Press conference of the President of the Government regarding the third extension of the State of Alarm.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

25 April 2020 · Press conference of the President of the Government regarding the third extension of the State of Alarm

Context
Sánchez addressed the Spanish public on 25 April 2020 to announce the third extension of the State of Alarm and limited easing of COVID-19 lockdown restrictions.
Main themes
COVID-19 pandemic response, state of alarm extension, confinement measures, infection rate reduction, partial easing of restrictions, children's outdoor outings, collective effort of Spanish citizens, path to recovery, vaccine and therapeutic remedies
Duration
~82 min
98th percentile
Words
9,860
98th percentile
Sentences
418
97th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
12.2
48th percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
40th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

418 sentences in 119 paragraphs

Good evening.

I appear once again this week and must begin by expressing the feelings of everyone regarding the loss of nearly 23,000 compatriots. It is much more than a statistic because, beneath the statistics, beneath the numbers of the sick and deceased, lies life, the lives of men, of women, with children, with spouses, with friends. Statistics add up something impossible to sum, because each human life is unique, as is the pain caused by the illness that has already affected tens of thousands and thousands of compatriots.

Many of them have recovered, and many others are fighting for their health with the professional and selfless assistance of our healthcare workers. On behalf of the Government, I wish them a full and swift recovery.

Six weeks ago, we declared a State of Alarm with extraordinarily harsh measures, extreme limitations on the activities and movements of the entire citizenry. Citizens stayed home to protect themselves and also to curb the contagion. And during this period, we have seen how the pandemic has ravaged 5 countries that are among the 7 largest economies in the West.

The same 5 countries that rank at the top globally in terms of the number of international travelers. Italy preceded us, followed by France, the United Kingdom, and finally the United States, which has temporarily become the epicenter of the pandemic and today accounts for more than a third of the world's infections and more than a quarter of the deaths.

We still ignore many of the issues related to the virus. One of them is what the next stage of its transit in this lethal journey will be. But we are, on the contrary, increasingly certain about a number of things.

The first is that we will only definitively win this battle against the pandemic when we have a vaccine or a therapeutic remedy, and that this process will unfortunately take several more months, hopefully few. The second is that it is possible to achieve partial victories against the virus through collective effort.

Six weeks ago, we entered a phase of confinement, a very tough phase of confinement, and the Government is very aware of this, when the virus was advancing at a daily contagion rate exceeding 35%. At that time, to explain it in colloquial terms, each infected person transmitted the virus to an average of more than 3 people.

Six weeks later, thanks to the collective effort of the entire Spanish citizenry, the daily increase in infections has been reduced to 1.5%. That is to say, each infected person does not even transmit the virus to another. And yesterday and today, for two consecutive days, and I find this to be extraordinarily relevant news, the number of daily recoveries has exceeded the number of daily infections.

We asked then for people to stay home, and they did.

We asked then to stop non-essential activities, and they did.

We also asked to intensify hygiene and protection measures, and the entire Spanish citizenry did so.

This first victory against the virus is a partial, modest victory, but it is the victory of the entire Spanish society and teaches us, above all, the path we must follow in the coming weeks. It is the victory of all, and that is why, on behalf of the Government, I thank you.

Tomorrow, as you know, a new extension of the State of Alarm will come into effect for another 15 days. The general rule of confinement will remain, but starting tomorrow, we will begin to introduce small reliefs in the restrictions we have been enduring for weeks.

The first relief will be, as you know, the outings of children under 14 years old, who will be able to go out for a walk for one hour within a radius of one kilometer from home and always accompanied by only one adult.

It is important, and I would like to emphasize this, it is important that we take this step by strictly following all the rules that have been made public and also the hygiene and protection measures before, during, and after the outings. It is advisable not to underestimate the enemy we face, because it is an enemy, the virus, with a high capacity for contagion, so it is crucial that just as we are benefiting from these conquests in our daily lives of freedom, of relief spaces, such as being able to go out on the street with our children, we must do so with the utmost safety, so that we do not get infected ourselves and neither do our fellow citizens. Consequently, it partly depends on the authorities to ensure this, but above all, it depends on each family to behave with the utmost responsibility, as has happened so far.

If we act with this prudence, which I am convinced we will, if the outings adhere to the rules and if we find that they do not generate new infections, this first relief will be followed by another one a week later.

In this regard, I would like to announce that if the evolution of the pandemic continues positively as it has been so far, starting on May 2, it will be allowed to go out for individual physical activity and walks with the people we live with, always under the conditions set by health authorities. It will be the Ministry of Health that issues an Order in the coming days, I insist, if the evolution of the epidemic is favorable as it has been so far.

In any case, while we continue in the immediate weeks of general confinement and also afterwards, the rule must always be the same with which we have acted since the beginning of the epidemic and especially since the beginning of the State of Alarm; it has cost us a lot to get here, and that is why we must act with the utmost prudence. It has cost us too much sacrifice to get here, it has cost us too much to bend the curve of infections and the fatal curve of deaths to put it at risk due to excessive haste.

If the current evolution is maintained and if we comply with the conditions set by the World Health Organization, we can consider the beginning of this second stage of the transition that I have referred to in previous appearances, what epidemiologists and experts call de-escalation.

As I explained last week, those guidelines from the World Health Organization refer to:

First, to the reinforcement of our healthcare assistance capabilities.

Second, to complete and updated information on the evolution of the epidemic. It is essential to have adequate, precise information on the evolution of the epidemic.

