Press appearance by the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, in Brdo pri Kranju (Slovenia), after the EU-Western Balkans summit.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

6 October 2021 · EU-Western Balkans summit · Brdo pri Kranju, Slovenia

Context
Sánchez addressed a press conference in Brdo pri Kranju, Slovenia, on October 6, 2021, following the EU-Western Balkans summit and an EU Council meeting.
Main themes
EU-Western Balkans relations, energy prices and electricity market reform, European defense policy, transatlantic relations and NATO, ecological transition and decarbonization, economic recovery post-pandemic, joint EU energy purchasing, marginal pricing system reform, Spain's Iberian Peninsula energy situation, EU global role with US, China, Russia
Duration
~42 min
91st percentile
Words
5,080
91st percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
41
38th percentile
Grade
16.1
84th percentile
Syntax
3.56
96th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 34%33%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Geopolitical 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

148 sentences in 72 paragraphs

President.- How are you? Good morning.

Thank you to the media for following this press conference. Thank you also again, as I always say at the end of the Councils, to the Foreign Affairs team and also to the Embassy for the work they do, which makes it much easier for us to reach agreements and have very fruitful debates for the whole of the European Union.

I will be very brief in this first intervention so that I can then take your questions; I will provide, as we always do, a brief summary of the main debates we have had over this day and a half of the Council.

Yesterday, as you know, we had an informal dinner of leaders where aspects related to the role that the European Union must play as a global actor in its relations with the United States, in its relations with China, and also, of course, in its relations with Russia were discussed.

I would like to say, in this regard, that from the Government of Spain, we have always maintained that regarding transatlantic relations, the debate launched by the French presidency, also by the presidency of the European Commission in the last State of the Union address, about a Europe of defense, Spain has never opposed it; on the contrary, we have always encouraged that we must also take steps towards the integration of defense policy, as well as foreign policy, but these must be complementary to the Euro-Atlantic policy framed within NATO, the Atlantic Alliance.

You know that we have an important summit next June 2022 in Madrid, the NATO summit, where the 2030 initiative will be defined by the Secretary General, the new NATO strategy for the coming years, and what we want is for all declarations, all defense strategies that can be articulated and the steps to be taken by the European Union to be coherent, to be complementary, with the need to continue strengthening the Atlantic Alliance with our American partner.

Secondly, the topic that arose at the Leaders' Summit was precisely the evolution of energy prices. And as you know, I mentioned earlier, in the stop we all presidents make before the formal council begins, that the Government of Spain has proposed over the last few weeks, in light of the escalation of wholesale prices in energy markets and also the rise in gas prices, a series of measures under the same premise that the evolution of energy prices, the evolution of wholesale prices in the energy and electricity market, is a European issue because it is affecting all European countries. Some European countries are more affected, such as the Iberian Peninsula, because we do not have interconnections and in some way we are an energy island, but it is affecting each and every one of the Member States and therefore, if each and every one of the Member States is vulnerable to the evolution of gas prices and the evolution of electricity prices, what is evident is that in addition to the measures that we have already implemented by governments, particularly the Government of Spain, to cushion this rise in electricity prices, we also need to provide a European solution, a European response that allows us to consolidate economic recovery after 20 months of pandemic. Right now we are seeing how economic recovery is being strengthened and consolidated in our country. Just a few days ago we saw the employment data, the drop in unemployment.

In short, I believe that this is a consequence of that economic recovery. Therefore, we must consolidate that economic recovery, we must consolidate the pace of decarbonization to mitigate and adapt to climate change, that Europe continues to be the world leader in everything related to ecological transition and, thirdly, consolidate the social support of all groups, of all Member States and their societies to this process of ecological transition and the fight against climate change.

In that sense, what has the Government of Spain proposed? Well, it has proposed different measures.

The first of these is that a system that was created at another time, precisely to promote and incentivize the use of renewable energies, which is the formation of prices based on marginal prices, needs to be changed. And we have to do this at the European level. That is the first proposal we have put on the table.

Secondly, what we have proposed is: let us follow the example of vaccines. Europe has been an inspiring example, a very effective integration process not only from the point of view of purchasing vaccine doses but also of equitable access for the population to those vaccines. We have been able, together, to purchase vaccines against Covid from large pharmaceutical companies that have allowed us to protect in record time. There is no continent like Europe right now in terms of protecting its population, and Spain is at the forefront, as you all know, and therefore this means that together we are stronger, that together we have greater negotiating capacity, for example, with large pharmaceutical companies and, why not, also with large natural gas producers.

