Appearance of the President of the Government and the Prime Minister of Portugal at the Luso-Spanish Summit

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

10 October 2020 · Luso-Spanish Summit · Town Hall, Guarda, Portugal

Context
Sánchez spoke alongside Portuguese PM Costa at the Luso-Spanish Summit in Guarda, Portugal on 10 October 2020, addressing bilateral and European cooperation priorities.
Main themes
Luso-Spanish bilateral relations, European recovery fund, COVID-19 pandemic response, cross-border development strategy, Portuguese EU presidency, ecological and digital transition, social and territorial cohesion, immigration and asylum pact, relations with Latin America and Africa, Treaty of Friendship, gender perspective in pandemic recovery
Duration
~50 min
94th percentile
Words
5,944
94th percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
14.0
67th percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 31%31%
  • Economic 26%26%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Geopolitical 15%15%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

216 sentences in 72 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon.

Thank you to the media for attending this appearance. Thank you, also, to the ministers of the Portuguese Government and of course to the vice presidents and the ministers, secretaries of state, and the rest of the delegation from Spain. Thank you, also, dear Prime Minister for the hospitality here in Guarda. Thank you, also, to the mayor for allowing us to use the facilities of this Town Hall to hold this important Summit.

A Summit that we have described in the bilateral meeting, in the plenary we had, as a Europeanist summit. I believe that today more than ever this Summit, if it has an accent, is the Europeanist accent for multiple reasons.

First, because Europe must provide a common response to a common problem, which is the pandemic. We are doing this from the perspective of health emergency, for example, negotiating with pharmaceutical companies for the arrival of that vaccine that we hope science can provide as soon as possible.

Also from the economic and social point of view with that great agreement we achieved last July with the Recovery Fund. I mentioned to Prime Minister Costa that we in Spain have been very attentive to the presentation of Portugal's Recovery Plan, both from the governance perspective and from the perspective of the objectives. And I want to emphasize the complete alignment that the Recovery Plan we presented this very week has with the objectives set by the Portuguese Government: ecological transition, digital transition, cohesion - social cohesion and also territorial cohesion - and the gender perspective in the face of this pandemic, which is logically affecting in a very singular way more than half of the population, which is the female population.

Secondly, I think it is very important the step we have taken, which was a mandate that was already established for us at the Summit in Valladolid in 2018, and that is to have a cross-border development strategy, as has also been said in the plenary by the different drafters and proponents this is a political strategy with a very clear objective, which is equality of opportunities, not only for people but also for territories. And in that sense, it is not a strategy that remains in vagueness or abstractions, but rather proposes a common governance system, also proposes concrete measures. And I think that is very important for territories that are included in the Border, whether in the Portuguese part or in the Spanish part.

And finally, we have proposed, in addition to many areas of cooperation from the agro-food perspective, from the territorial perspective, from the perspective of cultural collaboration and cooperation - for example, in strengthening that common heritage we have of both languages.

Finally, one of the most important aspects that, in my opinion, we will work on over the next weeks and months, is the Portuguese presidency of the European Union that will begin at the beginning of next year. For the Government of Spain, the fact that at such a crucial moment for Europe and the world, Portugal will lead that first semester of next year, is a source of tranquility, of confidence, because after all there are very important issues that we have to address, which affect the day-to-day lives of many citizens, millions of citizens, both in Portugal and in Spain. The exit of the United Kingdom from the European Union, the implementation of those recovery plans at the European level, also the Pact on immigration and asylum, which logically affects two countries like ours, relations with Ibero-America, with the backdrop, as we well stated in the conclusions of those cooperation frameworks, of trade that we have to establish with Latin America, but also with Africa, and that strategy that we have to define in Europe, in the Mediterranean, that is, with the southern neighborhood.

In short, there are many issues that if anything represent, it is the Treaty of Friendship that was the one that initiated these bilateral summits. That Treaty of Friendship that both countries achieved in 1977, linked with geographical proximity, also linked with interdependence in multiple areas from the social perspective, from the environmental perspective, to name just two. And that shared vision we have of how the Europe of tomorrow and the future should be.

Therefore, I want to thank you, dear Antonio, also to the colleagues from the Portuguese Government, for the proximity, the ease of being able to work together, the alignment of many of the objectives we have and that both administrations and both countries share, and the desire that we meet again. In this case, next year it will be Spain's turn in a new bilateral summit, which will exemplify what is being seen here today: the strength of our relations and above all, the confidence that they will continue to be even stronger in the future.

