Government statement by Chancellor Olaf Scholz on the current situation before the German Bundestag on November 13, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

13 November 2024 · Government statement before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the Bundestag on November 13, 2024, explaining his dismissal of the finance minister, announcing a December confidence vote, and urging cross-party action before snap elections.
Main themes
Dismissal of finance minister, snap elections and vote of confidence, cross-party legislative cooperation, cold progression tax relief, economic growth initiative, child benefit increase, protection of Federal Constitutional Court, caretaker government, Weimar Republic lessons, democratic stability
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,612
82nd percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
8.9
10th percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
1.90
3rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 40%35%
  • Social 20%18%
  • Geopolitical 18%16%
  • Economic 17%15%
  • Ceremonial 5%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 11%

216 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Madam President!

Dear colleagues!

I would like to express my gratitude for the opportunity to comment on the current political situation. I had requested this. It was necessary, as I have made a decision that has already been mentioned here: I dismissed the Federal Minister of Finance last week. This has led to changes in the political landscape in Germany. I stated the reasons for this last week. And I want to emphatically and explicitly say here: This decision was right. And it was inevitable.

At the same time, I made it clear that there will soon be new elections in Germany due to the possibility of initiating this through a vote of confidence from the Federal Chancellor. And I am very pleased that the democratic factions in the German Bundestag have reached an agreement on how this can take place quickly and orderly, so that the citizens can decide soon. The date at the end of February is now set. And I am very grateful for that.

As Federal Chancellor, I will do my part to make this possible. Therefore, I will request the vote of confidence on December 11, so that the Bundestag can decide on it on December 16. This will then be the basis for the elections in Germany, so that the citizens can express how things should proceed in this country.

Until then, the Federal Government remains in office. This is the arrangement we found in the Basic Law after the experiences of the Weimar Republic. Of course, the Parliament is also capable of acting during this time. We can take action. And therefore, it is my firm conviction: We should use the time we have now to pass together very important laws that cannot be postponed, that are necessary for the citizens. I believe we must show the country this now.

Yes, we are heading into an election campaign. Different positions will be presented. And that is a good thing. But at the same time, it is the case that we, as democrats with different starting positions, can still act, because that must also be the case in the future, after the election. That should guide us in everything we do today. Therefore, my offer stands: Let us work together for the good of the country until the new election! It is solely about initiatives that can be agreed upon with a good majority, a democratic majority in this Bundestag. These are not matters where one can only achieve a majority with those who hold different positions.

There are positions, there are questions, there are topics for our country that cannot be postponed until after the Bundestag election in April or May, for example, first and foremost the question of more net from gross. We have decided that we want to bring forward a bill that ensures that the cold progression is offset. This should take effect on January 1 of next year, so that employees have more available in this difficult time. Therefore, I believe it would be a good thing if we, as factions that find this right, make such a decision this year. Let us ensure that the diligent people in this country, who strive every day, are relieved starting in January!

Secondly: We need growth impulses for our country. The Council of Economic Experts for the assessment of overall economic development and for advising the Federal Government has made proposals on this today and clarified that the growth initiative we have launched is central to this. Some of the initiatives contained therein have already been decided. Many are here in Parliament. And many are not contentious among most of those who bear responsibility here in Parliament. Therefore, I believe it would be good for the growth perspective of our country if we could quickly and efficiently pass as much of this growth initiative as possible for good growth in Germany.

There is child benefit and the child supplement – that is also up for debate – and an increase is planned for the beginning of next year. I also want to say at this point: For the many families in this country, it would be possible and necessary for us to clear the way across party lines so that the child benefit increase can actually take place in January.

And finally, there is a topic that concerns me greatly and many others as well – we have already heard it –: the protection of our Federal Constitutional Court. We have a good tradition – by the way, also a lesson that the Weimar Republic has left us – with a strong Federal Constitutional Court. Therefore, it is worth every effort and endeavor that we in the German Bundestag pass the planned amendments across factions. I ask for the protection of the Federal Constitutional Court. A look at neighboring countries shows that this can sometimes become difficult when populists and extremists become too strong. Therefore, this is a matter that cannot be postponed.

There are certainly many other initiatives that we can decide on this year and next year. Not all will find a majority. But there are some for which, in truth, a consensus exists between the largest opposition faction and the governing factions. And I believe that this consensus should also carry weight. This is not a matter where we showcase each other, where we say how one or the other is, but these are decisions we still need to make because they are possible. And my proposal, my appeal to this house: Let us act in unity where we agree! It would be good for our country.

Great efforts are necessary. They are needed now. They will also be needed in the future. And it is also clear: The times we live in are incredibly tough. It will not be easy, neither before the election nor after the election. All citizens of this country feel this quite acutely. The Russian war of aggression against Ukraine continues unabated. It remains necessary for us to support Ukraine. It remains necessary for us to do everything we can to prevent this war from escalating further. This is also a challenge we face.

There is the danger of escalation in the Near and Middle East. We see that free trade, which has made our economy so strong, is constantly under threat, that open markets are under pressure – something that we, as Germany, as an export-oriented nation, of course must respond to. And therefore, it is right that we resist this with all our might. It is about Germany's future and a common future in Europe.

