Speech by Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz on the Dismissal of the Federal Minister of Finance on November 6, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

6 November 2024 · Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the German public on November 6, 2024, in Berlin, announcing his dismissal of Finance Minister Lindner and the effective collapse of his three-party coalition government.
Main themes
Dismissal of Finance Minister Christian Lindner, coalition collapse, federal budget crisis, FDP cooperation breakdown, Germany's economic challenges, investment and energy cost relief, automotive industry support, Ukraine aid, transatlantic relations after Trump election, coalition governance and compromise, irregular migration, Germany's security responsibilities
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,925
55th percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
9.6
16th percentile
Syntax
2.62
8th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%40%
  • Economic 19%18%
  • Geopolitical 16%15%
  • Social 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

134 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen!

I have just asked the Federal President to dismiss the Federal Minister of Finance.

I am compelled to take this step in order to avert damage to our country. We need a capable government that has the strength to make the necessary decisions for our country.

That has been my focus over the past three years. That is what I am focused on now.

I presented a comprehensive offer to our coalition partner, the FDP, again this afternoon, with which we can close the gap in the federal budget without plunging our country into chaos. An offer to strengthen Germany in difficult times. An offer that also incorporates proposals from the FDP. But which at the same time makes it clear: In light of the challenges we face together, we need greater financial leeway.

My offer included four key points:

First:

We will ensure affordable energy costs and cap the network fees for our companies. This strengthens Germany as a business location.

Second:

We are putting together a package that secures jobs in the automotive industry and among the many supplier companies.

Third:

We are introducing an investment premium and further improving tax depreciation options so that companies can invest in Germany now.

And

fourth:

We are increasing our support for Ukraine, which is facing a harsh winter. After the elections in the USA, this sends a very important signal: We can be relied upon!

However, I must once again state: The Federal Minister of Finance shows no willingness to implement this offer for the good of the country within the federal government. I can no longer subject our country to such behavior.

Dear citizens, I would have liked to spare you this difficult decision – especially in times like these, when uncertainty is growing.

In the USA, Donald Trump has clearly won the presidential election – I have already congratulated him on that today. As the German Chancellor, it is natural for me to work well with the future President of the United States. Especially in uncertain times, a close transatlantic relationship is essential.

It is clear: Germany must fulfill its responsibilities. And we must stick together in Europe more than ever and continue to invest in our own security and strength, because the situation is serious. There is war in Europe. Tensions are rising in the Middle East. At the same time, our economy is stagnating. Weak global trade is causing problems for companies. The energy prices resulting from the Russian war of aggression, the costs of modernizing our economy – all of this they must bear.

My discussions with the business community show: Our companies need support – and they need it now. Anyone who refuses a solution, a compromise offer in such a situation acts irresponsibly. As Chancellor, I cannot tolerate that.

Time and again, I have made proposals over the past three years on how a coalition of three different parties can reach good compromises. This has often been difficult. It has sometimes pushed the limits of my political convictions. But it is my duty as Chancellor to push for pragmatic solutions for the good of the whole country.

Too often, the necessary compromises have been drowned out by publicly staged disputes and loud ideological demands. Too often, Federal Minister Lindner has blocked laws on irrelevant grounds. Too often, he has engaged in petty party-political tactics. Too often, he has broken my trust. He even unilaterally canceled the agreement on the budget after we had already reached an understanding after long negotiations. There is no basis of trust for further cooperation. Serious government work is not possible under these conditions.

Anyone who enters a government must act seriously and responsibly. They must not shy away when things get difficult. They must be willing to compromise in the interest of all citizens.

But that is precisely not what Christian Lindner is concerned about – he is focused on his own clientele, on the short-term survival of his own party. Especially today, a day after such an important event as the elections in America, such selfishness is completely incomprehensible.

Public disputes have for too long obscured the view of what this government has achieved together: We are making progress on irregular migration – compared to last year, we have been able to reduce it by more than 50 percent. We are making great strides in securing energy and climate protection. For the first time, we are on track to truly achieve our expansion targets for wind and solar energy. Inflation has fallen to two percent, real wages and pensions are rising again. We have secured Germany's energy supply and stabilized energy prices. Just a few years ago, almost one in four had to work in the low-wage sector. Today, it is only one in seven. All of this is also good news. All of this has been achieved by the government made up of the SPD, the Greens, and also the FDP.

As Chancellor, I have sworn an oath of office. This oath is of great significance to me. I always keep the well-being of our entire country in mind. My firm conviction is: Never, never must we pit internal, external, and social security against each other. That endangers our cohesion – and ultimately even our democracy.

