Control session of the Government in the Senate

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

5 May 2020 · Senate, Spain

Context
Sánchez addressed a Senate control session on May 5, 2020, facing opposition questions about his absence from the Commission of Autonomous Communities and Spain's COVID-19 state of alarm.
Main themes
State of alarm extension, parliamentary debate and transparency, government-regions cooperation, COVID-19 management, ERTE aid measures, Popular Party opposition, public health law alternatives, institutional dialogue, autonomous communities relations
Duration
~62 min
96th percentile
Words
7,473
96th percentile
Sentences
241
92nd percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
13.8
65th percentile
Syntax
3.32
84th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 32%31%
  • Economic 27%26%
  • Social 25%24%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

241 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Mr. Maroto.- Thank you, Mr. President. Mr. President, you have been asking for forums for debate between political parties and regional governments for weeks, so we do not understand how you snubbed this Chamber a few days ago in the Commission of Autonomous Communities, as you know, the only institutional forum where the Government of Spain, the autonomous communities, and political parties meet. It is true that you are here today, in a control session in the Senate, but the regional governments are not here. It is also true that in a normal situation, it is usually the Ministry of Territorial Policy that attends those meetings, but we are not in a normal situation. It is also true that in other legislatures, the President of the Government did not attend those meetings; fortunately, we were not then in a prolonged state of alert. You say you will come, or we have been told you will come almost when summer arrives to appear, that is now when we need that debate, and thus, Mr. President, several regional presidents expressly asked you for it in the last of the meetings. They asked for a parliamentary debate, with transparency and stenographers, and not a closed-door Sunday videoconference that you like so much; you decided to disregard them, and we do not understand why you, Mr. Sanchez, spend the day begging for meetings to reach agreements, and when those meetings arrive, you are the one who is absent.

President.- Thank you very much, Madam President, thank you, Mr. Maroto, for your question. It is true that I did not attend that Commission; it is also true that many other regional presidents did not attend, not only from the Socialist Party but also regional presidents from the Popular Party, from historical communities like Andalusia or Galicia. I understand that you are not upset by that absence because you have not reproached those regional presidents, but you have reproached me. If what you intend to infer is that I avoided the debate or that I do not create those spaces for dialogue to not only proclaim but also to put into action that cooperation, collaboration, and coordination that we have been practicing over these 8 weeks of State of Alarm, not only with the autonomous communities but also with the FEMP, and also with social agents, I deny that, Your Honor. I believe that the Government of Spain is exercising dialogue, cooperation, coordination, and collaboration with all institutions at this critical moment.

In short, we were well represented by the Minister of Territorial Policy and Public Function, who I believe conveyed the fundamental message to the entire Chamber, and also to your parliamentary group, which is one of unity, of cooperation, so necessary, fundamentally between the two political parties that either in Spain or in autonomous communities that have been the focus of this epidemic, we are evidently managing public health for the benefit of citizens and with the sole and firm objective that all political forces have to save lives.

Mr. Maroto.- Mr. President, I believe that you decided to apply the "stay at home" rule just on the only day it was not necessary to do so. Your snub to the Commission of Autonomous Communities reflects your character when it comes to doing politics, not only arrogance but also the way of refusing a high-level debate in a parliamentary venue like the Senate. I can put myself in your shoes because maybe you decided not to come, and it is difficult to be president and come without having a plan. You tell us that you do not have a plan B; I even doubt that you have a plan A beyond that of feeling things out as they arise. Mr. President, however, with all due respect, the Spanish people deserve a Government that makes decisions based on circumstances; February and March are not the same as May or June. The Popular Party voted in favor, responsibly, of the State of Alarm two months ago, but two months later we understand that it is not responsible to do so again if there are alternative measures to guarantee safety and avoid a Government with absolute power that also violates the public freedoms of our democracy.

No one has suggested that we must choose between the State of Alarm and chaos. Put a muzzle on the Echeniques of the moment who ruin everything every time they open their mouths; leaving behind the State of Alarm does not mean, in any case, returning to absolute normality, as demonstrated precisely by the management of many regional presidents of my party who decreed confinements with the Public Health Law in hand long before you woke up and decreed the State of Alarm. It can be repeated; we can reapply positive measures, like those proposed by the president of my party, and we are waiting for your response.

