Press conference by President of the Government following meeting of Extraordinary European Council on Brexit
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez held a press conference on 25 November 2018 following the Extraordinary European Council meeting in Brussels that endorsed the UK's Brexit Withdrawal Agreement.
- Main themes
- Brexit Withdrawal Agreement, EU-UK relations, rights of EU citizens in the UK, political declaration on future relations, orderly withdrawal, financial settlement, internal market integrity, police and judicial cooperation, Spain's pro-European commitment, gender-based violence elimination, transitional period
- Duration
- ~43 min
- Words
- 5,168
- Sentences
- 188
- Readability
- 47
- Grade
- 13.3
- Syntax
- 3.25
- Vocabulary
- 2.00
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
188 sentences in 75 paragraphs
President of the Government .- Good day to you all. Thank you for attending this press conference to report on the Council meeting on Article 50.
First of all, I wanted, on the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women, to declare the commitment of the Government of Spain and all the institutions of Spanish society to combat a scourge we are called on to eradicate, particularly the men in our society. It is not only imperative to eradicate this scourge, but also to reduce the unforgivable and unbearable number of female victims of gender-based violence, and, above all, to also eradicate macho behaviour and culture which, unfortunately, for so many years, for so many centuries in our country, as in many other societies, has perpetuated this violence.
Secondly, I wish to convey, in relation now to the European Council on Article 50, that today is a sad day, and it is very important to stress this. It is a sad day for all those of us who are pro-European. It is a sad day because we have taken the first formal step in the divorce and separation of the United Kingdom from the European Union.
The best possible agreement would have been for there to be no Brexit, but that doesn't depend on Spanish society, nor on the European Union as a whole, but it depends on British society, on the United Kingdom which, unfortunately, expressed its intention to leave the European Union.
But, at any event, I must state, as a convinced pro-European, that I am satisfied that today we have been able to approve, to endorse - which is technically correct - the Withdrawal Agreement of the United Kingdom from the European Union, and approve the Political Declaration that lays the foundations for future relations.
Since our country's accession to the then European Communities in 1986, Spain has always been characterised as a profoundly pro-European country, committed, excited I would even say, by the European project. We have particularly shown this commitment in times in which certain parties have sought to question the benefits of this common project for our citizens and its potential to offer prosperity, progress, economic development and cohesion for our future development.
Our goal has always been for the decision adopted by the United Kingdom to have as little impact as possible on the European project, and on Spanish citizens and companies that have committed to it.
For all these reasons, after a long - a very long - and arduous negotiation phase, I am pleased that the European Council on Article 50 has endorsed the Withdrawal Agreement this morning, and also approved the Political Declaration.
As regards the Withdrawal Agreement, I can say that this agreement ensures the goal of the orderly withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union. And I will now highlight some of the elements of this that are also important, in my opinion, for the EU as a whole, and particularly for the country we represent, Spain.
In terms of the content, we have achieved practically all of the goals we had set at the start of the negotiations: safeguarding the rights of EU citizens in the United Kingdom, and vice versa . This is a key element for Spanish society. There are many parents watching this press briefing, this press conference, who have children living in the United Kingdom who should be aware that this agreement guarantees their rights and liberties in the United Kingdom and vice versa , in other words, that the rights and liberties of those British citizens who are living in our country are also guaranteed.
We have been particularly active, I stress, on this point in the negotiations, for obvious reasons, above all because we have many Spanish citizens living in the United Kingdom and, consequently, those citizens can continue to enjoy their rights until the end of their lives.
We also reached a financial agreement that ensures that the United Kingdom will meet its commitments. And this translates, for our country, into a guarantee of payments to our farmers, to the regions and to other beneficiaries of EU funds under the framework of the current EU Budget. This is another aspect of the negotiations we have paid particularly close attention to.
Thirdly, a sound system of governance, with an important role for the Court of Justice of the European Union, above all, in dealing with the most sensitive issues, such as citizens' rights and the financial arrangement.
The integrity of the internal market has also been respected, something you have also heard us talk about, and finally, another important aspect is to guarantee and strengthen, as far as possible, police and judicial cooperation, above all when addressing organised crime and counter-terrorism.
In addition, the agreement includes a transitional period, scheduled to last until 31 December 2020 which will particularly allow the United Kingdom, but also the remaining 27 EU Member States, to adapt to this new reality. This transitional period may also be extended for a maximum of up to two additional years. In other words, to give you an idea, we have two years until 31 December 2020, but if we all so decide, this may be extended for a further two years.
