Press appearance by the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, after the informal summit of the Heads of State and Government of the European Union.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

11 March 2022 · Informal summit of the Heads of State and Government of the European Union · Palace of Versailles, Versailles, France

Context
Sánchez addressed press after the informal EU summit at the Palace of Versailles on March 11, 2022, summarizing discussions dominated by Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
Main themes
War in Ukraine, EU unity and solidarity, economic sanctions against Russia, Ukrainian refugees, European strategic autonomy, defense investment, energy policy, humanitarian aid, military assistance to Ukraine, European Peace Facility, EU enlargement perspective for Ukraine, common foreign and security policy
Duration
~45 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,404
93rd percentile
Sentences
190
88th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
13.9
66th percentile
Syntax
3.30
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
24th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 24%23%
  • Ceremonial 23%22%
  • Geopolitical 21%20%
  • Institutional 18%17%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

190 sentences in 86 paragraphs

Good afternoon.

First of all, I would like to thank the diplomatic services of both the Embassy of Spain in France and our diplomatic representatives at the Permanent Representation of Spain to the European Union.

I also thank the media for accompanying us and following this press conference, and of course, I would like to express my gratitude for the hospitality and success of this informal European Council at the Palace of Versailles under the French pro tempore Presidency of the European Union.

I would like to provide a brief summary of this day and a half of intense work we have had at this informal European Council, and afterwards, I will submit myself, Director, to the questions from the media.

As you know, everything has fundamentally focused on the war in Ukraine. We have conveyed and shared the gravity of the moment, both for Ukrainian society and for the entire European Union.

This aggression, I reiterate, is illegal, unjust, and unjustified by the Putin regime against a free, sovereign people who are fighting for their freedom and therefore for the right to choose a path much more aligned with the values represented by the European Union and the entire European project.

I would say that, first of all, what we have conveyed, I believe, in the conclusions is a message of unity from the European Union. Unity regarding sanctions, regarding the condemnation of this illegal military action perpetrated by Putin in a free country like Ukraine.

We have taken stock of the economic sanctions, the damage inflicted on the Russian economy as a result of these rapid, forceful, and urgent sanctions implemented by the entire European Union. And also, indeed, as has been conveyed to the media, the design of a new package of economic sanctions against the Putin regime.

Unity also regarding solidarity with Ukraine in various areas. First of all, everything that represents humanitarian aid and also military assistance from Europe with the announcement made by the High Representative of the European Union, Josep Borrell, to increase the European Peace Facility fund by an additional 500 million euros to finance the delivery of both defensive and offensive military equipment to the Ukrainian resistance.

Unity also in humanitarian aid, both from the perspective of European mechanisms and also from the bilateral perspective of the countries of the European Union.

Solidarity also in the reception of these Ukrainian refugees. Many countries are currently receiving flows of refugees from Ukraine. Right now, the figures are around three million people who have left Ukraine as a result of this invasion by Putin, and in this regard, I would like to convey, as I had the opportunity to do yesterday, precisely to Spanish society and particularly to the associations of Ukrainians in our country, that the Government of Spain is already coordinating with the autonomous communities and also with the municipalities - and I will present this at the Conference of Presidents we will have this coming Sunday on the island of La Palma with the regional governments - we are, as I said before, coordinating and organizing solidarity from all public institutions, also in collaboration with humanitarian aid NGOs and with the entire civil society to welcome the Ukrainian refugees who come to our country in the most dignified manner possible.

Solidarity also with financial assistance to sustain the economy in light of the severe impact that the Ukrainian economy is suffering.

And finally, that solidarity was also reflected in the conclusions in the European perspective given to the Ukrainian people in their journey towards freedom and therefore, towards being able to freely decide what they want to be and which regions and political projects they want to align with.

Secondly, we addressed the issue of the economic implications that this war will have for the entire European Union. In this sense, the fundamental idea is the expressed will of all member states and also the community institutions that we must strengthen our strategic autonomy. This has had various elements; I will mention three to be very concise, although later, if you wish, I can go into more detail on them.

