Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the challenges and priorities of industrial policy, Le Bourget, June 23, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

23 June 2007 · Statement on industrial policy at the Paris Air Show · Le Bourget airport, Le Bourget, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed industrialists and ministers at the Paris Air Show in Le Bourget on June 23, 2007, outlining his vision for French industrial policy.
Main themes
Industrial policy, French industrial heritage and identity, competitiveness and economic challenges, industrial job losses, aerospace and defense industry, know-how preservation, wages and purchasing power, 35-hour workweek critique, European industrial cooperation, national community and pride, investment stagnation
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,525
93rd percentile
Sentences
354
96th percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
8.6
8th percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 64%62%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

354 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Mr. Minister of State,

Ladies and gentlemen Ministers,

And notably the Minister of Defense,

Ladies and gentlemen Presidents,

I would like to begin my remarks before you by expressing a regret: that I was unable to try in flight the machines I have just admired. The proposals were numerous. But I have a sense of the ridiculous. It is unnecessary to tell you that my technical skills are very notoriously insufficient, to say the least, and regarding physical abilities, there would be much to say in this period of transparency; I preferred not to test the exploits of your pilots. Looking at your machines, I can tell you that I imagined what it required, for your collaborators, in terms of physical condition and, at the same time, technical skills. Perhaps what touched me the most was the look of the spectators. Believe me, I saw a little Mathilde, whom life had not spoiled, who was very happy to be here. You are at the forefront of technology. From what I read, the commands were good. But what I noted is that you brought happiness to women and men who will never buy the first of your materials and who were nonetheless proud to be here, to feel they belong to a national community capable of manufacturing what you produce. Perhaps this is something you do not realize, but you are capable of making people dream, and that matters.

So rather than during the week, because I wanted to come today, on this Saturday, of popular fervor. There was the inauguration without public opening. I prefer to do the closing with the public, because I believe that popular fervor illustrates the deep relationship our country has with industry.

You know, for me, this is extremely important. During the campaign, I made many smile with my obsession to visit factories. I believe that a country that abandons its factories and industries is a country that loses its identity. A country without workers, a country without farmers, a country without artisans, is a country that loses its civilization. There is an industrial culture. There are relationships in factories that are, nowhere else, of the same nature. I remember this remark made to me by a great business leader: "Why do you go to the industries? There are fewer and fewer workers in factories and more and more offices." Of course, but there is something that our compatriots deeply feel, which is that if we let the factories fall, it is the offices that we will let fall next. If we let the workers fall, it is the management that we will let fall next.

It is a whole, a country. I want to fight. This was the subject, by the way, of many discussions these past two nights with our European partners. We must not let our industrial culture fall. There is know-how. There is accumulated experience that is the hallmark of great industrial nations. It is a strategic asset. There is the possession of technology and then there are the tools of production. The responsibility we have, you, industrialists, and we, governors, is to preserve this heritage.

I was thinking about this while visiting - I have done it several times - the Atlantic shipyards. I was thinking that it took decades to create industrial know-how. It only takes a few months to bring it all down.

The industry that is yours, Mr. President, knowing how to build airplanes, has decades of experience behind it. We cannot let that go, because the goodwill, the know-how that it represents, is the hallmark of great nations that have an industrial tradition.

We must face reality. The reality is a gradual erosion of our industry. Our industrial exports have stagnated in value, dear Christine, since 2000. The industrial added value, which increased by 7% per year until 1990, has hardly progressed since 2000. Industrial investment returned in 2006 to its 1995 level, eleven years without progress.

Too low investment in turn fuels the loss of competitiveness, which is the cause of 730,000 industrial job losses between 1995 and 2003. There are well-identified causes. I refuse to question the level of wages, because if France is to have a competitive industry, it is precisely to be able to pay wages that are in line with its standard of living while remaining competitive. I will take my responsibilities. I am a bit tired of these laboratory specialists who explain to you that there is a problem of competitiveness for the company and that there is no problem of purchasing power for employees. Because I ask the question: "Does it benefit a company's competitiveness to have employees who do not feel compensated in line with the work they invest in the company?" This is still a central question. I have fought for work. I told France that its problem was that France did not work enough when other countries worked too much. But it is not just any work and it is not just any remuneration.

