Government statement by Chancellor Olaf Scholz to the European Council on October 26/27, 2023, before the German Bundestag on October 19, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

19 October 2023 · Government statement to the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the Bundestag on October 19, 2023, delivering a government statement ahead of the European Council, following his visit to Israel and Egypt amid the Hamas-Israel crisis.
Main themes
Hamas attack on Israel, German solidarity with Israel, Middle East conflict escalation prevention, humanitarian aid for Gaza, hostage release, Hezbollah and Iran involvement, antisemitism in Germany, European Union unity, Israeli-Palestinian conflict, regional diplomacy, Ukraine-Russia war parallels
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,237
78th percentile
Sentences
154
82nd percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
10.9
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 35%34%
  • Institutional 30%29%
  • Social 20%19%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

154 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Madam President!

Dear colleagues!

Ladies and gentlemen!

Yesterday afternoon, I returned from a trip to Israel and Egypt. It was a journey into the gravest crisis the Middle East has faced in decades.

After the terrible attack by Hamas on Israel, it was very important for me to emphasize on the ground in Israel what many of us expressed here in the Bundestag last week: In this difficult time, Germany's place is firmly at Israel's side.

I also used the trip and my discussions – including with the King of Jordan, the Egyptian and Turkish Presidents, and the Emir of Qatar – to advocate for preventing this conflict from escalating further regionally. We all agree: Such a conflagration would be devastating for the entire region.

Therefore, it is now crucial that we do everything we can to help ensure that the situation does not escalate further, that there is no new escalation through a new front in the north. Therefore, I want to repeat here what I said last week in the Bundestag: There must be no entry of Hezbollah or Iran or their proxies into this war. That would be a grave mistake.

I am very glad that the discussions I was able to have with the Israeli Prime Minister, with the Israeli President, and also with Mr. Gantz, who has recently joined the government, all contribute to improving mutual understanding of the situation, as well as understanding what needs to be done. But we must also discuss the steps that are necessary. An important task we all have is to free the hostages and those who have been abducted. They must be released unconditionally.

That is why it was very important for me to speak with some of the relatives in Tel Aviv. It was difficult for them, as they described to me how they feel about the situation and what their emotions, fears, and worries are for their loved ones. But it was also something that deeply moved me and has not left me; because you can feel the fear and the concern. I want to explicitly say to all those who preach terror: Many of those who have been abducted were – as their relatives told me – always the foremost activists for peaceful development in the region. That must also be said here. We are committed to the release of the hostages.

But it is also about humanitarian aid for the citizens in Gaza. Because they are also victims and hostages of Hamas. They are not only used as human shields in this specific conflict, which is inhumane – it cannot be described otherwise – but they have also been brought under Hamas's control through a coup. And they are therefore helplessly exposed to the power and terror of Hamas.

From this perspective, it is very, very important that we find ways to ensure humanitarian aid. I have spoken with the Israeli government, with the King of Jordan, and with the Egyptian President. Together, we have tried to find ways to make this possible.

The American President was also in Israel and discussed these issues. I have the impression that now it could succeed – as difficult as it is – to find a way to ensure the most necessary supply of food, water, and medicine. Because it is also part of our clarity to say: Israel has every right to defend itself. But we are also clear with our Israeli friends that humanitarian aid is also part of what needs to be done. Israel is doing this, and we want to make it possible together.

For me, it is clear that we must not look away here at home. Antisemitism has no place in Germany. We will do everything to stand against it. We will do this as citizens, as those who bear political responsibility. But it is also about enforcing the laws and regulations that exist in Germany.

The authorities responsible for assemblies must be clear and must not allow gatherings where such crimes are anticipated and where it must be feared that antisemitic slogans will be shouted, that the death of people will be glorified – and all that which we cannot accept here. A clear stance is required here, and we show it together in Germany.

We have also talked a lot about these issues in Europe and held conferences. There was a joint statement from the European Council already over the weekend. The day before yesterday, we had a situation where we also discussed together. I was able to connect from Tel Aviv to a meeting of the European Council. I want to be very clear: We, as the European Union, stand united by Israel and will continue to do so together. We will continue to discuss this at the European Council.

I am also very touched that the Ukrainian President has found clear words regarding this war and the victims of violence. And this is very, very important because it relates to the solidarity of those who have been subjected to violence coming from outside and who have the right to defend themselves. However, I must say that I am more than outraged when I hear that the Russian President is currently warning everywhere that there could be civilian casualties from military conflicts. It cannot be more cynical than that.