That is why the second of the proposals we have put on the table from the Government of Spain is: let us make the Union a new fortress in the field of energy policy. When we talk about strategic autonomy, we are also talking about being autonomous in a strategic reserve that is fundamental if we want to successfully navigate this ecological transition, with this transitional energy that natural gas represents towards cleaner energies. This is the second of the proposals we have put on the table.

And the third relates to the speculative phenomena occurring in the CO2 emission markets. In the ETS market, speculative phenomena are occurring. This has nothing to do with ecological transition; it has to do with certain funds that are precisely speculating with the price and, therefore, from the European Union, we can do a lot to control and reduce those speculative phenomena that are occurring in the CO2 emissions market.

In short, I believe that the proposals put on the table by the Government of Spain have been well received. Above all, they have opened a debate within the European Union, they have created awareness that this is a problem that does not affect this or that country, but the whole of the European Union, which can jeopardize some important elements, such as, for example, economic recovery, and therefore we must act.

As you know, there will be different steps taken over the coming weeks. On October 11, the ministers of the Member States linked to the energy portfolio will meet.

Subsequently, we will learn what the communication is and, therefore, let us say, the menu of proposals that the European Commission will put on the table to address the rise in natural gas prices and also the wholesale energy market.

And, thirdly, we will have on October 21 and 22, already in Brussels, an in-depth debate on what measures we are going to implement from the Council and also from the European Commission.

Well, I believe that this is a debate that undoubtedly matters a lot to all citizens of Spain. And all I can convey to you is, first, calm; secondly, assurance that the Government of Spain is doing everything possible at the national level and also at the European level, so that all this runaway and, let us say, unprecedented rise that is occurring in natural gas and its price, and in the electricity market, does not affect the electricity bill, the gas bill for our consumers and also for small and medium-sized enterprises and the Spanish industry.

And finally today, as you know, we have had a summit of the European Union of the Western Balkans. I want to tell you that, from our own historical experience, we are not a founding country of the European Union. We joined the European Union in 1986, so, in some way and for historical reasons, Spain is always a friendly country and always shows itself favorable to enlargement processes.

Why? Because we, I insist, were not a founding country, as a consequence of the Franco dictatorship, we were very far from being able to join the then European Economic Community and it was thanks to democracy, and the reformist push that occurred then, that we consolidated our entry into the European Union.

And this, in short, this historical digression serves us to explain what the position of the Government of Spain is. We consider the Western Balkans a region of Europe, its Member States as brother states that must, in some way, be part of the European Union in the nearest horizon. We encourage all these countries to resolve their internal issues, their internal disputes that they have, as you all know, and also, logically, to comply with the reform agenda, especially linked to the rule of law.

From there, we have clearly expressed Spain's favorable predisposition to continue in that process of dialogue and negotiation by the community institutions and the countries of the Western Balkans.

And finally, I would like to say that the Western Balkans are also important to Spain, during the civil war in the former Yugoslavia, but also after the civil war in the former Yugoslavia, with the arrival of refugees to Spain during that time, with the sending of armed forces to guarantee the stability and peace of the former Yugoslavia; well, it is not a zone that is foreign to Spain, even though it is geographically distant, it is not a zone foreign to our country, because we received those refugees, we made that exercise of solidarity, both within our home and precisely in these countries, guaranteeing stability and peace for many years. And therefore it is a zone that concerns us and that matters to us, because in some way it also guarantees the stability of the region.

A region, as you all know, historically very tumultuous and that has also led to dramatic situations in the past.

And with this, Director, I would be ready to answer the questions from the media.

Q.- [José Miguel Blanco, EFE Agency] Thank you, good afternoon. Regarding the electricity tariff, I would like to know if any other European leader has expressed any reluctance to the idea of seeking joint solutions to alleviate this problem.

And in relation to the Housing Law, I would like to know your opinion on the announcement made by the leader of the Popular Party that he will appeal to the Constitutional Court and that he will not apply it in the communities or municipalities where he governs. Thank you.

President.- Well, thank you very much, José Miguel, for your questions. Regarding the first one, I can tell you that no, absolutely not. What there is, is a willingness to listen from certain Member States that have seen the price of energy in their countries and also electricity grow in recent days.

