a country on the brink of bankruptcy when the crisis hit in 2008. Ireland is now a country that has emerged or is on the way to emerging from the crisis. This is an undeniable point.

As for Portugal, thanks to the efforts of the Portuguese government, things are moving in the right direction.

As for Spain, thanks to the efforts of Mr. ZAPATERO's government and the sense of responsibility of the Spanish opposition led by Mr. Mariano RAJOY, Spain is no longer on the front line.

So, these are three countries to which Europe has provided credible resolution proposals. I would add that regarding the 2008 crisis, which was triggered by what happened with Lehman Brothers in the United States, it was Europe that proposed the G20. And all the operations on Basel III, on the elimination of tax havens, on the regulation of financial markets, have allowed us to respond to the 2008 crisis. We are facing a new crisis. Which one? And I thank you for considering that we must also be responsible for the debt of all developed countries, accumulated over the past 30 years.

I do not recall that Chancellor MERKEL and I were in charge when all these countries chose to become indebted, and even at the time when it was decided to admit into Europe and the eurozone countries that did not meet any of the criteria that were required at the time.

I would add that it does not seem to me that it was Ms. MERKEL or myself who requested the loosening of the pact at that time. We have to manage the consequences of those who admitted a number of countries that were not ready into the eurozone and who loosened the discipline on the pact.

Finally, I would add one last point: that Ms. MERKEL is responsible for Germany, that I am responsible for France, and that we find ourselves today having to make decisions in favor of countries for which we were not elected. And everyone can understand that this also raises democratic issues. What I mean to say, and I will conclude, is that there are not only technical problems, financial problems; these are countries where there is a lot of suffering, where there are protests and social problems. Our mandate is not to manage these countries, and yet we must ask them to make efforts. So I believe that rather than making the statement you made, perhaps you could have said, in essence, if Germany and France had not decided to assume their responsibilities, where would we be today?

MS. ANGELA MERKEL -- There is one thing that must be seen, and the President of the Republic has just said it, we are fighting against situations that date back several decades, and this is not a crisis of our currency; it is a crisis of debt. And that is why Wednesday will not be the last step. When we talk about the future, we say that we probably need to strengthen the control mechanism within the eurozone. There, there is a perfectly identical position between Germany and France, and therefore, there will be a succession of steps to be taken, but in today's situation, there are certain points to decide on Wednesday, which complement each other. Simply recapitalizing the banks is of no use; we must also ensure that the problems of Greece are placed on a long-term basis and a realistic solution.

To achieve this, the eurozone must prepare the protection of all other countries. All these points are linked. It is to these decisions that we are working; they are imperative, but they are not the last decisions we will take to overcome the debt crisis. If we do not achieve growth, if we do not achieve more budgetary discipline, if we repeat the mistakes of the past, we will not master the crisis. So it is a process that was born many years ago.

We have a common currency, but without having common discipline. And today, we are learning painfully, but we want to learn together that we must work differently in the future. This is the common axis on which we are working. No expert can tell us, because it is something new, it is unprecedented; such a situation in a monetary area like the eurozone has never existed, what the 100% sure solution is. And we have the political responsibility not only to do something courageous but also to measure the consequences the next day.

That is why we can only move forward step by step, because as we go along, we learn what the next responsible step can be.

QUESTION -- Madam Chancellor, Mr. President, regarding Greece, negotiations with banks on an additional contribution from the private sector have begun. If this negotiation does not succeed, can we imagine a write-down decreed by the states? And will there be a European Council on Thursday that would confirm the results of the euro area Council?

Ms. ANGELA MERKEL -- No, on Wednesday at 6 PM, there will be a relatively brief European Council of the 27, where we will talk about the recapitalization of banks that concerns the 27, and then the Eurogroup will meet for a longer time, and the colleagues who do not belong to the euro area will be immediately informed, because we want Europe to send a strong signal even if the real decisions in question will be made and must be made by the member states of the euro area.

Negotiations with the banks have just begun, which is why it is completely useless to make any speculation in this regard. We are conducting these negotiations to achieve a solid result that shows that Greece's situation is healthy in the long term.

THE PRESIDENT -- I certainly share the Chancellor's view. On the banks, I would say that everyone must take their responsibilities to avoid catastrophe, the heads of state and government, as well as private partners, in discussions that are taking place right now. You will allow me to say that the Chancellor and I have reminded all our European partners of our commitment to establishing a financial transaction tax. This is a commitment that we both made, and we care a lot about it. There is a proposal from the Commission, and the entire financial sector must be regulated and must also be called upon to assume its responsibilities, because if the world is where it is today, it is because, of course, there has been too much debt, but also because there has been a financial system that has obeyed no rules, and therefore, we must definitively turn the page on that world by opposing a number of regulations that will prevent the same causes from producing the same effects.