Mr. Costa.- Thank you very much, Pedro. I wanted to welcome the President of the Government of Spain, the vice presidents and ministers of the Government of Spain, and emphasize that it is only possible to hold this Luso-Spanish Summit at such a difficult time as the one we are all experiencing with the COVID-19 pandemic because the intensity of our relations makes it absolutely essential.

We are not just neighboring countries, we are countries that share the affairs of the European Union, the Community of Ibero-American countries, we are allies within NATO, and we have two languages with a wide international representation in this global world. That is why even in this situation we are living, we cannot stop having the normality of our annual meetings to deepen our relationship.

This year we meet here, in Guarda, founded by the second king of Portugal, Sancho I, known as "The Populator," and there could not be a better nickname for a Summit that is focused on the theme of cross-border cooperation and the development of these border regions, which on both sides of the border are precisely the most depopulated we have in our countries.

But Sancho I is also a good example of how familiarity marks the closeness of our relations; he married an Aragonese princess, and of his multiple daughters, one was queen of Castile and another of León; which means that from the origins our neighborhood relations are not marked only by mere friendship, but it is a very close family relationship.

This cross-border development strategy is a strategy for us to develop together in the coming years and has several dimensions:

The first and most important has to do with facilitating the lives of people; the people who live on both sides of the border. Through a cross-border status, through the creation of a health card that allows treatment on both sides of the border using the public services available in both countries.

The second fundamental dimension is the cooperation between our public services, for me, perhaps, the most evident case is what was agreed regarding the 112 Network that allows the closest responder to an emergency to respond. Whether it is a Portuguese ambulance in Spain or a Spanish one in Portugal, the one that is closest to the emergency will respond. But also a dimension of developing common projects, ambitious common projects, in accordance with the needs of the country, we can be a great digital actor, Spain will soon carry out the new cable connection with the African continent, in June Portugal will join the new cable connection with Latin America, an extraordinary advance in infrastructure to be a fundamental hub in these new digital industries, of data, of blockchain, of Artificial Intelligence.

But we must also talk about energy; the challenge of the digital transition completely transforms our relationship in terms of interconnections. We can be leaders in energy transition and develop the best environmental mix of renewable energies in all of Europe if we work together. But being countries that also have significant reserves of a mineral fundamental for the construction of electric batteries, such as lithium, we must have the ambition not to limit ourselves to extracting those resources, but rather, on the contrary, working together to develop the industrial capacity so that the higher value-added products that are manufactured from those natural resources are made in industries in the Iberian Peninsula and specifically in this border region so that we can develop and benefit together.

We decided to develop this strategy a few years ago, in Valladolid we gave it a fundamental boost by designating the technical teams, and I want to thank here and now the Spanish and Portuguese technicians who worked hard so that we can be here approving it, and approved in time to be integrated into the next Multiannual Financial Framework of the EU. This time we will not go separately to Brussels to defend our proposals, we will go together to present a vision, a strategy, concrete projects, and we want to develop them together, because we want this border region not to be a point of separation, but a meeting point between our two countries.

And, obviously, the new Recovery and Resilience Plans can, and must, incorporate these priorities, that is why in the program we are going to develop we identified 5 cross-border issues that are totally strategic to unblock this territory from our interior with a new union with Spain, to create a centrality in the Iberian market throughout the border area. The connection of Castelo Branco with Cedillo, of Braganza with Puebla de Sanabria, of Nisa with Cedillo, of Alcoutim and San Lucar del Guadiana; and the development of proximity between several communities on both sides of the border is essential for our common future.

I wanted to congratulate President Sánchez on the launch of his Recovery and Resilience Program that he presented this week and that defends the same priorities that we also defend; to strengthen resilience from the perspective of our strategic autonomy, to strengthen and accelerate the climate transition, to strengthen and accelerate the digital transition, for all of this I believe we have excellent conditions to leave here stronger and with better tools to help develop this border region; which means strengthening the resilience of the Iberian Peninsula, and with a stronger Iberian Peninsula we can work within the framework of the European Union, within the framework of neighborhood policy with the other southern countries, with the other countries of the Mediterranean basin, from the north and the south, and also with the entire Ibero-American community, almost a continent that is divided between those who speak my Portuguese and those who speak Pedro's Spanish.

Thank you very much to everyone for the work done, and I am sure that at the next Summit in a year in Spain we will take more steps to continue moving forward.

