Responses from the President of the Government in the plenary session of the Senate during the parliamentary control session.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

20 November 2018 · Plenary session of the Senate during the parliamentary control session · Senate, Spain

Context
Sánchez responded to opposition questions during a Senate plenary control session on November 20, 2018, defending his government's record on Catalonia and democratic reform.
Main themes
Catalan independence crisis, democratic reform, political change under Sánchez, bilateral dialogue with Catalonia, judicial proceedings against Catalan leaders, arms sales to Saudi Arabia, constitutional court appeals, infrastructure investment, General Council of the Judiciary renewal, PSOE vs PP governance
Duration
~53 min
95th percentile
Words
6,363
95th percentile
Sentences
269
94th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
3.18
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 75%72%
  • Geopolitical 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

269 sentences in 92 paragraphs

Mr. Sánchez, from the Democratic Party, we did not participate a little over five months ago in the change of government to promote merely a change of vocabulary, a change of facade, a change of forms, but above all, to urge a profound change of democratic strengthening, of strengthening of rights and freedoms that have precisely suffered a serious setback in these years of government of the Popular Party.

But Mr. Sánchez, where is the change you announced? Look, the Popular Party and the PSOE prevented in Congress the investigation of the attacks of August 17. Just like the investigation into the finances of the Royal House. The PSOE has maintained the sale of arms to Saudi Arabia, has not promoted any investigation into the violence of October 1, Enric Millo has been decorated, Soraya Sáenz de Santamaría is part of the Council of State, the Court of Auditors condemns President Mas and his councilors to pay 4.9 million euros, a true revenge. Or the fiasco in the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary. What changes have taken place, Mr. Sánchez?

You committed to finding a political solution to the challenges of Catalan society, through dialogue, not through judicialization, but nothing has changed and today your government is complicit in the more than 200 years of prison that the Prosecutor's Office is requesting for the political prisoners: peaceful and honorable people. Neither Belgium, nor Germany, nor Scotland, nor Switzerland, nor recognized jurists see the crimes that your prosecutor's office accuses them of, but they don't care because the accusations of rebellion, embezzlement, and sedition had already been anticipated a year ago, and this farce has been constructed to justify them.

Your gestures, Mr. Sánchez, are very similar to those of Mr. Rajoy when it comes to Catalonia. And what is your surprise recipe? To go back 15 years, promising a reform of the Statute, which no one has asked for, like Zapatero's, with his "I will support," while Guerra brushed it to his liking. They will not deceive us again. This is outdated. Is this your change?

In these 15 years, since Zapatero's "I will support," the Spanish nationalism that you represent with the PP and Ciudadanos has continued, yes, supported by Catalonia, generating a fiscal deficit of more than 16 billion euros, the Constitutional Court's ruling against the Statute, not executing the planned investments, announcing rains of millions that have never arrived. Today, with sad news, we want to express our solidarity with the accident that occurred in Catalonia involving Renfe. The non-investments of Renfe in Catalonia.

Mr. Sánchez, two ministers have resigned, you have failed in the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary. You are unable to propose anything to the Catalans, nor do you have a majority to do so. And you will not be able to approve the State Budgets. You came to the presidency to do exactly what? Where is your change, Mr. Sánchez?

President.- Thank you, Mr. President, thank you, Your Honor.

I had planned to tell you where you have been since June 2, but after hearing the string of reproaches typical of independence movements in recent years, the statement I would like to make to begin my response to your question is that you lived better with Mariano Rajoy as President of the Government, this is undeniable; it is undeniable.

Look, I believe we must be serious, Your Honor, regarding the crisis in Catalonia. Since we arrived in government, Your Honor, the celebration of bilateral commissions between the Government of the Generalitat of Catalonia and the Government of Spain, which had not met for seven years, has been unblocked; for almost six months of the legislature we have had after the motion of censure, there have been meetings in the sectoral bilateral commissions, for example, those linked to infrastructure, precisely to address, for example, commuter trains.

We have also talked about security, for example, to address the evident risks of terrorism, not only in our country but also in other parts of the European continent. We have also talked about the economy, and there have also been smaller-scale bilateral meetings, not as politically significant, but I believe they are crucial from the perspective of the day-to-day lives of people, such as education, science, etc.

Secondly, Your Honor, look, this government has maintained the commitment from the beginning of its mandate to reduce the level of conflict with the Constitutional Court in relation to the Generalitat of Catalonia. There have been three withdrawals, which I would like to emphasize:

The first, regarding the breach of the universality of public healthcare that occurred under the mandate of the Popular Party. You appealed to the Constitutional Court, we have recovered the universality of public healthcare, and consequently, the appeal for unconstitutionality presented by the previous administration has been withdrawn.

Secondly, we have also withdrawn an appeal before the Constitutional Court from the previous administration related to evictions, and also another regarding energy poverty. Therefore, one, we have recovered the bilateral commissions, that is, we have restored normality in institutional dialogue between both governments. Two. We are reducing the level of conflict regarding appeals for unconstitutionality before the Constitutional Court. And thirdly, we have agreed on almost 1.46 billion euros to be invested over the next four years in Catalonia to fully comply with the Additional Provision Three of the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia.

What has this led to, Your Honors? If one looks at the demographic studies that have occurred in recent months and takes the survey, for example, from the newspaper "El Periódico": 56 percent of Catalans, Your Honors, express that the proposal made by the Government of Spain to strengthen the self-government of Catalonia has 56 percent support and, therefore, they say yes to that proposal.

