Speech by Chancellor Olaf Scholz at an exchange on the job turbo on September 30, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

2 October 2024 · Exchange on the job turbo · Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed a Berlin exchange event on September 30, 2024, reviewing the Job Turbo program's progress in integrating refugees into the German labor market.
Main themes
Refugee employment integration, Job Turbo initiative, job center operations, labor market integration, work as integration criterion, language and integration courses, recognition of foreign qualifications, pragmatism in placement, Ukrainian refugees, childcare infrastructure, female refugee employment, employer engagement
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,943
55th percentile
Sentences
106
66th percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
9.6
16th percentile
Syntax
2.84
26th percentile
Vocabulary
1.88
2nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 40%40%
  • Social 34%34%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

106 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to begin with a threefold thank you: My first thank you goes to all of you for being here today and for allowing us to exchange ideas about what is working well and also about where there is still room for improvement. My second thank you is directed to the employees of our job centers. We just saw in the film: There was talk of rethinking and restarting with regard to the Job Turbo. Above all, however, due to the Russian war in Ukraine, you literally had to advise and place hundreds of thousands of additional clients overnight – women and men who often bring very different backgrounds, hurdles, and qualifications than those previously seen among clients in the job centers. The fact that and how you have taken on this task is truly commendable. Thank you number three goes to all refugees who work here in Germany and contribute to securing our prosperity, and to their employers who have given them a chance. Some of them are here today – welcome!

I can imagine how difficult it is to start from scratch in a foreign country, without language skills, without recognized professional qualifications, and perhaps also in a completely new field of work. That deserves support. And that also deserves recognition. Support and recognition are also due to the many companies, craft businesses, hospitals, daycare centers, and nursing homes that employ refugees – even if their German language skills are not yet perfect or if the stamp of the recognition authority for a foreign professional qualification is still missing.

My credo is: We need maximum pragmatism on all sides. Above all, however, there must be a goal above all else. And that goal is to get refugees into work faster than before. Of course, the thought also plays a role that we do not want to support inaction with taxpayer money, as that is not justifiable to anyone. This harms the acceptance of refugees and, overall, the many diligent people who are also contributing here. That is why we have quickly relaxed work bans for refugees and created a residence permit for long-term tolerated individuals.

Getting refugees into work as quickly as possible is also important for another reason: Work is – and I am deeply convinced of this – the decisive criterion for successful integration. And work is much more than just earning money. In the workplace, you have colleagues and a social environment – we just heard a few examples of this and how it was emphasized. You learn the language through daily interaction and, of course, much about the country in which you live. And above all, a workplace is always associated with receiving affirmation and social recognition.

For all these reasons, we launched the Job Turbo at the end of last year. And I still remember very well the many detailed discussions that all those gathered here had about it. In a difficult economic environment, employment of individuals from Ukraine and the eight main asylum countries increased in comparison to the previous year, and in July 2024 – these are the current figures – it rose to 266,000 among Ukrainians – an increase of 71,000 – and to 704,000 among individuals from the main asylum countries. Coincidentally, that is also an increase of 71,000 compared to the previous year.

The Job Turbo has contributed to this increase since October 2023. And the question is whether this is already a success. I believe: Yes. Can and do we want to improve further? Yes, as well. A new study by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development confirms that we in Germany are achieving very decent results, especially in the medium and long term, regarding the integration of refugees into the labor market. We are better than the majority of comparable European countries. This is, of course, also due to the fact that we lay a solid foundation for entering the workforce with our language and integration courses. 86 percent of male refugees who came to the country eight years ago are now employed here in Germany – a figure that I believe is not widely known.

For women – I must also mention this here – the situation is different. Many factors play a role – let’s say, for instance, the lack of childcare. But there will also be many other causes contributing to the fact that this has not yet worked out. I believe we need to make some progress with cultural understandings of work and family. In the meantime, we are doing a lot to help improve the childcare infrastructure in Germany. We are investing four billion euros in daycare centers and better childcare options. Above all, however, we must become overall faster and more pragmatic when it comes to placement. For me, this means two things:

First: From the very first conversation, it should be clarified what someone has learned and what work experience they have. This should also be documented for job placement. If necessary, a recognition procedure can then be initiated immediately, preferably in parallel with the integration courses. We must not lose any time here. We cannot afford that in times of labor and skilled worker shortages. That is why we are changing course. With over 65,000 positively decided recognition procedures – an increase of 25 percent compared to the previous year – we achieved a new record in 2023. I want to explicitly say: This is a success in light of the past. I remember that I once proposed as Minister of Labor to change something, which only succeeded on the second attempt.

