Intervention by the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, at a joint press conference with the President of the Federative Republic of Brazil, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

26 April 2023 · Joint press conference with the President of the Federative Republic of Brazil, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva · Palace of Moncloa, Spain

Context
Sánchez addressed a joint press conference with Brazilian President Lula da Silva at the Palace of Moncloa, Madrid, on April 26, 2023, marking Lula's first European visit of his third term.
Main themes
Spain-Brazil strategic partnership, bilateral economic relations, EU-CELAC summit, EU-Mercosur trade agreement, climate emergency and drought, defense of democracy, science and innovation cooperation, cultural ties, Ibero-American community, war in Ukraine
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,298
79th percentile
Sentences
142
79th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
12.2
48th percentile
Syntax
3.16
68th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
28th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

142 sentences in 78 paragraphs

Good morning.

Thank you to the media for attending this press conference. And thank you and welcome to President Lula and also to the Government of Brazil, to the delegation, and thanks also, of course, to the members of the Government of Spain for attending this important meeting.

I would like to particularly thank President Lula da Silva for his visit to Spain on his first trip to Europe in this third term. And it is an honor for me, as president, to receive him at the Palace of Moncloa. With this visit, what is made clear is the new stage that has opened in our strategic relationship between Spain and Brazil.

Our two countries share a past, but above all a common future as members of the Ibero-American community. And both governments share much more at a time filled with uncertainty and at the same time with opportunities.

Today we share a vision of the world in which traditional differences are overcome by new and troubling challenges. We share the defense of the environment against blind and suicidal denialism and, therefore, the urgency to act against the climate emergency.

Today we also spoke about drought, which is a challenge that Spain and Brazil share, and I also personally thank President Lula for the help and advice he has given us on this issue.

We also share our commitment to science, to health against the superstition of anti-vaxxers, who exist in Brazil and Spain. Also the value of civilization against barbarism and the unwavering defense of democracy and the democratic state against the hordes we saw in Washington or Brasília.

These are qualities especially valuable in current times, as they will allow us, I believe, to better face the great global challenges we face.

That is why today we give great importance from the Government of Spain to this visit. We also attach importance to this new joint declaration that we are going to sign or have already signed, Spain and Brazil, which will serve as a roadmap for this renewed strategic partnership between our two countries.

We welcome it, as well as the upcoming launch of the Permanent Bilateral Commission, which will allow us to coordinate and also enhance our relations in all those areas in which we have been collaborating intensely for decades.

And I would like to focus on some of them.

The first, obviously, is the economic one, and proof of this is that Brazil became last year, in 2022, Mr. President, our main trading partner in Ibero-America.

Spain is also the second largest investor in Brazil, and Spanish companies already have a long contribution to the creation of wealth and employment in key sectors for the Brazilian economy.

And, precisely yesterday, Madrid hosted an important economic forum that is a continuation of the business meeting held in São Paulo last month, and thus we demonstrate the strength of our ties in this area. In the field of science and innovation, we have signed today a letter of intent to promote joint innovative projects, especially from a technological point of view.

We have signed a Memorandum of Understanding on higher education and another on socio-labor cooperation, all initiatives that ultimately reflect the maturity and diversity of our relations.

And, in the cultural field, Brazil is the country that hosts the largest number of Cervantes Institutes in the world. Spain is closely following the initiatives to reintroduce mandatory Spanish teaching in Brazilian schools.

And also, of course, beyond bilateral issues, Spain and Brazil are well aware of the growth potential of the relationship between the European Union and Latin America and the Caribbean. And that is a relationship that both countries want to strengthen and tighten.

And for that reason, we truly celebrate, and I personally thank President Lula for attending the EU-CELAC summit, which will take place in Brussels on July 17 and 18. An important summit in which many issues will be addressed, especially the strategic relationship between both regions. And it is undoubtedly a meeting in which Brazil, as the largest country in the Ibero-American community, has a key role to play.