So, on the other hand, it is certain that the 35-hour workweek has greatly contributed to the destruction of our industrial fabric. Here is a strange matter. We are the only country in the world to have enacted legislation to prevent people from working. Moreover, it is quite reassuring about the balance of the world to see that no one has imitated us. Either we are very, very ahead, or something has not worked. I think something has not worked. There is a second subject, to be clear, we will do it, it is the reform of the labor market. Never has French labor law been so protective and at the same time have employees felt so exposed to precariousness. A magical system where everyone loses and they come to explain to me that nothing should be touched in the balances as if a shared injustice were less shocking, as if the problem of France were not to fight against injustices but that all of you should be late to ensure that no one is on time. Are employees worried? Yes, but it does not matter, because they are all in the same situation. That is not equality. The reform of the labor market, all other countries have done it and all other countries have achieved results. We will do it.

I advocate for a simple approach and, dare I say, unembarrassed regarding the relationship between industrial policy and competition. I believe competition is essential to ensure the best quality/price ratio, to stimulate service and innovation. But I will take my responsibilities. I reject a theological, ideological approach that makes competition an end in itself. When competition is useful, I am for it. When it goes against an effective economic policy, I want us to ask the question. Who can explain to me the benefits of competition in the electricity sector if it drives prices well above long-term production costs? In economics, my only ideology is pragmatism.

I also think that the great diversity of statements from our European partners on these issues actually masks a great unity of action. If we can recognize the great proximity of our interests, rather than making mutual accusations of ultra-liberalism or protectionism, we can establish a real industrial policy, European.

When it was necessary, in 2004, to save ALSTOM, we can look at it from a distance, but there were 25,000 employees. But imagine, here, what you would have said if you had been an employee of ALSTOM. I remember the note that was given to me by one of my collaborators at the time, in Bercy: perfect. Perfect note. Perfect conclusion. There is nothing to be done. It must be sold off. It is useless. It is over. First of all, it is industry. I brought in this brilliant young collaborator. I told him: "You redo the note imagining just one detail: it is your father who is an employee of the company. Would you write the same thing?" No one believed me at the time. No one. The ministers who are here can testify, it was necessary to buy back with public funds - it was the government of Jean-Pierre RAFFARIN - 22% of ALSTOM, not out of ideology, but because no one wanted to do it. The State bought it back for 800 million euros and it was the condition for the banks, whose enthusiasm you know they have for lending to a company that everyone says is finished. It was necessary to raise 10 billion euros, that was the condition. The State, which bought back 22% of ALSTOM for 800 million, sold it two years later for 2 billion 400 million and the private investor, who became the reference shareholder of ALSTOM, paid more than 2 billion for what we had bought for 800 million. It is not so often that the State makes a good deal. The shareholder who bought at that price has nearly doubled his investment since then, and ALSTOM is one of the companies with the best stock market performance in 2006. Should I have listened to those who told me at the time: "There is nothing to be done, it is finished in the name of competition, we should have done a joint venture with Siemens"?

Understand me, I am not saying that the State is always right, of course, but I want to unembarrass the question of industrial policy. If General de GAULLE, in his time, had not made the choice of nuclear power, would the market have given it to us? I was presented with Ariane Space. A number of major projects were presented here. If the State had not played its role, would the market have played it? Do countries spontaneously become specialists in the construction of airplanes, trains, cars, possessing nuclear power, while others do not? Or is it, at some point, the role of politicians and statesmen to say: "Attention, let’s look at the long term." The market is not the best, at least not the only advisor for the long term. Do we have the right to say this without being immediately accused of wanting to nationalize or of not being liberal? Liberalism does not mean that a Minister of Finance should sit idly by or that a President of the Republic does not also have the responsibility to imagine what the industrial apparatus of his country will be in twenty years. An industrial policy is not a dirty word. I want to say, from this point of view, that it is not a right to have an industrial policy for a country, it is a duty. This does not mean that we can do everything, that we must invest in all areas. On the contrary, we must make choices and, if possible, long-term choices.

