Speech by Chancellor Olaf Scholz at the Friedrich August von Hayek Foundation on the eightieth anniversary of the publication of "The Road to Serfdom" on March 19, 2024 in ...

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

19 March 2024 · Friedrich August von Hayek Foundation event marking the 80th anniversary of 'The Road to Serfdom'

Context
Scholz addressed the Friedrich August von Hayek Foundation in March 2024 marking the 80th anniversary of 'The Road to Serfdom', reflecting on freedom, economics, and geopolitics.
Main themes
Freedom and Hayek's legacy, modern supply-side policy, free trade and protectionism, Ukraine and European security, capitalism's global variants, economic growth and prosperity, climate-friendly development, Russia and authoritarianism, democracy and rule of law
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,741
84th percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 44%43%
  • Institutional 21%21%
  • Social 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Not in focus 1%

180 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Dear Professor Gerken,

Dear Prime Minister, dear Kaja,

Dear Federal President, dear Mr. Köhler,

Ladies and gentlemen!

"We are all capitalists today." This is what the economist Branko Milanović wrote in his book "Global Capitalism." This realization might not have surprised Friedrich August von Hayek, but it would have pleased him a little. A few years ago, Milanović traced how capitalism – with a few exceptions like North Korea – has established itself globally as the dominant economic system. In this respect – one might think at first glance – many of the great ideological debates that we still associate with Hayek belong to the past. In part, this is certainly true. Hayek was – like all of us – also a child of his time.

But a second look shows: Behind the finding of capitalism's global victory, there remains much room for, let’s say, interpretations. There is the Chinese model of capitalism with strong state-directed elements. There are resource economies like Russia, where the state or state-affiliated oligarchs control the large companies and also decide what happens to the profits. Now they are being used for warfare. We are experiencing that tariffs and trade restrictions are by no means dead; on the contrary! Sometimes they are just labeled more cleverly than before. Recently, at an event in New York, I said, in essence: "I hope I am not the last remaining free trader in this room." That, of course, caused some amusement. But the fact that free trade is currently in a difficult position worldwide does worry me. Because we know: Tariffs and protectionism ultimately mean higher prices, while free trade leads to more innovation and lower prices.

Hayek's great life theme was freedom, especially, but not only in economic terms, and that is precisely why engaging with his ideas is worthwhile today. Two flight hours from here, the Ukrainians are defending their country, their freedom against the ongoing Russian attack. You have already spoken about this, dear Kaja. What is at stake are nothing less than the fundamental principles of our European peace order: Violence must not shift borders, power is bound to law, power must be bound to law. We defend these principles by supporting Ukraine. Yes, we do this thoughtfully and closely coordinated with our partners in Europe and around the world. Above all, however, we do this in a long-term and reliable manner. Putin believes he has more endurance than the free democracies. Only if we prove him wrong will there be a just peace in Ukraine – and thus peace in Europe.

Hayek had already witnessed two world wars. The second was not yet over when he published "The Road to Serfdom." He was a scholar. He was concerned with principles. He once formulated this at the University of Cologne: "I am not […] primarily interested in the immediate problems of practice. The true economic politician must deal with what is politically possible in the existing state of public opinion. He must constantly make compromises between what seems right to him and what is practicable under the given circumstances." I quote only.

I can certainly agree with this job description, although there can also be situations where the right and the practicable go hand in hand. In this spirit, I would like to say a few words today about how, in my view, a modern supply-side policy that fits this time should be designed.

First and foremost, it is important: Economic growth remains the driving force of prosperity and development worldwide. Terms like "de-growth" or even the demand to forgo economic development in favor of the environment are met with shaking heads or at best deaf ears in the emerging countries of Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Caribbean. This does not mean that these countries do not share our concern about climate change and its consequences. On the contrary: Many of them are the main victims of the climate crisis. But these countries are looking for ways to organize growth in a climate-friendly manner, just as we are.