Measure number 1, Mr. Sánchez, that the aid for the more than 4 million people who are in an ERTE can continue to be maintained if the State of Alarm declines and that the ERTEs can be dismantled proportionally.

Measure number 2, to adapt our regulations, that of our country, to the new situation of reduced mobility if necessary; I just gave you the example of the Public Health Law, but there is more. Measure number 3, mass testing in workplaces, and also mass sampling for the general population, Mr. Sánchez, get in touch with the four Spanish companies that manufacture tests and masks, who are going through a huge embarrassment because they have to sell their products to third countries just because your Government ignores them. And we will talk at length about the shameful episode of the false masks bought as real.

Measure number 4, coordination with the autonomous communities; they are eager to do so, but in public and high-level debates like this, return to the Commission of Autonomous Communities. And fifth, Mr. Sánchez, clarity and humility. Look, clarity means thinking things through before saying them. Not improvising, not going back and forth, for example, not saying things like children will be able to go out for walks to supermarkets and pharmacies, or we are going to open hotels or only 30% or only with clients from the same province, or like the last famous phrase, that "things are going better for Portugal because they are to the west." Mr. Sánchez, and a little humility, I say this from the heart; the Spanish people are convinced that many governments observed this crisis and were caught off guard. We also understand the Spanish people perfectly that there are mistakes because you cannot get everything right, but what we do not accept, what we do not tolerate, is that in addition to being ineffective, you are liars, and you are lying, and the last occasion is the false international rankings, Mr. Sánchez, which are absolute truths that even the magician Tezanos cannot make disappear.

The State of Alarm, Mr. Sánchez, is a tool that is useful as long as there is no alternative tool, and we believe that this tool exists, and the State of Alarm must cease to exist unless your Government considers the State of Alarm to launch an alternative government plan, you and your partner. Let the State of Alarm serve as a launch pad for a model in which the Government has all the power, parliaments are closed, private property is attacked, the economy is intervened, the judiciary is attacked, freedom of expression is muzzled; does all this sound familiar?

In March, Mr. President, the State of Alarm was a tool to protect the Spanish people; continuing to do so "sine die" is only a tool to protect you. Because you are trapped, and hence those endless and tedious press conferences from Moncloa with digested and prefabricated questions. Mr. Sánchez, and while all this is happening, there is a huge health crisis, and there is going to be a terrible economic crisis at your hands, and in this sense, Mr. Sánchez, and for that reason our action, the Popular Party once again, once again, will be there to move Spain forward. Thank you.

President.- Thank you very much, Madam President, Your Honor, in short, you have divided your intervention into two issues to which I would like to respond. The first is dialogue and the issue of the State of Alarm and its validity and the position that your Parliamentary Group will maintain tomorrow, I hope, in the Congress of Deputies regarding the extension.

Regarding dialogue, I would like to remind you, not only myself, during this session period from February to June, I have attended the Congress of Deputies on 9 occasions, and this is the second time I appear in the Senate. I must remind you that indeed, as you have well recalled, although it seems that it is not enough for you, for the first time in the history of democracy, there has never been a Government in the history of democracy that has convened so many videoconferences in this case, because they logically cannot be in person, of regional presidents, 8 in 8 weeks, so you can get an idea of the change that has occurred and therefore of the manifest will of this Government; we have gone from 8 in 8 weeks to 6 in 16 years, Your Honor, previously, so I believe that the willingness for dialogue, cooperation, and collaboration of this Government is quite evident. You may criticize what you deem appropriate, but you cannot criticize, with the shortcomings that those conferences may have, which we surely need to improve, Your Honor, the willingness for dialogue, collaboration, coordination, and cooperation that the Government of Spain is manifesting in relation to the autonomous communities, as it cannot be otherwise. Look, just yesterday, three videoconferences were held; the first of them, for example, by the Ministry of Transport, Urban Agenda, and Mobility, where issues as important for the autonomous communities and for the large cities of our country were discussed, such as, for example, the financing of public transport. Yesterday, for example, the Minister of Finance also met with the finance and economy counselors of all regional governments to see how those 16 billion euros could be distributed, 16 billion euros that the Government of Spain is going to give to the autonomous communities and that will not be reimbursable, and it will do so, precisely, to finance 10 billion euros more in items linked to health spending, 1 billion euros for social services, and another 5 billion euros that will be given to the autonomous communities to counteract the loss of income as a consequence of the decline in economic activity of the autonomous communities, so, Your Honor, I believe that the willingness for dialogue and collaboration that the Government of Spain has with the autonomous communities is manifest.