Thank you very much, Pedro.

P.- Hello, good afternoon, I am Ana Fernández Vila from Europa Press. I would like to ask the president first about Madrid. I would like to know why the state of alarm was not declared earlier if the Government considered that the president of Madrid was doing nothing, as Minister Illa stated yesterday, and if they are considering tightening restrictions. And on the other hand, I would like to ask both of you if you have reached any agreement to advance on the issue of high-speed rail connections. If the AVE Madrid, Lisbon and the one from Vigo to Porto will ever become a reality, and if there are any timelines being considered. Thank you.

Mr. Costa. Okay, regarding Madrid I will not answer because it is a bit far from the border. As for high-speed rail, surely one day Portugal will not be left out of the Iberian high-speed network, which we will do in "tempo proprio." It should be noted that it is not a "point-to-point" connection, but a "connection" from country to country and that we have to find a connection that can integrate the whole of Portugal, contributing positively to the strengthening of our territorial cohesion. That will be a path that we will continue to "continuar a façer." For now, we will complete the work that is underway to increase the railway connections that are in progress in the southern corridor between Sines and Caya. And also here in the Vera Baixa and Vera Alta lines. After that, we will surely have the opportunity to continue working to develop what remains to be developed.

President.- Well, thank you for your questions. Regarding infrastructure - I will get to Madrid later - I want to complement what Prime Minister Costa has said. I believe that the declaration and the conclusions establish a fairly clear roadmap on cooperation in infrastructure. We have also been talking about some future axes that we will have to think about, design. For example, what the Mediterranean corridor represents, the Atlantic axis, and see how we can also find new connections between both countries there.

Secondly, Spain has been making a very important, very determined commitment to high-speed rail for many years. We are going to finish in a very short time, with the arrival of the AVE to the north of Spain, to Galicia. This will also have, logically, an impact on our neighbor Portugal. We also have a fairly certain commitment to Extremadura. It is a demand from the people of Extremadura that they have the most dignified possible rail transport. The Government of Spain wants to fulfill that commitment, not just politically and electorally, but socially. It is a justified demand, and therefore, we will continue to work in those scenarios and see how we can effectively give them continuity with our Portuguese friends.

Regarding Madrid, let's see. I believe that yesterday the Minister of Health was very clear, very explicit in his press conference after the Council of Ministers, where, as you know, we approved a territorialized state of alarm for the Community of Madrid, specifically for a certain series of municipalities.

I think what the Minister of Health has always said is what I share, what the entire Government shares. We have always placed public health, saving lives, above any other consideration. We have thought, and we also ask all leaders to do the same, to think about the sick, to think about the healthcare professionals who are facing COVID again in hospitals, in primary care centers. To also think about the families of the victims, about the victims themselves, and therefore, to be aware that we must provide a clear, forceful response to the evolution of the pandemic in certain territories.

It is evident, it is clear, because the data is there, that the accumulated incidence in the Community of Madrid and particularly in some municipalities is very high, and it is a worrying evolution. We also see the positivity rate of the PCR tests being conducted in the Community of Madrid. We also see the level of occupancy in hospitalizations in the Community of Madrid. We also see what the level of occupancy in ICUs represents. Therefore, it is evident that we must provide a determined response to the situation of the pandemic in Madrid. That is what the Government has done. In fact, what we are doing is simply providing a legal response, but continuing with the measures that have been implemented over the past week.

Therefore, we hope that during the next 15 days that the state of alarm will last, we can contain the pandemic in Madrid, that we can bend the curve, and consequently, we continue to extend our hand to the Government of the Community of Madrid to work together. But we had to provide a response to this situation because we could not stand idly by. And that is what the Government of Spain did yesterday by approving this state of alarm.

Q.- Fátima Marques Faria, from RTP. This Summit comes at the end of a particularly difficult week for both countries regarding the evolution of COVID-19 case numbers, precisely on the day Portugal reached its record with more than 1,600 cases. I ask both heads of government, is there an option for a return to border closures or health controls at some points along the border? Specifically for the Portuguese Prime Minister, can Portugal soon, similar to what happened in Madrid, implement some measures? And specifically, can we return to a State of Calamity? Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much for your question. Let's see, I believe that in addition, Europe, in the last European Council, both Prime Minister Costa and I had the opportunity to share this with the rest of the European presidents and prime ministers. The evolution of the pandemic is worrying across the entire European continent. We are seeing an increase in infections in each and every European country, whether it be France, Germany, Italy, the United Kingdom, or the Netherlands, to name a few examples, or beyond the Iberian Peninsula.

