Speech by Chancellor Scholz at the celebration of the 300th birthday of Immanuel Kant on April 22, 2024, in Berlin

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

22 April 2024 · Celebration of the 300th birthday of Immanuel Kant · Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz spoke at a Berlin ceremony on April 22, 2024, marking the 300th anniversary of Immanuel Kant's birth, connecting Kantian philosophy to current geopolitical tensions.
Main themes
Immanuel Kant's 300th birthday, Kant's philosophy of perpetual peace, Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine, Kaliningrad and geopolitical significance, Putin's appropriation of Kant, conditions for lasting peace, Königsberg's historical legacy, geopolitical upheavals in Europe, philosophy and politics, Ukrainian sovereignty
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,540
82nd percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
3.08
58th percentile
Vocabulary
2.37
86th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 63%61%
  • Social 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

180 sentences in 57 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

it is particularly the round anniversaries that trigger great attention. In the end, it is of course a coincidence that Kant's birthday falls in this year, marking the 300th time. A happy coincidence; for I believe that now, more than ever, Kant has so much to say to us ‑ precisely in this year, precisely in this time, not only in philosophical terms but also from a political and geopolitical perspective.

This begins with the fact that Kant comes from Königsberg. He grew up here, lived here his entire life, and researched and taught for decades at the Albertus University. The fact that Kant never left Königsberg seems strange to us today. Kant himself was completely at peace with it. “A city such as Königsberg on the Pregel River,” he wrote, “can certainly be considered a suitable place for the expansion of both human knowledge and world knowledge, where this can be acquired even without traveling.”

I personally believe that traveling is educational. Personal sensory perception, personal experience, and personal views never really hurt. But one thing is certainly true: Königsberg at the time of Kant was anything but an insignificant place far away from the action. East Prussia's metropolis was one of the largest cities in Germany at Kant's time, with 60,000 inhabitants, a significant center of trade and shipping, culture, and science ‑ smaller than Berlin or Hamburg, but at that time significantly larger than Cologne, Munich, Leipzig, or Frankfurt.

The city of Immanuel Kant is still Königsberg. And this city is still not further away from us today, in terms of kilometers, than it was then. From Berlin, it is hardly more than 500 kilometers in a straight line to Königsberg, so not further than the distances from Berlin to Aachen, Karlsruhe, Ulm, or Munich. However, it seems much further to us. It seems to us as if this Königsberg is far away and somehow fallen out of our time.

For Kant's Königsberg is now called Kaliningrad and belongs to Russia ‑ since 1946, as the capital of the Kaliningrad Oblast, first to the Soviet Union, and since 1992 to the Russian Federation. And with that, the honoree Kant finds himself right in the middle of the geopolitical upheavals of our time, right in the midst of the turning point that Russia's ruler Putin has initiated with his brutal war of aggression against Ukraine.

Not only Kant's hometown, Russia's exclave Kaliningrad, is once again in a particularly sensitive zone of European history and politics. Kant's great question about the conditions for the possibility of lasting peace in times of war is also back at the top of the agenda today.

Therefore, it is a good idea to take Kant's magnificent work

Perpetual Peace

into hand once again right now. I have done so, and I would like to say: In this very slim volume, there is much that can provide us with orientation and, despite everything, also confidence today. I want to talk about some aspects of it today.

Ladies and gentlemen, it is important at the outset that the great honoree himself and his work do not get run over in the upheavals of the present. Reports from Kaliningrad indicate that Kant is omnipresent there today. The appropriation of Kant is comprehensive; the philosopher from Königsberg is today something like the "brand" of Kaliningrad. His birthplace was demolished a long time ago, but the university in the city has been named Immanuel Kant University since 2005. There is a "Kant Market" in Kaliningrad, and Kant chocolate, people drink Kant mulled wine and buy Kant refrigerator magnets and Kant mugs. And when couples get married in Kaliningrad, they have themselves photographed ‑ somewhat morbidly ‑ in front of Immanuel Kant's grave.

All of this seems to be a direct consequence of the personal passion for Kant that Russia's president has repeatedly expressed publicly in recent years. Kant, Putin emphasizes, is one of his "favorite philosophers." He stated literally in July 2005 during a visit to Kant's grave: "Kant was a categorical opponent of resolving interstate disputes through war. And we try to adhere to this part of his teaching. (...) I believe that the vision Kant laid out should and can be realized by our generation." ‑ So said Putin.