The first relates to defense. There is a resounding, clear message from the member states that we must increase investment in the defense sector, that we must strengthen the common foreign and security policy. Europe must also provide security on the European continent, complementing NATO, of course.

Spain has argued that the NATO and European Union declaration must be approved as soon as possible. But in any case, what we have said is that we must strengthen that common foreign and security policy. And this is also closely related to enhancing collaboration and cooperation among member states to avoid and minimize the fragmentation that currently exists in the technological industrial base of defense in the European Union.

Regarding energy, you know that since this is an informal Council, we are talking about a back-and-forth process. In reality, what is important, fundamentally from a legal standpoint, will be the conclusions we will approve on March 24 and 25 at the formal Council in Brussels. Spain - and I believe I can say that there is an increasingly broad consensus among various member states, first regarding the diagnosis of the emergency situation we must address in response to this escalation of energy prices, particularly gas and its transmission to electricity prices - you know that Spain has been working and proposing measures for quite some time, since September 2021. However, there are about three elements I would like to share regarding energy, so you also know where the points of unanimity are and also the points still to be refined to reach an agreement that I believe can be very important for families, for companies, and also for industries, especially energy-intensive industries.

First, regarding supply, in a dual aspect, not only the diversification of supply sources, whether gas or renewable energies in our case - for other countries, for example, where we are, nuclear energy.

Secondly, also regarding the countries from which we source, particularly gas. And there, those proposals that Spain made last year regarding centralized gas purchasing have clearly been established. Ultimately, having much greater market power than if we could negotiate independently and not collectively.

Therefore, from the perspective of supply for Spain, above all and fundamentally, what has been important has been to incorporate in the conclusions that we must address the necessary interconnections with the European market from the Iberian Peninsula, something that, as you know, we also share in this demand with Portugal.

And finally, regarding prices, the need to cut the contagion effect that the rising gas price is having on the overall electricity price. There, as you know, the Government of Spain defends a clear, well-known position, made public to the media months ago, which is that we must decouple the gas price from the electricity price. But, regardless of whether this is the proposal or another, because indeed, in light of this proposal I have circulated in Spain, many other countries have also been contributing different proposals (Italy, Greece, Belgium, many other countries), but all with the same purpose, with the same objective, which is to decouple, to cut the contagion that the rise in gas prices may have on electricity prices.

And I believe this will be fundamental in the debate we will have on March 24 and 25 in Brussels, where, as I said before, we have played the first leg, now we will have to play the second leg. In the first leg, which is this informal European Council, I want to emphasize that it is important that it has been incorporated in the conclusions that we mandate the European Commission to propose a series of measures, somewhat in line with what the Commission itself pointed out in its communication published four days ago.

An important element that we have also incorporated at the proposal of the Government of Spain in the conclusions is the impact that the Russian invasion is having on a country as important as Ukraine, but also Russia, in terms of the export of agricultural products, for example, cereals. And we are already seeing that this is being reflected in food prices, not only in Spain, in Europe, but also globally. Therefore, also at the proposal of the Government of Spain, we have included in the Council's conclusions that the European Commission is mandated to study various options on how we can address the rise in food prices and also nitrogen fertilizers, which are also very important, and we want to increase the production capacity of food on our continent.

Finally, and to conclude, I would like to say to the media, and therefore also to the Spanish public opinion, that today we are commemorating March 11. It is the 18th anniversary of the terrible attacks that marked Spanish society, where 192 people died, compatriots, but also other foreign individuals whom we feel as our own, and there were almost 2,000 injured on a fateful day for Spanish society and also for European society. Eighteen years later, March 11 is a significant day to honor and also to pay tribute to the memory of the victims of terrorism, as we did two days ago, on March 9, precisely in the city of Madrid, and that afterwards, after this press conference, we will do as various European leaders to honor the memory and pay tribute, as I said before, to the memory of the victims of terrorism.

