Chancellor Scholz before works councils: Working for the future

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

7 November 2024

Context
Scholz addressed works council representatives on November 7, 2024, discussing geopolitical and economic challenges facing Germany amid Russia's ongoing war against Ukraine.
Main themes
Russia's war against Ukraine, European peace and security order, Germany's economic challenges, energy supply crisis, support for Ukraine, defense spending, border integrity, fiscal trade-offs, jobs and industry, works councils
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,252
79th percentile
Sentences
145
79th percentile
Readability
63
93rd percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
1.78
0th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 31%30%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Technological 15%14%
  • Geopolitical 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

145 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Good morning!

I would have said "Moin" in another context. Some understand that. I am pleased that we can talk to each other here in turbulent times, as has already been mentioned. But it was very important to me that we can discuss the current events, the challenges for the company, for the industry, for jobs, the economy, and all that concerns us.

Yes, these are indeed very special times. We just heard it, and that can only be emphasized. Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine has changed a lot for all of us. It has led to businesses no longer being possible because companies had to interrupt their activities there. We have seen that suddenly it is a huge challenge for Germany's energy supply, because many thought: How can we replace 50 percent of the gas from one day to the next? – We have experienced an incredible energy price and then price inflation, and many thought that this would lead to a significant economic crisis for our country in the long term. We have problems, but the economic crisis that everyone feared back then has not come, because we pulled ourselves together and ensured that we could secure our energy supply in other ways, with gas from other countries and with new terminals that we built quickly. But it remains an incredible challenge.

The war itself is also a challenge. I think there is probably no one in this room who does not watch the news on television or social media in the evening with concern and follows what is actually happening. A war in our neighborhood here in Europe! The largest country in Europe, Russia, has invaded the second largest country in terms of area, Ukraine, to annex a significant part or the whole of Ukraine. These are things we had hoped to know only from history books. But now it has suddenly become reality that simply because one has the power, a war is being waged, risking countless lives, so that later, when one is dead, one can read in the history books that one expanded one's own country by a few kilometers. This threatens peace in Europe, and we must not simply allow this to happen.

I would like to add at this point: It also calls into question the European peace and security order, which we have agreed upon in an incredible number of treaties and repeatedly reaffirmed, namely that borders should no longer be changed by force. That is something significant. Because there are quite a few politicians in Europe who, as presidents or heads of government, when they have nothing to do, could leaf through history books and see where what is now their country used to be. If everyone does that and suddenly looks in the afternoon and evening at what is written in those books, then we will have countless wars as a result of the wrong conclusions drawn.

That is why it is so important that this understanding has been upheld. That is why it was also so important that Chancellor Willy Brandt one day said: I am committed to signing a treaty that definitively establishes Germany's eastern border at the Oder to make peace and security possible. – That was his achievement. There was even a vote of no confidence in the Bundestag and a vote by the citizens on this. But Germany said: Never again should a German politician leaf through books and then say: There, the border should be changed. – This must remain and be the principle for all of Europe.

For this reason, and also for other reasons, we have economic problems and economic challenges that we must overcome. That is clear, and I will say a little more about that shortly. But of course, it is very costly to support a country in defending itself against such an attack. We are doing this as the second-largest supporter in the world after the United States of America, and in Europe as by far the largest supporter. The military aid that Germany has provided to Ukraine alone – and that is not all – has already amounted to almost 30 billion euros. When you consider the effort we have because we rightly provided protection to those who fled from the bombing terror in Ukraine, we are spending 12 billion euros per year to make this support possible. That is a lot of money. Some say that is not a lot of money. I say: That is a very large amount of money. – There are federal states in Germany that have a smaller budget. There are ministries, many ministries of the federal government, that have a smaller budget than this sum.

If one now comes to the conclusion that we should simply sweat this out on the side, then one sets the country on fire. I want to say this explicitly at this point. Then one sets the country on fire. This means that decisions must be made that we will not expand roads, that schools will not be further developed, that we cannot invest in research, that we cannot do anything for the economy and jobs, all the things that are challenging because we say: We want to do this at the expense of decisions in this country. – The proposals for how this should work are also broad: cutting pensions, somehow accessing certain social security systems, health and care, to say: We will take something out of there so that we can do what is our duty, namely to provide support.