And what there is, is an increasing conviction around the table of the European Council and also of the European Commission itself, as we have recently heard from the President of the European Commission, that this is a problem that we need to provide a European response to and that business as usual is not enough, because indeed, the rise in gas prices and the rise in electricity prices is so unprecedented that it requires unprecedented proposals, innovative proposals, strong proposals, bold proposals that are what the Government of Spain is putting on the table, as proposals, and that are, logically, subject to debate in order to reach an agreement that allows us to advance in a response that makes economic recovery a just economic recovery, that makes ecological transition a just ecological transition, that does not affect especially the most vulnerable groups and that, above all, does not jeopardize the economic and financial viability of the European industry. And this is what the Government of Spain is focused on.

That is why I insist, we are not just going to say this is the reality of the electricity market, the wholesale market or the price of gas. We are coming with proposals and with proposals, I insist, bold, that would also imply greater strategic autonomy for Europe in the medium and long term, because if we buy together and make a gas reserve in Europe, we are guaranteeing greater strategic autonomy on a fundamental issue like energy now that autumn and winter are beginning.

And secondly, as I said before, we will have to review this functioning and, let's say, the formation of energy prices, because it was done at a time when the intention was to incentivize renewable energy sources. Once renewable energy sources are financially much more competitive than gas or any type of fossil fuel energy, what we need to do is precisely review that pricing system which today is marginalist and, therefore, is benefiting those more expensive energies to the detriment of the less expensive ones, which are the funds, or rather, the sources of renewable energies, precisely to continue with that ecological transition and to ensure that this ecological transition is as fair as possible.

I must tell you in this regard that the feeling I have is that it will be an intense dialogue and negotiation over the coming weeks. I insist that first there will be a meeting of the energy ministers on the 11th; subsequently, there will be a communication from the European Commission where we will see exactly what the European Commission proposes as a menu of measures that we can implement at the European level; and finally, on October 21 and 22, we will have a much deeper conversation within the European Council than we had today, which was an informal summit, as you all know, but the fact that this topic was addressed at the informal Leaders' summit is precisely because Spain requested that this debate be raised yesterday.

Regarding the Housing Bill, well, let's see, I think it cannot be said that we should reject a bill that has not even had the opportunity to be read, that has not even been debated in the Cortes Generales, and therefore, to close all doors to a potential agreement on one of the fundamental issues pending in our society, which is to turn housing not into a problem, but into a right. To turn, I insist, housing into a problem as it is today, rather than into a right.

The Government of Spain has put on the table, for the first time in the history of democracy, a set of responses, balanced responses from the point of view of what our Constitution demands, which is absolute respect for private property, but also committed, committed to young people's access to housing. We have an age of emancipation for our young people in our country that is absolutely unacceptable, outrageous, much higher than the average of 26 years in the European Union.

A law that is also committed to one of the main deficits that our country has, which is social housing. Let us remember that there are many municipalities, unfortunately, that have sold and disinvested public housing in our country over the last few years, putting it in the hands of investment funds.

And, thirdly, promoting one of the fundamental tasks that our country has ahead, which is everything related to public housing, the promotion of rental housing, with tax incentives precisely for landlords and also, logically, for those who want to rent a home.

Therefore, it is a law committed to social responsibility and balanced from the point of view of what the property owner represents in our country.

And from there, I would ask the opposition to read the text before announcing that they will challenge it before the Constitutional Court, to read the text and to give parliamentary processing a chance as well. Because it seems to me that this is a topic that affects all citizens above ideologies. And the fact is that people have a problem accessing housing, and that has nothing to do with voting for the right, voting for the left, or voting for the center. No, it has to do with the fact that housing for many families in our country, and especially for young people, is today a real problem.

And from the public authorities, what we must do is turn that problem into a right. And it is the right to housing, to decent housing. And that is what the Government of Spain is working on.

And I must say that I am deeply proud that this Government has been able, in the midst of a pandemic, 20 months of pandemic that we have fortunately today with a much lower incidence, to put on the table for the first time in more than 40 years of democracy, a proposal for a State Housing Law. I believe that simply that fact, that milestone, that parliamentary initiative, deserves the respect of all political forces.

Therefore, what I would like is for the opposition to reflect because many voters, also from the center-right and the right, have problems with housing and that we could turn this Housing Law into a state agreement, into a great national agreement in which not only the autonomous communities, the municipalities, the Government of Spain, but also all political forces, could provide a common response to a problem that affects, I insist, all citizens, regardless of how they vote when elections are held.

And finally, José Miguel, allow me to say that, as this State Housing Law was indeed proposed within the framework of an internal budget negotiation within the Government, first, I want to highlight the importance of having General State Budgets again this coming year, because these General State Budgets will, I insist, once again provide responses to scholarships for our young people, to housing for our young people, to the dependency of our elderly, to primary care in the National Health System that has suffered so much and has done so much to defend us during the Covid period, or also to everything related to employment and the protection of our workers, including the self-employed.