Naturally, these discussions will continue within the framework of the G20, because of course, there is the problem of Europe, and then the problem of the world as well, and I cannot ask enough of all our partners to help us, to not criticize too much because each region in the world has its own problems, and must therefore focus on solving its own problems without thinking of criticizing those of others.

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL - I would absolutely like to support the idea of introducing a tax on financial transactions as the President of the Republic has just said.

THE PRESIDENT -- It is truly a moral, political, and economic obligation.

QUESTION -- What exactly did you say to Mr. BERLUSCONI? Did he give you commitments on new reforms in Italy? Are you reassured after hearing him, given that Italy is increasingly in the crosshairs, particularly of rating agencies?

THE PRESIDENT -- We were together in this meeting. And how do you say? We trust in the sense of responsibility of all the Italian authorities, political, financial, and economic.

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL -- We have made it clear that Italy is a large and important partner in the eurozone and everything must be done in this country to live up to the responsibility that is its own. And I believe that this can be seen as a discussion among friends, and I hope that the necessary measures will be taken, because trust will not simply arise from the construction of a firewall. Trust needs a clear perspective. Italy has great economic strength. But it has a very high public debt that will need to be credibly reduced in the coming years. That is the expectation regarding Italy.

THE PRESIDENT -- In any case, there is no question of calling on the solidarity of partners if those we are helping do not themselves make the necessary efforts for the response to be comprehensive and the solution to be within the reach of the decisions we are going to make.

QUESTION -- A question for both of you. You have both spoken of progress in discussions on the EFSF. I would like to know if the option of using the ECB to strengthen the EFSF is no longer on the table or is still under discussion. What models are still being discussed?

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL -- The finance ministers considered two models yesterday. Neither of them involves the European Central Bank, because the treaties do not allow it. These two models now need to be detailed, and I believe we must wait for the results of this work, and in light of these results, we will need to discuss it.

THE PRESIDENT -- The central bank is independent, and France values this independence as much as Germany does. This is a point we discussed in detail with the Chancellor. So it is not for heads of state and government to give any instructions whatsoever. For the rest, I defer to what the Chancellor has said. At most, I will clarify that no solution is viable if it does not have the support of all European institutions. It is a team effort.

QUESTION -- I would like to ask you if you have confidence, you spoke of trust in the Italian authorities, in Mr. BERLUSCONI, and whether the measures you are asking for are of a budgetary nature or for growth.

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL - Growth and debt reduction, both must go hand in hand. Moreover, it is the same in Germany or in other countries; it also involves structural reforms. We had a conversation with the head of government of this great country that is Italy; he is our interlocutor, and we trust him.

THE PRESIDENT -- Exactly.

QUESTION -- Can you tell us more about who will pay for the recapitalization of the banks?

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL -- Yesterday, a very clear hierarchy was established. First of all, the banks will try to capitalize themselves or recapitalize if they cannot do so. What we do not know today is that if they cannot do so, it will be the states that will be called upon, and if the state cannot, we could, under certain conditions, use the EFSF, which serves this purpose, which allows for bank recapitalizations via the states. But that is the last step. First, it is up to the banks to seek the necessary capital in the market.

THE PRESIDENT -- What is important for us is that savers do not lose money, that bank customers have confidence in them, and that the economy has the necessary credit to function and return to the path of growth. Essentially, within the framework of the G20, we had set objectives known as those of Basel III, which were scheduled for 2019, if I remember correctly. We will therefore anticipate what are called the prudential rules so that as of 2012, these rules can apply to our banks. There is no economy that can function without credit, and there is no credit that can be made available to individuals as well as businesses without healthy, controlled, and regulated banks.

This is what we are trying to do. For the rest, the phasing planned by the Chancellor is exactly what we have accepted: the private sector, the states, the Fund. Thank you.

QUESTION -- A quick word about the rugby team.

THE PRESIDENT -- Regarding the rugby team, it happens that in the elevator where I was with Angela MERKEL, I had Marc LIEVREMONT, the coach, on the phone; I told him how sad all the French were, of course, to have lost this final by one point, but that all the French were proud of the French team, of their audacity, of their fighting spirit, of the extraordinary heart they put in. And ultimately, they were so criticized that they played such a match in the final; we can say one thing, if there was a beautiful match to be played, it is better that it was the final than the ones before. Really, it came down to very little; Angela can also testify that I only left the meeting room for the last ten minutes. That shows the mobilization and concentration I have demonstrated just now.

Thank you all.

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL -- In any case, our congratulations; being vice-champions of the world is wonderful.