Secondly, what we want is to provide a common response. I think it is also important during these months of the pandemic to be aware of those things we have done well, but also those things where we need to be much clearer with citizens. For example, regarding quarantines. Whether they should be 14 days, or if they should be seven days. We need to provide a homogeneous response across the territory, and therefore we do not contemplate at all the closure of borders, as I understood from the question posed by the Portuguese journalist. We have no such intention at all. Moreover, any decision we make will be made from a homogeneous and shared perspective, obviously, with the Portuguese government and with the rest of the European governments.

Mr. Costa.- As President Sánchez has said, Europe is facing a very strong new wave with a higher number of new cases than in the first wave, although fortunately we are much better prepared, first individually with the use of masks, with the habit of frequently washing our hands, with physical distancing, and I again call for everyone to download the COVID tracking app, which is essential for quickly detecting situations of proximity with accidental risk contacts. The app is anonymous; no one knows who the risk contact was, who is infected, but it is essential to have information about school, work, a store, etc., to know who has been within 15 minutes at less than 2 meters of an infected person. Its use is fundamental to control transmission.

I believe we are all aware that society, families, and businesses cannot bear the cost of a total shutdown like that at the beginning of the pandemic again; the costs in terms of jobs are brutal, we have thousands of unemployed since the beginning of this pandemic, thousands of families with loss of income, it is an immense social cost, which is why we must manage to control the pandemic with new tools; we cannot stop everything again. These new tools must be the individual responsibility of everyone; we must be very responsible in maintaining the rules, and the costs are not only economic; they are also social. The cost of not being able to move freely, having to be isolated, not having contact with family is a cost that is difficult to measure but real. We all know the cost in terms of learning from having to close schools; these are costs we cannot afford again, which is why we must appeal for greater individual responsibility and less legal imposition for compliance with the rules.

Regarding the borders, Portugal and Spain have been exemplary throughout these months, and contrary to what happened in other countries, there were no unilateral measures; neither Portugal closed the border without consulting Spain nor vice versa; we always worked together. I believe that right now a border closure is not justified; we are in a totally different situation than in April, not in the number of cases, but in the knowledge we have of the virus and in the capacity of the health system to combat it, and also in the severity of the cases. Now the affected population is a younger population, and the infections are less severe, allowing national health services to have the capacity to treat the sick, and therefore those measures are not justified.

Q.- Hello, good afternoon. I wanted to ask Prime Minister Costa the agreed question from the delegation of Spanish journalists. Both in Spain and in Portugal, you are relying on European funds for your economic recovery. Are you concerned that the European negotiation may pose some impediment given the resistance we have already seen from the so-called frugal countries? How do you think the management of the pandemic in Spain is, and can it somehow hinder the Portuguese economy as well?

And on the other hand, to President Sánchez. Just yesterday, the World Health Organization said regarding Spain that when governments differ, people die. Do you consider it a failure to have had to declare the state of alarm without an agreement with Madrid? How do you now expect to redirect the situation with President Ayuso? In 15 days, how do you see the horizon? Because you would have to request authorization from Congress if you decide to extend the state of alarm. Thank you.

Mr. Costa.- Okay. Regarding the European funds, they are critical for the response capacity of the different countries to face the economic and social crisis. We are not only experiencing a health crisis but also an economic and social one, and something that has been historic is that in July Europe managed to take an incredible step for some years, which is to issue joint debt to finance a robust response program to the crisis. Every day we lost is one more day we lost in protecting citizens, protecting jobs, protecting people who have to continue facing this.

We also need to improve public health. We need to improve the economic and social health of our societies. So, my hope is that very soon the European Parliament and the Council reach an agreement that allows the European funds to be available by January 1, 2021. That would be the best way to start the Portuguese presidency of the European Union.

I am not going to comment on the management of Spain, Great Britain, or the United States in the pandemic. We are all trying to do our best, and if we look at the figures in different countries, at different times, there are countries that at first had excellent results and that are now having very poor results. This is not a time to judge; it is a time to support, help, be solidary, and try to do better. Because we are fighting a new enemy that we do not know, and that even science does not know. It is learning day by day because we are witnessing a process of real-time research, having to decide in real time without knowing all the variables.

So, what we all have to do is try to learn a little from each other and help each other. No one should think that there are magic solutions because there are none.