From here, from Versailles, from Paris, from France, I would like to convey, of course, to the families of the victims of all types of terrorism in our country, the solidarity, the remembrance, and undoubtedly, also the tribute of the entire Spanish society to their contribution to defending a cause, which is the cause of all, which is democracy, which is freedom, which is a way of living in peace and coexisting based on respect for human rights.

And with this, I hope I have been sufficiently concise, but I am, of course, at the disposal of the media, Director, to answer questions on these issues or others that you consider appropriate.

Q.- [Andrés Gil, Eldiario.es]

Yes, hello, good afternoon, President. Andrés Gil, from Eldiario.es.

I wanted to ask you, in light of the conclusions that call for a greater effort in defense from the countries of the European Union… Well, Spain I believe spends around 1.2 percent of GDP. NATO also has the 2 percent target. I wanted to ask you if Spain is indeed considering, following that, reaching the 2 percent defense spending and if it is also considering reinforcing the defense budget. And if it is also considering mobilizing more soldiers or making more effort on NATO's eastern flank, as other countries are also doing.

Thank you.

President.- Thank you very much, Andrés, for your questions.

The commitment to 2 percent of Gross Domestic Product in defense is a commitment that was already made at the NATO Wales Summit a few years ago, and therefore, that is the commitment that all member countries of the Atlantic Alliance, including Spain, must work towards. The commitment of the Government of Spain, the perspective of the Government of Spain, I have mentioned on other occasions, is to reach in 2024 to be above 1.22-1.24 percent of Gross Domestic Product in the defense chapter.

What I find relevant in the conclusions is, above all, to propose that the increase occurs in investments, which is where we, if we look at the commitments already made at Wales by NATO, we exceed and fulfill by far. We are dedicating, I believe, around 20 percent to investments, and it is precisely here where the Europeans in the conclusions, if you look at the wording, will see that we are putting the emphasis.

Why? Because what we are fundamentally talking about is ending the fragmentation of the technological industrial base of defense in Europe and, therefore, spending better, investing better to create synergies that, unfortunately, are not currently being produced.

In relation to whether we are sending more or fewer soldiers to the eastern front, the NATO borders regarding Russia, I would like to say that we have already expressed to both the Atlantic Alliance and the Supreme Command of the Atlantic Alliance our willingness to logically comply with those graduated response plans that have been made to us, for example, that in these last few days we are sending 150 more military personnel to Latvia over the coming weeks to reinforce the Eastern Front.

Therefore, it is not that we plan to send more. On the contrary, what we have said is that we will logically fulfill the commitments we already made, I believe I recall that in September of last year, within the framework of those graduated responses that are logically available in this case to the Supreme Command of NATO in Europe. Well, not in the European Union, but in Europe.

Q.- [Carlos E. Cué, El País]

Yes, thank you very much.

On the topic of energy, from your responses and the information we have, it seems that there is some resistance from certain countries - it could be Germany. What I wanted to raise is if at the next Council, if a key issue for Spain, which is the price caps, is not established, would Spain be willing to do it individually? How far could the Government go if a European agreement is not reached on this?

Regarding the agreement with Vox, yesterday you said that the PP will pay dearly for it, and I wanted to ask if any president - out of curiosity - if any European leader has raised anything about this with you. And what will you do from now on? Will you call Mr. Feijóo, who is already a formal candidate, officially the only candidate? Will you call him, will you ask for that sanitary cordon? Would you be willing to talk about the most voted lists, which is what he is talking about? What do you propose to face this situation?

And finally, the Conference of Presidents on Sunday - aside from what you have commented on refugees - regarding economic measures: what economic measures does the Government have in mind to address this situation? For example, the reduction of fuel taxes, which is much talked about.

President.- Thank you very much, Carlos, for your questions.

Regarding the first question, I believe I was clear, in addition to the last press conference I held, but also in the appearance before the Congress of Deputies, where I said that the Government of Spain would do everything in its power to defend the industry, businesses, small and medium-sized enterprises, and also citizens so that they are not hostages to this energy blackmail that Putin is subjecting the entire European Union to. Point one.