And in that sense, you know that yesterday I had the opportunity in Seville to share an initiative that is precisely the aid of 250 euros to young people for the entry into a rental agreement that would last around two years.

Well, today we are celebrating Spanish Cinema Day. Cinema, like the performing arts, ultimately, the culture of our country, unfortunately, during the pandemic and as a consequence of confinement, has suffered a lot. And I want to announce that in the General State Budgets that we will present to the Cortes Generales next week, we are also including a youth voucher, a cultural youth voucher, as they do in France, as they do in Italy, a direct aid to all those young people who turn 18 years old, when they reach adulthood, we will give them, if these budgets are approved, 400 euros for the purchase of books or for the consumption of any type of artistic activity, such as theater, cinema, dance, music. Ultimately, what we want is to continue protecting young people, giving them more aid precisely for emancipation and also so that, well, together, we can help, lend a hand to such an important industry as the cultural industry in our country, and also bring young people even closer, because I am convinced that they are, to the culture of our country.

Q.- [Sandra Gallardo, Radio Nacional de España] Hello, President, good afternoon, I wanted to ask you about one of the proposals you have put on the table regarding energy, to explain how you can carry it out. You compare the centralized purchase of vaccines with the strategic gas reserve, but the situation is different because in that case the vaccines were distributed by governments and in the case of gas, the electricity companies, the energy companies are private companies. I don't know how that would be resolved without entering, let's say, into that private profile of those companies.

And on the other hand, if finally, as various media outlets are already pointing out, the Prosecutor's Office archives the investigations regarding the emeritus king, if the Government would have any objection to the return to Spain of King Emeritus Juan Carlos.

President.- Thank you very much, Sandra, for your two questions.

Regarding the first, the proposal we make is, well, you saw, for example, that the Minister of Foreign Affairs traveled to Algeria precisely with the Secretary of State for Energy and also with some companies, in particular with one, which is managing one of those gas connections.

In reality, the proposal made by the Government of Spain is, above all, that the European Commission negotiates on behalf of the 27 member states. And if the 27 member states do not agree that we all go together, because some do not consider it necessary, because they have a different energy mix, then what we propose from the Government of Spain is a reinforced cooperation, that is, that those countries that want to can join together and tell the European Commission that it can negotiate on behalf of the countries that consider it appropriate, but obviously in collaboration with the companies, with the private companies, as could not be otherwise.

And, secondly; well, I learned about this news in the Council. I have always said it, and that is the guarantee that all Spaniards must have, and it is that from the Government of Spain we have always defended the equality of all Spaniards, regardless of their names and surnames, and that, therefore, what the Tax Agency has done, what the Prosecutor's Office has done, is to work in absolute freedom, with all the economic and material resources they needed to investigate every last fact that had to be investigated. And from there, we will obviously abide by what the Attorney General of the State tells us.

And regarding your last question: well, it is not for me to answer.

Q.- [Víctor Tuda, Europapress] Yes, good afternoon. I wanted to ask about the rental voucher for young people: the Bank of Spain says in a report that these measures can be counterproductive and contribute to raising rental prices. I don't know if you fear that it could have that effect. And I would also like to know if young people from Autonomous Communities whose governments apply this measure could benefit from the voucher.

And then, a completely different topic, regarding Kosovo's participation in the summit, I would like to know if you have been able to speak with the Kosovar Prime Minister and if you have been able to convey any kind of message regarding the recognition of Kosovo.

President.- Well, thank you very much, Víctor, right? Thank you. Thank you for your questions.

Regarding the first, let me say that the problem that young people currently have is that the age of emancipation we have in our country is absolutely unacceptable.

Young people are suffering from job insecurity, young people are facing a difficulty - more than a difficulty, let's say it as it is: an impossibility of being able to access a home for rent or ownership - and, consequently, what we must do is facilitate and articulate policies that facilitate their access to housing and, therefore, allow them to emancipate themselves much earlier than they unfortunately do now in our country.

We are convinced that these direct aids will incentivize that emancipation, that they will help young people to be able to emancipate themselves earlier, and we certainly make no distinction. That is to say, regardless of what each autonomous community does, the color of the government they have, the young people in those territories will be able to access that aid. And I would also like to emphasize: we should make this state law a law that opens a new time in Spanish politics, that is a state agreement; because I insist, it is the young people, it is the citizens who today suffer housing as a problem, as an inaccessible good, and we must all turn it into a right.