There is a second remark I would like to make always on competition. Of course, I am for competition, market opening, and globalization. But I say things as clearly as possible, I had the opportunity to say it to Mr. LAMY, to Mr. MANDELSON, and at the last G8 in G24 format, to a number of our major partners: India, Brazil, China, Argentina. I no longer want Europe to show naivety.

For me, good competition, I will tell you, is very simple, it is reciprocal competition. I tell our partners around the world: "You want us to open our markets. Very well. We will open them the minute you open yours. You want us to lower our tariff barriers. Very well. We will lower them the minute you lower yours." But, from this point of view again, I think we can no longer continue to impose on our industries and our companies environmental dumping, social dumping, fiscal dumping, and now monetary dumping.

I do not care if this displeases, I say it because I believe it, we did not create the second currency in the world so that if this continues, we cannot build a single airplane on the territory of Europe. To say this is not to insult anyone. I remember a politician who humorously said: "A politician who spoke about currency was irresponsible." And on what grounds? Are there taboo subjects? What do I ask? I ask that we do with the euro what the Americans do with the dollar, what the Chinese do with the yuan, what the Japanese do with the yen, and, sorry to say, what the British do with the pound sterling. How can our industrialists still be competitive if the dollar devalues by 34% against the euro? Did we create the second currency in the world so that we cannot use it? I asked the Chinese President, in Rostock the other day: "Are you going to revalue the yuan?" The man is courteous, he smiled at me. I drew absolutely definitive conclusions from that. I wish that we could build airplanes in Europe. I do not say this simply, dear Louis GALLOIS, for Airbus. Every time the euro appreciates by ten cents, Airbus has to find a billion euros. What company can withstand that? I could multiply the examples of those who manufacture in the eurozone and sell in dollars. How can we operate like this?

I add, to be sure that I have made myself understood in this room and then elsewhere, that the United States of America, with which I feel so close, is presented as a great liberal country. They have no qualms about implementing differential taxation depending on whether the product is made in the United States or elsewhere. What the United States does, I ask that we do the same. Take the Small Business Act: within the framework of the WTO, the United States has an exemption. There is no reason why Europe should not have one! This is called reciprocity. No more, no less. It is not aggressive to say this. I will be going to China where the Chinese President has invited me. I have great admiration for this extraordinary China that has a millennia-old history and embraces the future like a young country. But let those who are here, who sell to China, explain to us how they are spontaneously offered a partner? I am sometimes amazed when I see French or European industrialists presenting their Chinese partners to me. I wonder how they met? It must be a love at first sight of sympathy. We could also talk about technology transfers. How does that happen? Europe and France have no lessons to receive in terms of liberalism. But let things be clear. Naivety is over. Reciprocity begins now. The same goes for the Kyoto Protocol. How can we imagine that we will impose on our companies, and this is normal to preserve the planet's balance, to produce cleanly while continuing to import into our country products from countries that disregard the Kyoto Protocol? That is why I support a carbon tax on imported products to rebalance the conditions of competition. Otherwise, we have decided to give up everything. I say it. I will not give up anything.

Of course, in industrial policy, it is primarily about developing innovation, nuclear energy, aeronautics, space. We will help you invest massively. But France, to preserve its rank, must absolutely be among the countries that clear the way, not among those that follow those who clear the way. Our historical movement of catching up has come to an end. Until 1995, France's industrial hourly productivity was growing twice as fast as that of the United States. Since 1995, it has been growing half as fast. We must now find, within ourselves, the technological breakthroughs that will allow us to compensate for this. That is why I indicated that I would propose to the government to increase public research funding by a quarter, dear Valérie Pécresse, focusing on project funding, not on structure. Yes, because I need to tell you something. We will put money, a lot of money, but we will put it on projects, not on structures. Because we want the best teams, and I believe it is necessary to apply the same logic at the European level. Rather than letting five national teams, three of which are of average level, work separately on the same theme with their national funding, let us create a European scientific foundation that will pool resources and allocate them to the best teams on the continent.

