Speech by Chancellor Scholz at the Commemoration Event for the 85th Anniversary of the Reich Pogrom Night on November 9, 2023, in Berlin

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

9 November 2023 · Commemoration Event for the 85th Anniversary of the Reich Pogrom Night · Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed a commemoration in Berlin's Beth Zion Synagogue on the 85th anniversary of Kristallnacht, the 1938 Nazi pogrom against Jews.
Main themes
Kristallnacht anniversary, antisemitism, Holocaust remembrance, Jewish persecution, German guilt and silence, moral responsibility, solidarity with Jewish community, October 7 Hamas attacks, defense of Israel, memory and commemoration
Duration
~14 min
48th percentile
Words
1,669
48th percentile
Sentences
81
53rd percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
2.91
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.33
80th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 57%56%
  • Ceremonial 22%21%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 8%7%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

81 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Dear Mr Schuster,

Dear Federal President,

Dear President of the Bundestag,

Dear President of the Bundesrat,

Dear President of the Federal Constitutional Court,

Dear Ambassador Prosor,

Dear Ms Friedländer,

Dear colleagues from the Cabinet, the Bundestag and the Länder,

Distinguished guests of honour,

Ladies and gentlemen,

Some of you were perhaps present when, ten years ago, Eli Fachler spoke here at this very spot about his memories of the night of 9 to 10 November 1938.

Hidden behind the curtains of the family's flat, he witnessed as a 15-year-old boy how his synagogue here in Brunnenstraße was looted and desecrated. He described the crashing of the furnishings being destroyed, the splintering of the wooden pews, the shattering of the smashed windows. He described his mortal fear at the end of what had begun, as he put it, as an "ordinary day", one that had started with going to school.

That we are able to gather here today in the Beth Zion Synagogue is owed solely to the particular location of this building, closely surrounded by other houses. The perpetrators did not dare to set it on fire; the danger of the flames spreading was too great. As shocking as it is: that this building was not reduced entirely to rubble and ashes is ultimately owed to the banality of how the surrounding buildings happened to be laid out.

No neighbours or eyewitnesses were on hand to stop the perpetrators. No one stood up to protect this house, here at Brunnenstraße 33.

And even after that night of 9 to 10 November 1938, when streets throughout the country were strewn with the shards of glass from Jewish shop windows, when Jewish women and men were arrested in and dragged out of their flats and houses, open protest was almost entirely absent. Apart from a few courageous women and men, the Germans remained silent.

In response to the frequent question from those born later as to why his generation had done nothing when Jewish Germans were deprived of their rights, deported and murdered en masse in 1938, the theologian Martin Niemöller explained after the war the bitter logic of the gradual destruction of a community. Right into the midst of the atrocities of the Shoah, people could always tell themselves: it isn't happening to me, it's happening to "the others".

You know the saying; it has been quoted often, and it exists in various versions: "When the Nazis came for the communists, I remained silent; I was not a communist. When they locked up the social democrats, I remained silent; I was not a social democrat. When they came for the trade unionists, I remained silent; I was not a trade unionist. When they came for the Jews, I remained silent; I was not a Jew. When they came for me, there was no one left who could protest."

Ladies and gentlemen, "us" and "them", the others, those who do not belong: it is with this division that a society's descent into the catastrophe of indifference, intolerance and inhumanity begins, as Martin Niemöller described it.

Our constitution gives the necessary, the central answer to this in its very first sentence: Human dignity, the dignity of every human being, shall be inviolable. That is not a mere statement; it is our task. Our task is to defend human dignity; to actively stand against the division into "us" and "them", against exclusion.

Ladies and gentlemen, exclusion has particularly affected Jewish women and men for centuries, and it still does, again and again, here in our democratic Germany too, and that after the rupture of civilisation that was the Shoah, committed by Germans. That is a disgrace. It outrages me and shames me deeply.

When, in 2023, doors and walls are once again daubed with Stars of David in order to exclude citizens of the Jewish faith and to mark their homes and businesses; when the terrorists of Hamas are celebrated on our streets and squares for the murder, the torture, the dehumanisation of their victims; when Jewish women and men are afraid to live their religion, their culture, their everyday lives openly, to exercise their fundamental right to be visible as members of our society; when incendiary devices are thrown at the synagogue here in Brunnenstraße, 85 years after the pogroms of 1938 – then something has indeed come apart at the seams, Mr Schuster.

