Tribune by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, published in "Le Monde" on December 9, 2009, on the debate surrounding national identity, under the title "National Identity, an Antidote to Communitarianism: Respecting Those Who Arrive, Respecting Those Who Welcome."

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

9 December 2009

Context
Sarkozy published a tribune in Le Monde on December 9, 2009, addressing the debate on national identity prompted by Switzerland's referendum banning new minarets.
Main themes
National identity, communitarianism, Swiss minaret referendum, populism and democracy, globalization and identity, immigration and integration, freedom of worship, European identity, French national debate, direct democracy, belonging and cultural anxiety
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,399
41st percentile
Sentences
62
41st percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
2.89
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.27
65th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 76%76%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

62 sentences in 23 paragraphs

National identity, antidote to communitarianism

Respect those who arrive, respect those who welcome

By referendum, the Swiss people have just voted against the construction of new minarets on their territory. This decision can legitimately raise many questions. The referendum requires a yes or no answer to the question posed. Can one respond with a yes or no to such a complicated question, which touches on such deep matters? I am convinced that one can only provoke painful misunderstandings, a sense of injustice, and hurt souls by providing such a blunt answer to a problem that must be resolved on a case-by-case basis, respecting the convictions and beliefs of each individual.

But how can one not be astonished by the reaction that this decision has provoked in certain media and political circles in our own country? Excessive, sometimes caricatured reactions towards the Swiss people, whose democracy, older than ours, has its own rules and traditions, which are those of a direct democracy where the people are accustomed to speaking out and deciding for themselves?

Behind the violence of these positions lies a visceral distrust of everything that comes from the people. The reference to the people is already, for some, the beginning of populism. But it is by becoming deaf to the cries of the people, indifferent to their difficulties, their feelings, their aspirations, that one feeds populism. This contempt for the people, for it is a form of contempt, always ends badly. How can one be surprised by the success of the extremes when one does not take into account the suffering of the voters?

What has just happened reminds me of how the rejection of the European Constitution was received in 2005. I remember the sometimes hurtful words that were spoken against that majority of French people who chose to say no. It was to irreducibly oppose the France of yes to that of no, to open a fracture that, if it had deepened further, would have never allowed France to regain its place in Europe.

To reconcile the France of yes and that of no, it was first necessary to try to understand what the French had wanted to express. It was necessary to admit that this majority had not gone astray, but that it had, like the majority of the Irish or the majority of the Dutch, expressed what it felt and knowingly rejected a Europe that it no longer wanted because it gave the impression of being increasingly indifferent to the aspirations of the peoples.

Unable to change the peoples, it was necessary to change Europe. The France of no began to reconcile with that of yes from the moment when, instead of judging it, we sought to understand it. It was then that, transcending what divided it, France was able to take the lead in the fight to change Europe.

So, instead of vilifying the Swiss because their answer does not please us, it is better to question what it reveals. Why in Switzerland, a country with a long tradition of openness, hospitality, and tolerance, can such a rejection be expressed so forcefully? And what would the French people respond to the same question?

Instead of unconditionally condemning the Swiss people, let us also try to understand what they wanted to express and what so many peoples in Europe, including the French people, feel. Nothing would be worse than denial. Nothing would be worse than not facing the reality of the feelings, concerns, and aspirations of so many Europeans.

Let us first understand that what has happened has nothing to do with freedom of worship or freedom of conscience. No one, neither in Switzerland nor elsewhere, thinks of questioning these fundamental freedoms.

The peoples of Europe are welcoming, are tolerant; it is in their nature and in their culture. But they do not want their living environment, their way of thinking and social relations to be distorted. And the feeling of losing one's identity can be a source of deep suffering. Globalization contributes to intensifying this feeling.

Globalization makes identity problematic because everything in it contributes to shaking it, and at the same time it reinforces the need for identity because the more open the world is, the more intense the circulation and mixing of ideas, people, capital, and goods are, the more one needs anchoring and reference points, the more one needs to feel that one is not alone in the world. This need for belonging can be met by the tribe or by the nation, by communitarianism or by the Republic.

National identity is the antidote to tribalism and communitarianism. That is why I wanted a great debate on national identity. This silent threat that so many people in our old European nations feel, rightly or wrongly, weighing on their identity, we must talk about it together for fear that, by being repressed, this feeling will end up nurturing a terrible resentment.

The Swiss, like the French, know that change is a necessity. Their long history has taught them that to remain oneself, one must accept to change. Like the generations that preceded them, they know that openness to others is an enrichment. No other European civilization has practiced, throughout its history, the mixing of cultures more than they have, which is the opposite of communitarianism.

Mixing is the will to live together. Communitarianism is the choice to live separately. But mixing is not the negation of identities; it is for each, in relation to the other, the recognition, understanding, and respect.

It is, from the one who welcomes, the recognition of what the other can bring to him. It is, from the one who arrives, the respect for what was there before him. It is, from the one who welcomes, the offer to share his heritage, his history, his civilization, his way of life.

It is, from the one who arrives, the will to integrate without brutality, as naturally, into this society that he will contribute to transforming, into this history that he will now contribute to writing. The key to this mutual enrichment that is the mixing of ideas, thoughts, and cultures is successful assimilation.

Respecting those who arrive means allowing them to pray in decent places of worship. We do not respect people when we force them to practice their religion in basements or warehouses. We do not respect our own values by accepting such a situation. For, once again, secularism is not the refusal of all religions, but the respect of all beliefs. It is a principle of neutrality, not a principle of indifference. When I was Minister of the Interior, I created the French Council of the Muslim Faith (CFCM) so that the Muslim religion would be placed on an equal footing with all other major religions.

Respecting those who welcome means striving not to offend them, not to shock them; it means respecting their values, their convictions, their laws, their traditions, and making them – at least in part – one's own. It means making one's own the equality of men and women, secularism, the separation of the temporal and the spiritual.

I address my Muslim compatriots to tell them that I will do everything to ensure that they feel like citizens like everyone else, enjoying the same rights as all others to live their faith, to practice their religion with the same freedom and dignity. I will fight against all forms of discrimination.

But I also want to tell them that, in our country, where Christian civilization has left such a deep mark, where the values of the Republic are an integral part of our national identity, anything that could appear as a challenge to this heritage and these values would condemn the necessary establishment of a French Islam that, without renouncing anything of what founds it, will have found within itself the ways by which it will integrate smoothly into our social and civic pact.

Christian, Jew, or Muslim, a person of faith, whatever their faith, a believer, whatever their belief, each must know how to guard against all ostentation and provocation and, aware of the chance they have to live in a land of freedom, must practice their worship with the humble discretion that testifies not to the lukewarmness of their convictions but to the fraternal respect they feel towards those who do not think like them, with whom they want to live.