Third, to the identification and tracing of sources of contagion.

And fourth, and finally, to the rigorous adherence by everyone to the rules of protection, hygiene, and social distancing that I referred to earlier when I spoke about children and their outings starting tomorrow.

Naturally, in a strongly decentralized country like Spain, in a composed State like ours, compliance with all the recommendations listed by the World Health Organization depends on close collaboration, cooperation, and coordination among the different levels of administration: from small and large municipalities, to provinces, to councils, to autonomous communities, and to the Government of Spain.

It will be, along with all of them, how we will undertake this transition stage, this second stage, this de-escalation stage, which is, I do not want to hide this appreciation, as fraught with risks and dangers as the first stage in which we are containing and reducing the epidemic to the maximum, overcoming the peak and bending the curve every day as I mentioned earlier.

I want to be very clear on this point. I want to be very clear on this point: we must be very prudent because we do not have an infallible manual. There is no defined roadmap. We are facing something unknown.

There is no country in the world that has completed a de-escalation process towards that new reality, that new normality in which we will operate when we have the epidemic under control. There are, however, partial experiences, and they come from countries with different cultures and political and social systems that make it difficult to transplant their lessons.

Naturally, we will be guided by the recommendations of experts, starting with the Center for Coordination of Health Alerts and Emergencies, to which I want to pay tribute and recognition for the work they are doing throughout the day and logically following, as I have pointed out before, the recommendations of the World Health Organization; and naturally, we will exchange experiences with other countries, especially with our European partners as we have been doing so far. After all, unity is the great advantage of humans against the virus. A coronavirus in Asia and another in Europe cannot exchange advice. But humans can.

But we certainly start with uncertainties. We do not have absolute certainties about how to navigate this de-escalation. Those who believe they know everything about this epidemic will learn nothing.

And that is why the question I would like to answer in this appearance is this:

What will the de-escalation, this transition, look like once we begin it in May?

First of all, I want you to know that this transition, this de-escalation will be gradual. What does gradual mean? It means that we will not recover all activity and social mobility at once, but we will do it in stages. In stages. In each field of activity, successive steps will be set. Both regarding the reopening of businesses and restaurants; both in leisure, tourism, and culture activities; both in the agricultural sector and in the tourism sector or any industrial sector; both in religious activities and in cultural and leisure activities; both in sports and again in restaurants.

All activities will be recovered in stages and under conditions and limitations that will vary with each successive advance we make.

Therefore, first of all, it will be gradual. And alongside that, secondly, this de-escalation, this transition to that new normality will be asymmetrical. That is to say, it will depend on the territory in which one lives. The epidemic has spread unevenly. The data we receive daily from the Ministry of Health shows this. It has happened the same everywhere: there are highly affected areas neighboring others where the virus seems to have passed by. The pandemic has not hit all areas of the country with the same intensity. And therefore, the de-escalation, in addition to being gradual, must be asymmetrical, differentiated according to the territories on which we act.

Thirdly, necessarily, the de-escalation must be coordinated. That is to say, it will be governed by the same rules, although different speeds and spaces will apply, it will be seen with the same rules. Experience shows that the virus does not distinguish between administrative boundaries. That we are interdependent. And to protect the least affected places, we have all had to confine ourselves, and thus we have managed to reduce the spread of the virus where it was most rampant, but those territories where it was less affected have also benefited.

And precisely to ensure this maximum coordination, the entire de-escalation process will be governed by the same Integrated Dashboard for the entire country. This Dashboard will integrate several indicators that will be evaluated both from a quantitative and qualitative perspective.

This Integrated Dashboard and the indicators that compose it will be accessible to the public, so that any ordinary citizen, from any territory, can know the objective criteria on which public authorities will base their political decisions that will regulate the path towards that new normality.

Therefore, unlike what still happens in this first stage of general confinement, in the de-escalation, in the transition, we will not all advance at the same speed, but we will do so with the same rules. The maxim, consequently, will be one: we entered together and we will exit together as a country. We entered together and we will exit together as a country. The de-escalation will be, it must necessarily be, as a team. We will do it at different speeds depending on the epidemic in each place, asymmetrically, yes, but coordinated. As a team. We will measure each step in each place and before continuing to advance, we will consolidate the previous steps.

Always aware of our own situation, but also of the situation of all others. I remind you: We are interdependent. If this epidemic has demonstrated anything, it is that it does not heed administrative boundaries, nor inter-territorial or inter-provincial borders. That is why it is very important that we are aware that we must all go hand in hand, working shoulder to shoulder, pulling together. The results we have obtained in this first stage have been achieved thanks to the unity we have shown as a society, as a country, as a community.

Our responsibility and our shared responsibility protect us. We are each other's insurance. Some people, from others. Some localities from others. Some provinces from others. Some communities from others. Some countries from others.

We must therefore avoid entering into a sort of race to the bottom. Competing to see who can do it faster, who reaches the foot of the mountain first. The territories or people who feel more sheltered may be tempted to rush or even skip the rules, but they must hold back for their own good and the good of others. Because if one were to rush or fall, not only would they hurt themselves, but they could also drag the rest down with them.

This criterion is being systematically studied by the Government of Spain, also systematically in the Interterritorial Health Council with the various Health Councillors from the different territories, from the different regional governments, and it is what I will personally convey tomorrow to the regional presidents in a new videoconference of Presidents.