We will discuss at the European Council what we need to do, how we can continue to support Ukraine. And of course, it is also about how we can ensure that the necessary actions are taken this winter. We in Germany are doing this by putting together a winter package that includes many aspects, especially everything necessary for air defense, by ensuring that there is an additional Patriot unit that can be deployed there, new IRIS-T systems delivered, new Gepard tanks, and new ammunition that is required. This is also part of our commitment to enable Ukraine to defend itself against the terrible rocket attacks, against the drones, against everything that is directed against the infrastructure, the civilian infrastructure of Ukraine. We will not relent in this.

And in Europe, we will also need to discuss how we can maintain financial assistance for Ukraine's budget management – a topic that will need to be discussed in the context of the medium-term financial framework. We have a clear position on this: This assistance for Ukraine, for the financial stability of the country, must be ensured by us as Europeans together. And at the same time, it is even more important – as we discuss this – that this cannot all be solved only with additional money that comes with demands on Europe, but that it also involves reprioritization. This is the position I will represent for the German government in Europe.

We will discuss questions that are important for the future of Europe. And I want to briefly address this here because it will be a topic of the European Council, namely the question: How can we strengthen the competitiveness of the European Union? For this, we need a lot of activities. I am very glad that the Commission has now come forward with proposals for reducing bureaucracy. And I will do everything to ensure that we tackle this in reality, that it does not remain just a paper, but becomes real policy of the European Union. I am glad that we find support in this from our French friends. We carefully discussed this at the German-French summit in Hamburg. Reducing bureaucracy in Europe will be a common theme for Germany and France and hopefully then for the entire European Union.

Because we are not done with all the projects that move us and that we need to address the crisis that has been triggered – first by the COVID-19 pandemic and then by the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine – it is necessary that the improvements and changes we have planned for state aid law actually take place and that we also manage to make this regulation usable for the future. I will advocate in Brussels for an extension until 2027.

We live in times when there are many, ever new challenges. I have already mentioned the wars: the war of Russia against Ukraine; the war that has now begun because Hamas attacked Israel with a terrible act of terror and harmed the citizens of the country. But it is clear: There are also other and new challenges that we face. And one of the biggest challenges we have to tackle is dealing with irregular migration, with the large number of those seeking protection in Europe, some of whom receive and should receive protection because they meet the criteria we have laid out in German and European laws. But there are also very, very many who do not meet these criteria. And therefore, it is necessary that we do what is necessary everywhere in Europe, in Germany, and here at all federal levels, so that we can manage to limit irregular migration in Europe and to Germany, that we can handle it as states, and that we always maintain control over this situation and do not lose it.

One of the major tasks in this is to protect the external borders – the external borders of Europe, mind you. And therefore, we will provide assistance to the European states that are at the external border in their efforts with our capabilities. We will ensure that European institutions contribute to this and also give them the legal means they need.

One of the major reforms that has now become possible is the reform of the Common European Asylum System. And I want to say it here and now: This reform, which has not progressed for many, many years, which has not succeeded for many, many years, is now possible because it has been achieved, also through the vigorous efforts of the Interior Minister, to ensure that there is a strong consensus in Europe on this issue.

There is a large faction with many former Interior Ministers – they are no longer in office, but still in their political ranks. And they have worked on this and have not finished it. Now it could actually succeed.

For the first time in many, many years, it has actually been possible for the Interior Ministers in Europe to reach a common decision on all the issues associated with it. Now we can be sure that in the negotiations with the Parliament, it will also be possible to reach an agreement. And I want to be very clear about what this is about: This is a European solidarity mechanism, in which the destination countries of secondary migration have a strong interest: namely Austria, Germany, the Netherlands, the Scandinavian countries, and some others, those who have to experience that a large part of those who appear at our borders have actually come through many other countries in Europe without ever being registered. And this will be changed with the agreements that are now associated with this. Everyone should be registered in the countries where they first arrive. And I find that a significant progress that is exactly in our interest.

Connected to this is the possibility that we also have a solidarity exchange; because this is necessary if everyone on the ground is to be registered. And it is also connected to the fact that we can improve the rejection, the return of those who do not have to process their asylum procedure here according to the Dublin rules.

But it is clear: It is also necessary that for those who have little prospect of successfully applying for asylum, quick decisions are made right at the European borders. All of this is included in this package, and I am very much in favor of putting all our ambition into making this happen now, after it has come so far.

Among the things we need to do, we must also not close our eyes. And that is why, in recent months, we have increased the protection of our German borders with our neighboring countries through repeated new decisions.

We have done this – also through agreements with Switzerland, Austria, the Czech Republic, and Poland – regarding joint police patrols, in many cases also on the territory of our neighboring countries, which is an effective measure. But we have also strengthened the protection of the border here at home and from Germany, and we will deploy more police for this purpose. And that is why it is necessary for us to notify the European Union about this enhanced practice and what we still want to do. The protection of Germany's borders is also a task that this government recognizes and will implement.