I also want to stress the particular value of this agreement as regards our economic agents, our companies. The manufacturing sector, fruit and vegetable exporters, which is an important sector for the economy, the agri-food industry in our country, as well as the industrial sector will find a suitable framework in the Withdrawal Agreement to continue their export activity. This is due, not only to the transitional period, but also because the agreement guarantees a sound foundation for the future trade relations that may be defined between the European Union and the United Kingdom.
And this is also positive for our companies that invest in the UK, and of course, for the tourism sector, which is fundamental for the buoyancy of our economy. We should not forget that the United Kingdom is one of the main destinations for Spanish investment and it is the leading emitting market of tourists that come to enjoy our country.
The United Kingdom will leave the internal market, but this agreement contains the necessary elements for the foundations of this economic relationship to be reasonably firm, guaranteeing equal conditions between the United Kingdom and the European Union, and this is something that we must also preserve and pay close attention to in the new period of negotiations that will now commence between the European Union and the United Kingdom.
I now want to convey a message with great clarity: the approval of the two texts, by the European Council of Article 50, does not mean that the agreement has come into force. I believe it is important to let the public know this, because this will only happen when the British Parliament, firstly, and then the European Parliament, ratifies the Withdrawal Agreement. Hence, what we have done is sign the terms of the divorce, which must now be ratified by the British Parliament firstly, and then by the European Parliament. Until then, it will not come into force, I feel it is important to underline this.
No-one doesn't want this to happen, but we must prepare ourselves for all outcomes and, in this regard, I want to say to you that the Government of Spain has been working for some months now, and we are still working, shoulder-to-shoulder with the European Commission on the famous contingency plans for the different sectors affected by an eventual cleavage or a non-agreement on the withdrawal of the United Kingdom. Well, that is as regards be the Withdrawal Agreement.
In terms of the Political Declaration, the text thereof frames, as you are aware, the future relations between the EU and the United Kingdom. At the same time, the text clearly underlines the principles on which these relations will be founded, including respect for the decision-making autonomy of the European Union, the defence of the internal market, and also the defence of the four freedoms that define the European construction project.
The Political Declaration will allow us to continue enjoying intense economic relations between the European Union and the United Kingdom, which is essential and important for Spain, taking into account our trade surplus.
The text also includes the goal of implementing an ambitious agreement on air transport, which is also important for our country, which we consider to be a good starting point in one of the key sectors in the future for Spain.
In terms of fishing, which is also important for quite a number of countries, including ours, we must ensure that the target we have set, which is tying down access to waters and markets, is met. This must be met taking into account that the Fisheries Agreement must be concluded before the end of the transitional period, that is, before 1 December 2020.
On the issue of security and the fight against terrorism and organised crime, the agreement contains the necessary elements to ensure that cooperation with the UK is guaranteed, which I also feel is fundamental, for the security of one and all.
In short, this new era has only just begun; once the ratification process has been completed, negotiations will start next year on future relations between the United Kingdom and the European Union.
On the question of Gibraltar, the Government of Spain supported the Agreements presented after achieving, as I said yesterday, the necessary guarantees on the key role that Spain must play in relations with Gibraltar. I referred yesterday to this triple institutional shield.
Firstly, we have two declarations from the European Union - one from the European Commission and another from the European Council - and from the United Kingdom ruling out the application of Article 184, which was the article disagreed on throughout the week, in terms of the content of future relations, including its territorial scope. And this was an essential point for the Government of Spain, for the Spanish State.
Secondly, we obtained a Political Declaration from the European Council and European Commission strengthening Spain's position going into future negotiations on Gibraltar. This, in my opinion, is an unprecedented text, over the whole course of the dispute over Gibraltar and during our membership of the European Union.
The European Union, for the first time in all these years that we have been an EU Member State, has taken sides and adopted the same political position as the Government of Spain on the dispute over Gibraltar in its relations with the United Kingdom. That seems key and essential to me because it equips Spain with the necessary instruments to go into negotiations on the future of Gibraltar with sufficient guarantees.
The most important aspects of this Third Declaration of the European Council and European Commission on the agreements on future relations are as follows, and I feel it is important to reiterate what I said about them yesterday:
Firstly, this excludes Gibraltar from the general negotiations between the European Union and the United Kingdom, which hadn't been the case until now. It excludes Gibraltar from the general negotiations between the European Union and the United Kingdom
Secondly, it demands the prior agreement of Spain for the negotiation of any European Union agreement that applies to Gibraltar; in other words, the European Union acknowledges Spain's leadership in the definition of any relations that the European Union may conduct with Gibraltar.
Thirdly, it specifically refers - and this is fundamental, because it is something that has not achieved to date - to the obligation to respect the territorial integrity of EU Member States, one of the most important foundations - as you can imagine - of our claim.