I know well that we are all exhausted from the effort made in these past weeks. With everyone's sacrifice, we have contained the spread of the virus and are increasingly reducing its damage and impact. Which remains significant, but is becoming less so. Despite the great collective results we are achieving, I must remind you that we are still vulnerable.

And that is why I announce that this principle of caution as a general rule will be very much present in the De-escalation Plan that the Government of Spain will approve next Tuesday in the Council of Ministers, and I will publicly present it that same Tuesday.

A De-escalation Plan that we have been preparing well in advance, for more than three weeks, and which is based on the criteria of experts. The heart of its development is an independent report from the experts who have been advising us since the beginning of the epidemic.

Concluding the de-escalation must lead us to that New Normality to which I have referred in previous appearances, which will govern our lives until we have a therapeutic remedy, or also a vaccine, that fully protects us against the virus.

And during this journey, caution and unity must be our guides.

Unity, of course, in Europe, which is so far the most affected area on the planet by the epidemic.

It is true that, initially, the Union - especially some member states - hesitated to assume the need for a joint, solidary, and forceful response. But things are changing.

The European Council session held last Thursday was crucial in this regard. To begin with, a financial package of 540 billion euros was ratified, and it was guaranteed, at Spain's initiative, that this financial package would be ready by June 1 at the latest. In addition, progress was made towards the next Multiannual Financial Framework, that is to say, to put it simply, the European budget for the next 7 years.

And, most importantly, we initiated negotiations for a large Recovery and Reconstruction Fund that for Spain must amount to up to 1.5 trillion euros, following the logic we have demanded from the beginning, and also other countries, to deploy a sort of Marshall Plan for Reconstruction to address the harmful economic and social consequences that this epidemic is having.

The Union is moving forward on the only possible path: the path of unity, the path of the Pact for the Economic and Social Reconstruction of the continent.

A path to which we, the political representatives of our country, are also called. At all levels and regardless of which party is in power.

We are experiencing the greatest upheaval of our lives, and no one was prepared to face it. But what is important is to avoid one mistake: the greatest of mistakes, the mistake of division and confrontation.

It would be the most fatal, most lethal mistake, because it would prolong the crisis and bring more social suffering. And it would also be the worst mistake because it is avoidable. Because we all know that together we can do more, that our unity is the strength that can help us ultimately defeat the virus.

We all know that we are sailing in the same boat and we will stay afloat and reach port if we row together. And we will lose and put ourselves in danger if we hit each other with the oars.

If this were not a mission for all, beyond legitimate political differences, then what sense would our coexistence have? How could we call ourselves compatriots? The only enemy is the virus, and its allies are hatred, falsehoods, and division.

It is our duty to reach an agreement in all institutional areas. In the Communities and Cities, also in the Congress of Deputies, in the provincial councils, in the Cabildos, and in the Consells that make up our country.

I do not want to end without reiterating, as I did at the beginning of this intervention, my affection and solidarity, which are those of all Spanish society, to those who have lost a loved one; our wish for a speedy recovery, also, to those who suffer from the disease, and my gratitude to all for the courage and discipline with which we are fighting against the virus. Unfortunately, full and complete victory is still not close; we still have hard moments and times to fight, but we have already begun to win. With sacrifice, resilience, and a spirit of victory. And united. Always united.

The commitment of the Government, my personal commitment as president, is to bring everyone together so that all of Spanish society wins.

Social and economic reconstruction is our only horizon, unity is our path, and leaving no one behind is, without a doubt, our duty.

Thank you.

State Secretary for Communication.- Thank you very much, president. We will now begin with questions from the media. The list is made up of various media outlets such as the Catalan News Agency, El Diario del Puerto, La Voz de Galicia, Radio Espejo Canario, La Política Online, EsDiario, Nos Televisión, Radiotelevisión Castilla y León, Crónica Balear, and a few others that are still configuring their systems.

Here we have the colleagues who will participate. We ask you to state your name when asking questions, as you do every day, president. Go ahead, Catalan News Agency. Q.- Good afternoon, president. I am Roger Pi de Cabanyes from the Catalan News Agency. You have always said that you are a defender of the State of Autonomies; however, in this first major crisis of your Government, you have preferred to centralize competencies. Tomorrow, at the Conference of Presidents, the president of the Generalitat and other presidents will ask you to let them apply their own de-escalation plans. What will you respond to them, because they believe that management is better from proximity in this de-escalation situation?

Then I wanted to ask you about the issue of children; the possibility is being raised for them to go out in time slots and by age, that is, each age at one time and each age at another, to avoid too many people on the street. Why is the Government of Spain not applying this possibility?

And then one last question, you announced that a de-escalation plan is being prepared. Does this imply that a new extension of the State of Alarm will be requested?

President.- Thank you very much, Roger, for your questions. First of all, a clarification. The Government of Spain coordinates. It does not recentralize; it coordinates. I share, as do many other mayors with whom I have had the opportunity to speak, as well as regional presidents, that the principle of subsidiarity, that is, responding from the closest administrations, is the most effective; but it is also true, and I have said it before in my intervention, that the virus does not respect administrative boundaries and that, consequently, if anything has demonstrated the State of Alarm, it is that it has been effective precisely because we have managed to coordinate, unite, shoulder to shoulder, and walk in a single direction, which is the relentless fight against the virus.