Among the things we have firmly resolved to do are, of course, faster asylum procedures here at home. We must document this in the agreements we have reached and will reach with the countries in the spring, summer, and now in November, and we must begin with the corresponding administrative practices that will actually make this possible. For me, at the center of this is the large repatriation package that the federal government is currently discussing and will present to the German Bundestag, which is to be passed this year. It will make it easier to carry out deportations. It will make it easier to establish identities. It will make it easier to deal with those who keep coming back and trying to submit new applications. It will make deportations more enforceable, also through an extension of detention. All of these are measures that are necessary, not least the fight against smuggling crime. All of this is included in these laws, and we will advance all of this together.

We also want to achieve that the administrations become faster in their actions. It should no longer be the case, as is currently the case, that there are some countries, such as Rhineland-Palatinate, where if someone appeals against their negative asylum decision in the first instance, it takes four and a half months to decide, while others take almost 40 months for the same.

We need a general acceleration of the procedures. This explicitly applies to what happens at the beginning. The asylum application and the hearing should take place in the initial reception facilities. That is what we will now agree upon with the countries. I am convinced that what we are doing will lead to a significant acceleration.

In addition, we will designate Moldova and Georgia, both of which aspire to join the European Union, as safe countries of origin. This is a step that we have not achieved for many, many years, the last time being when we made a corresponding regulation for the Western Balkan countries viable in the Bundestag and Bundesrat. And now we may hope that we will also gain a majority in the Bundesrat for this step after many years. This is a significant progress, and it is justified; because both countries are ones for whose citizens there should be no successful asylum applications, as they aspire to join the European Union.

However, the most important thing we need for the future are migration agreements. This is – I want to emphasize this – the decisive difference from much of what has happened in recent years. In many countries around the world, there are politicians who believe that a bold appearance can actually bring someone back, and they want to profile themselves with that. These are often the ones who fail – one can see this because sometimes even the number of asylum applications rises during their time in office – because they cannot find a way to establish cooperation with the countries of origin and transit. That is why migration partnerships are what we need, so that we not only have repatriation orders but can also enforce them, because the countries of origin must take back those who need to leave.

And we will achieve this because we now have something to offer; because with the changes we have made with our Skilled Workers Immigration Act, we can say: We are opening a desperately needed legal pathway for the immigration of workers and talents to Germany, which we need so that our economy does not shrink but grows. At the same time, we are using agreements that ensure that all those who need to be returned are taken back quickly and without bureaucracy.

We are currently negotiating this with many governments. The Federal Government's Commissioner already has six concrete corresponding agreements in view that he is negotiating, and we will add more. I can report from many conversations with heads of government and state leaders from around the world: There is great interest in this and also a willingness to agree on both parts of such an agreement with us, which would be a significant progress and a significant change. And I want to add: I have also requested that German diplomats, German ministers address this issue in their discussions with foreign governments and ensure that those we want to return are also taken back.

Many citizens are complaining about this, and many representatives in the communities, many mayors, and district administrators say this: It cannot be that on the one hand there are great labor needs, and then those who are here cannot work. Therefore, we will do many things that are necessary for this.

We will expand the opportunities to work for those who are refugees here and will stay, with laws that enable bureaucratic action possibilities on the ground, and we will ensure that this works. By the way, we will also launch a major offensive so that Ukrainian citizens who are in Germany and have completed language and integration courses can now all enter the German labor market.

And we will do everything to support what the municipalities and states want to undertake in this regard. I welcome it when community service is offered locally. I support it when in the facilities, material benefits are offered instead of cash payments; this option already exists from the legislator today. I support states and municipalities when they want to develop a uniform payment card to facilitate payment transactions in this way. All of this is something we need to work together on in Germany. There will be concrete support and concrete assistance from the federal government for those who need to act on the ground.

At this point, I want to say that we must work together. That is why I was very pleased with the conversation I had with the two speakers of the Prime Ministers' Conference, Mr. Rhein and Mr. Weil, and the opposition leader Mr. Merz. I believe this is a topic that requires factual cooperation between democrats, between those responsible in government and opposition, at the federal and state levels, and in municipalities. My impression is: A new willingness has emerged to do this. Thank you for that. Good!

In conclusion: Citizens expect humanity and order. They expect that the federal government, states, and municipalities pull together. We are doing this, and we will continue to do so in the future. This task must be solved. It can be solved with a clear stance and without any resentment. That is what citizens expect from us. The federal government will contribute its part to this.

Thank you very much.