Speech by Chancellor Scholz at the 2023 Economic Conference of the SPD Parliamentary Group on October 11, 2023, in Berlin

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

11 October 2023 · 2023 Economic Conference of the SPD Parliamentary Group · Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the SPD Parliamentary Group's 2023 Economic Conference in Berlin on October 11, 2023, discussing Germany's economic challenges and geopolitical crises.
Main themes
German economic resilience, energy security, inflation and supply chain diversification, Hamas terrorist attack on Israel, German solidarity with Israel, migration and irregular migration, SPD economic policy, post-COVID recovery, Intel investment in Germany, historical responsibility
Duration
~42 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,096
92nd percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
9.9
20th percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
1.81
1st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 34%34%
  • Institutional 20%19%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Environmental 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

216 sentences in 64 paragraphs

Dear Verena,

dear Rolf,

thank you very much for the invitation, for the opportunity to say a few words here. I do not want to make it too long in the end, because we want to discuss together, but it is of course a very special time in which we are discussing here.

Corona has still somehow had a grip on all of us, and we thought: Now it’s starting again! - And then came this terrible war that Russia has started against Ukraine, with dramatic consequences, for example regarding energy prices and energy security.

Who could have predicted last autumn, as everyone feels so certain today, that we would get through the winter? Who would have really believed that a country that imported 50% of its gas from Russia would be able to replace that when the import from Russia suddenly stops, without having previously built the infrastructures needed for it to actually work? But we managed it. And we also contributed with a lot of money that we invested to get through such a time.

We have the issue of inflation, which is not only related to the war, not only to Corona, but also to secular changes that some economists have written about for a long time, but were hardly heard when they said: This is a very special phase we have had over the last 30 years, with full employment and low inflation - which ultimately had something to do with the fact that part of the world produced a lot for another part of the world. But something has emerged: in Asia, in South America, even in many places in Africa, and hopefully much more, where independent demand is now arising. And we notice that, because at the moment that happens, it will of course be the case that the things that were previously cheap there will also become more expensive for us. A decision that we derive from the war, that we do not want to rely solely on one supply chain or one export market, one location for direct investments, has consequences for the costs that this entails.

Here, Intel has been mentioned, which is kindly diversifying and wants to invest in Europe and has also realized that these investments would make sense in Germany - like some other competitors as well. But it is a decision not to stick to one’s own location, because the world is safer when you have many locations. This investment is one that we benefit from, but it is now taking place everywhere - sometimes with one result, sometimes with another.

Nevertheless, I find that these are very challenging times, and new challenges keep arising. One I want to mention here: This is the terrorist attack by Hamas on Israel.

I want to say it quite openly: I feel no different than probably everyone here in the room. When you see the images of abducted children, women, families, people who are murdered in their beds, who are humiliated, who are dragged through the streets, who are degraded even in death, then that is something that does not leave you, and where you also feel the horror that in Israel everyone feels even more, because they are afraid for their own lives, for the lives of friends and relatives and loved ones.

This is something that touches us deeply, and I am very grateful that tomorrow I can give a government statement on this before the German Bundestag, which is also supported by what the parties in Germany, many parties in Germany, jointly declared over the weekend, by what we hear from the democratic factions of the German Bundestag, who have initiated a joint declaration. Here, especially in light of our history, it is about showing solidarity with Israel as a united country, in awareness of our own historical responsibility, but also in the awareness of ensuring that peace and security in Israel are guaranteed.

A major issue is also moving us, not just us. When you look around the world, this applies to many wealthy countries, such as the USA, similar to Europe: This is the question of migration on the one hand and irregular migration as part of it, the movement of refugees that is taking place from all over the world to safe and often wealthy countries like ours.

We know that this is something where we also have to take responsibility and want to take responsibility, because some may still remember what was reported from the time of Nazi rule: that ships docked here and could not land anywhere and returned, and that the people who returned, who had fled Germany full of hope, all died. - By the way, a reason why we enshrined the right to asylum in our Basic Law as an individual right in Germany. - By the way, of those who apply, 1.5% - most others have other grounds for protection - which we accept from international or European treaties like others in the world as well.

But there were reasons why we did that, and that must not be overlooked when discussing the challenges that cannot be ignored. This humanitarian impulse is part of the founding conditions of our republic.