And just three years ago, in 2021, Putin ordered by decree that Kant should be extensively celebrated in Russia on the occasion of his 300th birthday: as one of the greatest thinkers and philosophers of humanity. A large international congress was also planned, which was supposed to take place now, in these days, in Kaliningrad.

But then what changed everything happened. At Putin's command, Russian troops invaded the entire Ukraine, an independent and internationally sovereign neighboring country. Since then, Putin has provided a confusing variety of justifications. Even before the war, in the summer of 2021, he claimed in his essay titled

On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians that both nations are actually "one people." This is as false as the motive behind it is transparent.

Ukraine is an independent nation with its own history and diverse culture. Independently of that, Ukraine is a sovereign state, so ‑ to put it in Kant's words ‑ "a society of people over which no one else but [this state] itself has the right to command and dispose."

Putin denies all of this. Sometimes he speaks of the "denazification" of Ukraine, at other times about the necessity of defending Russia against the alleged aggression of what he calls the "collective West." According to him, it was not Russia that started the war, but this "collective West."

Ladies and gentlemen, all these attempts to justify Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine are far-fetched. They are absurd and fabricated. They assume threats to Russia that do not exist. Kant already critically pointed out the unhealthy habit of "concocting evil intentions in others." This is exactly what we are dealing with here.

Reality looks different. Putin's brutal invasion of Ukraine is a war of choice

, an attack war chosen by Putin himself. It is Russia's ruler who has instigated this largest military conflict in Europe since World War II ‑ willfully, destructively, and unprovoked.

Under Putin's command, Russian soldiers have committed indescribable war crimes against the civilian population since the beginning of their full invasion of Ukraine, shooting civilians indiscriminately, torturing, raping, and abducting children. We must never forget the massacres that Russian soldiers committed against civilians in Bucha and Irpin. I have seen these terrible devastations in Irpin with my own eyes. The images of that day will always remain with me.

Under Putin's command, Russian troops have also leveled residential areas, train stations, hospitals, schools, and entire cities elsewhere in Ukraine. Mariupol, Bakhmut, Popasna, Rubizhne, or Avdiivka: These and other names stand for destroyed cities, for obliterated communities. They stand for a will to annihilate that, in its sheer excess, few of us in 21st-century Europe would have thought possible.

Under Putin's command, Russia's war against Ukraine has disrupted global supplies of food, energy, and raw materials, with dire consequences especially in many countries of the Global South.

Under Putin's command, Russia has also been sacrificing hundreds of thousands of its own citizens at the front since the beginning of the war. Forcibly recruited individuals and mercenaries, prisoners, young and old, in many cases members of ethnic minorities, are all being driven to their deaths as cannon fodder ‑ indiscriminately, thoughtlessly, mercilessly.

Or to take up the biting criticism that the Enlightenment thinker Kant directed at the despotic heads of state of his time: Under Putin's command, subjects in Russia today are once again being used and consumed as ‑ in Kant's words ‑ "things to be handled at will." It is precisely this instrumentalization and objectification of people that Kant denounced. It stands in diametric opposition to all his ideas about human rights, the freedom, autonomy, and dignity of every person. For this reason alone, Putin has no justification whatsoever to invoke Kant.

Ladies and gentlemen, what applies to Kant's conception of human rights and human dignity also applies to his thoughts on war and peace. Here too, Putin has no right whatsoever to refer positively to Kant ‑ on the contrary.

Since Russia, under Putin's command, began its neo-imperial war of aggression against Ukraine, nothing in Europe and beyond has remained as it was. "The world afterwards is not the same as it was before," I said on February 27, 2022, in the German Bundestag.

We have since had to cope with the consequences of this historical turning point together ‑ and we are coping with them. This includes supporting the Ukrainians in their brave fight for freedom and independence ‑ humanitarian, financially, and also with weapons. I consider this not only politically and strategically necessary, but also ethically required for peace. For the defense of one's own existence against an aggressor creates the very conditions under which Ukraine can negotiate freely and without coercion about peace and where Russia is also willing to engage in such negotiations. Therefore, we support the attacked Ukraine together with all our partners ‑ for as long as necessary.

Ladies and gentlemen, with his illegal war of aggression against Ukraine, Putin is inflicting severe damage not least on his own country and especially on the citizens of his own country. Economy, culture, civil society exchange, science, and research: In every conceivable area, it is Putin's regime itself that is depriving millions of Russians of their freedom and life opportunities, of development and future ‑ or to put it in Kant's terms: of human dignity and autonomy.