We also have a huge untapped source of innovation with public procurement. The logic of public procurement today is quite simple, the absolute minimization of risk. If there are those who feel targeted, they are perfectly right. Because, obviously, as soon as you take a risk, a whole bunch of things fall on your head. So, the wise manager is no longer the one who takes risks, but the one who takes the least. That is not how we will progress. We must not avoid SMEs, we must not avoid innovative products. I want to reverse this logic, to develop a true precursor purchasing policy. Public procurement should be an opportunity to launch a new product or process and to be its first major client. Public procurement should be a springboard, not a lock. For that, dear Christine, we will need to raise awareness among public buyers.

In terms of innovation, the creation of competitiveness clusters has been an important step. The current support system lasts until 2008. It seems essential to me to make it permanent and to strengthen it after a precise evaluation of the action of each cluster. Ladies and gentlemen, we will not do anything new without evaluation. Public support will be renewed for the clusters that have achieved tangible results.

The second strategic priority is to broaden the industrial base of our country. The aeronautics sector alone represents two-thirds of France's high-tech exports. These figures are both a tremendous tribute, Hervé, and at the same time, a terrible fragility. The example is given with the rise of the euro, which hits France harder because aeronautics is particularly sensitive to this issue. We can no longer bet everything on the performance of a few large companies. We need to diversify the base of our exports and industrial innovation. For us, the heart of our economic policy will be to have more medium-sized enterprises, medium-sized because they must be large enough to export and to conduct the high-level technological research necessary.

The lack of medium-sized enterprises is the industrial weakness of France. Since 2002, we have created many companies. But small ones rarely become medium-sized, and medium-sized ones never become large. Out of 1,000 companies created in the United Kingdom, ten years later, 7 have more than 15 million euros in turnover. In France, two.

I propose to refocus the action of the Industrial Innovation Agency on medium-sized enterprises, on ambitious projects. I no longer want to find companies that are too large to qualify for support from the competitiveness fund or Oséo, and too small to qualify for support from the AII.

France lacks a venture capital and private equity player that has real technological expertise, a vision, a commitment to the national territory, and sufficient financial capacity, meaning a player capable of investing in equity 10, 20, 50 million euros at once. I do not see any in our country that meets the criteria I just mentioned. I want us to engage in a thorough reflection on the reasons for such an absence. Let things be clear. We cannot continue to have a banking system. You can easily borrow money, especially when you do not need it. And here, I am one of those who believe that we do not suffer from a lack of projects, but from a lack of funding. I want such a fund to emerge from the financial market in Paris, and immediately, I tell Augustin de Romanet, I believe it is necessary to redirect the action of the Caisse des Dépôts. France Investissement must now redirect its action towards direct intervention, at least doubling the resources it allocates to it.

The third major action is to adapt the qualifications of young people to the new realities of globalization and technological progress. We have university programs, even if it is painful to say, that have become traps. Traps where students, your children, poorly informed and poorly prepared, face massive failure rates, and where those who obtain their degrees experience the bitter reality of precariousness and downgrading. We will only get out of this by fundamentally reforming the principles of operation of the French university to set professional integration objectives for each university and to give it autonomy, resources, and governance.

So they say - but this is extraordinary - "Mr. Sarkozy, you want to take care of everything." I did not understand that I was elected to take care of nothing. But if taking care of everything means thinking that Europe has a problem, that it is not normal for the 5th largest power in the world, France, to have universities that struggle to emerge in the rankings of great universities, it is still my duty to try to give your children the best universities in the world. Who could dare to say that the governance problem in universities does not exist? Who could dare to say that the problem of university autonomy does not exist? Of course, there are issues of resources. But then, I will propose a reasoning. The additional financial resources that Valérie Pécresse needs will be programmed. I say it very clearly, there can be no reform without resources. But there will be no resources without reforms. Because in France, in the first part, we often say: "no, no, Mr. President, we need resources for there to be reforms. We will be there." But no resources if there are no reforms. Because resources without reforms is a bottomless pit. And we pour, and we pour, and we pour. In the end, we have nothing.