It is important to me that we never lose sight of the possibility of a positive perspective for our world. Therefore, I want to say that our world, which today has eight billion inhabitants and will have about ten billion by 2050, perhaps, if all goes well, and it looks a bit more like it could go well, will make prosperity possible for almost all citizens of the planet by 2050, similar to what we had in 1950. But just imagine if we were to run the economy in 2050 as we did in 1950. It would not be a good place to live, to breathe. We would not have stopped climate change. The worst conditions would prevail, and some of the illusions about eternally cheap prices for coal, gas, oil, uranium, and whatever else would quickly dissipate. But we must hope that it is at least possible for global prosperity to grow to the point that billions of people outside Europe and North America have the opportunity to lead lives not unlike ours! This will only succeed with incredible technological progress, with changes that we are now organizing, with technologies that make it possible for more prosperity to be achieved without making life on the planet more difficult.

That is why, in my view, combating the climate crisis is primarily about technologies and machines, about know-how and indeed also about capital. All of this is present here with us – in the classic industrial countries. At the same time, we are looking for new energy sources and energy suppliers, many of which will also be based in the global south, for example, when it comes to hydrogen, which we will import, just as we import coal, gas, and oil – not only that; we also produce it ourselves. What a market can emerge from this – especially for us as a technologically strong industrial country – Hayek would certainly not need to be told.

Secondly, we create growth here in Germany by removing growth brakes. Looking at all the studies on potential growth in Germany, it is clear where they see the biggest growth brake for Germany: in the lack of skilled workers. You all know the numbers: The baby boomers – now adults, called boomers – are retiring. 13 million workers will leave the labor market in the next 15 years. The fact that we still have the highest number of employees ever is mainly due to the free movement of workers within the European Union.

A modern supply-side policy must continue this success, and this is possible, of course, by doing what we can achieve here at home, by doing everything we can with training and education to ensure that the workforce in our country can maximize their skills. This applies to the transition from school to vocational training, which remains the most important education in Germany alongside university studies. But it also applies to those who are already employed. When I was Minister of Labor in Germany during the financial crisis that followed the collapse of Lehman Brothers, I advocated for further training during the period of unemployment during short-time work, which I made possible on a large scale in Germany. My impression was: I met everyone who did that personally. That does not speak for great success.

But now, when I visit companies, I see that what I dreamed of back then has happened, that companies have looked around in their own shops, in their own factories, and seen: I have here forty-year-olds and fifty-year-olds as unskilled or semi-skilled workers or those who stand at the assembly line but have trained as bakers. Why don’t I offer them the opportunity to start vocational training in my company now, even as a forty-five-year-old or fifty-year-old, that fits what is needed? – I have seen them, the proud women and men who have done that. This is a potential that is still completely untapped and that we must harness.

But – I also want to say this – we must ensure that the situation for women’s employment in Germany improves by becoming better at dealing with the employment opportunities for young families. In international comparison, what we have to offer is truly embarrassing. There are individual countries in Germany where there is everything that exists elsewhere and that we want: a comprehensive offer of crèches and kindergartens, all-day programs in all schools at all grade levels, also free of charge. When I was the head of government of a state in Germany – the state of Hamburg, a small country that contributes to Germany's federal success – I took this opportunity and said: We will do it this way! – This has immediate consequences for employment. We should not underestimate that! I am glad that in the last legislative period we passed a law in which we persuaded the states, with a contribution from the federal government, to introduce all-day schooling in primary schools by 2029. I comment: at least.

But the most important potential that we must utilize is the immigration of skilled and labor workers to protect ourselves from labor shortages in Germany. I have already said: In the past, we did not have to be very skilled. We had the free movement of workers in the European Union with more than 400 million citizens, with more than 200 million workers, and it led to all the forecasts of the 1990s being wrong. Instead of the number of employees decreasing, it increased by millions – by six million. Today, we have the highest number of employees in the history of Germany: 46 million, a very, very large number. But I have already talked about the boomers. We need more workers, and the European Union is no longer a sufficient resource for the demands of the German labor market, as those who have come from elsewhere can report. Our openness and the strength of our economy have effects in the countries of the Balkans, in many countries of Eastern and Central Europe, from which large numbers of workers have come to Germany, many from Poland, millions.

Now we must look further. That is why, in a time of strained debates, we have managed to make decisions that may be the right, bold decisions, namely to defend the openness that has enabled our economic strength in recent years. With the Skilled Workers Immigration Act, which is probably the most modern in the world and can compete with regulations in Canada, the USA, Australia, New Zealand, and wherever else, our country can continue its success story.