I simply recall the data: a 35% daily infection rate before the State of Alarm and a 1.5% daily infection rate now. We still have a long way to go because, unfortunately, the number of deaths and daily infections is still high, but in any case, we are on the same path. Therefore, proximity, of course, but also coordination.

That is why, when I spoke earlier about de-escalation, it is evident that we have been working for weeks not only internally within the Government but also with the Autonomous Communities and during this week with the municipalities, through the Spanish Federation of Municipalities and Provinces, that this de-escalation must adhere to the criteria I referred to earlier. One, gradualness; the different activities that will be recovered over the coming weeks will not all happen at once but will logically be based on a series of parameters that I will refer to later. Along with gradualness, territorial differences as a consequence of the evolution in the territories; there are provinces that have had weeks or days with zero infections or very few infections, while others, like Catalonia, concentrate a large part of those infections. And finally, coordination; coordination is fundamental, not only between the Government and the Autonomous Communities but also between the Autonomous Communities and the Provincial Councils and municipalities. And I previously referred to the Dashboard. It is important that this Dashboard is coordinated primarily by the Government of Spain. It is a Dashboard that will allow us to evaluate periodically that gradualness, that asymmetry between the different territories, and the phases that will be implemented. This Dashboard has, logically, a fundamental principle, as I said in my first intervention, which is that we must strengthen the strategic capacities of the National Health System in each and every one of the territories. What we have suffered in this first wave has been an invasion of the virus. An invasion across the country, but also across the entire European continent, and that is why it is important that once we know the level of contagion that this virus has, we strengthen health strategies.

What are those health strategies? First, reinforced healthcare, for example, the number of ICU beds. For example, primary care, which will now have, in this de-escalation phase, a prevailing importance because we must anticipate the evolution of the epidemic in each of the territories. Secondly, there must be epidemiological surveillance, and in this sense, it is important to strengthen the public health systems that are in the hands of the Autonomous Communities. Also, logically, the development and execution of PCR tests that we can carry out on citizens in each of our territories. Thirdly, the identification and containment of infections through isolation measures, as are being implemented in most territories, and undoubtedly, collective protection measures, whether hygiene measures, masks, or distancing measures that have become the norm in the behaviors we all have.

Therefore, I believe it is very important to shoulder the burden and set aside other issues that have nothing to do with the fight against the pandemic and logically recognize that this State of Alarm has borne fruit, that we are having a very high level of compliance with confinement, exemplary across the entire Spanish population, and that precisely this State of Alarm has benefited the entire Spanish population, wherever they live, whatever they think, whatever they vote, and whatever they want. Therefore, I believe it is important to prioritize the defense of public health and the idea of saving lives over any other consideration.

Secondly, regarding some proposals that you mentioned, which are being made by the Generalitat of Catalonia, I must say that the Ministry's Order is clear, and it is the Ministry's Order that must be followed regarding the requirements and demands for the exit of minors under 14 years old starting tomorrow. And the logic is quite simple; we propose from 9 AM to 9 PM precisely so that those workers who arrive home can also reconcile that hour of walk they have with their children throughout the day.

And finally, the De-escalation Plan is a plan that we are going to approve in the Council of Ministers and that I will present myself next Tuesday to the entire Spanish citizenry where, indeed, what we are going to do is a de-escalation plan that will last throughout the month of May and, in principle, we will see what happens in June. But what I would also like to convey to you is the importance of being cautious, of being prudent, of being aware that this is not a race to see who is the first to open a shopping center or a small business. That is not the issue. The issue is that we must all be aware that only by working as a team will we all reach the finish line. It is not about who arrives first, but that we all reach the finish line, and that is the purpose of the Government of Spain, and in that area, we are. Precisely, Tuesday is when we are going to present the de-escalation plan in the Council of Ministers because we want to hear from the regional presidents their de-escalation plans tomorrow because throughout this week, we have been meeting with the health counselors, in this case, the Ministry of Health, and also the Fourth Vice President, who is in charge of proposing this transition plan towards that new normality, and that finally, the day after tomorrow, on Monday, there will be a technical meeting to agree and refine the technical requirements that will constitute that joint, global Dashboard that we will apply throughout the territory from the Government of Spain.

Secretary of State for Communication.- Now we have a question from Diario del Puerto.

Q.- Miguel Jiménez, from Diario del Puerto. I wanted to ask you about transport and logistics. You know it is an essential sector for the economy, but on this occasion more than ever due to the pandemic. The president of the National Road Transport Committee, which is the highest representative body of the sector with the administration, has warned this week of the risk of collapse due to the drop in activity and, above all, due to the economic crisis we are in. This sector demands a series of fiscal and economic measures that they have requested from the Ministry of Transport with a letter that was submitted on March 30, and the sector is anxious because the Government has not responded to it. The Minister of Economy, Nadia Calviño, believes that in the current context there are neither necessary nor insufficient measures for this sector, and therefore, the sector's anxiety has increased. I would like to ask you if the President of the Government is going to respond to their concerns and, above all, if their requests will be addressed. Thank you very much.

President.- Miguel, I'm sorry, but the sound of your question was cut off. I understand that we are talking about the logistics sector, and I will certainly speak with the Ministry of Transport and the economic team to find out what the demands of this sector, which is so important for our country, are.

Secretary of State for Communication.- We now move on to La Voz de Galicia. Go ahead, La Voz de Galicia.