Pedro and I have heard from our colleagues in another council that it was one of the countries that before the summer was one of those that quickly lifted all restriction measures and was one of the champions of "success" and now says: look, everything has changed. Now it is having the worst results in the entire European Union. So what we need to know is that the risk exists and work to ensure that tomorrow is better than today, but knowing that it could be worse.

President.- I believe that, as Prime Minister Costa rightly comments, humility is fundamental in facing this pandemic because there is indeed no clear roadmap. Science is still discovering how to tame the virus, and therefore, I believe that all authorities, all administrations, must act with the utmost humility.

Secondly, with the utmost unity. I share the reflection that not only the WHO made yesterday but has been making for a long time. This is not the first time. We have heard the Director-General of the WHO say many times that the partisan use being made of the pandemic, or the pandemic by some political actors, only serves to divide societies and make them weaker in their response to the virus.

That is why the Government of Spain, from the very first minute, has said that we must promote unity, that we must banish partisan fighting from the pandemic because indeed if there is a common enemy, that common enemy is the virus. This is an epidemiological battle, not an ideological battle. This is the essence of the challenge we are facing. That is why I said that we must banish partisan fighting from the pandemic.

That is why I appealed for unity, not only in the area of budgets, which is fundamental in our country for the coming year, but a unity that we are practicing from the Government of Spain. We have already achieved six agreements with social agents on fundamental issues, such as the extension of the arts, which is covering more than 750,000 workers, and self-employed workers. The ICO lines that have guaranteed the financial survival of more than half a million companies in our country, with an unprecedented effort on the part of the administration. Ultimately, from the entire citizenry with their taxes.

Therefore, I believe that unity, the banishment of partisan fighting from the pandemic, should be, I believe, the tone, the direction that guides the political action of all actors and all parties. We have certainly practiced it with social agents, with the autonomous communities, with the Conference of Presidents, the European Union, with that agreement to which Prime Minister Costa previously referred, and I would like it to reach Parliament.

Regarding the Community of Madrid, I insist again, we all have to put ourselves in the shoes of healthcare professionals, of the sick, of the victims of COVID and their families, and be aware that we must prioritize public health and the defense of life over any other consideration. And the dilemma was quite simple in this area for the Government of Spain.

After the resolution of the High Court of Justice of Madrid, we could take two attitudes. Either do nothing, or apply the state of alarm precisely for that perimeter confinement, proposing the same restrictions in the city of Madrid and in other municipalities of the Community of Madrid, but with a different legal instrument. And we hope that after these seven days plus the 15 days, we will be in a situation where the pandemic in the Community of Madrid can indeed be controlled, not only having flattened the curve, but being able to contain the pandemic.

And precisely yesterday, the Minister of Health said, because there have also been other resolutions from other high courts of justice in other territories, that invoking the law of 1986, the Health Law - which the Community of Madrid surprisingly did not invoke in this last matter before the High Court of Justice of Madrid, but did in six previous resolutions - invoking that law of 1986 allows for action with a legal backing that I believe is solid in the face of perimeter confinements like the one we are proposing in Madrid.

Therefore, what I want to say with this is that there are sufficient legal instruments. They are being endorsed precisely by the high courts of justice of the different territories. Yesterday we learned, for example, of a case in Castilla y León. Or in other territories: in Andalusia, we have also learned of a similar resolution in the same sense.

In short, what I want to say is that we should banish partisan fighting against a common enemy, which is the virus, and from a battle that we must fight from a scientific, technical, and not ideological point of view. Because this is an epidemiological battle and not an ideological one.

From there, of course, I also mentioned to the president of the Community of Madrid in the various telephone conversations we had in these two previous days that we are always, always, always open to talking with the Community of Madrid, to negotiating and dialoguing about measures that can be implemented in the coming weeks. Because, I insist, we - I told the president of the Community of Madrid at Puerta del Sol and I reiterate it every time I am asked about this issue - we do not come to impose, nor to oversee, nor to judge. What we come to do is to help, to collaborate, to cooperate. And at the moment when the solutions that we consider from a technical and scientific point of view should be taken to curb the curve, in this case in a specific territory of our country, the Government of Spain cannot look the other way. We have not done so at any time during this pandemic and we will not do so as long as the pandemic lasts. All Spanish citizens, wherever they live, can be assured of that. We will always put ourselves in the shoes of those who suffer from this pandemic, of healthcare professionals, of the sick, of the victims, and of their families.