Thirdly, yesterday there was a new meeting of the Minister of Health with the health counselors, where the de-escalation plan was explained to them, where the markers of that comprehensive panel of markers that we are going to develop and evaluate together with the autonomous communities were explained, and tomorrow there will already be bilateral meetings between the Minister of Health and each of the regional heads to see which territories move to which Phase depending on the evolution of the epidemic; that is the manifest will we have for co-governance, for co-decision with the autonomous communities. That has never been done in history, Your Honor, acknowledge it; you can criticize the Government of Spain for successes, for mistakes, for whatever you consider, but you cannot criticize the Government of Spain for a clear and manifest willingness for dialogue, cooperation, and collaboration with the autonomous communities.

Regarding the State of Alarm, Your Honor, look, I believe it is evident based on the data in Spain, and also in Europe, that the measure that is stopping the contagion and the spread of COVID-19 is precisely confinement. The restriction of mobility, we are seeing it. Therefore, what is the only instrument that is constitutionally recognized, or that recognizes that power for the Government in this case of Spain to be able to confine, restrict mobility, and consequently prevent that intradistrict or interprovincial mobility? There have been regional presidents from the Popular Party, for example, from Murcia, from Andalusia, from Castilla y León, who have reproached the Government of Spain for not having closed the interprovincial borders so that, for example, people from Madrid would not go to their second homes on the coast. How can the Government of Spain do that if not with the State of Alarm, Your Honor? It cannot do it; it cannot do it, Your Honor, therefore I believe we can all agree that the only instrument that right now allows the Government of Spain to fight against COVID, save lives, and defend the public health of all citizens is precisely the extension of the State of Alarm.

Therefore, Mr. Speaker, I believe it is very important that we are aware that at such a critical moment as the current one, where there are so many uncertainties, where there is so much anguish on the part of the citizens, it is expected and desired of the two main parties in this country that there is an agreement for precisely that extension of the State of Alarm during this de-escalation that we have over the coming weeks. I believe, Mr. Speaker, that this is what all the countries in Europe are doing. I believe, Mr. Speaker, that it is to recognize the authority of the Government of Spain at such a critical moment. I believe it is also to recognize the willingness of the Government of Spain to cooperate with the autonomous communities, and I believe that it is above all a manifest will, at least of the Government of Spain and the parliamentary group that supports it, to be cautious, to be prudent in this de-escalation, and above all to guarantee a horizon of hope that we are seeing on the faces of many children under 14 years old, and also of many older people who have regained, precisely, their smiles because they are leaving their homes and are beginning to recover that normality. Let us work for it, Mr. Maroto, I believe you will not regret it, neither you nor your Parliamentary Group. Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by the deputy Lorena Roldán Suárez, of the Ciudadanos Parliamentary Group in the Senate.

Ms. Roldán.- Thank you, Madam President. Mr. Sánchez, welcome, it is a pleasure to see you, you have not come to the Senate since February 25, exactly 70 days without submitting to the control of this Chamber. Do you know how many sick people there were the last time you came here, to the Senate? Five, that is how your accountability has evolved in a crisis like this, but since we finally have you here today, I wanted to ask you to explain how you assess the evolution of the pandemic in our country and the socioeconomic crisis. Thank you.

President.- Thank you very much, Madam President; Mr. Speaker, thank you for your question. Well, just to record again that the start of the legislature was at the beginning of this year and in this session from February to June I have attended the Chambers 10 times, 9 to the Congress of Deputies and this is the second time I have appeared to account to the Senate. Obviously, the will of the Government and mine in particular is, without a doubt, to continue accounting in the Congress of Deputies and in the Senate.