Furthermore, as you know, Brazil will preside over Mercosur in the second half of this year, coinciding with the Spanish Presidency of the Council of the European Union. And this coincidence of both Presidencies I believe represents an extraordinary opportunity to try to materialize our approach in concrete progress in the EU-Mercosur. Spain, as you know, maintains a firm commitment to advance in the ratification of this important trade agreement. And that is why we welcome President Lula's and his Government's support for this agreement.

And finally, in our meeting we have also addressed, of course, global issues, such as the climate emergency in the context of drought and undoubtedly also the war in Ukraine.

And I want to thank President Lula for his involvement in this issue, because Brazil's involvement and commitment to global issues has been missed during these last years. And, therefore, I recognize his interest in promoting a group of mediating countries to achieve lasting peace in this part of the world.

I believe that Spain and Brazil desire the same thing: peace. And for this peace to be lasting, and also just, it is important that we all get involved, that we engage, that we respect the fundamental principles of international law and the United Nations Charter, such as territorial integrity and the international order based on rules.

And without forgetting that in this war there is an aggressor and there is a victim, the aggressor is Putin and the victim in this case is a people that is only fighting for its territorial integrity, for its national sovereignty, and for its freedom.

And, in that context, Spain has been working from the beginning to achieve that just and lasting peace.

And, in that sense, I want to thank, of course, Brazil's commitment to global issues, also in the area of peace in Ukraine.

I also want to conclude, as I did on this issue speaking with President Xi, that if we want that peace to be just and lasting, it is essential that the voice of the victimized country, in this case Ukraine, and its President Zelensky, be heard and that his peace formula also be taken into account.

Finally, other issues addressed have undoubtedly been the importance that our governments attach to environmental issues, to the fight against the climate emergency.

I believe that Brazil's return to the climate agenda represents, dear President, a true relief and hope for the international community.

We greatly value President Lula's commitment to the preservation of that public good that is the Amazon, and we want to continue working together in this regard.

That is why we have invited Brazil to join the Alliance for Resilience against Drought.

In short, I wanted to conclude, President Lula, to the media, by conveying that this visit marks the beginning of a new stage in our bilateral relations, that we renew our strategic partnership. And we do so convinced that from this unity of action we have much to contribute to the prosperity and well-being of our citizens in bringing our regions closer together and, ultimately, to the construction of a world that needs to be much safer and more sustainable if we want to face the real threats that much of our population suffers.

And with that, I give the floor to President Lula.

Thank you very much.

Q.- [Bianca Rothier, O Globo] Yes, my name is Bianca Rothier. I am the correspondent in Europe for Globo and Globo News, but I am asking this question on behalf of all Brazilian journalists at the Palace of Moncloa, here on behalf of the pool.

Good morning, Mr. President of the Spanish Government. Regarding the agreement with Mercosur, much is said about the management of environmental policy under the Bolsonaro government, deforestation, but there are also economic issues, especially from France, regarding agriculture. How do you intend to advance with the agreement if you have these resistances from countries in the European Union, especially, particularly from France?

President.- Well, thank you, Bianca, for your question. I believe that the Spanish Presidency of the Council of the European Union will have a very important milestone for relations between the Ibero-American region, Latin America, and the Caribbean and the European Union, such as the celebration of the CELAC-European Union Summit in Brussels, not in Spain, in Brussels, which is the first one held since 2015, if I remember correctly.

And what we want to do at that summit is precisely to establish a mechanism for permanent dialogue between both regions, because what we want is to strengthen the ties between both blocks.

I believe we have many things in common, shared interests. The first of these is that I am convinced that we can be much stronger and more influential in this context of geopolitical change that is taking place if Latin America and the Caribbean and the European Union strengthen their ties. And, within that strategy of investments, political, social, and business relations, I believe that Brazil and Spain share the view that the cornerstone on which to build it, in addition to these summits and this permanent dialogue, is the agreement between the European Union and Mercosur.