But I want to be very clear: Currently, far too many are coming to Europe and Germany in an irregular manner. Therefore, it is also our task to limit irregular migration to Germany, to ensure that fewer come.

The numbers we have are quite impressive. We have granted protection to about 1 million people who have come from Ukraine - more than, for example, are currently in our neighboring country Poland - a large number. That has worked quite well - with a lot of support from citizens. But then, due to global developments last year, another 240,000 came who applied, and this year it could be 300,000, maybe even more. If you add all this up for two years, no one who has political responsibility can shy away from the statement that there are more than can be easily managed, even for a large country like Germany, and that is why it is about reducing the numbers.

We have made many decisions regarding this, for example, that we agree with other European countries that the borders, the external borders of Europe must be secured. We have also worked very hard to ensure that Europe finally cooperates, that there is a solidarity mechanism. This has now succeeded after many, many years at the meeting of the European interior ministers, and we are now in discussions with the European Parliament and will succeed.

We have said that we will take a path that we have taken from time to time, last time I believe eight years ago, that countries from which so many come, but hardly anyone is recognized - like Moldova and Georgia, countries that want to join the European Union - are considered safe countries of origin, so that the procedures are very quick and efficient. We have agreed with the countries on how procedures can be quick and efficient: that all authorities on site are available 24 hours a day, that there is digitization, that we also work together to make the procedures efficient. That is right.

Of course, I understand everyone who tries to exploit the inefficiencies of our system in some way. But as a state, we must ensure that we are efficient. That is why I have decided that we will seek a vote among the ministries of the federal government with the states and with the associations on a repatriation package that we want to initiate in Germany, which contains all the many individual steps that lead to making such repatriations better and easier possible. This includes, for example, a regulation that says: 28 days of custody prior to deportation, when it has become necessary, is possible if it cannot be achieved in another way. This is not an easy step, but one that is necessary if we want to ensure the efficiency of the entire system.

The states are also currently discussing these matters, and they wish for something similar. This also applies to some other issues that are now being discussed regarding community facilities, regarding the question of whether more material benefits can be provided, regarding the question of whether community service can be offered locally. We welcome it when states and municipalities make such offers. They are provided for in the law and can be utilized. We will not only have nothing against this, but we will support everyone in doing so. But it is important that we work together on this issue. Therefore, I hope that from the meeting that the prime ministers are having now, something will come by Friday that is very similar to the things we have been preparing for a year and have gradually put on the legislative path. Everything speaks in favor of it, when I hear what is being discussed.

And I have also invited, alongside the representatives of the states, the speakers of the Prime Ministers' Conference, Mr. Rhein and Mr. Weil, and also the opposition leader for Friday evening, because it would be good if we could work together on this matter. I wanted to mention this here, even though it may not be an economic policy issue, but it concerns everyone, and that is why I wanted to say it. I believe this is a topic where the state must show that it also has things under control. That is part of our tasks.

But I am also concerned with a topic that must also move us when it comes to economic growth, namely the question: Do we have enough workforce? This will have played a role here as well. I know that this is a daily topic for many businesses, small, medium-sized, large businesses, service providers, industrial companies. Everyone is asking: How will things be? - And everyone has reasons when they look at the calculator.

The somewhat cutely described generation, to which Rolf and I also belong, are the baby boomers, men and women just under and just over 60 - I see a few others. 13 million of us will soon retire - not me; I have decided to work longer. That is a trend; others are doing that too; so it’s not bad.

But: 13 million is quite a lot. And we will be able to cope with that by being simply excellent in terms of education, by doing everything necessary: with crèches, with daycare centers, with all-day offers, with always new opportunities for everyone to achieve a proper school graduation. It is good if we succeed, for example, with youth employment agencies to ensure that the transition from school to vocational training or later to a degree is successful for others, that one or another qualification is relevant for many, by making employment more attractive - even in a circle of many entrepreneurs, I would like to advocate for minimum wages and good wages - by ensuring that it continues to work.

I was really very pleased when I visited many companies that are finally doing what I, as Minister of Labor in 2008/2009, almost in vain advocated for: namely, that they qualify 30-, 40-, 50-year-olds who have been in the company for a long time and work as unskilled and semi-skilled workers, so that they can then be deployed more broadly. There are even subsidies for that.