And, in relation to your question, the evolution of the health and socioeconomic crisis, I will answer you in two aspects. In the health crisis, obviously, with caution but with enormous hope, I believe that the data invites us to think that we are on the path that citizens expect and desire after this enormous effort they have made in confinement. Therefore, caution and hope. And in relation to the socioeconomic impact that these very harsh confinement measures are having, the commitment of the Government of Spain is that no one is left behind, and I also believe, Mr. Speaker, that during these 8 weeks we have been in a State of Alarm, many of the Royal Decrees that have been validated by a parliamentary majority, even your parliamentary group has supported them in the Congress of Deputies, have been weaving a network with four pillars. One for families, and there are all the measures we have implemented, for example, the social electricity bond, the moratorium on housing payments, or the mortgage for home ownership.

To the workers, I want to clarify a point because it is being said by the opposition that there are 3 million workers who are not receiving the ERTE, I have to question those figures and I give you the exact figure so that the opposition has the correct data: in the month of April, benefits for COVID ERTE have been recognized and paid, according to what the Minister of Labor has conveyed to me, to 3,330,000 workers, the total bill for ERTEs in April is 4,512,000, there would be about 300,000 workers without ERTE who have recently entered, something that will be done in the next 10 days. Therefore, Mr. Speaker, I refute the figures that the opposition is using, the Government of Spain, with all the difficulties, is facing that network that workers need, I do not want to forget the self-employed, more than one million self-employed workers are receiving the benefit for cessation of activity, this has not happened in any crisis over the last 40 years of democracy. I must also remind you that today in the Council of Ministers, we approved the third ICO line to guarantee liquidity for companies and self-employed workers, remember that the Government of Spain's plan was to reach 100 billion euros, we are now on the third ICO line of 20 billion euros. And, finally, to the Public Administrations and, in particular, the Autonomous Communities, with those 16 billion euros that the Minister of Finance announced yesterday to the Councillors of the regional Governments as non-reimbursable funds to finance health spending. And, simply, to remind this issue, here we are in the territorial Chamber, as a result of the extraordinary effort that the Government of Spain is also making, we have increased the total of regional financing to the regional Governments by 7% compared to the previous year. I believe, Mr. Speaker, that the effort that the Government of Spain is making in collaboration with the autonomous Governments and local Governments is extraordinarily positive and therefore, that is the will we have, to leave no one behind, to create that network to protect families, workers, companies, and undoubtedly, also Public Administrations that have to continue facing an extraordinary effort in the fight against Covid.

Ms. Roldán.- Thank you, Mr. President. These data you give me are very good, but you should talk to the social agents because to this day there are many people who still have not received the ERTE. And look, we are perfectly aware that the situation is complicated and, precisely for that reason, we have supported those Decrees despite the mistakes, because we are aware that it is a limit situation and, obviously, we do not have a pandemic instruction manual. We know this very well in Ciudadanos because we also govern in four Autonomous Communities, but what there is is a common sense manual that says that consensus is better than unilateralism, that planning is better than improvisation, and yet, you have dedicated yourself to collecting announcements without listening to absolutely anyone and demanding a responsibility that your Government does not put into practice despite the fact that there are parties, like mine, Ciudadanos, that are being loyal to the Spaniards.

And what has been the next thing you have done? You have requested the extension of the State of Alarm in a press conference and I say one thing, if that has to be voted on in the Congress of Deputies, why don’t you talk to the political forces that make up the Congress of Deputies? It is common sense and not only do you not talk to us, you have gone a step further, you have threatened 47 million Spaniards with taking away their social benefits and with health consequences if the State of Alarm is not extended here as you want, it seems to me a tremendous irresponsibility that you address the opposition using so many people who are in the middle of ERTE or who are waiting for a benefit as hostages. Those people are already suffering enough, Mr. Sánchez. The State of Alarm must serve precisely to stop the spread of the coronavirus and I believe that the Spaniards have demonstrated exemplary behavior with this confinement and I think it is time to return a bit of that responsibility they have had. But what you cannot do is use the State of Alarm at your convenience, so we ask you from here not to use a Decree against the pandemic to sneak Mr. Iglesias into the CNI Commission, do not use a Decree against the pandemic to appoint senior officials in secret or to make contracts of which the address is not known. Do not use the State of Alarm again to continue polarizing Spanish society, this country should not have to choose between a unilateral drift and a Government alone in the face of the crisis. We do not have that dilemma because we have extended our hand to you from day one and we have not asked for anything in return except that you save the lives and jobs of thousands of Spaniards.