Fourthly, and this is very important, we have another declaration from the European Commission. To date, we only had had a declaration from the 27 Member States, in 2017, from the European Council of the 27 remaining States, without the United Kingdom, which formalised Spain's position on the question of Gibraltar. Now we also have a Joint Declaration from the European Council and the European Commission. And this is not insignificant, the Commission negotiates on behalf of the 27, and the Commission is the guarantor of compliance with European Union treaties.
This is also a declaration that only refers to this issue, rather than being a mere point of a document on guidelines on negotiations which is precisely what the European Council's 2017 declaration represented, which may logically be modified by other guidelines (I am referring to what happened in 2017).
In short, this package strengthens, like never before, and I want to underline this, what was established in previous guidelines from the European Council whilst it wards off any risk of interpretation that may be raised by Article 184, let's say, in its text or in its initial drafting.
In conclusion, I believe that this is a reasonable agreement, in the albeit sad transformation of the European Union from a union of 28 members to one of 27. I have said this publicly; I feel that this is a loss for the European Union, but also, and more importantly, for the United Kingdom, which is leaving the European Union. But, at any event, this is a reasonable agreement that guarantees, and this is important, the rights and liberties of our citizens in the United Kingdom. There are many parents that are concerned about the fate of their children who live in the United Kingdom, and this agreement guarantees that they are going to continue enjoying the rights and liberties that have been enjoying during the years they have lived and been residents in the United Kingdom.
Secondly, this offers certainty to our economic sectors, which are many. And this was fundamental for our country, which is one of the countries potentially most affected by Brexit, by our trade relations, by our tourist ties, and also, by our cultural relations.
And thirdly, in relation to Gibraltar, because it places Spain in a position of strength in negotiations with the United Kingdom as regards the future of Gibraltar, a position we had not found ourselves in to date, and I believe that this is a milestone in the European construction project, because we should remember that when Spain joined the European Economic Community in 1986, we took on the agreements that the United Kingdom had previously signed up to and negotiated with the then European Economic Community that we were not a member of at that time.
That is why I believe there is a before and an after, after this European Council at which the negotiation position of Spain with the United Kingdom on the question of Gibraltar has been redefined.
Hence, we can only be satisfied with this, and I wish to close, because I have them before me - we are at the Council headquarters - by thanking the whole team of diplomats, of State lawyers, the Ambassador to the EU, the State Secretary for the European Union, and all those people working under the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Pepe Borrell, who have been working day and night to ensure that we reached an agreement that is very satisfactory for our interests as a nation and also, I believe, very satisfactory for the European Union as a whole, on a day, I repeat, that is sad, because a great country like the United Kingdom is leaving us.
I will now take any questions.
Q .- Taking into account the agreement reached, and once both the United Kingdom and Gibraltar leave the EU, do you feel the time will have come to bring up the debate on co-sovereignty? And if this is the case, how do you propose to do this, taking into account that the people of Gibraltar don't seem to be in favour of this? Thank you.
President of the Government.- Well, I believe we shouldn't get ahead of things. In other words, I believe that the goal of the Government of Spain in this phase was to achieve all the guarantees, all the instruments to be able to address future negotiations, which will be the most complicated part. If this was difficult, then imagine how much more difficult the part to come will be. And hence, I firmly believe that, not only for Spain, but for the European Union as a whole, and for each one of the Member States that make up the European Union.
So, in relation to Gibraltar, I repeat, we are in a position of strength that we were in before. The European Union acknowledges the position that Spain has always held on Gibraltar and, above all, this is acknowledged by the United Kingdom, in a letter that precisely states the correct vision of the European Council and of the Commission on this Article 184 of the Withdrawal Agreement.
Aside from that, this is not an emotional question, although that would be sufficient in itself, regarding Gibraltar, about national identity, that we obviously want to resolve. Spain has spent many years appealing to the United Nations that the issue of a colony like Gibraltar should be resolved pursuant to international law. And this is also a question of prosperity in Campo de Gibraltar.
The Government of Spain, just three weeks ago, approved a plan for the development and economic stimulus of a very deprived zone of our country, as is Campo de Gibraltar, with a provision of 1 billion euros. Together with this, what we want to resolve is the question of Gibraltar so that economic development is fair throughout Campo de Gibraltar. It must not only be concentrated in the Rock of Gibraltar as a result of its singular features at the cost of the rest of Campo de Gibraltar remaining underdeveloped.
Hence, we are going to have to talk with the United Kingdom about many things, but at least it will be us - Spain - talking. And that has been acknowledged by both the European Council and the European Commission, it has been acknowledged by the United Kingdom and I feel that this is what gives us sufficient guarantees for us to have agreed or, better said, ratified, today the Withdrawal Agreement, and also the Political Declaration on the future.