I spoke with President Trump on Sunday. To begin with: It was a good conversation, a good conversation about many questions that concern us together, and incidentally an important signal – across party lines. From my perspective, the good transatlantic cooperation between Europe and the USA, the good transatlantic cooperation between Germany and the USA has been a foundation of our country's success for decades. We should do everything in the coming decades – regardless of who governs where – to ensure that these relationships continue to develop positively.

At the same time, Germany must live up to its responsibilities and resolutely continue on the path we have embarked upon. This path includes – I want to state this explicitly here – also what has been initiated as a consequence of the turning point by the government and supported by this German Bundestag: the special fund for the Bundeswehr, that we spend more on our defense, that we better coordinate in NATO and focus on national defense. We have further tasks to fulfill in Germany and Europe – for our security and for the security of Europe.

We must also strengthen our state and the economy. The crises of recent years show this. And we must work more closely together in this context. There was great consensus on this issue at the last European Council in Budapest. And everyone felt the desire to link arms. I agree with the French President that we must play a central role in keeping this Europe on course. And we will have to address these issues at the upcoming G20 summit in Brazil.

One task we have in Europe is clear: We must ensure that Ukraine, as a democratic, sovereign nation, has a good perspective. We have a responsibility to ensure that it is not left alone. This will need to be discussed there. But I also want to state explicitly – and this must be clear –: There must be no decisions made about Ukraine without Ukraine. Ukraine can count on our country and our solidarity.

In doing so, I do not want to hide the fact that, from my perspective, it is crucial that we do everything to ensure that this war does not escalate further and that we do not become a party to the war. And I want to say one more thing here: I affirm, I emphasize that I still find it right that I contributed to ensuring that there has been no escalation. I state explicitly: The country in Europe that does the most to ensure that Ukraine is not left alone and is supported is also a country that must ensure that this escalation does not occur. Therefore, I repeat my position on this issue: I am against the use of the weapons we supply being fired deep into Russian territory. And I will not change my position regarding the delivery of cruise missiles from Germany.

We will certainly discuss this in the election campaign. Therefore, I state this here so explicitly and emphasize it: I am glad that I have been able to take responsibility in this difficult time, as I am sure it has contributed to our acting thoughtfully and reasonably in a dangerous situation.

In the Bundestag election, the question will also be decided as to how we secure support for Ukraine in the future. Yes, we have done a lot to make this possible. I have worked worldwide – also together with the Federal Minister of Finance – to bring about a 50 billion dollar loan that enables global support, especially given the fact that many countries are no longer really able and willing to do as much as is necessary. How urgently required this was, we see now when we learn that a large part of the funds does not need to be spent, as we originally thought, primarily for defense, but must first contribute to budget stabilization.

Yes, it is right what we have done to organize support. But one question must be answered – we have discussed this in the government over the past years repeatedly, and we have really tried everything to make it possible differently. This question is: Should support for Ukraine be financed with more than twelve billion euros from the German federal budget at the expense of decisions that are necessary for the future of our country? My answer is: No.

Therefore, we cannot cut investments in our infrastructure, let roads, bridges, and railways rot, and not bring the necessary investments forward. It cannot be that the necessary funds for the modernization of our economy are lacking and that we pay for this with less growth for companies and fewer jobs. I also repeat what I have said elsewhere: It cannot be, and it should not be from my perspective, that support for Ukraine leads to cuts in pensions, care, and health. I want to spare our country all of this.

Now some act as if this were not up for debate. But! I say: Yes, it is up for debate. And this will also be the major debate in the upcoming Bundestag election. Therefore, it is good that it will take place soon and that the citizens will have their say.

I want to address the question of the pension level. There is the government's proposal, which is before Parliament, to stabilize the pension level. I also want to say clearly and unequivocally here – let us engage in the controversies over this question –: Those who do not want to stabilize the pension level will ultimately cut pensions. They will be lower for today's employees. And that is something we should not accept. This is a pension cut by omission. I state explicitly: Not with me.

This also applies to the proposals we recently discussed in the governing coalition with representatives of the FDP. The idea that one should change the formula by which the pension level is calculated sounds at first like mere mathematics. But in the end, compared to today's calculations, a lower real level results. And that means for future generations that their pension level and thus their pension will be lower. To this, I also say: Not with me!

Last week, I made proposals on how we can achieve all of this, how we can maintain external and internal, economic and social security, without pitting one against the other. The coalition partner was not willing to do so. This is a disagreement on a fundamental issue. And I could not and do not want to impose that on this country. That is why I had to draw consequences.

Now, the citizens will also decide in February on the question of whether we hold our country together or whether we split it apart. This is not a question for some cultural supplement, where one ponders how it could be. This is a real question that the citizens have to decide. And this is also the central question of the upcoming election. That is what it is about in February. I want to avoid distribution struggles of "everyone against everyone." I do not want one to be played off against the other. I want our country and our democracy to remain strong.

