Government statement by Chancellor Olaf Scholz on the budget situation before the German Bundestag on November 28, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

28 November 2023 · Government statement on the budget situation before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the Bundestag on November 28, 2023, to explain the government's response to the Federal Constitutional Court's landmark ruling on the debt brake.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court debt brake ruling, budget situation, fiscal policy consequences, COVID-19 pandemic impacts, Russia-Ukraine war, energy crisis, German debt brake constitutional law, Ukraine support, gas supply disruption, refugee reception, special budget funds, government coalition negotiations
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,474
67th percentile
Sentences
131
75th percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.92
36th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 34%29%
  • Institutional 28%24%
  • Social 21%18%
  • Geopolitical 13%11%
  • Ceremonial 3%2%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 15%

131 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, I would like to explain today here in the German Bundestag how the government is dealing with the consequences of the recent ruling by the Federal Constitutional Court. On November 15, the court made a very detailed and far-reaching statement for the first time on how the so-called debt brake in the Basic Law is to be applied precisely. Prior to this, there had already been an urgent application on the same matter. In this decision, the court stated with regard to the regulation on the debt brake – I quote – that "the conditions for the relevant constitutional norms have not yet been delineated in the jurisprudence of the Senate." "Not yet delineated," means that much in dealing with the debt brake has so far been legally rather unclear.

In this situation, we made budgetary assessments two years ago that have now been legally rejected by the Constitutional Court. The Federal Constitutional Court has thus created clarity, and the court has the final word. This is a good democratic tradition.

Scientifically, the ruling may continue to be discussed, but politically, the discussion is over with the Karlsruhe ruling. With the knowledge of the current decision, we would have taken different paths in the winter of 2021. Paths that the court has also indicated in its ruling. The ruling affects the budgetary practice of this government, but also of previous and future governments. The ruling concerns the previous practice of the federal government as well as that of many states, not only because the states also use special assets in a manner similar to the federal government.

In recent days, we have been intensively discussing the consequences of the ruling. These discussions are – as should be expected – not yet concluded. Carefulness takes precedence over speed.

It is clear: This ruling creates a new reality – for the federal government and for all current and future governments at the federal and state levels. A reality that, however, makes it more difficult to achieve important and widely shared goals for our country.

It has also become difficult because Germany has been shaken in the past two years by severe, unforeseen external crises. This presents us with challenges that our republic has probably not experienced in this concentration and severity before.

527 deaths and 69,601 new infections per day – these were the numbers in the daily COVID report from the Robert Koch Institute on December 8, 2021. That was the day this federal government took office. Our country was then in the midst of the Delta wave; Omicron was on the horizon. Entire sectors of the economy were backed against the wall.

Two months later, Russia attacked Ukraine. There is no doubt about it: This war of conquest on European soil creates a completely changed security policy situation for Germany and for all of Europe for years to come.

Our country was inadequately prepared for this. We have drawn consequences from this, by the way, also together with your faction, Mr. Merz, and I am grateful for that.

Germany is today the second-largest supporter of Ukraine – after the United States of America – also in terms of arms deliveries. We will continue this support for as long as necessary. Our civilian support is added on top, through the federal budget and also through the European Union – money that we, of course, had not planned for when we took office and before the war began.

And yet this support is of existential importance – for Ukraine – that is clear – but ultimately also for us in Europe. Because none of us wants to imagine what even more serious consequences it would have for us if Putin were to win this war. More than a million Ukrainians – women, men, and children – have fled to Germany from suffering and death in their homeland within a few weeks. We have taken them in here; that was the right thing to do.

It was a matter of humanity. But of course, the reception of so many people represents an enormous effort, even for a strong country like Germany.

Shortly after the war began, Putin then initially reduced gas supplies to Germany and finally completely halted them overnight. Nord Stream 1 and one of the pipes of Nord Stream 2 were blown up, the pipelines that were supposed to supply us with cheap gas in the coming years, gas that my predecessor repeatedly and rightly referred to as the necessary bridging energy for the energy transition.