Q.- Thank you, President of the Government, Pablo Suanzes, from "El Mundo". You have said, in reference to these declarations, that this is a great and unprecedented step forward; you have even said that this goes further than the guidelines approved last year. However, this text, this declaration, as you say, is political, and does not form part of the Withdrawal Agreement; it does not form part of the Political Declaration; it doesn't even form part of the Conclusions from the European Council, which the guidelines were contained in last year. This is an annex to the Minutes of the Council; the political value, even the legal value of this Declaration is not as binding as it could have been. There is a political message, that is clear, but at a lower level. And there are some delegations that point to this as only being a political issue in reality. There is a political change but, in the event that there are disputes with the United Kingdom in the future, what guarantees are there that Spain will not have problems?
President of the Government.- Every guarantee. We have the whole legal foundation. Let me ask this another way. In 2017, when the government of Mariano Rajoy pushed through a Council Declaration on the guidelines regarding the negotiations, does that only have political but not legal validity? Look, in the end, we have been operating, as regards Gibraltar, with what was agreed in 2017, but we have now added something more. We have added what we have called the triple shield.
Firstly, because what is being done in the Withdrawal Agreement is to clarify and set out the legal interpretation of what Article 184 represents, and that has not only been done by the European Council, but also by the European Commission, which is the negotiating party and the party which, moreover, guarantees compliance with EU Treaties. And furthermore, it does this under the approach adopted by Spain, I don't mean the Government of Spain but the Spanish State as regards the dispute over Gibraltar. Hence, I don't feel there is cause for debate on this. The debate is that there is a clarification, an establishment of, let's say, the legal and political meaning of this oft-mentioned Article 184. That's the truth.
In relation to the withdrawal of the United Kingdom, we all lose out, above all the United Kingdom. But as regards Gibraltar, Spain wins, and Europe wins.
Q.- Yes, President of the Government, Jaume Masdeu from "La Vanguardia", I wanted to look at one of the critical moments of these negotiations, when the controversial Article 184 was introduced, by surprise, with malice aforethought and under the cover of darkness, according to your State secretary. I wanted to know whether you interpret this as a miscalculation by the Barnier team, or whether you felt betrayed at that time.
President of the Government.- I believe that the Government of Spain, at least, in this five-month experience we have had, and I can assure you that this is something shared by the European Council, has been acknowledged to have taken constructive positions, for having been a pro-dialogue government, for having been a government that proposes solutions, and that does not create unnecessary problems. Hence, that is the premise.
Secondly, I even said that this was a reasonable agreement. But, as usual in this type of highly complex document, with so many different approaches, which deals with so many different causes and so many economic and trading interests, and so many rights and liberties and even questions of identity, not only in relation to Gibraltar, but also to Ireland and even Cyprus. And you have to acknowledge that the devil is in the detail. And when the State lawyers realised, after a thorough and detailed analysis of the doubts generated by Article 184 and its connection to Article 3 of the Agreement, then we obviously got to work, particularly the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
And then, clearly, as [Jean-Claude] Juncker tweeted yesterday, we resorted to "Solidarity, determination and dialogue, that is how the European Union was built". Spain has shown solidarity throughout this process, supporting, for example, Ireland, supporting the demands made by Cyprus and also supporting sector demands from other countries. Determination, because at the same time as we say the risks to Spain's position on such a sensitive issue as Gibraltar, we said that this must be revised and redefined and a clear political and legal position needs to be adopted by the European Commission and the Council which is backed by the United Kingdom. And that is what we achieved. And then, dialogue. When you are in negotiations then this dialogue must be decisive and firm and then, when you reach an agreement, you must acknowledge the good work done by the negotiating team of the European Commission.
But, I insist, this is a process. And you have to look at this when you reach the end. I believe that all's well that ends well.
Q.- Jacobo de Regoyos, from "Onda Cero". I would like to come back and look at the issue of sovereignty. You answered my colleague from "El País" by saying that we should not get ahead of things, but I heard you mention co-sovereignty yesterday and you then got ahead of things. Coming back to the statements you made yesterday, when are you going to talk about co-sovereignty, since you yourself brought this up? Thank you.
President of the Government.- Yes, we are going to talk about that. That is why I said yesterday in my press briefing that the most complex and difficult times are about to begin. But, I repeat, this not only affects the issue of Gibraltar, although that is undoubtedly important, it also affects many other issues on which we will have to see what relations will be like between the United Kingdom and the European Union. And hence, I repeat, it is good that we focus on Gibraltar, which is something interesting for the media, and that we have been decisive and firm - just look at the outcome - but these are also many other issues.