There are few arguments against reaching that agreement, but if we also weigh them and contextualize them at a time when clearly Europe, and I speak for Europe, President Lula will speak on behalf of his region, if there are arguments and there is an opportunity, it is clearly now.

It is not because Europe needs allies, and those allies—especially with those with whom we have societies with social affinities, cultural ties, historical connections, and of course commercial and economic relations like those we have—are Latin America and the Caribbean.

That is why from Spain we are going to work to overcome those resistances. Indeed, there are countries within the European Union that have doubts about the completion of this important agreement. But I believe that those doubts should dissipate if we think about all the potential that an agreement of the magnitude represented by the European Union and Mercosur would have for Latin America and the Caribbean and for the European Union.

We are going to work in that direction, we will do so with the European Commission. As you know, trade policy is a cession of sovereignty that all member states made to the European Commission. They are the ones who negotiate on behalf of the 27 member states. But we will certainly have things to say there.

And what I have committed to President Lula is that, to work. And, moreover, I believe that it coincides with the fact that they will lead Mercosur, we will lead the Council of the European Union. I believe that the circumstances, the context, are such that we can, in short, complete this process and reach an important agreement. Hopefully, hopefully we can, hopefully we can reach it. We will certainly work to reach an agreement this year.

Q.- [Javier López, 20 minutos] Hello. Good afternoon. I am Javier López from 20 minutos. I will ask the questions from the Spanish journalists.

President Sánchez, do you consider that President Lula's position can be equidistant in the conflict? And two questions at the national level.

First, yesterday the OECD stated that Spain is one of the countries where wages have devalued the most. You have asked employers to raise them, but what else can the Government do? I don't know if you are debating any aid plan, any bonus for food, in line with what is being done in the Valencian Community, and also regarding housing, if you could give us any data, more than the 20,000 new homes you announced yesterday in the Senate debate.

President.- Thank you very much, Javier, for your questions. Briefly, because as President Lula says, he has an important visit with our Head of State. And he has asked three questions: one about Brazil's position on Ukraine, what our interpretation is; two: about housing; and three: about real wages. And I will answer you briefly on all three.

Regarding Brazil's position on Ukraine. Well, I believe President Lula has said it. Brazil has returned. Brazil is a global power. Brazil, for years, unfortunately, has not had its voice heard. It has been introspective, it has not been active in conflict resolution and in responding to the global challenges we have.

No one can imagine that we can respond to the challenge of the climate emergency without Brazil's commitment, for example. Just to cite another case.

And I, from that point of view, when President Lula calls for a reform of the United Nations Security Council, I do not believe he does so because he considers that the United Nations and the multilateral system are outdated; he does so and advocates for that reform precisely because he believes in the multilateral order and because he believes in multilateralism to respond to the global challenges we face. One is the climate emergency and the other is, indeed, war. And there, if we look at the facts, Brazil, in the United Nations General Assembly, has always expressed its strong condemnation of the invasion of Ukraine and, therefore, has always advocated for the territorial integrity of Ukraine.

Then we may have nuances. I have them. Regarding some of the things President Lula da Silva has said, but I think what is important is, first, Brazil is defending the territorial integrity of Ukraine. Therefore, Brazil is defending an international order based on rules. And, thirdly, the fundamental thing is that we all work for peace, for the end of these hostilities and, evidently, that the territorial integrity, the national sovereignty, in my opinion, of the people who are being attacked, in this case Ukraine, is respected.

And, in that context, what I have conveyed to President Lula is that I believe the step Brazil has taken is important, as I also believe it is relevant that a global actor like China has set forth a position document.

And I also think it is very important that the international community, all countries, not only the Europeans, who have already taken a clear and strong position, also take into account what the formula for peace is that the country being attacked is advocating and demanding, which is the one that must be heard firsthand, which is Ukraine.