And it must not matter whether antisemitism is politically or religiously motivated, whether it comes from the left or from the right, whether it disguises itself as art or as academic discourse, whether it has grown here over centuries or comes into the country from outside. Every form of antisemitism poisons our society, as Islamist demonstrations and rallies are doing now. We do not tolerate antisemitism – anywhere.

At its core, this is about keeping the promise that was made again and again in the decades after 1945; the promise on which our democratic Germany is founded; the promise: "Never again!" We must keep this promise especially now – not only in words, but above all in our actions.

Never again: that means first and foremost the physical protection of Jewish institutions and communities. Ensuring this protection is, as you, Federal President, recently put it, both a task of the state and a civic duty. But that alone is of course not enough. You are right, Mr Schuster: if Jewish women and men in Germany have to live behind ever larger protective shields, then that is unbearable.

Never again: that therefore also means that the police and the judiciary consistently enforce the law. Nothing, absolutely nothing – no origin, no political conviction, no cultural background, no supposedly postcolonial view of history – can serve as a justification for celebrating the murder, the gruesome slaughter of innocent people. We fight every form of antisemitism, terrorist propaganda and misanthropy in Germany. Anyone who supports terrorism, anyone who incites antisemitic hatred, will be prosecuted. With the new citizenship law, we are making it absolutely clear that antisemitism is an obstacle to naturalisation.

Never again: this applies not only on the streets and squares of our country, but also online, where targeted false reports reach young people in particular, where world views are formed, but also deformed. That is why it is important that we are consistent in what we do. That is why everyone must also know: antisemitism – anyone who engages in it also puts their residence status at risk.

It is good that the European Commission is vigorously using the new legal powers over large online platforms that we created together with the Digital Services Act. Europe should penalise violations by platform operators. That is right and necessary, because systematic disinformation and inhuman incitement endanger the foundations of our democracy.

Never again – that means that we keep alive the memory of the crime against humanity of the Shoah, committed by Germans. The responsibility that arises from our history must be accepted by everyone who lives here in our country, and by everyone who wants to live in this country, and understood as their own. It is the foundation of our democratic community.

The understanding of our social and historical responsibility must be passed on in schools, universities, in vocational training, in integration courses and in everyday life. So that the young generation grasps historical events for which there are no longer any eyewitnesses in their families, and so that we, in Germany as a country of immigration, also reach those in whose countries of origin the Shoah is not spoken about, or is spoken about in a completely different way. That is sorely needed.

At the same time, we must not be taken in by those who now sense their chance to deny, across the board, more than five million Muslim citizens their place in our society. Everyone who lives here must be measured by the same standard, and that is our free democratic basic order, which demands and guarantees diversity and respect towards others.

Never again – that of course means friendship and solidarity with Israel. The terrible turning point of 7 October 2023 allows only one conclusion: Germany's place is at Israel's side. Israel has the right to defend itself against the barbaric terror of Hamas, terror that murders innocent people, terror that massacres soldiers and civilians indiscriminately, men and women, the elderly and small children, terror that seeks to annihilate the only Jewish state and its inhabitants.

Our sympathy goes out to all those who have lost friends and family members. Our thoughts are with those who continue to fear for their children, parents, siblings, spouses, for their loved ones who are being held hostage by the terrorists. I was able to speak with some of them during my visit to Israel. Their heartbreaking worry and their pain stay with me. The Federal Government will continue to do everything, everything in our power, to bring the hostages home.

Part of our friendship with Israel is also that we continue to promote and nurture exchange between Germans and Israelis as best we can, wherever possible: with youth exchanges and volunteer services, in business, science and research, in art and culture, between states and between people. In this solidarity, we will also continue to work for a stable, lasting peace in the Middle East.

Never again – that means, not least, that we stand up against hatred. I am therefore very glad that many citizens all over Germany have shown their solidarity with the victims of Hamas terror – at rallies and vigils or on social media. That gives us confidence; that strengthens our community. I thank everyone who takes a stand for humanity!

Ladies and gentlemen, our Germany is founded on our standing together indivisibly, on citizens of the Jewish faith belonging as a matter of course, and on our confronting terror and hatred together. Never again – that holds, and we will keep that promise, today, tomorrow and for all time.

Thank you very much!