Of the countries that support Ukraine, there is hardly any that goes the route of wanting to finance all this from the current budget. I say: Germany has done this so far because we have scraped together everything we could find in the corners of our budget. But there comes a point when the decision is: Either we pit internal security, external security, social security, and economic security against each other and ensure that cohesion and togetherness in Germany no longer function, or we say: This is a major, temporary challenge that we face, but it is clear that we must finance this outside of the normal budget. We cannot do this at the expense of the future and cohesion in Germany. – That is my position.

Yes, and that is also the reason – everyone is watching television and reading news on social media – why I will dismiss the Federal Minister of Finance today. I want to admit that I did not take this lightly. I count myself among those who do not shy away from responsibility and do not shy away from what is the hardest for most, namely making compromises. There are people who are great and always say: Forward, to the barricades, everything after me! – But the world is not such that everything is only directed by one or two people; rather, we must get along with each other, we must make compromises. In a democracy, it is also completely right that there are different views that must be debated and with which solutions must be found. But the foundations for what we do must also be right. That is why I find this decision correct – I want to say that – even after I made it yesterday, and I will do what is now necessary for our country. The government is doing its work – that will be the case in the coming weeks and months – and the citizens will soon have the opportunity to decide anew how things should continue. That is their right. Therefore, I will ask the Bundestag to hold a vote of confidence at the beginning of next year and then, in the end, the one that really matters, namely the citizens, to tell us how things should continue in Germany.

I come to the topics of economy and work that I have already mentioned. Yes, this is a great challenge – everyone knows that – because of the war and many other wars, by the way, also due to the increasingly growing protectionism that we are facing. This is an incredible challenge, by the way, a challenge that Germany faces much more than all other countries. Because if one wants to describe the German economic model – and some from other countries are currently doing this with mockery – one must say: We are the most closely intertwined economy in the world. There are also others that export many goods and services, but there are hardly any countries that export and import as much as Germany does when you consider it together. – This affects almost every product, including many services that we have. Also in this company, people are engaged in software development and other things all over the world, which are also part of a decision that states: Germany is connected to the whole world, with investments in other countries, with products and services that one receives from other countries, with products and services that we sell to other countries.

We have done quite well with this – that must be said – and have enabled a lot of prosperity for our country and contributed to it in other countries. If a world should now begin in which everyone divides into zones, in which political camps are tied between countries and everything no longer functions in the same way, then we will certainly feel that. That must be said very clearly.

That is why it is all the more important that we do what is in our power, what is in our hands, namely to ensure that we continue to navigate well into the future, because we are at the forefront technologically, because we are technologically leading. It is something special what you said. With our 84 million inhabitants, we are the third-largest economy in the world. Before us is China with over a billion inhabitants, and before that are the United States with a few hundred million inhabitants, not quite as many as in the EU, but economically equally strong. Then Germany is number three or four, depending on how the exchange rates between the euro and yen are at the moment. I think it is very, very important to realize that this is something special and that if we want to stay at the forefront, we can only achieve this by doing it with the most modern technologies that also have a chance in our country. By the way, this is a good reason why this conference is dealing with artificial intelligence. Because – I do not want to preempt the results of the conference and the discussions that will be held – there is indeed a clear answer that also corresponds to the German economic model. We use it. We want the research to be here. We also want the application to be here. We want new companies to emerge here that are based on it. At the same time, we naturally want to ensure that there is no misuse of the possibilities. I think that is an attitude one can have. But that does not mean closing oneself off; rather, it means using the opportunities and limiting the risks by being well-informed and doing what is necessary. Therefore, I think this is a good topic for this conference. It is one of the future questions of our economy and the whole world.

This applies to many, many other questions that concern us together: quantum computers, robotics, all the technologies that are there, including what we connect with analytical biology. – This is related to the other things because we can suddenly calculate things in a very short time that others previously estimated would take 50 years of calculations and operations. This can now sometimes be done in minutes and seconds. This is what is now important for our future, that we invest heavily in research and development, that we ensure that we have good infrastructure, and that we do this in all fields that are important to us.

One area of focus is, of course, also related to this company and its competitors. There is – I want to say – a great opportunity for Germany. We have not done so well with what is called hyperscalers, nor with the privately investing companies. There are now many other competitors who are very successful in this and are now investing a lot in Germany. But the telecommunications network can very well be where we can overtake and where we are very good, because we have good infrastructure, a first-class offering, and also develop the things that are possible with it, in various dimensions. I want to make this possible by saying: Our offerings should be top-notch worldwide. There should be nowhere better so that companies and citizens can utilize the new possibilities for fiber optics, for 5G, for all that plays a role.