And from there, I obviously want to thank, as it cannot be otherwise, Lula and Brazil's commitment to being active and participating, as a global power that it is, in resolving all the global challenges we have as humanity.

Two. On real wages. Indeed, yesterday you said… Look, earlier I heard President Lula talk about some of the income protection policies he implemented when he had the honor of being president for two terms. And how he denounced that precisely the far-right had dismantled many of those income policies in favor of, or rather, against inequality and also against the hunger that part of his population suffers.

Well, in Spain too, dear president, we suffer poverty, we suffer inequality, we are one of the countries with the highest inequality in Europe, and that has a lot to do with the neoliberal response to the financial crisis.

This government is doing the opposite; it is reinforcing welfare state policies, it is approving reforms with the agreement of unions and employers, when possible.

For example, the labor reform, the pension reform, that is guaranteeing social peace, which perhaps people consider something that is given, but it is worked on because there were other moments with other crises where we had social conflict as a consequence of, well, the majority rejection of those counter-reforms that were made in this case by another administration, right?

And, in that sense, I want to remind you of the following: the labor reform recovers rights. It places collective bargaining at the center of labor relations between unions and employers.

Unions have been saying for a long time that there must be a much fairer distribution of the benefits of this growth. We are seeing that corporate profits are rising above wages and, therefore, what employers must do is sit down with the unions at that collective bargaining table that they agreed upon in that labor reform and reach a pact also for the wage improvement of workers, because, after all, that will also be good for the economy, because they will have greater purchasing power and, therefore, will be able to help the economy.

And just a note on this issue. The government of Spain, with the pandemic and now with the war, simply the war, ─I recalled it yesterday in the Senate and last week in Congress─ has allocated 45 billion euros to mitigate the effects of the war in Ukraine on households in our country. It is one of the largest amounts in the entire European Union.

And they are having an effect because we are seeing how economic growth is maintained, we lead that growth among the major European economies, how we have the job creation that we have and how we are also reducing inequality between two shocks as important as a pandemic and now a war.

But from there I believe that what is relevant is that everyone also assumes their responsibility. We assume it with these income protection policies, but I also believe that in this case employers must do their part, in this case collective bargaining with the unions.

Therefore, once again I ask that they sit at the table and reach an agreement that I believe is good for the economy, for the country and also, therefore, for employers.

And finally, on housing.

Earlier, President Lula mentioned the housing policies he implemented during his two terms.

Here, President Lula, I will only give you one piece of data.

In Spain, unlike what happens in the European Union, where the average is 9%, only 3% of the total housing in Spain is public, is protected.

Moreover, during the financial crisis, many of those public houses were sold to investment funds, and that makes it extremely difficult for Spain, especially our young people, to emancipate and access housing.

This government has made housing, housing policy, one of its main priorities.

We are building or have built 60% of those 100,000 homes that were included in the state plan at the beginning of the legislature. We have announced the mobilization of 43,000 new homes through the financing of loans from the Official Credit Institute.

Secondly, the mobilization of those 50,000 homes that are state-owned in Sareb, and yesterday we also recently announced the availability of land by the Ministry of Defense for the construction of another 20,000 homes.

That is to say, what we want is not to reach that 9% of the European average of protected housing of the total housing stock in our country, but to exceed it.

And, regarding the location of those homes from the Ministry of Defense, well, obviously when it is approved in the Council of Ministers, you will know.

You know, in any case, that the Ministry of Defense has properties throughout Spain and, therefore, there will be housing on Ministry of Defense land throughout Spain.

And with this, I want to thank, of course, the Brazilian Government Delegation and the Spanish Government Delegation for their presence to the media, also Spanish, Brazilian, and international.

And, President, I sincerely thank you for your commitment to Spain, and that we continue to work together on the bilateral and multilateral agenda, which I believe will be good for Spain, for Brazil, and for the world.

Thank you.