Since then, such a thing has existed. But it is still far from perfect. And that is why we are advocating to all those responsible, especially in the states, that recognitions become overall faster, more digital, more uniform, and simpler. The vast majority of federally regulated recognition applications are processed by 47 responsible authorities. That number needs to be reduced. And the criteria must not differ in every state and every chamber. As a new approach, we are therefore examining a uniform nationwide responsibility for the recognition of nursing professionals.

But let us not forget: In most professions, one can also work without recognition. I would like to see more pragmatism in reality, which is not the case in other countries like ours. Countries with a different, less established professional tradition handle this more loosely – for example, the USA, where professionalism as a criterion does not even exist in the same way. And while it is indeed the case that a dishwasher can become a millionaire – this must be explicitly stated – it is a permanent “training on the job” that constitutes reality. People prove themselves in the workplace because these nice professional qualifications we have do not exist to the same extent. That is not good. But if this leads to the situation where one cannot even demonstrate one’s talents in the private sector just because one does not have the right paper, then that is a problem and a cultural tradition that we can break even without changing the law.

My second point concerns the Job Turbo and its three phases. Yes, language acquisition is important and is intentionally designed as phase one of the Job Turbo. But that does not mean that one cannot already work or be placed in a job in parallel to language acquisition. I know that for many professions, German is important. But there are also many activities where one can start with limited German skills. The migration of guest workers to West Germany and contract workers to the GDR largely occurred without language acquisition. People had to start working right away.

Now, it does not always have to be that way. We have our integration and language courses. But the fact that someone is practically prevented from starting to work when employers and employees want that should not be the reality of our republic; rather, I believe that several parties need to change their attitudes. I believe some companies that can still see in their own archives who came to them in the 1960s could perhaps learn that they can simply dare to hire people who have talent and want to contribute. The rest worked out quite well back then. Why should it not be the same today? So, I am again advocating for pragmatism among refugees, employers, and of course – I can say this – among the job centers and the placement staff there. I would like to encourage everyone who is here.

Perhaps I may add something: When things are going well, one is already literate and is essentially not engaged in anything else – good conditions that are not always present – then, I have been told, it takes hardly more than a year to speak German well enough to communicate everywhere and with everyone. This may indicate that it is not such an insurmountable hurdle after all.

Of course, I admit: If there are people waiting for placement who may have been hardly literate in their own countries or only attended school for three or four years, then that is more difficult. But the world is such that many of them have acquired all these skills and qualifications over the course of their lives. And that is why we should simply give it a try and say: Here, do everything you can to make this work!

The CEO of the job placement agency Stepstone, Sebastian Dettmers, wrote a book some time ago and called it “The Great Worker Shortage” instead of “Unemployment.” There is a lot of truth to that, especially when we look at our demographic development and how many so-called baby boomers will retire in the coming years.

At the same time, we know: There is no country on earth whose economy grows sustainably while having a shrinking working population. That is why we must do everything, really everything, to get those who are already here into work as quickly as possible. How important this is is shown by looking at two numbers:

The number of foreign employees has increased by 283,000 people in the past twelve months. Without these employees, the number of employed persons in Germany would have decreased by 163,000 – and that within a year. If you look around Europe, you see that similar developments are even taking place in other countries because they do not have a balance through labor from other countries. The forecasts for the employment of some countries in Europe that this entails are daunting. But they are indeed very surprising.

Therefore – I want to point this out to everyone – it would be good to maintain and further develop an open understanding of labor forces that are active in the labor market and come from other countries. This has helped Germany in recent decades – with social security contributions that have not become too high, with tax revenues, and with the financing of our tasks. And, as can be calculated quite simply, this will remain the case.

We certainly want Germany to remain a growing country. For this, we have created a modern immigration law, a growth initiative that sets work incentives, launched better childcare offerings, and – last but not least – the Job Turbo. It is important to me to acknowledge your contributions to this. That is why we are here today.

Now I look forward to the exchange and hand over to Andrea Nahles, the head of the Federal Employment Agency, who of course must not be absent.

Thank you for your attention!