Point two. Right now, within the European framework and in this important Council that we will have on March 24 and 25, the position of the Government of Spain is clear: we need to make decisions, we need to take measures because we are facing an emergency situation, and it is much better that we take them at the European level. And I certainly believe it is essential that we review the way prices are articulated, the way prices are formed in the energy market on our continent, because it is clearly not responding effectively to this stress that the price of electricity has been subjected to for some time, but evidently in a much more exacerbated way since the invasion of Ukraine took place.

But at the national level, we have already taken measures that, in fact, in the appearance in the Congress of Deputies, in that framework of the National Economic Response Plan to the consequences of the war, we have launched, we have extended until mid-year an important package of tax reductions and if not suspensions: in VAT, in the electricity production tax. In short, tax reductions that you know and that we have extended until June, initially. We will see exactly how this situation unfolds.

And finally, at the national level, we have also proposed improvements and we have also extended the protection of the most vulnerable consumers.

But it is evident that we need to take measures at the European level. Throughout the next week, I will embark on a tour of various European countries to talk with different leaders so that we can collectively put together a proposal that halts this absolutely irrational escalation of electricity prices, of gas prices, and that, therefore, we can all defend the industry, small and medium-sized enterprises, and our citizens from the energy blackmail that Putin intends to inflict on the entire European Union.

But we will do everything that is in the hands of the Government of Spain. Everything that is at hand, I repeat, of the Government of Spain to defend our economy and our citizens. And I would like, in this case, for the opposition not to use this war and its economic consequences precisely to attack the Government of Spain, as they did with the pandemic, but rather to lend a hand.

I appreciate that they do not insult me. I think that is always good news, but in addition to not insulting me, it would be good if, for once during this legislature, they lent a hand at such a critical moment for Europe and for Spain, as is precisely the situation derived from this invasion by Putin in Ukraine.

Regarding the agreement with Vox: I have had some comments. Allow me not to reveal here who has told me. What I will say is that we have seen in an international news agency a very serious, very serious, very concerning headline. And it is the statement that the far-right, for the first time since the Franco era, will be able to participate in a regional government or in executive tasks.

And this is what the world thinks of what has happened in Castilla y León yesterday, after the agreement between the Popular Party and the far-right was made known. And this is also what the president of the European People's Party thinks, who has said that the Spanish right has capitulated to the far-right.

And therefore, for me, this is a serious situation. I believe we are facing a serious moment for Spanish democracy. We are at a critical moment for Spanish democracy. I do not want to sugarcoat this situation, because when one sees what the main messages are coming out of that agreement formed between the Popular Party and Vox, they raise deep concern.

They talk about, at such an important moment as guaranteeing social peace, reducing and weakening precisely the social agents, the employers, and the unions.

At a time when this week we are celebrating International Women's Day, March 8, and many women and men in our country are taking to the streets in defense of real and effective equality between men and women, we have seen how violence against women begins to be trivialized again.

And, thirdly, we have also seen how immigrants are once again being targeted at a time when Spanish society is expressing profound solidarity with those victims in the form of refugees from the conflict in Ukraine as a result of the Russian invasion.

And to put one more element on the table, it seems to me a profound sadness and I will say also a deep discomfort that in a country like ours, which is, according to the United Nations - not according to the Government of Spain, according to the United Nations - one of the countries in the world with the highest number of missing persons, even after forty years of dictatorship and a civil war, that there is frivolity and a proposal to repeal a Historical Memory Decree in Castilla y León, seems to me to be a serious situation. And I regret that the Spanish center-right is not also capable of having that message of humanity with many relatives of those people who are still searching for the remains of their loved ones, who are buried in places, unfortunately, still unknown to all of them.

If these are the priorities of the new government of Castilla y León, formed by the Popular Party and Vox, then I believe they are not only far removed from the daily concerns that the citizens of Castilla y León may have, but they are also distant from the principles and values that, I am convinced, the majority of citizens in our country hold, which are those of coexistence, those of cohesion, those of social peace, and undoubtedly also those of memory, recognition of the victims of Francoism, and above all, the need to continue searching for and exhuming the remains of relatives who, unfortunately, still remain in unknown places for many of them.