We must of course do something about the employment of women. Not only is the wage gap between men and women unchanged, a bit too large, but it is also the case that in many places where women could do something, there are hardly any or only a few. There is still room for improvement.

The employment of women has improved; we are almost at Scandinavian levels, but there is still more to be done. And if we could also reduce the part-time rate a bit and become a bit more Scandinavian, then much more could be achieved.

But all of this together, and also if we succeed in having older people say, "I would like to work until the retirement age" or perhaps even voluntarily beyond that without raising the statutory retirement age, then all of this together will not be enough to replace those 13 million. And that is why we also need skilled labor immigration. This is very, very important to me.

I just said something about irregular migration. But regular migration of men and women who bring exactly what we need, what we require, from workers, caregivers to doctors and engineers, would of course benefit us greatly.

How much the prosperity of some nations depends on showing this openness can be seen in the USA. There is one thing that never leaves my mind: Half of those who earn a doctorate in the USA - a Ph.D., something similar - were not born in the USA.

Yesterday, I had a conversation in Hamburg with my friend Emmanuel Macron and the ministers from Germany and France with a German AI expert, who is a professor at Stanford and an entrepreneur, Mr. Socher for those who want to know him, and he told me: 80% of those he works with in California were not born in the USA.

Therefore, of course, our prosperity very much depends on the fact that we have managed to have a population today that has a 25% immigration background - with a very conservative counting method. But the fact that we can do this and that we must do it also means that we must always consider these two things in their own reality: irregular and regular migration, that we understand the interrelations, but that we still properly organize each path on its own so that we maintain control - and sometimes they also fit together. Because if I make a contract with a country from which we need skilled workers and labor, in which I say, "It states that they can come" - and how that can work simply and well organized - "those we need because they have a work contract, they are needed here, or we have a points system" and at the same time say, "But those who have to go back, you must take them back," whether they are criminals, which we can expect, or people who sought the wrong path by trying to organize immigration through asylum, which did not happen for reasons of flight, then that is something that can work.

The speeches of some politicians in this world are always like this - it is no different for Germany than anywhere else - that they say: "This must be done this way!" And then you look - and what happens? - Nothing. Then comes the next speech: "This must be done this way!" And what happens? - Nothing. We should focus on the things that are effective.

What no one can overcome is that one's own sovereignty, what can be regulated by one's own laws, always ends at one's own national border. And if you want others to take someone back, you have to convince them to do so. However, we now have the best argument for fair contracts, which are in our interest and in the interest of those with whom we conclude them, due to the fact that we need labor. We want to do this, also for the benefit of our economy.

We want to renew the economy, and we want to make it CO2-neutral, this has been discussed here multiple times - from various perspectives. A great challenge, I believe, one does not need to philosophize about it for long. But it is one where it is now very important that we experience the moment where everyone is sure: It will succeed.

To make the magnitude of what we are currently doing understandable, I always tell myself and then like to share with others: This is almost like the industrial mobilization that Germany had at the end of the 19th century. Leuna, which was established at the beginning of the 20th century, was built in two years on green fields with then 10,000 jobs, with processes that had not yet been industrially tested; they came directly from the lab to the factory. Such a thing was possible.

We need that pace, that enthusiasm for progress now, and the confidence that it will succeed. And if I should describe what I believe is currently the issue for many companies and for many citizens as well: Will it be so or will it not be so? Can one believe that it will succeed? We should talk about that and not beat around the bush. My answer is: Yes. But there are reasons why everyone - or many - are not so sure.

The first is: Everything is new. So before it has worked, one cannot be sure that it will work. And it is not simply more of the same or anything else, it is different. But once it works and you see how everything runs, it also goes faster, and the confidence grows. - We are at the moment where we must set off and everyone must jump on the train. That is what we as a nation must achieve as a performance - also emotionally and morally.

At the same time, it is also the case that incredibly many are shaped by what they have seen. Our country is great. We have, to make it really stick, exited nuclear energy twice, once at the turn of the millennium with Schröder and Fischer and then again - black-yellow - with Mrs. Merkel after the reactor accident in Fukushima. And because the drama was not enough, we discussed in the end: Should we extend it for a few more months? - We did! So actually two and a half times. But now we are out.