Q.- Hello, good evening, President. How are you? I am Fran Varado from La Voz de Galicia. I wanted to ask you about that de-escalation; I don't know if you can offer any details about what you just announced that starting on May 2, outings to practice sports individually may begin to be allowed. I don't know if you could provide any details and if it will also be accompanied by any other new measures, as some regional presidents have requested, in this case, I am referring to what Mr. Feijoo requested in the Xunta de Galicia, that car dealerships or small markets also be opened by appointment... And then I also wanted to ask you about that plan you just announced that will go to Congress on Tuesday regarding the de-escalation, how far it reaches, that is to say, the other day we heard the Minister of Employment set the horizon for the opening of the hospitality or tourism sector towards the end of the year, and I don't know if you think these statements create a bit of uncertainty in one of the main economic sectors. How far does that de-escalation plan reach? And finally, a last-minute question. The President of the Generalitat, Torra, seems to have just called for a demonstration in Catalonia during the state of alarm.

R.- Well, thank you, Fran. Regarding the last question, I don't have any news; I cannot answer you because I do not know the details or the announcement that has been made. Regarding the other two questions you asked me, let me say, let's see, this is very important because, of course, on some occasions, it can be said, "Hey, why not in my province or in my autonomous community where we have low daily contagion levels, why can't we do different things or more things than the confinement we have been suffering for weeks?" And you are right. But it is also true, and this is what I would like to convey to the public, that the analysis and evaluation we have to make is much more complex. If it were only about the number of daily infections, then indeed, the argument would fall by its own weight. But it is not only that. That is why it is very important to define a series of objective parameters based on which we will decide the graduality of the phases that we will implement in that transition towards that new normality. I want to start with the end: that normality will not be the one we had before the state of alarm. It will not be until there is a vaccine. Until there is a therapeutic remedy, it is evident that we must maintain social distancing, that we will have to maintain, in short, all the hygiene measures that we have been learning during these weeks thanks to the information that you, the media, have provided. But when we talk about why this economic activity is allowed and this economic activity is not, it is not only the number of daily infections that will allow us to gauge what the de-escalation is in one territory or another; there will be other issues such as, for example, the occupancy rate of ICUs, the degree of strengthening of public health systems in each of the Autonomous Communities. Also primary care. That is to say, what we cannot afford under any circumstances is that when there is a new outbreak of Covid-19, what it does is put our National Health System at risk again. Therefore, when we talk about economic activity, we will also have to be aware that we will allow some businesses to open or not based on parameters that may not seem obvious but that need to be put on the table. For example, what does the opening of economic activity imply in terms of mobility for that business? These are simply the issues that we need to incorporate into our dashboard, to which I referred earlier to implement the de-escalation.

There are countries that have given a linear response and set dates for the opening of different businesses. We are not going to do that. We are not going to set a date for the opening of this or that business. What we are going to define is a dashboard, a series of objective, indisputable indicators based on which we will make the different territories transition towards that new normality in accordance with different phases. And in those phases, we will logically include the opening of economic activity, the opening to that new normality in our daily lives by citizens in their day-to-day, in their homes.

This is a bit of the philosophy. And that is why I cannot answer why we are not going to open this business or that one. We are going to open them. They will be opened. In different phases until we reach that new normality, but the philosophy will be different. The philosophy is much more complex. Let's see what capacities we have so that as we recover and move towards that new normality, we do not put at risk what has been achieved so far. And above all, we guarantee the health capacities we have to face any type of outbreak that may occur in any territory. This is a bit of the philosophy I would like to convey because I think it is fundamental.

Regarding the de-escalation, let me clarify that it is not in Congress; it is in the Council of Ministers, which is why I want to hear from the regional presidents tomorrow. Many of them have already announced their territorial de-escalation plans through the media; we will take them into account, but I want to emphasize that it is the Government of Spain that will lead this de-escalation, this transition to the new normality, and in that sense, I remind you that it will be gradual, coordinated, asymmetrical, and based on parameters, on indicators that will be understood not only by the institutions that will have to implement that de-escalation, such as the Autonomous Communities, but above all and first and foremost by the citizens, because it is they who will also confront the virus firsthand by taking these decisions that we will logically make based on the criteria of experts in our country.

Q.- Good afternoon, President. Nuria Val from Política Online. The Bank of Spain and the IMF have presented their public deficit forecasts for Spain close to 10% of GDP. The public treasury in the last month has also increased its debt issuance, and the risk premium is starting to rise again even with the ECB's purchases. When will the Government present its forecasts? And do you think that failing to do so soon will increase uncertainty among international investors and provoke a higher risk premium? On the other hand, do you support the Vice President's criticisms of the Justice for the conviction of Isa Serra? And why does Moncloa dispense with the heads of the Armed Forces, the National Police, and the Civil Guard in the press conferences to inform about the management of the pandemic starting tomorrow? Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much for your questions. Regarding the economic forecasts, the Government of Spain will present the economic forecasts when it is due, when it corresponds to the community authorities, in this case, to the European Union. It is evident, not only in Spain but in all countries, and not to mention international organizations when they make their forecasts, they present ranges that demonstrate the complexity and difficulty they have in predicting the economic and social impact of this epidemic. Remember, for example, that the forecasts range from a minus five drop to a minus ten drop in Gross Domestic Product. That is to say, we are talking about forecasts that even they estimate with ranges of double. What is evident is that the economic and social consequences of the pandemic are terrible, they are tremendous. In Europe and in the world. They will be. They will be. Unfortunately, they will be. And we hope that the pandemic lasts little, and that is why it is so important that we overcome it by being intelligent in how we de-escalate and, above all, in how we assume in our own daily lives that new reality, that new normality to which we will have to resort until we find a therapeutic remedy and a vaccine against Covid-19.