Look, Mr. President, you told us that you did not have a plan B and I tell you one thing, you had the obligation to have a plan B, a plan C, and a plan D if necessary to protect the Spaniards and if you have not had time or do not know how to do it, listen, because we have been there day and night. We have presented plans, reports, written proposals, we have offered ourselves in every possible way to save lives and save jobs, but it turns out that you do not have a plan B, and we will see what happens with A. I understand that it must be very uncomfortable for you to come here to listen to how we refute your excuses, that it would be comfortable for you if there were a submissive opposition and a frontal opposition with nothing to contribute, because it would be the perfect excuse to continue acting with that unilateralism, but you know what happens, that in this country there is a political center, liberal and moderate, and we will never renounce trying to reach consensus for the good of all Spaniards and you may try to make Ciudadanos submit to your holy will or that we go to the corner of the angry, but I tell you no, that neither you nor anyone will succeed in moving us from where we must be, which is in moderation, accompanying each criticism with a proposal and watching over and working for the interest of all Spaniards.

I do not know if you have heard the spokesperson of the Generalitat saying that in an independent Catalonia there would be fewer deaths, I do not know if you have seen how Bildu instigated protests against the UME when they were going to disinfect their streets, I do not know if you have seen how Esquerra Republicana took advantage of this pandemic to present a motion against the State here or if you have seen the PNV and Mr. Torra deny the help of the Army in the field hospitals. These are your partners, Mr. Sánchez, and you have no problem talking and negotiating with them. Why don’t you talk to the social agents? Why don’t you talk to the sectors most affected by COVID? Why don’t you talk to those who have tried to help you from minute one? And I will tell you one thing, single command does not mean single voice and State of Alarm here free disposal sine die for the Government. You have the obligation now to propose a plan to exit the State of Alarm, unlink the ERTEs and help SMEs and workers from the State of Alarm, do not use those families as hostages, help them because it is just, plan with the Autonomous Communities a plan in case we have a resurgence that does not require returning to the State of Alarm.

In short, Mr. Sánchez, lose your fear of consensus. Look, our proposals are very clear, we want to save lives first. How? By supplying masks to the entire population with clear usage instructions and of course, mass testing. And on the other hand, we also have to save jobs, because right now the next steps we take in these phases of de-escalation will be crucial for millions of families, we have a lot at stake. What we do in these weeks will depend on the jobs of millions of Spaniards, so if you need a plan B and you have to reach a consensus, you have to listen to the opposition, to the autonomous Governments and to the social agents. I told the minister the other day and I tell you again today, "Do not do it for us, do it for the Spaniards," set aside sectarianism and arrogance and let us all work together because so much is at stake, let us implement these plans, the Reconstruction Pact that Ms. Arrimadas proposed to you a month ago and yet, it seems that you do not have the political will to move it forward. I ask you from here for responsibility, that responsibility that you demand from others, have it yourself and let us help those who from the very first moment want to do so.

President.- Thank you very much, Madam President, Mr. Speaker. It is true that in that review you have given of various statements made by regional leaders and leaders of different parties who do not seem to profess with their political proposals, you have forgotten one regional president who said today that every day there are accidents and that does not mean that cars should be banned. That is not a plan, Mr. Speaker, that is frivolity.