By the way, that is why the most plausible statistic from the Federal Office is that we will have 90 million inhabitants by 2070 and not 84 million, and the most plausible prediction is not the pessimistic one that we encounter every day, but that as an open economy we will manage our labor shortage problem and therefore will have growth and production potentials that cannot be recognized today with the statistical method of simply projecting the past into the future and being unable to imagine anything new.

Yes, we have done it, and now we are expanding everything that is needed in practice: digital consulates – which will be the case at the beginning of next year – better practices here at home, simplification of regulations. We do not want Germany to be unable to grow because there are no additional workers from outside.

At the same time, we have managed to open the perspective that this can also be politically supported. It was not always, but in the end, a desired process that the Skilled Workers Immigration Act and the new citizenship law were completed at the same time as our regulation on the management of irregular migration on the other side.

Because an open society must also promise its citizens that it has things under control. For example, if one is open to labor immigration, one cannot simultaneously say that anyone can come and say, "I will stay here, I am a refugee," when it is not true.

That is why we had to change this part, and we did. That was – if I may confess to you – very, very difficult in a federal state. Because for everything that in your country the government is directly responsible for, in Germany, 16 times someone is responsible, namely one of the states, 401 districts and independent cities, 11,400 municipalities, 560 foreigner authorities.

We have negotiated in three major rounds with the heads of government of the countries about their and our competencies. As far as we are concerned, I can say: We have decided on the most far-reaching legislative changes in the last 25 years regarding irregular migration that one can possibly imagine. Everything that can reasonably be desired has been done and decided.

You can see it – if I may make this joke – in the separation pain of Mr. Söder and the opposition leader. Because they still bring up points, but they are no longer reasonable. Some have even been declared unconstitutional by the Constitutional Court. I believe we have created a foundation for this openness because we can manage it, and we can also defend it. Because, in my view, it always includes having good administration and a state that functions and on which one can rely.

There is still a bit to do in reality. Perhaps a suggestion for those with separation pain: If one wants to propose something new again, one should only get back in touch once the digitization of their own immigration authorities is completed or when the administrative court proceedings initiated by those applying for asylum are short everywhere. That is possible. In Rhineland-Palatinate, it is three and a half months, in North Rhine-Westphalia, Hesse, and Bavaria around 20. There are even countries with 40 months. We certainly want to change that.

I return to the topic. – Why do I say this? Supply policy means, in this case, ensuring that we have enough workers in the labor market. We have set the course for this, and therefore we can be confident.

A second part is, in my view, important for the question of how to improve growth, and that is reducing bureaucracy. I fear Mr. Hayek could not have imagined what more bureaucracy could be reduced – so much had not yet been put together. We have made a great effort in recent decades – at all levels of politics in Europe, in Germany, in the 16 states, in the districts – to make it increasingly difficult. My thesis is: We have now reached a state where, in many places, no one can execute the laws we have passed anymore. That is at least a warning signal that this cannot continue. In any case, we must achieve more speed by changing many regulations that are currently in the way. I have certainly made that my goal. We have reached an agreement with the states in our federal state on over 100 legislative projects to make this work.

Final remarks on this topic of supply conditions and the growth brakes that we must resolve: What is the one reason for the success of the German economy in exports? It is research and development. In my view, this is completely underestimated. But if you look at the large European countries – not the small ones; there are great examples among them – you will find that, apart from Germany, not a single one spends more than three percent of its economic output on research and development: not the United Kingdom, not France, not Spain, not Italy, etc.

This is also the reason why the economic statistics in the world are so skewed: first place the USA, second place China, third place Japan, fourth place Germany. Somewhere between Japan and Germany, or perhaps even ahead of China and the USA, the European Union should lie if it had as many research expenditures overall as in some countries and also as we do. That is the cause.

It is the truth: In an innovative society with many disruptions, we cannot expect much income from the things we could do 20 years ago. There must be things that we do not yet know and must still develop.