But it is evident that the economic and social consequences will be very significant due to the halt in activity. What I can guarantee you in any case is that the Government of Spain has a maxim that I have said from the beginning, which is that we will not leave anyone behind. That during these last weeks, almost six weeks, we have been implementing social and economic measures to try to keep the productive fabric alive, the jobs created in those companies, and logically also the social protection of those affected as a result of the halt and the layoffs that have unfortunately occurred during these weeks.

Regarding what you mentioned about the criticism made by the Vice President of the Government regarding a ruling from the Supreme Court, let me say the following. Let's see. The Government abides, as it cannot be otherwise, by the resolutions of the Supreme Court and the Judiciary. This has always been the case. A different matter is that, logically, Mr. Iglesias, as I am, and as other political leaders are, not only are we part of the Government, but we are also leaders of different political organizations. I am the Secretary General of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, and Mr. Iglesias is the Secretary General of Unidas Podemos, and as such, he has made his assessment of this ruling that affects a leader of his organization.

And regarding the last question, which I do not remember right now...

Q.- Why does Moncloa dispense with the heads of the Armed Forces?

President: Ah, excuse me. Yes, yes. You are right. We do not exclude anyone; on the contrary, I take this opportunity to sincerely thank the daily work of each and every member of the technical team, the daily work they have done not only through the media in their appearances but also in their offices, deploying and making effective the entire state of alarm from the General Secretariat of Transport to the DAOs of the National Police and the Civil Guard, and logically also to the JEMAD. Therefore, that is not the issue. The issue is that, from this point of view, the mission is indeed accomplished, and starting tomorrow we enter another phase that I am explaining, which is a phase of de-escalation, recovery, a new normality, and consequently, the spokespersons will necessarily have to be different.

In this case, I believe it is important that Dr. Simón continues to inform about the evolution of the epidemic, and depending on the issues to be addressed, we will obviously incorporate technical personnel who will contribute to informing about the decisions to be made. Alongside Dr. Simón will also be the General Secretary of Transport because both mobility and, let’s say, the technical and scientific analysis provided by Dr. Simón are currently essential, fundamental for this stage of de-escalation in which we find ourselves.

Q: RADIO ESPEJO CANARIO Regarding the criteria you referred to for initiating the deconfinement in the Canary Islands, we have already met the requirements established by the World Health Organization that you mentioned. In fact, there are islands like La Graciosa with 700 inhabitants, where the virus has never arrived, but they have a very rigorous confinement like the rest of Spain. I wanted to know if starting May 2, the Canary Islands will be among those communities that can begin the de-escalation of this confinement. And secondly, the Canary Islands also have 3 billion euros in surplus. Since March 23, the European Union, lifting the clause, has given the possibility to bypass the spending rule, the stability rule. When will the Government of Spain decide that the communities can use that surplus?

President: Let’s see, regarding the first point, a clarification: the de-escalation does not start on May 2 in the terms you mentioned, but on May 2, if the evolution of the epidemic continues as we have seen in recent weeks—today is the second day we believe that the daily number of recoveries exceeds the number of new infections, and that implies that we are definitely bending the curve. And that is why I think it is important to make this clarification. On May 2, there will be an opening to allow for individual physical activities and also walks with the person you live with. This is what will be approved starting May 2.

Secondly, what we are going to do next Tuesday in the Council of Ministers is approve the de-escalation plan, and that plan will be very important because we will present to the autonomous communities the parameters based on which we will evaluate their strategic health capacities, and consequently, from there, we will start to decide which territories, which localities, will move to one phase or another and consequently to a lesser requirement of confinement. But it is important to keep this in mind. Thirdly, it is also essential to be aware that there is no territory that is outside the virus. That there is no territory that is not vulnerable to the virus. Why do I say this? Because those territories that may not have been affected as severely as, for example, the Community of Madrid, that does not mean they are safe. Moreover, it is especially important to safeguard and protect those territories where citizens have not been victims of the virus as intensely as in others. Because that indeed means that they are populations that, unfortunately, will be more vulnerable if a wave returns. That is why it is so important not only to look, as I said earlier in response to your colleague from La Voz de Galicia, not only is it important to evaluate the number of infections we have, the number of deaths we have in this island or in this territory, but also to evaluate other issues that relate to what I mentioned earlier, to the strategic health capacities, so that when there is a resurgence, it is as minimal as possible and does not jeopardize the healthcare assistance of those affected by the virus.

And that is the approach. I think it is very important, and today Dr. Simón mentioned it in his press conference of the technical committee, to be aware that in this transition to that new normality, we will have to learn new indicators, we will have to learn to read those new indicators, we will also have to learn that, for example, a figure that was fundamental for us, such as the number of daily infections, will no longer be as important. And yet, other types of indicators that experts have told us are fundamental for anticipating the arrival of the virus and the resurgence of the epidemic in one territory or another will start to gain much more strength. Therefore, a lot of caution, a lot of prudence.

We must be very aware that we are facing something unknown, and we will put all our scientific intelligence from experts in epidemiology into knowing how to combat and prevent the virus, and therefore territories that may not be severely affected by the virus today, that does not mean it cannot happen in the future. Therefore, in that sense, I think it is important to carry out that pedagogy.