With the cessation of supplies from Russia, 120 billion cubic meters of gas were suddenly missing from the world market – mind you: with unchanged demand! You all know the consequences: Market prices skyrocketed; at one point, they had more than tenfold. And gas, our bridging energy, is still more than twice as expensive as it was at the beginning of the energy crisis.

This does not go unnoticed by an industrial country like Germany. We not only reacted quickly and built liquefied natural gas terminals on the northern German coasts in record time. In the past winter of 2022, we provided up to 200 billion euros to give citizens and our companies the security they needed to cope in this dramatic emergency.

And it was right to help; because in this way, we helped millions of citizens and many businesses through this extremely difficult time. From the very beginning, it was clear: It is not enough to look only at the winter of 2022/23. It was always also about the winter of 2023/24, of which nearly all experts have unanimously told us that it could be even more critical than the previous one. If we now anchor the funds that were necessary for these aids in the budget for 2023 once again, we are merely confirming what we had already decided at the end of 2022. What was necessary and right then is still just as necessary and right today.

I have just mentioned the COVID pandemic. Here too, it was necessary and right that we decided on extensive COVID aid in the previous government – over several years. Here too, it was about security and a perspective for the citizens. This is how and only how Germany has come through this century pandemic better than many other countries.

It was necessary and right that we decided on a special fund immediately after the start of the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine to strengthen and better equip our armed forces over the coming years.

And it was necessary and right that we helped the citizens of Rhineland-Palatinate and North Rhine-Westphalia, especially the citizens in the Ahr Valley, when their possessions were destroyed by the floodwaters in 2021.

Of course, the reconstruction after such a disaster is not completed in five months. Such a reconstruction, often from scratch, takes years. We owe it to the victims and those affected on the ground to stand in solidarity with them, just as we have jointly decided and promised.

We therefore want to anchor the aid for the Ahr Valley and the energy price assistance once again in the budget for this year and make use of the exception rule in Article 115 of the Basic Law. We propose this to you in connection with the supplementary budget for 2023. The Federal Constitutional Court has expressly indicated this path in its ruling. Moreover, it has confirmed that the legislature has a scope of assessment and judgment in exceptional emergency situations, as Article 115, paragraph 2, sentence 6 provides for.

However, the ruling creates a new reality in that aid in such emergency situations must now be newly decided by the Bundestag every year, but can also be newly decided. This takes into account the fact that the usual leeway of a regular budget cannot suffice in such emergency situations.

So how do we now specifically deal with this reality?

First:

On the very day of the ruling, the Federal Minister of Finance froze expenditures from the economic plan of the Climate and Transformation Fund. Exempt from the freeze are obligations that the federal government has already entered into contractually. Also exempt are measures that promote energy efficiency and the use of renewable energies in the building sector. This is required by legal certainty and reliability towards the citizens. With a supplementary budget for 2023, we will also reduce the reserves of the Climate and Transformation Fund by 60 billion euros.

Second:

We have made provisions so that new financial obligations for the coming years are not automatically entered into, and this will remain the case until we have precisely answered all the questions that arise from the ruling. It is important: Ongoing expenditures are not affected by this. The state will continue to fulfill its responsibilities. I say this also to the citizens who are unsettled due to some wild proposals and some targeted misinformation on social media. In your everyday life here and now, the ruling of the Federal Constitutional Court changes nothing, completely independent of whether you receive child benefits or BAföG, a pension or housing benefit.

Third:

We ensure that the ongoing budget for 2023 complies with all the requirements of the Federal Constitutional Court. The cabinet approved the draft of a supplementary budget for 2023 yesterday. This has been forwarded to the Bundestag as the budget legislator. In addition, we will propose to the Bundestag, as already mentioned, to pass a resolution in accordance with Article 115, paragraph 2 of the Basic Law. I just mentioned it: This secures retroactively the energy price brakes for 2023, which have become necessary due to the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine. This is important for the citizens, for our hospitals, and for the companies. And with this, we also secure support for the families affected by the floods in Rhineland-Palatinate and North Rhine-Westphalia.