In any case, what we have done is propose a de-escalation plan, a transition plan that must have four elements: gradualness, coordination, asymmetry, and homogeneity regarding the evaluation of those parameters that will allow the different territories to move from one phase to another. Therefore, we have developed a de-escalation plan with the support of experts, multidisciplinary, not only epidemiologists, economists, scientists, people who have contributed their knowledge to this de-escalation plan, and we have also agreed with the Autonomous Communities on the parameters, the indicators, believe me, Your Honor, we have done it. We have agreed on those indicators to assess each territory in the phases, and it is true that we have proposed that they be the provinces, but we have told the Autonomous Communities that we are willing to evaluate other proposals that they may put on the table. Regarding Plan A, Plan B, Plan C, I believe, Your Honor, that you and I can agree that the confinement has worked. Has it worked, yes or no? It has worked. The restriction of mobility, has it worked, yes or no? I believe it has worked, Your Honor. Well, what is the only instrument we currently have in the Constitution to guarantee confinement and the restriction of mobility? And you, who govern in the Community of Madrid with the Popular Party and also in Murcia, how can the Government of Spain prevent Madrilenians from traveling to their second homes in Murcia, if not with the State of Alarm? There is no other alternative, and since there is no other alternative, what we must do is be aware that we need to provide certainty and security to citizens, that we cannot play with experiments whose evolution and effectiveness we do not know exactly. And what the Government of Spain is simply asking is that we carry out this de-escalation under the umbrella of the State of Alarm, and when we reach that new normality, which we hope will be much sooner than later, we can manage this situation until we find a therapeutic remedy or the vaccine and we can manage it with other instruments, but right now, we need the restriction of mobility; right now, we need to be aware that confinement is working, and that is why I ask you, Your Honor, to have your group support once again tomorrow in Congress.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator Eduardo Fernández Rubiño, from the Parliamentary Group of the Confederal Left (Adelante Andalucía, Més per Mallorca, Más Madrid, Compromís, Geroa Bai, and Catalunya en Comú Podem) in the Senate.

Mr. Fernández.- Thank you, Madam President. First of all, I want to ask you, Mr. President, about the young people in our country in this crisis that is coming. But first of all, of course, I wanted to join in the condolences and words of affection for all the victims of this coronavirus crisis. And yet, also out of respect for these victims, I would like to say that it makes me somewhat sad, it even makes me somewhat envious of other countries, and perhaps it is because I have been in this Chamber for a short time, but it makes me sad to see that the opposition in this country and the main opposition party enters into an electoral campaign in the middle of a national emergency like the one we are experiencing. The truth is that it deeply saddens me for my compatriots that the main opposition party plays electoral games at a time like this.

Undoubtedly, I think it is irresponsible not to support the state of alarm tomorrow. I believe it is what citizens are expecting so that we can continue with the exit from this crisis. It seems to me to be playing Russian roulette with citizens for a handful of votes. And I have to say it like that even if it is harsh. That said, Mr. President; that does not absolve you of responsibility, it does not relieve you of the responsibility to seek agreements, to negotiate with your partners, to call us one by one, and to make the people who have supported the Government feel included in the proposal, including the Autonomous Communities. I believe you can do much more to assume that responsibility, and I truly hope you do so that we can continue to support the measures the Government presents at a time like this.

And, without further ado, I want to ask you about the situation of young people in the face of the coming crisis. Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you, Your Honor. I also share your reflection regarding the will of the Government of Spain, and even my own will to weave those agreements, that collaboration, not only at the inter-institutional level with the autonomous governments, with local governments, but also with parliamentary groups, with parliamentary forces.

And regarding the question you referred to about young people, I would like to say, as I mentioned earlier to the spokesperson of the Ciudadanos group, that what we have done is propose a triple network, in this case, to families, to companies, and also to workers. And, just to outline some of the measures that we have implemented over these eight weeks of the state of alarm and that have been validated in Congress, I must tell you that the preferential nature of remote work has been extended; the coverage of unemployment benefits has been applied to workers dismissed during the trial period of a new job; protection for fixed-discontinuous workers has been reinforced; the impossibility of dismissing for reasons related to Covid-19 has been established. More than 40,000 workers will benefit from over 17 million euros for the exceptional unemployment subsidy due to the end of temporary contracts. You know that temporary contracts, above all, are for younger people. It is a type of contract that is predominant among those over 25 years old. Also, 2,700 people who have been dismissed during the trial period of a new job with this Government will have access to unemployment benefits. Likewise, the extraordinary subsidy equivalent to 80% of the IPREM for people with temporary contracts of at least 2 months who do not reach the minimum contribution period has been established. A budget of more than 1,000 million euros has been approved for the Autonomous Communities aimed at employment policies. The scope of ERTEs has been expanded. This is very important. One of the main innovations compared to previous crises is the use being made of ERTEs. Access to unemployment benefits derived from an ERTE has been expedited. I was just providing the data so that all of you could take it into account and know it in a much more concrete way.