And we must remember that those relatives who are asking us, the public authorities, to commit to exhumations, are already very elderly relatives, who want to leave in peace, with the rest of having been able to find the remains of their parents, their loved ones, their ancestors, who unfortunately did not have the ability to find during the forty years of dictatorship or during the early years of democracy.

I believe we owe it to them, and therefore, all these issues that have been set as supposed main priorities for the Popular Party and Vox, are nothing more than the result of a very retrograde vision of Spanish society and what Spanish society needs to heal the wounds of the past and look confidently to the future.

Regarding the president of the Xunta de Galicia, Núñez Feijóo, obviously, as soon as he is appointed, I will have the opportunity to talk with him and share some of these concerns with him.

And regarding the economic measures, I would say that, as I presented to the deputies in the General Courts a week ago, the plan that the Government of Spain is developing is an open plan, it is a dynamic plan, which has two dimensions: the European one, which we will try to finalize at the European Councils on March 24 and 25, and also, logically, the Government of Spain will take measures in all areas to protect vulnerable consumers, to protect families and citizens of our country, and above all, the sectors affected by the rise in gas prices, gasoline, raw materials, and also, logically, the primary sector of food, derived from this military conflict, which is evidently bringing economic consequences, but which, I insist, and I think it is also important that you reflect this in your reports, would be much greater if Europe did nothing. If Europe did nothing, the cost would be much greater than what we are currently suffering as a result of an attempt to destabilize security and European borders by Putin.

Q.- [Almudena Guerrero, TVE]

Good afternoon, Mr. President, if I understood you correctly, you just announced a tour of various countries to try to unify a common proposal on energy matters. I don’t know if you can give us more details about that tour, which countries you will visit.

And secondly, returning to Castilla y León, Mr. Feijóo holds the PSOE responsible for the agreement with Vox for not wanting to negotiate, he says, with Mr. Mañueco. Picking up my colleague's question, would you be willing to reach an agreement with the Popular Party to allow the most voted list to govern? Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much, Almudena. Regarding the first question, if you allow me, over the next few days we will give you a bit of the tour, the names of the prime ministers and presidents that I will visit. We are finalizing it right now with them. Over the course of this day and a half, we have had the opportunity to chat and we have been, let’s say, somewhat naturally arranging those meetings, but I prefer, first of all, to finalize it with them and then communicate it to all of you.

But we will indeed make a tour of various European countries to somehow see if we can reach an agreement that I believe is not only urgent but necessary, because there are many productive sectors in the European economy and therefore in Spain that are suffering and should not have to suffer so much as a consequence of a design that is outdated in our energy market and price formation.

And therefore, it is that will that we have expressed and that you have known for some time, to try to cut the effects of gas prices on electricity prices.

You have heard me say this many times when I accompany you on many trips, especially here, to the different European capitals, and therefore, I do not want to delve into something that you know perfectly well.

And regarding the second issue, look, the Socialist Party gave an alternative to the Popular Party, and the alternative was the abstention of the Socialist Party in the Cortes of Castilla y León, if a democratic cordon to the far-right was proposed. That is how it is. And therefore, I believe it is necessary that each one, you have heard me say on other occasions, must move from ambiguity to the concrete, and the concrete is that when the Popular Party, whoever leads it, has had to choose, it has chosen not to put a democratic cordon to the far-right, but to embrace the far-right and form, for the first time in the democratic history of our country - and this is very serious, very serious - a coalition government with the far-right.

And I insist, the reading that is being made outside of Spain about this coalition government, there is an international agency that reflects it as it is. It is the first time that there is a government in our country throughout this democracy since Franco, since the dictator Franco. This is the case, it is what they read, it is the reading made by international agencies. I am not saying it. And in fact, that is why the main leader of the European People's Party spoke of capitulation, of the capitulation of the right by an extreme right party like Vox.