No country will have a competitive industry without a high-quality higher education and research system. This is the work we have engaged in with the Prime Minister and Valérie Pécresse. We will go all the way. Research with more resources, better organized, and universities with more autonomy. The usual blabla about "we are afraid." The Gauls were afraid that the sky would fall on their heads. They quickly understood to move or remain surrounded. The perennial discourse about "be careful, university is dangerous! Be careful, do not think anything, do not say anything, do not do anything, do not count on us."

And vocational training will face the same challenge. Our system today does not manage to concentrate its efforts on employees in fragile sectors to prepare them, dear Jean-Louis, for jobs in growing sectors. If you want to do INSEAD, and you are in a company that is doing very well, it is possible. If you are an employee in a company that is relocating its activity to a region where there is nothing else, vocational training is not for you. It is a shame because that is precisely where we needed it. There will be a reform of vocational training. I will lead it in very close consultation with social partners, but we will have results. I am told, you want to simultaneously reform universities, reform national education, and reform vocational training. Yes, of course, at the same time. Because it is linked. Because in the complex systems that our societies have become, if you do one without doing the other, you completely destabilize the system. That is why it should not be a problem to do it at the same time. Since until now the strategy was to do nothing at the same time. You cannot blame me for doing everything at the same time. Ultimately, only nothing and everything change. But if it was so logical to do nothing in all sectors, I maintain the same reasoning. Except that we will do it. Why? Because if we only reform higher education without reforming vocational training, the one who has less chance, the one who is not meant to pursue studies, the one who was not born into the right family, the one who has no means, do you think he has time to wait any longer? Wait for what? For things to get worse? And who will pay for the chance to get out? Stagnation always penalizes the same people.

So, in terms of taxation, the problem is quite simple. France has the European, and perhaps global, exclusivity of the only tax ideally designed to penalize industry: I am referring to the professional tax. We have two national specialties, the mandatory 35-hour workweek and the professional tax. Here is a tax that taxes fixed assets, thus productive investments, precisely those that allow our country to be competitive with high wages. Fantastic, to have a tax to tax investments. Here is a tax that disproportionately affects industry, exposed to the threat of relocations. Here is a tax that will be paid regardless of results and especially regardless of the order book. How many industrial sites in France are losing money because the professional tax is calculated this way?

Just because this problem is old does not mean it is unimportant or unsolvable. French industry must no longer be the adjustment variable of decentralization. A positive step was taken by the previous government on the professional tax. I now want a comprehensive reflection on the reform of our taxation, with a particular focus on the professional tax, because I believe that a new ambitious step is necessary. We will prepare it in consultation with local authorities, with the deadline being the 2009 finance bill. This reform is a real remedy against relocations. Two objectives: lighten the burden on industry and take into account the financial health of the company.

I would like to conclude by specifically addressing the aerospace and defense sector. 25 billion euros in exports, 92,000 jobs, it is the main player in high technology in our country. This is why the difficulties recently faced by Airbus resonate throughout our entire industrial fabric. What do people say, and why did Jean-Louis BORLOO and I go to Airbus? I will explain that to you. Because I think that if I were a worker in the industry and I saw that Airbus was having difficulties, I would say to myself: "if Airbus has difficulties, an example of technology and performance, what will it be for my industry!" That is why I did not want to let go.

I have met with Airbus employees four times; I returned to Toulouse to see them the day after my inauguration. It was, by the way, something moving, I say this to Louis GALLOIS. I can tell you that it is significant to see, in someone's eyes, that they have confidence. I measure that every day as I walk through the aisles here. I do not intend to betray that trust. I am fully determined to do everything possible to ensure that this extraordinary success of the European industry is consolidated and amplified. I proposed to German Chancellor Angela MERKEL that we hold our next bilateral summit in Toulouse on July 16, at the headquarters of Airbus. I convinced Angela MERKEL. I told her honestly that I would go to Hamburg with her to the same Airbus factories. Because for us, the issue is not a Franco-German rivalry that makes no sense; the issue is to make Airbus a high-performing company that can be managed.