A prime example of this comprehensive self-harm is this year's Kant anniversary. It was inevitable that the German Kant Society decided not to hold its international anniversary congress in Kaliningrad this year as planned. For it is obvious: Enlightenment and war of aggression ‑ they do not go together. Categorical imperative and war crimes ‑ they do not go together.

However, this does not mean that Putin and his power apparatus would refrain from bending Kant to their purposes. The opposite is the case. Especially in this anniversary year, particularly disturbing and absurd interpretations of Kant are being heard from Russia. Just earlier this year, Putin stated during a visit to Kaliningrad: "Kant is a fundamental thinker, and his call to use one's own reason is highly relevant. For Russia, this practically means that we have been guided by our national interests." ‑ Oh really! I explicitly doubt that Immanuel Kant had precisely this in mind when he declared the motto "Sapere aude!" in 1784 as the slogan of the Enlightenment. Kant was certainly not concerned with national interests in his "Answering the Question: What is Enlightenment?" "Have the courage to use your own reason!" ‑ This was aimed rather at individual

"self-thinking," at criticism, at the dignity, autonomy, and freedom of each individual. All of this is trampled on daily in Putin's autocracy and stifled in its infancy, for example, through censorship, digital disinformation, and surveillance. Where the "state owners" ‑ another term of Kant's ‑ of the 21st century employ such practices, they do not want self-thinking citizens. Rather, they want ignorant and immature subjects, because only these can be manipulated and "consumed" as "things to be handled at will" for their own purposes. There can be no doubt that Kant would condemn such methods in the strongest terms.

Nevertheless, Putin's regime remains determined to appropriate Kant and his work at almost any cost. The long-time Russia correspondent for "ZEIT," Michael Thumann, puts it succinctly: "There are at least two Kants, one philosopher whom we revere in Germany, and one thinker buried in Kaliningrad who is being made compatible with Putin's worldview."

Yet Kant's compatibility with war and violence has its limits, even in Russia. This may explain why kantophobic tones have recently been heard from the Russian power apparatus. Before the congress of the Russian Society for Political Science, the governor of the Kaliningrad region, Anton Alikhanov, recently stated: "Today, in the year 2024, we have the courage to assert that not only did the First World War begin with the work of Immanuel Kant, but that the current conflict in Ukraine also began with him." ‑ Kant, according to Alikhanov, is not only "one of the intellectual creators of the modern West," but he also has an "almost direct connection to the global chaos" we are dealing with. Moreover, he has "a direct connection to the military conflict in Ukraine."

A man rubs his eyes. Of all people, Kant, for whom peace was the "highest good" of all, is now said to be responsible for Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine. If Kant were indeed to blame for the Russian war against Ukraine, how would that fit with Putin's various attempts to nonetheless enlist Kant as the "greatest thinker of humanity" for Russia's purposes?

Ladies and gentlemen, it is quite simple. None of this adds up. It does not add up because Kant cannot be considered a keyword provider for war of aggression, violation of international law, and despotism in general. Kant's categorical stance is completely clear. "No state should violently interfere in the constitution of another state," he writes. Yet that is precisely what Russia is doing in Ukraine. Kant warns emphatically against war of aggression and mercenarism, against the "use of humans as mere machines and tools." Nothing else does the cynical burning of its own recruits, prisoners, and mercenaries represent, as the Russian regime is massively conducting in its fight against Ukraine. No state, Kant further demands, should allow itself in war with another "such hostilities that must make mutual trust in future peace impossible." Methods such as the "employment of assassins" and "poisoners," the treacherous use of "hellish arts," or the "instigation of treason in the warring state" – all of this must not happen under any circumstances.

We would phrase the intended meaning differently today, but it is completely clear what Kant was concerned about. Methods like these are all too familiar to us from the current Russian actions. Kant warns emphatically against their use. For, as he writes: "Some trust in the enemy's way of thinking must still remain in the midst of war, for otherwise no peace could be concluded and hostility would turn into a war of extermination." Kant foresaw here with great insight what has become possible in our nuclear age, the "extermination of both parties at once," which, according to Kant, would ultimately mean that "eternal peace would only take place in the great cemetery of humanity."

Ladies and gentlemen, these observations and reflections already show that the great Enlightener Kant was anything but a naive preacher of peace. Just as we do today, he lived in an age of great upheavals and military conflicts. He had no illusions about the malice of human nature, even less about, as he wrote, "heads of state who can never be satisfied with war."

Nevertheless, and precisely for that reason, Kant reflects on how lasting peace could become possible. Nevertheless, and precisely for that reason, Kant counters the right of the stronger with the authority of law. Nevertheless, and precisely for that reason, Kant looks to the future and progress. That is exactly what makes the urgent relevance of his draft

Perpetual Peace

so significant. That is why it is so worthwhile to refer to this small book right now, especially in this time of unrest.