Regarding small and medium-sized enterprises, the deferral of payments to Social Security has been implemented. We have launched the extraordinary benefit for cessation of activity for self-employed workers. A six-month moratorium on Social Security contributions has been established. And we have set up an ICO line of 100 billion euros - we are on the third tranche - for small and medium-sized enterprises. Today we approved in the Council of Ministers a third tranche of 24.5 billion euros.

I want to tell you with this, ladies and gentlemen, that, of course, we can surely do many more things, but what cannot be denied is the will of the Government of Spain with that commitment I expressed earlier in response to previous questions.

This is a Government that is committed to ensuring that we all come out of this crisis and that we will not leave anyone behind.

Mr. Fernández.- Mr. President. No one doubts that the main victims, the generation that has suffered the most from this crisis, has been that of our grandparents. They have been the most affected. This pandemic has taken away the lives of thousands of them. It has prevented them from enjoying their retirement, their grandchildren. And even, perhaps the most painful thing, as a society, the possibility of saying goodbye to their loved ones, which I believe is something especially painful. But in economic terms, the Covid-19 crisis is particularly hitting the younger generation. This is something that the Minister of Employment, Ms. Yolanda Díaz, has recognized. She has said: the problem we have is with young people. And you only have to look at today’s employment data to see to what extent the temporality, which particularly affects young people, is closely related to the job destruction we have seen today.

And this situation is especially threatening a generation that had already been permanently on the edge. Spain was already one of the countries with the highest youth unemployment in the European Union; it was already a country that has suffered, in the younger generations, from completely unsustainable precariousness.

We already had a generation that was labeled the lost generation, Mr. President. A generation that had its future stolen to emerge from a crisis with measures that were certainly unjust, leaving thousands of young people stranded while, by the way, the banks were rescued.

Our country has already sent thousands of researchers, engineers, and doctors into exile. And we cannot simply allow that to happen again. The 2008 crisis caused a generation to live worse than their parents for the first time since the Transition. This generation is about to face its second major crisis. The collapse of the financial system condemned them to perpetual precariousness, and now they may lose again the possibility of starting a family, of having children, with the enormous problem of birth rates that we have and that our country faces. And without stability and without a long-term plan other than just getting by.

The youngest of this generation, born after 2000, simply do not remember any moment in their lives that has not been marked by the word crisis. Millennials and Generation Z, Mr. President, will go down in history as the generation of crises, in the plural. And, of course, it is not about seeing which generation has suffered more. All have had their share. All have faced challenges and difficulties. All faced wars, the oil crisis, built the welfare state, lived through a dictatorship. Each generation has its challenges and its difficulties, but they cannot be abandoned, Mr. President. The Government must be there because we have made a huge investment in this generation as a society and because our relatives, our grandparents, have sacrificed and renounced much to give us opportunities. There are structural causes. And I know that this cannot be solved with a magic wand or a patch. We need to change the productive model of our country and change the model as a country so that we do not have young people in perpetual precariousness as we currently find ourselves. But it is necessary that we generate, therefore, a model that creates jobs with high added value and not temporary jobs as we have had until now.

Right now, no one doubts that healthcare workers are essential; we cannot stop asking ourselves how it is possible that 1 in 3 doctors, when they finish their training, go to live in other countries. This is happening. It certainly cannot surprise us when we have communities like the Community of Madrid that have been cutting back on healthcare for decades and undermining the opportunities of our healthcare workers, who we need so much right now. But those cuts cannot make us double our efforts and understand that it is the welfare state that provides opportunities for our young people and allows us to be stronger.

The same goes for the ecological transition, which is one of those fields where we can develop R&D+i, where we can generate quality jobs. The European Commission is saying this in a recent report in which it talks about the Green New Deal as one of the main solutions for the coming economic crisis and also, moreover, for the crisis that is looming, which is the climate change crisis, as young people have been continuously pointing out.