And about the first political force... Are you talking to me about Andalusia? About the city of Madrid? Are you talking to me about Orense? Are you talking to me...? In short, I believe that the People's Party, when it talks about the first political force, it is always when they are the first political force. I believe that one must be coherent. And of course, one must above all be anchored to what the European center-right is doing or, at least, the center-right that we would like the People's Party to resemble, which is the center-right of a Germany that says no to the extreme right, which is even capable of renouncing a government like that of Thuringia, precisely so that the fascist extreme right does not enter a government of such an important Länder as that. And in a system as decentralized as ours, the fact that the extreme right enters an autonomous government is not trivial, because we are talking about managing healthcare, managing education, managing policies that affect the day-to-day lives of citizens.

And it seems to me of extraordinary gravity and one cannot sugarcoat it. Of course, I do not sugarcoat it, especially when one sees what the objectives and priorities set by that government are: gender violence, trivializing it and saying that it does not exist; talking about immigration; talking about the need to repeal the Democratic Memory Decree; and talking about the need to weaken precisely that which is guaranteeing social stability and social peace, such as social dialogue, in this case, in a region as extensive and important for our country and our political system as Castilla y León.

In short, I believe that things must be faced head-on and if one wants to impose a democratic order on the extreme right, it can be done. And those who do not want to impose it will have to answer for it, but they should not look for excuses, because if they are anything, they are bad payers.

Q.- [Carina Verdú, Antena 3]

Thank you, President, we have seen you these two days meeting with your European colleagues without wearing a mask. If I am not mistaken, here in France, on Monday it will no longer be mandatory. When will it no longer be mandatory in Spain? When will it stop being mandatory indoors in our country?

President.- Thank you Carina, thank you for your question. I also ask the Minister of Health that. We hope it will be soon.

You are seeing that in recent days we have had a slight increase in the accumulated incidence over 7 days. In short, the trend is downward. We are the country in Europe with the lowest accumulated incidence, but it is still high because we are around 400 points and we will see if this month we can lower it completely and have a scenario much more comparable to other countries that have much higher incidences than ours, but that have made the decision, based on their criteria and the advice of health professionals, precisely on this issue.

But well, I think it is important the dynamics we will have in the coming weeks so that the Conference or the Council, better said, of inter-territorial policy among the health counselors and the Minister of Health, makes a decision that we hope will indeed be favorable to be able to remove our masks indoors depending also on what cases and in what situations. It is not the same to use public transport with or without a mask, than to perhaps be indoors in a meeting without a mask.

But in any case, I do not want to get ahead of myself. Let us allow the professionals to advise us and we hope it will be soon.

That question you ask, rest assured that I also ask it to the Minister of Health.

If there are any more...

Q.- [Emmanuel Berretta, Le Point-original question in English]

Thank you for the press conference. I understand Spanish, but I do not speak it very well. I have a question about the issue of interconnection between France and Spain. What is at stake exactly? Could you be honest with us? And have you discussed this with President Macron during this summit?

President.- Yes, yes, yes. We did, and in fact, Portugal and I, António Costa and I, had the opportunity to talk with President Macron and we also discussed at the table the need to accelerate interconnections, not only of gas but also of renewable hydrogen, green hydrogen. In the case of Spain, I believe that Spain and Portugal can contribute to diversifying energy resources and the question is, of course, who pays for that interconnection? And this is something that, on our part, we believe must come from the funds of the European Union and, well, I think it is... you know, if we consider that this is going to be a crisis that will last a long time, years, it is important that we develop much greater resilience for the European Union, especially in terms of energy policy. And that is why I think it is important to diversify sources, accelerate Fit for 55, the green transition, interconnect countries like Portugal and Spain that we could provide and we could also reduce the impact of the Russian gas crisis on very important economies like Germany among others.

This is a debate we had during the Council. I remember that one of my first public European meetings was in Lisbon with Prime Minister Costa and also with President Macron. I had been in office for one, two, three weeks and we talked about interconnections. And this is, I believe, one of the tasks we have to face and talk honestly between both countries, Spain and France, because this situation is an emergency. And I believe we must offer all the resources we have to reduce the impact of this terrible war.

Thank you very much.