It is important: In doing so, we are placing the funds already approved by the Bundestag for crisis management on a different legal basis. Thus, we are complying with the requirements of the Constitutional Court, but also with the fact that the energy price crisis is definitely not yet completely over and the destruction after a century flood has not yet been eliminated. That we can nevertheless end the energy price brakes at the beginning of the coming year has a simple reason: In the meantime, electricity and gas tariffs are available again throughout Germany, which, although significantly higher than before the crisis, are mostly below the upper limits we have set for the price brakes, and also noticeably below the prices in the previous autumn and winter. We have also filled our gas storage facilities so well that we do not expect sudden price jumps. It is also clear, however: Should energy prices rise dramatically again unexpectedly, we are always able to act quickly.

Fourth:

The governing factions decided last week to discuss the impact of the ruling on the budget draft for 2024 in detail. For this, they postponed the conclusion of the budget discussions. This gives us time to explore existing leeway in the budget, set priorities, and of course also to limit expenditures.

Together with the Bundestag, we are now working intensively to make all the decisions necessary for the budget 2024 as quickly as possible. Because the citizens and our companies need clarity in turbulent times. And it is clear: The citizens can trust that the state will keep its promises to them. We will not leave anyone alone with the challenges we are currently facing so intensely. "You’ll never walk alone," I promised last year, and that remains the case.

In the end, it is also about something fundamental, namely about cohesion in our country, about the social state. It is about the question: Does everyone stand alone when things get tough, or do we link arms? I am deeply convinced: We all fare better when we leave no one behind. We all fare better when we face the challenges side by side.

It is also clear: In our support for Ukraine and in dealing with the energy crisis, we must not let up in any way. That would be irresponsible, it would jeopardize our future. At the same time, it would be a serious, an unforgivable mistake to neglect the modernization of our country in dealing with all these acute challenges. This modernization is necessary and right. It creates the conditions for good jobs and a strong economy, so that the foundation of our future prosperity remains secure. Of course, the heads of government of the states also have the greatest interest in ensuring that future investments are realized locally, investments in the chip industry, in climate-friendly steel, or in battery factories, for example. Furthermore, we share a conviction: Only if Germany modernizes will we be able to respond powerfully to unforeseen crises in the future.

At the beginning of our government, we decided not to stand by any longer while Germany's infrastructure deteriorates. We realized: We must now invest vigorously in the modernization of Germany. We must now ensure that we successfully transform our economy in Germany and remain competitive as a strong industrial nation. And we must now do everything we can to finally advance the energy transition in Germany and Europe, which has been promised by many previous governments but never truly implemented. We must now resolve the backlog of reforms. We must now pick up the pace after years of stagnation.

I stand by all these goals. The federal government I lead has been working on all these goals from day one. The major modernization projects for our country have not become obsolete; on the contrary: No matter where you look, whether in the USA or France, in China or Japan, governments everywhere are investing massively in the future. Countries around the world are investing in modern and digital infrastructure, in clean energy supply, and in climate-friendly technologies. We are in the midst of a departure into a new era, comparable in its dimension only to the transition into the industrial age. Now, in the very next few years, it will be decided where value creation will take place in the future, where innovation and prosperity will be at home in a climate-neutral world.

I want Germany to be at the forefront; because it is a lot at stake for all of us. It is about secure jobs. It is about a competitive economy. It is about a good life for future generations. And it is about our ability to manage future crises safely. With these clear premises, we are now discussing the budget for the coming year, with the necessary calm and in responsibility for our country. The citizens can rely on that; I stand for that as Chancellor.

Thank you.