I also ask you, Mr. President, to provide certainty to university and vocational training students, who do not know how they will finish the course. We must refund the tuition fees to all students who request it because that also affects their precariousness and their lack of certainty.

And finally, in short, Mr. President, I believe that there will be no possible reconstruction of the country without including young people. If they do not participate, those who have to take the reins in the future of our own country, there will be no agreed reconstruction or possible pact. The most important pact will not be with the right, nor the one between the right and the left, or between the Government and the opposition. I believe that the most important pact must be an intergenerational pact to prevent the so-called lost generation from becoming the crushed generation. Look, Mr. Sánchez. When Zapatero came to power, many young people, the truth is that many young people told him: Do not let us down. And when the 2008 crisis hit, unfortunately, he did not rise to the occasion with them. He did not rise to the occasion with them. The consequences of forgetting those young people are well known to me, your Government, and yourself. And, therefore, I ask you to do whatever it takes so that we do not have to see a generation taking to the streets with banners that say: Without work, without a home, without fear, precisely when there is a progressive Government sitting in Moncloa. Thank you very much, Mr. President.

President.- Thank you very much, Madam President. Thank you, Your Excellency, for your intervention. I am left with the idea you expressed about the intergenerational pact because I believe it is the most essential, the most important.

Just a few days ago, the Government of Spain conveyed its economic forecasts in the Stability Plan to Brussels. Previously, we had seen the economic forecasts from the International Monetary Fund. It is evident that the Government of Spain, not only Spain's but also all European governments and all governments in the world, including the main economies, will have to make a huge leap in public debt to cope with the support of incomes that we are currently providing.

I will give you just one piece of information. The Government of Spain, with all the economic resources it is putting in, is supporting the income of 31% of the employed population in our country. The amount we are investing, that we are pouring in, is not insignificant.

Earlier, I mentioned the figure of more than 3 million workers who are in ERTEs, who are receiving a benefit, and the economic resources we are channeling into this policy. More than 4.2 billion euros during these weeks.

I mention this mainly because we will indeed have to make that leap in public debt, not only in Spain but also across all European countries. That is why the Government of Spain is asking for an economic recovery plan at the European level that allows us, through transfers and not through loans, to face the economic recovery that we need now, as soon as possible. And in that context, I share with you, and it has also been a subject of debate in the Council of Ministers, that this crisis cannot serve as an excuse to weaken the welfare state, that this crisis cannot serve as an excuse to abandon our goals of ecological transition, of how we need to reindustrialize our country but we must do so with sustainable parameters. I believe that is the intergenerational pact you referred to earlier, and I certainly share it. That if we are going to have to make that leap in public debt, at least your generation and the generations that come after you have a much more sustainable country, a much more sustainable economy, more respectful of the environment. I want you to know that this Government is in line with what you have indicated.

And look, even if one reviews what the government agreement we signed between Unidas Podemos and the Socialist Party, which led to the first coalition government in democracy, and progressive as you rightly pointed out, there are many elements that today gain even more strength. Not only the ecological transition, not only the strengthening of the welfare state and the education to which you previously referred. But also a new framework for labor relations. It is more than evident that we need to establish it. Why? What we have seen during this very tough month, as we have seen in unemployment figures and Social Security affiliation, has ultimately been the temporary contracts, the most precarious contracts, which are mainly those held by young people in the labor market, the first victims and the first to be expelled as a result of the halt in economic activity.

It is evident that we need to open that debate. And that is what the Government of Spain is working on, Your Excellency. I want you to know that, of course, we are not going to use the crisis, as was done by other administrations previously, to abandon debates that are fundamental. Not only to provide an effective response to this crisis but to seize the future so that indeed your generation and the generations that come after you have a much better future than other generations, to which you previously appealed, did not have.

It is true that you speak of many crises. I can guarantee you, Your Excellency, that this is the crisis of our lives. This is an unprecedented crisis in humanity and, therefore, one of the main lessons we must draw, at least in Europe, is that we must strengthen our common project. I have missed that reflection in your intervention. I believe that, moreover, your generation, if it can contribute anything to that public debate, is to demand from Europe that we have public levers, much stronger common public policies than we have had so far.