For Kant, it was clear: "The state of peace (...) is not a natural state, but rather a state of war. (...) It must therefore be established." Established, safeguarded, organized, continually secured, and if necessary restored, and that always with the means of law and politics, which Kant explicitly understood as "applied legal doctrine."

Ladies and gentlemen, we Europeans must reacquaint ourselves with the thought after decades of peace: The peace that most of us have experienced for so long as a self-evident normality and "natural state" – it is not that at all. It is indeed not "natural." It must still be "established" today – and again today. All the more important it is that we clarify what political and legal conditions are necessary to promote and fundamentally make possible peace among states, even if they do not guarantee it.

For Kant, these are the legally guaranteed freedom and equality of all citizens – and by the way, also of female citizens – in representative democracies, a functioning separation of powers, a liberal and freely debating public, a flourishing world trade with its, as Kant puts it, "mutual self-interest," and last but not least: a federal league of nations of sovereign states.

A global legal order, in which all states are internally republican and democratic and externally respect the rights of all other states, that was for Kant the "salvation of the world" to be aspired to. For that would then be a world in which no smaller neighbor would have to fear the larger one anymore and in which within all states, the citizens would be protected from arbitrariness.

I would like to say: This thinking, this conviction, this goal of Kant's has deeply shaped my own political work. That is at least the essence of what I also consider desirable, against all resistance and setbacks, but still, in Kant's words, "in continuous approximation."

Ladies and gentlemen, not a single one of the necessary ingredients for lasting peace, from Kant's perspective, was in any way tested during his own lifetime, let alone firmly established. In the meantime, much of that has become reality, here in Germany, within the framework of the European Union, and partly also on a global level. We have achieved much more than Kant himself would probably have thought possible. Let us make it clear how indispensable, yes how precious these achievements are when it comes to peace, now more than ever!

Yes, we have every reason to criticize and correct the ongoing shortcomings of our achievements; a UN Security Council, for example, in which Russia can prevent its own sanctioning and condemnation by veto; or an international law that, contrary to Kant's hopes, unfortunately still lacks a strong enforcement mechanism. At least the hope that the global "spirit of trade" would somehow ensure lasting peace by itself is also somewhat clouded, because it cannot coexist with war, as Kant says.

Nevertheless: We should not, for heaven's sake, have the recklessness to jeopardize what has been achieved since Kant's time – whether out of arrogance or boredom. For it would be the highest political good of all that we would be endangering: peace itself.

Ladies and gentlemen, the burning question remains how peace can again be made possible tomorrow, where bitter war is still being waged today, where shots are fired and people die, as is currently the case in Ukraine or, in a very differently situated conflict, in Gaza. This issue concerns not only those people who are directly affected by such acts of war. It also occupies the citizens here in our country. It is evident that we cannot find practical solutions to the warring conflicts of the 21st century in Kant's

Perpetual Peace

. But there are indeed some very wise and thought-provoking hints from Kant.

One of them I have already mentioned. It concerns the necessity of refraining from all methods in war that destroy any remaining trust between the warring parties and thus make a subsequent peace agreement impossible. We can only urgently appeal to the warring parties of our time to be aware of this danger – and to act accordingly.

Kant's second hint concerns the question of under what conditions warring parties can and should make peace. For Kant, it is clear: Those who are attacked may defend themselves, and they should not be forced to enter into a peace treaty that the aggressor concludes in "bad faith," intending to resume the war at the "first favorable opportunity." Such a peace agreement, Kant writes, "would be merely a truce, a postponement of hostilities, not peace, which signifies the end of all hostilities."

I believe we should consider this warning from Kant when we seek ways out of the wars of our time. Where shots are fired and people are dying, a truce may be desirable if it offers the prospect of paving the way for a lasting and just peace, at least that. However, where in the end nothing better could be negotiated or mediated than a temporary "postponement of hostilities," that outcome would already be the prelude to the next war. The danger, in any case, is great. And where the rights of the individual mean nothing, where oppression prevails and arbitrariness – there, too, no lasting peace will prevail. Nothing else does Kant tell us when he insists: "The rights of humanity must be held sacred, no matter how great the sacrifice may be for the ruling power."

We all wish for peace in our time. But a peace at any price – that would not be peace at all. This insight also teaches us Kant. Reason and historical experience should guide us to heed it.

Thank you very much.