We made a second decision: We are phasing out coal-fired power generation. This was firmly agreed upon in the last government with Mrs. Merkel and me. A large conference, Mr. Brudermüller was also there, we negotiated until late at night. We had previously discussed with the states how much money we would pay for the transformation; it ended up being double, but whatever - or however. In any case: We had already achieved that.

But then no one noticed that we were starting somewhere, that it was working, but everything got delayed: The expansion targets for the power lines kept being pushed further back! Some people almost chained themselves to prevent construction here. Then they also had to go underground! Everywhere, the approval times for wind power plants - onshore, offshore - were extended, six years for such a small - they are no longer small - wind power plant. That is absurd!

If you add all this up, you must truthfully say: If we let everything just develop on its own, we would not finish in time. That is part of the truth.

With the laws that my government started in 2021, we would not finish in time. That is why we have passed many new laws. But the mentality must be turned around. We must not do everything one after the other and then see that one fits into the other, but we must say: If it means 80% renewable electricity and even more than today, not 600, but maybe 750 or 800 terawatt-hours of electricity by 2030, in seven years, then we must count: How many wind power plants is that actually? How many power grids is that actually? And we must look backward: What kind of pace do we need to ensure that it actually succeeds? And what I would like to tell you here is: Exactly that is what we have done. We have made all these decisions, we have changed the laws, and we are even changing a few more to make it even faster. But the message is: We are ready. For the approvals, we have reached the speed for onshore wind plants that we need to achieve the goal by 2030. For solar plants, we have even already reached the scales in terms of what has been built. And if we continue like this, adding a bit more speed, then it will succeed.

We have changed laws, changed laws across Europe that are intended to increase the speed. That, I think, is the first good message: One can now justifiably rely on the fact that it will succeed.

We have also done many other things, for example, written into the law: What does the final electricity system look like in 2045? - Then it will not remain with the long-delayed lines that we currently know, but five more will come - large ones: from north to south, from west to east, and across the country! But then we already know it now, it is already in the law: One can start planning right away, it is faster and can then also be built so that it is finished on time. One can rely on that.

We are now thinking about how to organize a 24/7 electricity system. Because it is not the case that most people say, "I will take the electricity when it is there" - that is nice, one can do that, but not for everyone. Therefore, I think one must also ensure that this is the case. And we need corresponding generation capacities when there is no sun, no wind, and that with hydropower and biomass is not enough to still produce the electricity that industry and the economy, we all need. We are making that decision now as well.

We know that the future of the CO2-neutral industry is electrified. But we also know that it needs a gas, instead of oil and gas, a natural gas, namely hydrogen. But then it must be produced in large quantities, here at home with the electrolyzers, which we must regulatory unlock so that it can simply be built and not prevented by all sorts of legal regulations, which would never make it a business model. And then we must ensure that we can import hydrogen and that others can create a large business worldwide with us together, as large as the gas and oil business of the past, with Argentina and South Africa, with Namibia, with the Arabian Peninsula, with Ukraine, with many others. And we are doing that too.

And we are building a hydrogen network. This year, if it works out, we will make the decision: about a private sector investment of more than 20 billion for the establishment of a hydrogen network, whereby of course the money is not earned at the beginning, but over 30, 40, 50 years. Such a thing can be a proper capitalism like the German one - it has gotten out of practice because everything was always there. Therefore, we are very far along with those who are doing this, and we are organizing in a good public-private partnership how it can work so that one can now start with the investment, knowing that initially less hydrogen will flow through the pipes than later and that it must pay off over the distance. But we are doing it.

That means: What I want to advocate here is to have the confidence that we have understood exactly what needs to be done to create the infrastructural technological prerequisites for an economic development that is CO2-neutral and keeps us competitive as an industrial nation.

Now there are still some who believe: The gas and oil will all come back. - I do not believe that. We will process oil, but as a material, just as we process steel, but we will no longer heat with it and we will not use it as fuel and as a combustible.

That is why it is so important that one answers a question, connecting to what I said at the beginning: What happens if, with ups and downs, back and forth, but still over the course of time, the success of globalization continues and by 2050 perhaps 10 billion people in the world - perhaps 2050, perhaps only 2070 - have a prosperity like we did in 1950? For that, we have not buried enough gas in any earth, not enough coal, not enough oil, and also not enough of everything else, by the way, I believe, also not enough uranium.