There are 300,000 Spaniards living in the United Kingdom and more than 200,000 British citizens living in Spain. There are multiple interests: air transport, the industrial sector, fisheries, where Spain has been firm and defended the position of these sectors. And it has done this with solidarity, determination and dialogue. That is what is most important.
Of course we are going to talk about everything. Why do you think it was so important for us to be so well-equipped? And right now, Spain has a great many more guarantees. We are in a position of strength, such as we have never been in before during our entire membership of the European Union, in terms of negotiating the question of Gibraltar with the United Kingdom. Among other things, we should be grateful for this latest boost, thanks to the negotiating capabilities of the team of diplomats, State lawyers, the political team from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and also to the generosity of the European Commission and Council who appreciated and empathised with our cause, fully taking on Spain's political discourse and focus on the question of Gibraltar.
I place great emphasis on the matter of the diplomatic service and the State lawyers, because the Government of Spain has always taken the question of Gibraltar on-board with a great sense of State.
We came to power in June, and we had to sprint the last few metres of a race that had been going on for some time. We did this with the same negotiating team. We did this with the same rules, within the same framework and with the same goals. So much so, and I feel that this is very important, which is why I want to underline it, that we have reached an agreement with the United Kingdom on Gibraltar, with a protocol and four memoranda that guarantee the rights to free movement, tax relations, issues affecting tobacco, etc., which have all been resolved by this government acting with a sense of State.
That is, we have done no more than pick up the baton from the previous administration and finish the race. And I believe that this is also good for all those people living in Campo de Gibraltar who work in the Rock of Gibraltar. Hence, these protocols and memoranda will be diligently upheld and will remain valid throughout the transition period, this two-year period, and we now need to talk with the United Kingdom about all these issues. That is why we wanted to be well backed in the knowledge that the instruments and the recognition of the European Union was going to be full, and this is the case of both the European Commission and Council.
Q.- So, President of the Government, Spain is now in a stronger position. How exactly are you going to best use this? So that we can explain this is a little better to the public, how can this best be used? In other words, will this be used to unblock certain agreements or to guarantee certain demands in relation to Gibraltar? I don't know if you can be more specific, not only about co-sovereignty, but perhaps also about the status that Gibraltar will henceforth enjoy. And just by way of clarification, how far away is the signing of a future declaration where we can see the future relations that Spain will have with the United Kingdom, in these documents that will be signed in the future? Would you like to see Spain included in a legal text, at least on a more legal basis than the political declaration signed today? Will Spain try and fight to ensure that this reference to Gibraltar is contained in EU Treaties? Thank you.
President of the Government.- Well, let's look at one thing because I feel that this should at least go down on record. We are not the only country that has raised objections to the Withdrawal Agreement, but we are the only country that has managed to obtain a declaration from the European Council and the European Commission backed by the United Kingdom. The others have had to be content with a single declaration from the European Council. Hence, we are talking about a very important political achievement by the State that places us in a very significant position of strength on a key issue, not only for the economic and balanced development of Campo de Gibraltar, but also for the country as a whole. That is the first point; the second point, I repeat, is that we are going to talk about everything. And the third point is that we are going to start moving forward along the path. Let's not reveal everything that we are going to do.
Of course, the Government of Spain's approach is to resolve, once and for all, a conflict that has been going on for more than 300 years. That is our aim.
Q.- Yes, thank you and good afternoon. I wanted to know if you have had the chance to speak today of the Withdrawal Agreement with the British Prime Minister, And secondly, I wanted your opinion on the evaluations made yesterday by the leader of the People's Party in relation to this agreement, when he spoke of a failure considering that it has no legal value, and saying that an opportunity has been lost to precisely make progress on the co-sovereignty of Gibraltar. Thank you.
President of the Government.- Well, as regards your first question, yes, of course I have spoken with Ms May and I told her three things that I feel are very important. The first was my wish for the British Parliament to ratify this agreement by a majority, because I feel that it is the best agreement we can reach. There is no other. This is The Agreement.
Secondly, I expressed to her the wish of the Government of Spain and also, I believe, of the Spanish people, who hold the British people dear, to have the best possible diplomatic, economic, social and cultural relations.
And thirdly, I told her that it is also our intention to overcome our differences and reach agreements with them. We not only seek to enhance our economic and trading ties, but it is also our noble, true and genuine intention to reach an agreement that resolves this conflict.
As regards your second question, the only thing I can recommend is to read the British press and draw your own conclusions from that.
Thank you.
Non official translation