Speech by Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz at the beginning of the questioning of the Federal Government before the German Bundestag on November 15, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

15 November 2023 · Questioning of the Federal Government before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the Bundestag on November 15, 2023, responding to a Constitutional Court ruling invalidating a 2021 supplementary budget and outlining key government policy priorities.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court ruling on supplementary budget, Climate and Transformation Fund restructuring, irregular migration management, Germany Pact Tempo planning reforms, electricity price relief for manufacturers, Ukraine solidarity and Russian aggression, federal budget crisis, refugee financing, digitization and hydrogen economy
Duration
~8 min
30th percentile
Words
1,017
30th percentile
Sentences
50
33rd percentile
Readability
41
37th percentile
Grade
12.9
56th percentile
Syntax
2.96
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 34%32%
  • Institutional 32%30%
  • Geopolitical 21%20%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

50 sentences in 18 paragraphs

Madam President!

Dear colleagues!

I would like to first address the ruling that the Federal Constitutional Court has issued today. It has declared that the supplementary budget law from 2021 is not in accordance with the Constitution. This is a decision that the federal government and certainly the budget legislator will take into account – yes, that we will take into account – and we will now carefully examine what the specific implications are. Such an examination is also appropriate. Because when one closely considers many of the accompanying considerations, it may lead to a very profound change in the budgetary practices of the states in Germany, but also of the federal government. And there should be no hasty decisions, but rather a careful examination.

I have spoken with the parliamentary leaders of the governing coalition about how we want to proceed regarding the ongoing budget discussions. This is, of course, a matter for Parliament. In this respect, the government has no guidance to provide. But I can inform you from these discussions that there is a shared understanding that the budget discussions can continue, regarding the reconciliation meeting and decision-making processes.

However, the ruling of the Federal Constitutional Court has immediate consequences for the Climate and Transformation Fund, for which the 60 billion euros allocated in 2021 are no longer available. Therefore, the economic plan will need to be discussed anew, and it must be restructured. In order for this to work well, the Federal Minister of Finance has decided, in accordance with his responsibilities, to impose a freeze on future commitments, except for immediate measures that deal with issues such as building emissions and similar matters. In this respect, this is something that can be a good practice and allows sufficient time to make a careful decision about which funds from the Climate and Transformation Fund are available, so that the work of the state and the government can continue.

We now find ourselves in a very special situation in which we come together. I want to return to three decisions and considerations from last week that will also be important for our discussions today and likely for your questions as well.

At the beginning of last week, an agreement was reached with the 16 states regarding a common approach to irregular migration. This is now the third very comprehensive decision we have made following the Chancellor's meeting with the heads of government of the states in the spring and the corresponding meeting in the summer. An agreement has also been reached on the permanent financing of fluctuating numbers of refugees. Accordingly, as the federal government, when the number of refugees increases, we will provide more money to the states and municipalities, and when it decreases, we will reduce it accordingly. Above all, however, a significant improvement in the management of irregular migration and also in legislation has been agreed upon, which is now being implemented step by step. Some of the discussions in the German Bundestag on this matter are already underway. This has been a significant step, and it will also ensure that our shared responsibility can be fulfilled well.

The

second

agreement reached with the states at this point is regarding the question of the Germany Pact "Tempo." We have agreed on 100 individual measures that are intended to help ensure that planning and approval processes in Germany proceed more quickly, so that the economy can grow better, as it does not take so long to complete approvals and planning. I believe this is a significant advancement. I would like to say that we intend to follow this first major Germany Pact "Tempo" with further measures, for example in the area of data usage and the digitization of healthcare, in the field of pharmaceutical research, and in the hydrogen economy.

The

third

message from the matters that have been brought together last week is the proposal made by the federal government regarding relief for large electricity consumers in the manufacturing sector through a reduction in electricity prices. We have proposed to reduce all political costs associated with these electricity supplies, particularly by lowering the electricity tax for manufacturing companies to the minimum required by European law, by continuing the options available for particularly challenged companies with electricity price compensation and the super cap, and by even expanding this with opportunities that have now presented themselves to us.

This is a good step. Three measures that contribute to making Germany function better.

The last topic I want to address: While we are discussing here and these matters concern us, there remains the terrible war of aggression by Russia against Ukraine. I want to assure you once again: Germany's solidarity with Ukraine and our support for Ukraine's right to defend itself is unwavering. We are firmly committed to continuing this. Today, after the United States, we are the most consistent and extensive supporter of Ukraine; and we want to and will continue this.

We are also challenged because Hamas has attacked Israel, because there has been a brutal, horrific attack on children, the elderly, civilians in Israel, on celebrating youth, barbarically, with incredibly horrific acts, kidnappings of hostages to Gaza. Therefore, I want to emphasize at this point: It is the policy of the federal government that we stand by Israel. Israel has every right to defend itself.

Of course, it is our duty to do everything we can to ensure that the conflict in the region does not escalate, that Iranian proxies in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, and Yemen do not become involved in this war, and that Iran does not feel provoked and encouraged to act aggressively here. We warn everyone: This is something that cannot be accepted. There must be no expansion of this war. – Therefore, it is an important part of our policy to speak with everyone in the region, just as it is our responsibility to ensure that humanitarian aid can reach Gaza. All of this is part of our policy.

You see: significant questions that concern us all. Therefore, I am very much looking forward to your questions.