Why do I say this? Federal Minister Lindner has publicly and ultimatumly demanded a fundamentally different policy: Billion-euro tax cuts for a few top earners – and at the same time pension cuts for all retirees. That is not decent, that is not fair. Tax gifts with a watering can – and to finance this, a grab into the pockets of our cities and municipalities. A withdrawal from investments in the climate-friendly modernization of our country – that is also what Christian Lindner wants. This fuels uncertainty in our economy. And it jeopardizes our chance to be at the forefront of the technologies of the future.

The USA, China, and others are not standing still. Christian Lindner speaks in convoluted terms about the "extraction of efficiency reserves" in our social security systems. Behind this hides severe cuts in health or care and less security when someone is in need. This is disrespectful to all those who have worked hard for these securities, to all those who pay taxes and social contributions.

Politics begins with a consideration of reality. And the reality for Germany is: Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine has fundamentally changed the security situation for years to come.

We must invest significantly more in our defense and in the Bundeswehr – by the way: especially now, after the election outcome in the USA. 1.2 million Ukrainians have found refuge with us from Russian bombing terror. That remains right. With nearly 30 billion euros, we are supporting Ukraine in its defense struggle – we do this also because it serves our own security. A Russian victory would cost us many times more. Supporting Ukraine is and remains important.

And I also say very clearly: I am not willing to finance our support for Ukraine and investments in our defense at the expense of social cohesion – at the expense of pensions, health, or care. Both must be there: security and cohesion!

Therefore, I will not put citizens in the position of having to choose: Either we invest enough in our security – or we invest in good jobs, in a modern economy, and a functioning infrastructure. This either-or is poison!

Either security or cohesion, either supporting Ukraine or investing in Germany's future – creating this dichotomy is wrong and dangerous! This plays into the hands of the enemies of our democracy. Above all, however, this either-or is completely unnecessary, because Germany is a strong country. Among all major economically strong democracies, we have by far the lowest debt.

There are solutions for how we can finance our community and its tasks solidly. There are solutions for a budget that strengthens internal, external, and social security at the same time. I have proposed such a solution.

The Basic Law explicitly provides in Article 115 for the adoption of a resolution to exceed limits in an extraordinary emergency situation – just as the coalition had agreed at the end of last year precisely for this case.

The Russian war of aggression, which has now been raging for the third year, and all its consequences constitute such an emergency situation. When an emergency situation exists, the federal government not only has the right to act, but it is obliged to act.

What happens next? Federal Minister Lindner will be dismissed by the Federal President. I agree with Vice Chancellor Robert Habeck: Germany needs clarity about the further political course quickly.

The regular date for the federal election in the fall of next year is still a long way off. In the remaining weeks of the Bundestag sessions until Christmas, we will put all draft laws to a vote that cannot be postponed. This includes the compensation for cold progression, so that all employees will have more net from gross starting January 1. This includes the stabilization of the statutory pension. This includes the rapid implementation of the rules of the Common European Asylum System. This includes immediate measures for our industry, which I am currently discussing with companies, trade unions, and industry associations. These decisions should be made by the last session of the Bundesrat this year, on December 20.

Right in the first week of the Bundestag session in the new year, I will then pose the question of confidence – so that the Bundestag can vote on January 15. This way, the members of the Bundestag can decide whether to pave the way for early new elections. These elections could then take place by the end of March at the latest, in accordance with the deadlines set by the Basic Law.

Ladies and gentlemen, I will now quickly seek a conversation with the opposition leader, Friedrich Merz. I want to offer him the opportunity to work constructively together on two questions that are crucial for our country: in quickly strengthening our economy and our defense. Because: Our economy cannot wait until new elections have taken place. And: We need clarity now on how we can solidly finance our security and defense in the coming years – without jeopardizing cohesion in the country. Especially in light of the elections in America, this is perhaps more urgent than ever. It is about making the decisions that our country needs now. I will seek discussions on this with the responsible opposition.

Dear citizens, as Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, I will continue to devote all my strength to guiding our country through this difficult time. I am confident that with the right decisions, we will emerge from this crisis stronger.

I would like to add a personal remark: I spoke at the beginning about the necessity of making compromises. We must not lose this ability!

Anyone who has looked at the USA in recent weeks has witnessed a country that is deeply divided. A country where political differences have destroyed friendships and families. Where ideology makes cooperation across political boundaries almost impossible.

This must not happen to us in Germany – especially because we will also have to deal with election results in the future that require cooperation and compromises! This is often laborious. But that is exactly what has made Germany strong. That is what defines us. And that is what I am working on as your Chancellor.

Thank you very much.