Regarding the last of the questions, this has been a proposal made by the president of the Canary Islands in repeated videoconferences. The Government of Spain is studying it, but it is also true, and I want to break a lance in favor of the Minister of Finance and spokesperson because she is making an extraordinary effort and work; the financial resource capacities of the autonomous communities have increased by 7% during this month, precisely so that they can face this epidemic with public money and liquidity.

Q: Ana Martín ESDIARIO: You have insisted in this appearance that it is important to have the most reliable information possible about the infected and asymptomatic, considering the crucial phase we are entering, but in parallel, there are currently no studies, nor has the seroprevalence study even started, which has been announced for weeks, that was supposed to start on Monday and will not be so. And also, according to the members of that scientific committee, mass testing is not being conducted. I would like to ask you, first, can Spaniards be at least assured that the Government knows what it is doing? And that it is not going blindly in this phase? Secondly, you said today at the beginning of your appearance that the virus is spreading through the five countries with the most international travelers. I wanted to ask you if that is the explanation the Government gives for Spain having the highest mortality rate in the world, given that we have had the most restrictive confinement measures on the planet for five weeks? And finally, can you comment on the outings starting on May 2, if there is an age limit for adults? Or if it also includes the older population, which is the one at the highest risk of contagion?

President: Thank you very much for your questions. Regarding the last of the issues about May 2 and the outings for sports or walking, I said before my intervention, it will be the Ministry of Health that, in the coming days and depending on the evaluation we make from the experts advising us, will definitively decide whether to implement this measure for individual sports, I insist, and also to go out with the person with whom we live.

Therefore, let’s wait for that order where some of these issues will be classified, but I believe that the truth is that the evolution of the epidemic and the control of it and the data we are seeing over the last few days invite reasonable and moderate optimism regarding the fact that it will indeed be possible to do so starting May 2. And in that sense, I encourage all citizens this week to comply with our rules in an exemplary manner as we have been doing so far because we will indeed have that new achievement starting May 2 for our own benefit, in the streets of our cities.

And regarding your first question, let’s see, I believe that the Government of Spain was looking at the data while you were asking me. The Government of Spain, to date, based on the data we receive from the department, we are above one million PCR tests, consequently, the most reliable in our country. And indeed, we are among the countries conducting the most tests. Also, today, just yesterday, I had noted that nearly 800,000 additional rapid tests will be distributed to the autonomous communities, so to date, the Government of Spain has distributed 2.8 million units for diagnosis in the terms set by the protocols, which you will know are in those high prevalence environments of the disease, such as hospitals or also the residences of older people.

And lastly, it is evident that societies and economies like ours, which receive 82 million tourists a year, are unfortunately more exposed to this type of epidemic and are hit very hard, especially when we have societies that depend on such a large number of tourists, not only national but also foreign. I am not saying it is the only cause; I am saying that there may indeed be a direct correlation between one thing and the other. I also find this appreciation reasonable.

Q: Dutch Public Television: Hello, good afternoon, President, I am Rutt Salzberg from Dutch Television here in Madrid. I am particularly interested in how things are going at the European level. First, have you noticed a change in the atmosphere within the European sphere? The relations, especially with my country, the Netherlands, have been quite complicated. Has anything improved? Have you spoken with Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte? Are you noticing that things are getting better? And secondly, for you, the conditions for financing the European recovery fund, this money for Spain should be support without conditions. The Netherlands has said it should be a type of loan; there are rumors that it may come with conditions. What do you expect in that regard from the European Commission?

President: Well, thank you very much for your question. I must tell you that I have not only a political respect for Mr. Rutte, but I also have a personal respect, I have a certain friendship with him, and I must say that I have not responded to any of the, well, comments made by some member of his government. Regarding Spain and other countries that are indeed being hit by COVID-19, I must say that I missed, perhaps, a personal message from the Dutch Prime Minister towards Spain or even towards the Government of Spain as a consequence of that unwarranted criticism made by the Dutch Finance Minister.

And regarding the second questions, indeed, this is the issue, this is the problem. The problem is that we have to measure what solidarity means in Europe. This is a pandemic, it is an epidemic that has hit the entire European Union squarely, symmetrically at first, and consequently what is being questioned and what citizens are asking is about solidarity and how we measure and implement that solidarity, how we materialize it. There are countries that indeed say, yes, solidarity, but through loans. And indeed, with some type of requirement. Well, right now what we are doing from the Government of Spain, to put our case, but I have no doubt that many other governments are doing the same, we are increasing public spending, we are going into debt precisely because what we want to do is save lives. There is no moral risk here; what there is is a collective objective of an entire society and all its institutions to save lives. Therefore, there is no conditionality, let’s say, foreign to this, to invest all resources in PPE, in healthcare personnel, in supporting people who have entered unemployment as a consequence of the closure of activities, in sustaining the productive fabric. That is what the Government of Spain is focused on. Therefore, there is no moral risk; we are a government that wants to fulfill our obligations, like everyone else, we are a government that wants to comply with our fiscal obligations, that wants to have a sustainable public welfare state. A sustainable public pension system, but we are at war. And in a war, what conditionality is going to be placed on that solidarity?