If we do this, there will also be applications that companies will actually use step by step. This happens quite suddenly, by the way, just like with other issues that are important for modernity, such as the electrification of mobility. I have argued with many people and said: It works quite differently than you think, especially when it comes to charging infrastructure. For years, there were too many charging stations for too few electric vehicles, and suddenly, in one year, there are far too few for the many that have newly arrived, because people thought it would progress step by step. In reality, there are developments that go very slowly, but then they break through, and then we must be able to keep up with the infrastructure and the possibilities we have. This is also central in the field that plays a role for this company, that we invest enough and can keep up.

What can we do as a state? – We can create an environment where research plays a significant role, a setting in which we ensure that the most modern technology is also desired, and of course, the framework conditions for investment can be established. Cables need to be laid; mobile phone masts need to be built. Someone has to erect them. This is very practical, hard work that needs to be done. If the construction goes quickly but the approval takes a long time, then you have your problems.

That is why this is one of the major things we need to achieve as a breakthrough in Germany. We must ensure that the regulations, concerns, and rules that have grown over decades in Europe, in Germany, in the 16 states, in the 401 districts and independent cities, and in the 11,400 municipalities are streamlined so that things can move quickly again. It simply takes too long.

To this end, we have made quite a few laws. A few more are coming. I could tell many great adventure stories about this – I will not do that now – about whom I negotiated with, how many hours, and around which corner we turned to make it happen, so that the mobile phone mast comes faster. But there is one thing I would like to say. We still need a significant change in mentality in Germany. We cannot decree that; we can only strive for it together. My impression is: In the mid-1980s, if a mobile phone mast had come – there were not so many back then – the employee of the Lower Nature Conservation Authority would have called the investor and said: Come by! – Then they would have gotten in the car, driven to where it should stand, and one would have said: “I want to build it there,” and the other would have said: Can’t it be there? – By the way, that would still be a completely correct legal approach today, to solve it quickly and efficiently. Now everyone thinks that assessments about sight lines, flower populations, and various other things must be created. I wish that we not only streamline the laws so that decisions can be made quickly, but that the enthusiasm for quick, pragmatic decisions also grows everywhere. Because we cannot write that into any law; that is how one must be.

I want to address another topic that has already played a role in my opening remarks, which I believe is also important independently of current events. I think Germany's stability has something to do with the fact that we are a successful social state. Helmut Schmidt once said: Next to democracy, this is perhaps the greatest achievement that the Germans have fought for. This is not a charitable event, as some always think. This is not a kind of extended soup kitchen.

I want to elaborate on the topic of pensions. This is the most important asset that most citizens have. Those who leave school at 17 have five decades of work ahead of them, during which they pay contributions. Then you hope the whole time, for those 50 years, that this is something you can rely on, that the retirement age does not keep rising, that there is a stable level. I want to say this: These are protected values that are also protected by the Basic Law. Therefore, I am against the idea that every time someone wants to profile themselves as a reform politician, they say: First, we cut pensions. – The citizens of this country do not deserve that.

By the way, there is a small detail. I must mention this anecdotally because it drives me and, to be honest, also outrages me. There is the possibility of retiring two years earlier than the statutory retirement age if one has worked for 45 years. This is always referred to as “pension at 63.” We are no longer there; the regular age is already at 66. But this is always criticized in the professional journals where economics professors express their opinions. In the talk shows of the republic, it is said that this is a privilege that must be abolished immediately. One thing bothers me about that. If you leave school at 17 – some here in the room may have left at 15 or 16 and started working – then you reach 45 years before retirement. If you studied, you will not make it to 67. Now, in such a talk show, there are all sorts of people – I myself studied; this is not a discrimination against people with higher education – Professor So-and-so, Doctor So-and-so, Manager So-and-so, and when it is said that this is a privilege that must be abolished, then a lot of people who will never reach 45 contribution years are talking about whether people who started before their 20th birthday should no longer have this small privilege. That is wrong.

Therefore, I believe that we need impulses for economic growth. We must do something to ensure that the conditions for our companies work. We need to get energy prices under control, especially those that can rise because we are expanding the large power grid. That must happen, but it must not become a brake on investment calculations. But we must also ensure that our country stays together. Only if both succeed, economic growth, good research, good development, good infrastructure, and functioning social cohesion, can Germany be the strong country it wants to be and in whose traditions we want to continue to work for the future.

Thank you very much.