We will invite the strategic shareholders of EADS, Daimler and Lagardère, to join us at this summit for a working meeting. My wish is that these shareholders and the two states speak each in their role but with one voice around a common strategy for the company. I am thinking of governance that must now prioritize the efficiency of decision-making. Airbus is not an international organization; it is a company. A company is managed, not like the UN, which I respect greatly, of course, or even like Europe, even if we have made some recent progress. We could have done it faster, though. EADS must become a normal company, where leaders have the necessary leeway to act quickly and well, where the hierarchical lines are clear, and where shareholders assume their role according to their economic interests, no more, no less. All of this is perfectly compatible with the preservation of the strategic interests of the states. We need to mature now. This is not a Franco-German fight. There is a company behind this. There are people. You have created an extraordinary company. We will give you the means to compete on equal terms.

I also think, I say this to Jean-Louis BORLOO and Christine LAGARDE, about the financing of new models; the A350 made a remarkable commercial breakthrough at this show, for which I warmly congratulate Louis GALLOIS and the Airbus teams, but the challenge of a rapid and high-performing development of this aircraft is all the more essential. We must think about a new approach, integrating the entire industry chain, and I will make proposals on this in Toulouse in a few weeks.

I would like to affirm a deep conviction about EADS. I do not want there to be any misunderstanding about the meaning of my concern regarding this issue. If I have a firm will to change the situation of this company, it is because I want to demonstrate that the fundamentals of this company are remarkable and that a Franco-German group can function. That is what is at stake.

I say this in front of Hervé MORIN, our Minister of Defense; Europe can no longer afford, with defense budgets that remain significantly lower than American budgets, to have 5 surface-to-air missile programs, 3 combat aircraft programs, 6 attack submarine programs, and about twenty armored vehicle programs. Fortunately, we have made Europe. We took a first step with the A400M. But the future lies in common programs and European integration of the industry, both of which I believe go hand in hand. And I will be vigilant, my general, as the head of the armed forces, to ensure that the European division of labor consists of each country bringing its best technologies rather than consolidating its weaknesses. The logic of "just return" at the level of each country, with the national tensions it generates, is a poison that hinders and weakens the implementation of European programs in industrial, technological, and scientific fields. Too many European defense programs and more recently Galileo have suffered from this. This is one of the essential conditions for better control of the equipment effort of the armed forces, whether in terms of their schedule or their actual costs. We will have to discuss this again. It is my responsibility that our armed forces have the equipment they need to fulfill their missions and meet our country's international commitments.

I am committed to this. Our defense effort will be maintained and strengthened. But clearly, our equipment effort, despite the salutary recovery initiated by Jacques CHIRAC, continues to suffer from a mismatch with missions and needs. I therefore wish that the preparation of the next military programming law be an opportunity for a complete overhaul of the methods of defining and managing the programs undertaken, including in the design and presentation of the programming law itself. We are not obliged to resume a process that has not produced only successes. I want us to really think starting from a hierarchized expression of capability needs, rather than rushing headlong into a catalog of equipment. I know I can count on the high military hierarchy in our country for this.

I also wish that we make progress towards greater rigor and greater transparency in the evaluation of costs throughout the life of the equipment. This must lead everyone to question their way of working: the state, the Ministry of Defense, the General Delegation for Armaments, which must continue and accelerate its reform, but also the industrialists with whom we are fortunate to be in relation. It is up to everyone to make an effort to ensure the reliability of the respective commitments made. The nation is ready to make the necessary investments for its defense and security, but, if you allow me this expression, the national community must get its money's worth.

If I must conclude this visit with a message, it is that the idea that France can establish an industrial policy and set ambitious goals for it, and should not fear the future, is a reality. I wanted to say this in front of the aerospace industrialists because they know no other limit than the sky, and in front of those in space because they know no limits at all. I will adhere, as far as I am concerned, to the maxim of that great French aviator Guynemer: "There is a limit to everything; one must always exceed it." Honestly, if I had known this before, I would have probably wasted less time and been quicker.

Thank you.