Q.- Prime Minister Antonio Costa, I would like to know what the situation is for the approval of the Budgets for 2021. Today we had statements from the coordinator of the Left Bloc, Catarina Martins, who said they were at an impasse, and I would like to know how the negotiations are going with another actor, this will be easier, the Portuguese Communist Party. For President Sánchez, I have a curiosity; I would like to know if there is any particular interest in having Portugal and Spain take a common position on 5G networks coming from China, considering the position of the U.S. and the pressures being received in Europe from the U.S. Thank you.

President.- Well, as this is the last of the questions, I would like to thank the media for their presence and, of course, thank Prime Minister Costa and the Portuguese authorities for their hospitality.

On this issue, I would like to say that Spain takes pride in being the country with the largest fiber optic network in our territory. To give you an idea, the extent of fiber optic in our country represents the total sum of countries as important as Germany, France, and I believe the United Kingdom. Therefore, we are talking about a systematic commitment we have made for a long time to extend fiber optic. We are one of the countries that have launched pilot projects for the extension of 5G very early on.

In fact, major telecommunications operators in our country have announced significant multimillion-dollar investments precisely for the extension of 5G throughout the territory. In fact, one of the main technology corporations in our country, Telefónica, has guaranteed that before the end of this year, 75% of the entire Spanish territory will have access to 5G technology.

And we are doing this with various foreign companies, not only with Huawei - therefore with this Chinese company you referred to earlier - but also with Nokia and other European and American companies.

Therefore, we will continue to bet on this technology, and we will also continue to bet on and diversify, let’s say, those alliances with other operators, not only from our continent but also from China. And in that sense, what I believe is that we need to reinforce something that Prime Minister Costa mentioned earlier and that I share. I believe that the Iberian Peninsula can become a great hub for data interconnection. In the conclusions of this summit, we talked precisely about those 5G gateways that we can build throughout the Iberian Peninsula.

And I believe that is the future. But the future is not only for large corporations but also for small businesses in territories like Guarda or others that are on the other side of the border, in the province of Salamanca or in other areas of the border. Because, after all, when we are talking about interconnection, we are talking about equality of opportunities, not only from a social point of view but also territorial.

I believe that one of the great successes of the strategy we are launching today is precisely that we talk about the need for 5G, for technologies to reach every single point of our countries.

Mr. Costa.- Regarding the negotiations of the Budgets that we will present in the Assembly of the Republic next Monday, I believe that the essential conditions have been created for there to be an agreement.

First, this crisis cannot justify cuts to the progress made since November 2015. This budget does not cut the achievements made since that date.

Second, it is a budget that contains advances; it is not austere and seeks to increase the income of families, support job creation, and invest in public investment to boost the economy. Regarding income, we send a clear signal that, despite the crisis, we maintain our commitments, and, for example, the minimum wage will rise to €750 by the end of the legislature, and this year, despite the crisis, we will raise the minimum wage.

Regarding the lowest pensions, as we have done in recent years, we will again make an extraordinary increase in them, which is especially relevant this year because, with no inflation or economic growth, applying the formulas of social security, pensions should not have increased.

The situation is very complicated for people living in precarious situations, in the informal economy, and if the measures we have cannot provide them with a minimum dignified income, we will create extraordinary social protection for periods of crisis that guarantees that no one is left with income below the poverty line; we will also alter the calculation of unemployment so that it is contributory or does not fall below the poverty line.

And finally, we will reduce the withholding of salaries to ensure that all employees have higher incomes in 2021 because there will be lower withholdings.

Therefore, there are advances; the income of pensioners, employees, and those in vulnerable situations who need social benefits is increasing. In short, these are progressive budgets, which is why I believe there will be an agreement with the Left Bloc and the Portuguese Communist Party. Of course, there are issues on which we do not agree, issues we are working on, and which have submitted written proposals to the document sent on Friday. We are preparing the response to the PCP; tonight I will receive the written response from the Left Bloc, and we are working on the written response.

In essence, there is no reason not to reach an agreement, and we are negotiating it, and with political will, I believe we will have a good Budget in 2021, and it is key because, in the crisis situation we have, where we will have such important extraordinary resources from the EU for the Recovery and Resilience Plan, it would be incomprehensible not to be able to use our own budgetary resources. We need to have a solid Budget that strengthens the economy, job creation, and families. We need a good budget for 2021, and surely the left will build that budget; there is no other way.

Thank you all, and I take this opportunity to thank the City Council of Guarda for their hospitality. Thank you.