And of course, this includes that we invest more in security. We are doing that; there should be no doubt about it. But I say with the same clarity: This must never come at the expense of our cohesion, never at the expense of pensions, health, or care. Security and cohesion – one cannot have the one without the other. I said this last Wednesday. And I repeat it here: I will never put the citizens in the position of having to choose: Either we invest in our security or in good jobs and the economy and infrastructure, either we spend money on the Bundeswehr, or we have secure pensions, either we support Ukraine, or we invest in Germany. This either-or is wrong and leads our country astray. This either-or is a stimulus program for populists and extremists. It harms and tears Germany apart.

This strange either-or and the corresponding proposals come, by the way, almost always only from people who do not have to calculate whether the money or the pension will last until the end of the month, from people who do not have to worry about the new washing machine, the annual vacation, or the school trip for the children. But I am concerned about those who have to think about these things, who do not have a loud lobby, who work hard and still cannot make significant progress. This either-or would hit them particularly hard. And we should not allow that.

By the way: In none of the other major economically strong democracies is there a comparable debate. I do not agree with everything that is decided elsewhere in the G7 countries. And I am very proud that Germany is a country that manages its money well and has a national debt that is heading towards 60 percent, while that of our partners is over 100 percent.

When I speak with the heads of government in Canada or Japan, they do not say: more money for digitalization and climate protection, but we will cut pensions for people. The British Prime Minister would not even think of saying: We will invest more in our army, but we will cut health care. A conservative predecessor of the current Prime Minister tried that, and she was in office for exactly 45 days. In all these countries, it is clear: We must now strengthen our security, but we must also invest in a modern economy and good jobs, in infrastructure and technologies, for the good jobs of the future, so that we can earn money with them in 10, 20 years, in technologies where Germany can be at the forefront.

That is the decision at hand. It is about whether we, like our partners worldwide, move forward, invest powerfully and securely for the future, and hold the country together, or whether we pit one against the other at the expense of our future, at the expense of our cohesion. I have made it clear and repeat what I stand for, what I fight for. I am confident that the upcoming election will bring broad support for this course.

There are still just over three months until the election. Then the citizens will decide. Before that, there will be the election campaign. That keeps democracy alive. One thing we should never forget, despite the discussions we have during the election campaign and in conversations with the citizens: There is also the day after the election campaign, the day after the federal election. On that day, democratic competitors will have to sit at a table and look each other in the eye. Competitors must come together and work out solutions, and that must be done together. Then, polarization does not count, but cooperation and compromises, across party lines and also – this is becoming apparent – across political camps. This is all not easy. I have experienced this in the past three years and – I do not want to hide this – have also paid a high price for it.

But I am convinced: The path of compromise remains the only right way. It takes strength and courage to move away from one's own position to enable a solution for all. There is no other way in a federal democratic country. Where everyone has worked well together, there are good results, by the way, also together with the CDU/CSU, often also in the states. And that is a good thing. As an example, I mention the special fund for the Bundeswehr – a necessary response to the turning point in times. I also mention the cooperation with the states when it comes to irregular migration. Asylum applications have decreased by more than 50 percent. This is a great success of joint action in government, executive, and legislation.

We have also become faster in expanding renewable energies, wind power, and solar energy, and the power grids. Real wages are rising again, as are pensions. Inflation is back at two percent. And we have – let us not forget – secured the energy supply of this country when Russia suddenly turned off the gas tap and stabilized energy prices with very many billions.

As a Social Democrat, I add: I am also proud that the low-wage sector has become smaller. Previously, one in four was employed there; today, it is one in seven. A significant and by no means the only contribution was the increase in the minimum wage, which gave six million employees more money. Those who earn little, work hard, and are diligent deserve respect. They are the achievers in this country.

All of this shows what is possible when we pull together. That this has not been possible in government work recently is something I regret. From that, I drew the necessary consequences last Wednesday. By that, I do not mean only the consequence of dismissing the federal minister. I have also drawn the consequence for myself: Public disputes must never again overshadow the successes of the government. I will ensure that – with the consequences that this can have. Of course, this does not work with a fist on the table or by declaring everyone an opponent, but by making compromises possible, fighting for them, and enforcing them. That is why I will certainly not regret that I offered compromises day in and day out, until the end, until the last day of this governing coalition. There is no democracy without compromises, no cohesion, and no cooperation without compromises.

We have all followed the elections in the United States. We have seen how controversial, how highly emotional the debate has been there and how divided the country is. I read a book by an American author titled "Why We’re Polarized," a topic that must move one. The country is deeply divided. Political differences tear friendships and families apart.

I do not want it to come to that in Germany. I want us not only to talk about each other but also with each other. I want us not to look down on others. Rich against poor, young against old, conservative against liberal, born here or arrived later, big city against countryside – if we split up like that or allow ourselves to be split, then we have a problem. Some want that division. It is their political business model. They are the ones who want the division.

And that is why I say: We Democrats must work together to ensure that this does not happen. Even if we have different political views, one thing is clear: We live in one country. We are better off when we stand together, when we can still look each other in the eye after a dispute. This applies to politics, and it applies to our entire country.

Thank you very much.