P.-Radio Televisión de Castilla y León: Good evening, Mr. President. Álvaro de Lúa from RTCYL. Thank you for this press conference. We have not clarified whether older people will be included in the adult walks, referring back to my colleague Ana Martin's question. Will our grandparents be able to go out on the street starting on the second? Another issue, the president of Castilla y León and other presidents of autonomous communities have requested an extraordinary fund to address essential social services. I do not know if the government is considering the creation of that fund. And finally, the WHO asks, as you have said, to have precise information on the evolution of the pandemic to begin the de-escalation. We currently have a snapshot, after so many changes in the counting criteria. Can we affirm that we know what the real situation is in Spain? Thank you.

President.- Well, thank you very much, Rodrigo, for your words. Regarding the first question, it will be the Minister of Health, in an Order, who will establish the criteria based on which this exit will take place throughout the week, starting next May 2. Regarding the second question, I would just like to point out that the Government already, at the beginning of the crisis, during the State of Alarm, put 300 million euros in the hands of the autonomous communities and also allowed municipalities to use another 300 million euros from their municipal surplus to address urgent social needs in all territories. Therefore, I believe that from that point of view, I do not know the proposal in detail, but, well, the Government of Spain has provided these resources from the very beginning: 600 million euros in the hands of the autonomous communities and municipalities to address the most immediate urgencies. And, in addition to all that, as you well know, the Government of Spain has been working very intensively in recent weeks, in collaboration and negotiation with the autonomous communities in the construction of a new benefit, which is the minimum vital income, which will undoubtedly be a turning point in the field of social protection in our country.

And regarding the World Health Organization, you are right. We have said this from the very beginning, and I repeat it because I think it is crucial. We need a much richer and more anticipatory evaluation of the information in this stage of de-escalation, transitioning to that new reality to which we will be forced as a consequence of the presence of the virus until there is a vaccine or a therapeutic remedy. And I insist, what is important, what is important is to evaluate together, between the Government of Spain and each of the autonomous communities, the strategic health capacities. One: reinforced healthcare. Primary care is fundamental. In this stage of de-escalation, it will play a crucial role. Strengthening primary care systems in each and every autonomous community will allow us to be closer to the moment when contagion among citizens can occur. Secondly, ICUs, ICUs, not only for people infected with COVID but also for people suffering from other pathologies who, unfortunately, during this sudden invasion of the virus in our country and throughout the continent, have logically been postponed due to the urgency that healthcare personnel had to attend to COVID-19, and I refer to people infected with COVID-19. Therefore, reinforced healthcare, secondly, epidemiological surveillance. We need to strengthen our public health system. Public health systems are in the hands of the autonomous communities. They need to be reinforced. They need to be strengthened so that they can provide us with information in a timely manner, at a time when timing will be critical. It will be critical because we need to be ahead, anticipating any risk of contagion that may occur. Three: identification and containment of contagion. And there are very interesting experiences that different autonomous communities have been developing regarding isolation mechanisms. For example, hospital hotels. And finally, collective protection measures: hygiene, distancing, masks, everything that we have incorporated into our daily lives. And these will be the criteria, the markers that we will use to ensure that we effectively transition symmetrically and gradually through this de-escalation to that new normality. And I believe I have answered your questions, Rodrigo.

P: Good afternoon, Mr. President, Esther Ballesteros from Crónica Balear. I wanted to ask you about the proposal launched by entrepreneurs from the Balearic Islands aimed at extending the 75% discount that citizens of the islands have on air and sea travel to all Spaniards as a way to revive tourism, one of the sectors hardest hit by the current crisis, especially considering the great dependence of the Balearic Islands, and also the Canary Islands, on tourism. Has the Government considered working on this possibility?

And on the other hand, this week there has been great outrage in the Balearic Islands as a result of the pressures being exerted by German owners with second homes in Mallorca, who demand to be able to travel to their homes under the state of alarm. Entrepreneurs, also German, threaten to seek investment opportunities away from the islands if access to the archipelago is not allowed for these owners. In this regard, Minister Abalos has stated that formulas will be studied so that these owners can visit their homes during the confinement. Do you not think that advancing in this possibility would create discriminatory treatment between owners of second homes in Spain?

Thank you very much.

President.- Indeed, as you indicate, Esther, there is an infinite case law of very diverse realities, of complex societies, such as ours, where a fundamental right such as free movement is an essential right enshrined in our Constitution, and that we are currently, let’s say, restricting as a consequence of a greater good, which is to save lives and prioritize the public health of all citizens.

In this sense, I would like to say that the Government of Spain has been working from the beginning to try to support such an important sector of our economy, particularly in certain territories, among which are logically the Balearic Islands. We are in perfect and permanent communication with the tourism sector through the Ministry of Industry, Trade and Tourism.

We have implemented various measures to try to alleviate, let’s say, the dramatic consequences that this crisis has for the tourism sector and for employment. And we will continue to do so, we will continue to do so.

Indeed, one of the fundamental issues that we will have to incorporate into this de-escalation plan, which I did not want to refer to either, because it does not fall within what I consider most important in terms of explaining what the nature and philosophy of the de-escalation plan will be, is the control of international borders.

I believe this is one of the debates we are having. The other day in the European Council, we opened this debate to some countries, not only Spain, but some countries. And evidently, I believe that over the next few weeks, depending on how the epidemic evolves, not only in our country but in other countries, we will have to see if we can find joint solutions to promote tourism within our continent.

But I insist, with great caution, with a lot of caution. We still have a long way to go to reach that scenario, and all I can convey to you is the empathy and commitment of the Government of Spain to the tourism sector, which undoubtedly brings a lot of wealth and employment to our country.

Thank you very much to all the media for your questions.