You see, yesterday in the Council of Ministers we approved two royal decree laws, two royal decree laws that promoted, on the one hand, rehabilitation and urban renewal and, on the other, what we did were legislative modifications, precisely, for example, modifying the Horizontal Property Law to incentivize that rehabilitation and urban renewal. With this, we are not only contributing to adapting and mitigating the effects of climate change, reducing greenhouse gas emissions, but we are also going to improve the energy security of each of the homes, especially the most vulnerable homes, those of the poorest quality.

Well, this is a commitment that the Government of Spain has. And the second commitment that the Government of Spain has, and I also announced it in my investiture speech, is that we were going to put in place for the first time a state housing law, because we have to make housing a right. Today it is not, unfortunately, although it is enshrined in the Spanish Constitution. Today access to housing is not a right, and this transcends the partisan discussion between the left and the right, between the center or the north and the south. It is that no: we are talking about a significant part of the Spanish citizenry suffering as a problem what should be a right, which is housing.

And we are launching a series of unprecedented proposals from the public sector to solve this problem or contribute to it, and I insist, I would like those who have already announced their appeal to the Constitutional Court to think twice. But if they do not know the text, if they have not given even a chance to the parliamentary process to articulate a law and present their amendments. Let us give an opportunity to the agreement, to a state agreement that I believe the Spanish people deserve regarding housing, which is, I insist, a constitutional right that, unfortunately, we are not fulfilling today.

And regarding Kosovo, I would like to say that I have indeed had the opportunity to greet the Prime Minister, and to tell you the following: look, the approach, the approach that the Government of Spain has, and it is also public, is that we have welcomed this dialogue forum between Pristina and Belgrade, and what we encourage both parties to do is to find an agreement that is ultimately consistent with international law, respectful of international law, and satisfies both parties. And what the Government of Spain has to do, and especially a government like ours, which is active in European debates, is not to shy away from the debates, to be present in the debates.

Can you imagine if the Government of Spain were to be absent from this summit when the other 26 member states are present? We have to be in the debates, we have to be present in the forums to also give our opinion, and that has been expressed.

Q.- [Andrés Gil, El Diario.es] Hello, yes, thank you very much. I wanted to ask you about the joint purchase of energy: if in the event that the Commission does not agree to represent the states, because there is not enough critical mass for it, if Spain is considering reaching an intergovernmental agreement with four or five, six, seven, eight, however many share Spain's position to start with that joint purchase.

And, on the other hand, of course, the reform of the marginalist market takes time, with the legislation, the European legislative procedures; in that time frame, are you considering doing like France, which has announced that it will block prices until spring?

And now, speaking of which, if you could provide a bit more information about the cultural voucher. If it is just a one-time payment, if it is for people who turn 18... Well, if you could give us a bit more information about that.

Thank you.

President.- Well, thank you very much, Andrés.

And starting with the last of your questions, I would like to say that we are indeed talking about a cultural voucher of 400 euros for all young people who turn 18, and that 400 euros will be given to facilitate access to culture for these young people in the purchase of books, going to the cinema, attending live performances; in short, consuming culture and, let’s say, creating a virtuous circle between youth, access to culture, and the defense and promotion of the cultural industry. I believe that today, precisely as we celebrate Spanish Cinema Day, this is a measure that, to me, seems exciting, a measure that is committed not only to young people but also to such an important industry that has suffered so much, like the cultural industry during these long months of the pandemic.

Regarding the first of the questions: well, I think we need to take it step by step. I believe we have to fight -if you allow me the expression- for the European Commission to commit to leading that negotiation on behalf of the 27 member states. As I said before, we would be open to it being a reinforced cooperation if, in the end, there is some country that does not want to participate. I believe that if there is a majority -and I have the feeling that there is a majority of countries that would be willing- then we should articulate a reinforced cooperation.

And finally, regarding the legislative framework, I would like to say two things. One: I believe it is necessary to open that debate at the European level. I believe there is a marginal pricing system that is no longer valid today, which is precisely penalizing the use of renewable energy sources, and therefore, we need to review it thoroughly and transform it.

And, on the other hand, to emphasize the measures that the Government of Spain has put on the table: which are involving a reduction in revenue of billions of euros and also, logically, a cushioning of the evolution of wholesale prices and their impact on the bill or the electricity bill that Spaniards have to pay monthly, quarterly, or annually.

Thank you very much.