For this, it is necessary, on the one hand, to resolve growth brakes, and on the other hand, to enable growth, especially in future industries – and for that, we must make the necessary investments. The state can help – it must also do so in times of transformation – and support this through incentives. But private investments remain at the center.

This is also my third point, and I am not so far from Hayek. Because, contrary to what is sometimes portrayed, Hayek did not want a laissez-faire state. Hayek wanted the state to provide public goods, for schools and roads and national defense. And if he were still alive, he would certainly include digital infrastructure.

It is clear: The state should never be the better entrepreneur. Its task is to set framework conditions and enable planning security – especially in times like these, right in the midst of the greatest change in our economy since the industrial revolution. Because it is not enough just to proclaim: By 2045 we will be climate-neutral; the rest you can handle.

Companies want to know where they will get electricity around the clock, how much energy will cost in the future, and when a hydrogen network will be established in Germany. That is why we have worked backwards and asked: When exactly must what be done so that Germany can operate in a climate-neutral manner by 2045? What is needed so that by 2030, 80 percent of our electricity comes from renewable energies?

On this basis, we then made all the planning acceleration laws, built hydrogen-capable liquefied gas terminals, laid the foundations for a hydrogen network – by the way, with over 20 billion invested purely by the private sector – and agreed with the suppliers on a power plant strategy that ensures a reliable electricity supply, even when the sun does not shine and the wind does not blow.

Perhaps it needs to be translated: We rely on renewable energies, but we know exactly that even if we have 120 percent wind and solar power, there will be moments when that is not enough, and then otherwise unprofitable power plants must be able to step in. We have now set this in motion so that the overall system works.

This is working. A look at the current prices and futures for electricity and gas is enough to confirm this. Just a few months ago, and still felt in people's minds, we had heated discussions here in Germany about a state-subsidized industrial electricity price of six cents per kilowatt-hour. Today, electricity prices on the spot market are already moving back into this range. The futures markets are predicting a further decline. That is also why I am glad that we did not do that back then, to introduce a permanently subsidized electricity price.

The same applies, by the way, to the calls that some are now raising again, that we must now shrink the welfare state, cut pensions, or reduce workers' rights. None of this is new – it remains wrong nonetheless. Hayek himself explicitly advocated for a welfare state. Because in a market economy, every citizen is exposed to a certain degree of uncertainty. A minimum security is necessary so that every citizen has the opportunity to participate in work and knowledge production again and again.

What was true in Hayek's time is even more true today. We are in competition for the best and brightest minds worldwide. One of our most important arguments in this regard is also our welfare state with its affordable healthcare system and its free education. We are also talking here and today about the greatest changes of our time and about the insecurity they leave among many citizens.

What it means when populists and extremists exploit this insecurity can be observed in many Western societies – what risk these populists and extremists also pose for economic development, as well. That is why security – which includes social security – is so important in this transformation, and that is why we pay attention to social balance in everything we do.

Germany is a strong country with a robust economy and a well-functioning labor market, precisely because our social cohesion is strong, precisely because we have a tradition of strong social partners. This inner cohesion, this social solidarity, is endangered when citizens get the impression that social changes, such as transformations, do not turn out well for them and their families.

A modern supply policy for today's time therefore means that everyone who works and makes an effort must be able to live from it. That is why, for example, the increase in the minimum wage was so important, from which six million employees in Germany have benefited, and that is why I also advocate – I want to say this right here – for more collective bargaining and social partnership. I also find the work of trade unions right and important, even if I say about the current wage conflict in the railway sector: At some point, one should come to a conclusion.

Hayek viewed trade unions quite differently – that must be said – and criticized them for keeping those who would also work for wages below collective agreements away from work. But such an argument is called into question or becomes irrelevant when there is not mass unemployment but a shortage of workers, which will be our topic for the next decades.

This is – it must not be concealed – not the only point where we would, so to speak, decide differently today than Friedrich August von Hayek when looking in the rearview mirror. That he, actually a warning against tyranny, advised a military dictator like Augusto Pinochet on economic matters in later years is certainly difficult for us today to understand.

All the more important I find it that we agree clearly and distinctly on one thing in this time. Capitalism alone does not mean freedom. Economic freedom always also includes political freedom. And now I look forward to the discussion. Thank you very much.