One must always answer this question when one says: It has gone well so far and it will continue to go well. - Everyone does not understand that this is a question of mathematics, where one must calculate: If now everyone also becomes an industrial demander just like us, which we wish for them to be the same, with as many cars as in Germany, everywhere, in Africa, in Latin America, in Asia - that does not go well with the technologies we have today, and it will be unaffordable. Therefore, it is not just a good-hearted argument when we say, "We want that," it is also indispensable for our own economic future that we succeed in producing prosperity without impairing biodiversity and climate, and that is exactly the path we have taken.

Two more things are important to me. The first is: It must go faster. I have already said it for the transformation that I have described concretely. But it applies overall.

Speed also has something to do with growth - by the way, also with the question of where the investment takes place. Sometimes it helps if one has already been a mayor. So there is, for example, an industrial settlement, and in the city, it is said, "We have a finished development plan, the access road is already finished, actually, you can start next year and build your hall there." And if it goes really well: "We have already built one, maybe it fits." The other says: "Yes, there is the area, the development plan will be finished in four years, do we want to risk the project?" If one is planning something like Intel, then that might be a number. Or if Mr. Brudermüller comes and says, "I would like to build Leuna again here," then we also say, "Everything will be done." It is still something that one must keep in mind: Speed counts. And the trust in speed is also important for investments.

I was recently in New York and took the opportunity to have the Empire State Building shown to me, an old building, yet tall, very pretty. The construction time, I believe, was 15 months. In that time, we wouldn’t have approved it — and neither would anyone else in the developed world, not even in the USA. We don’t need to think of ourselves as worse than others; we are just like everyone else.

And I believe that is the point where what I have called the Germany Pact comes into play. It was about the question: Can we link arms and do all the things necessary to achieve the pace we need? Because it has been lovingly worked on with care, energy, and imagination for decades by all parties, municipalities, districts, states, and federal governments to get us to where we are today. And at some point, that becomes too much.

And it also involves banal questions. One of the things we have now decided is to create an expert database so that when you need an expert, you can find one. But the real question is: Why do we need so many experts? And has anyone ever counted whether what we are planning can be realized with the physically possible number of experts? The answer is: No.

This means we have no chance of sticking to what we have. That is why I have deliberately designed it as a cross-party and cross-institutional concept, because if everyone has been going in one direction for so long, then I believe they must also go together in the other direction and always tell themselves, “What we are doing isn’t so bad,” and “Hopefully, this is what will succeed.”

I said that was the penultimate remark; the last remark will also come, and then we will be done with what I want to say here at the outset.

I also advocate, quite independently of that, for optimism or confidence regarding Germany as a business location. We all know the problems; they have been discussed here, and I agree with everyone, but I explicitly say: It is quite strange: If so many direct investments are taking place in Germany now, if large and small companies decide they want to invest in Europe and then come to Germany, and we somehow feel that the opposite is the case. I was recently at Ford in Cologne and had the opportunity to work with a Mr. Ford on the fact that there will soon be electric vehicles from this nearly 100-year-old plant in Cologne. It is being remodeled, and then they will come. A great industrial story, an American company in Germany.

A newly emerged American automotive company with electric vehicles has decided it wants to build a large factory in Europe and has come to Germany and Brandenburg and wants to expand it further. Brandenburg just had an economic growth of 6%. That is the situation in which we feel: Everything is passing us by.

There are several battery factories being invested in in Germany, and we want a few more and are negotiating about it. That’s not bad.

The semiconductors have already been discussed here. That is also a strange story. They are coming to Germany because the ecosystem for highly qualified semiconductor production is still present here, and great semiconductors are also produced here in Germany; the know-how exists. And actually, only the state and industry took a detour about 30 years ago and said: This is a business that is too expensive for us, it has too high capital binding, let others do it, it can always be bought cheaply somewhere. - Then we learned: That was probably a mistake. But when many companies — and it’s not just Intel, it’s Wolfspeed, it’s Bosch, it’s Infineon, it’s GlobalFoundries, which are already here — decided to invest anew and significantly here, they did so into an ecosystem that already exists.

And that should be the conclusion. We should remain confident. We can do it too.

Thank you very much!