The survey conducted by GAD3 for the newspaper "La Vanguardia" reaches 70 percent of respondents. You may tell me, well, let's add a 4 or 5 percent margin of error. Well, not 70 percent, 60 percent. What I want to tell you with this, Your Honor, is that if we consider what is the proposal that brings together more and divides less in Catalan society, certainly, in the opinion of the Government, it is not the right to self-determination that you proclaim and defend but the strengthening of Catalan self-government, which is what the Government of Spain is focused on.

Mr. Cleries.- Thank you, Mr. President.

Mr. Sánchez, you talk about normality, this is what should exist between institutions. But look, if you want to reach 80 percent of the population, propose a referendum and it will succeed. This is the secret, to succeed with a referendum. And, look, these days, do you know what has happened? It has become very clear the lack of independence of the Judiciary.

Your vice president, Mrs. Calvo, told me here, in the Senate, that my colleagues are in preventive detention because they have committed crimes. Without trial, she has already sentenced them; surprising judicial independence.

The PP and the PSOE recently announced that Mr. Marchena would be the new president of the General Council of the Judiciary. They wanted to reward the author of the rulings against the political prisoners. Article 123 of the Constitution states that it will be proposed by the General Council of the Judiciary, by the members. Does the PSOE and PP Executive form part of the Council? Because this is surprising. I see that when it suits them, they disregard the Constitution. The Popular Party and the PSOE have attempted a judicial 155. Mr. Cosidó, whose previous boss and minister was already dedicated to 'fine-tuning' the Prosecutor's Office, and with him formed a well-known tandem in the sewers of the State, made it clear to his senators: we have made a great move; we will control the Second Chamber of the Supreme Court from behind, where those charged from October 1 will be judged; also Chamber 61 and hundreds of renewals and appointments. They want to control what suits them, but Mr. Sánchez, let it be clear, with your complicity and that of the PSOE. This is Spanish democracy, without independence of the Judiciary. All this smells very rotten. All this makes us once again confirm that those charged from October 1 will not have a fair and impartial trial. Everything that has happened further discredits Spanish justice, demonstrating the lack of independence and impartiality.

This renewal, which was intended and is intended, is clearly politicized, but above all that has happened, we demand the resignation of Mr. Cosidó, but let it be clear, Mr. Sánchez, your government and your party are accomplices and protagonists of this shameful situation, the sad reality of Spanish justice. Today, citizens distrust Spanish justice even more. What must be done is to dialogue with the Government of the Generalitat for what we discussed earlier, agreeing on a self-determination referendum as recognized by the international treaties signed by Spain.

The other day you proposed one, a second, to the United Kingdom for Brexit. If it is good for the United Kingdom, why is it not for Catalonia? Mr. Sánchez, it is democracy, simply.

I sincerely hope that on December 21 your meeting with President Torra, and especially, the summit between the Spanish government and the Catalan government, a long-awaited summit, will signify a turning point that makes effective the change announced in your investiture and that does not disappoint us any further.

Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you, Mr. President. Your Honor, I truly believe that arguments can be stretched a lot, but one cannot criticize the government. To say that politics must be judicialized when you say, for example, that you do not want to sit with the Government of Spain to talk about the Budgets until there is a change of direction in the Prosecutor's Office or the State Attorney's Office, and on the other hand, to say that justice is politicized. Either one thing or the other. Your Honor, what you cannot do is hold both arguments.

Look, Your Honor, the government does politics. It does not issue sentences, neither condemnatory nor acquitting, it is that simple. Regarding the political proposal you make to me, look, and I find it even appropriate that you have referred to the Brexit referendum because we will indeed have an important summit, an important European Council, next Sunday in Brussels.

Let's see, I believe, Your Honors, that if we have to draw a lesson from what has happened in Scotland, from what happened in the United Kingdom regarding the referendum, it is that they are absolutely divisive referendums, that fracture society, and do not unite it.

Precisely, those who lost the referendum in Scotland are requesting a second referendum. Those who lost the referendum in the United Kingdom are requesting a second referendum. Why? Because they do not feel identified with the result of that first referendum.

What you are trying with your proposal, apart from being unconstitutional, apart from being illegal, --of course, it is not recognized in international law what you are saying for the case of Catalonia and Spain--, but that does not matter to them.

Let's go to the political. The political, Your Honor. The political is that what you are proposing is to fracture Catalan society in two. Look, since 2014 how many unrecognized referendums have you held that the Spanish state has not recognized? Two. How many electoral processes have been held in Catalonia? At least four. In those two, and in those four, 42-43 percent of Catalan society is voting for pro-independence formulations and the rest is not.

Therefore, accept reality. You are not a majority in Catalonia to defend the right to self-determination. You do not even have the two-thirds required in the Parliament of Catalonia to reform the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia and you expect the Government of Spain to assume as its own something that is unconstitutional, absolutely divisive and that, moreover, is not a majority in Spanish society as a whole.

I believe, Your Honor, that what is important is that you be brave, that you take a step forward, that you tell the Catalan society that supported you, that believed in you, that independence is not possible, that you do not have the majority, and that you will sit down with the rest of Catalan society, which is not nationalist, with the Government of Spain as well, to find a formulation that brings together and does not divide Catalan society. And that is called self-government and that is called the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Cosidó, spokesperson for the Popular Parliamentary Group

Mr. Cosidó.- I want my first words to convey my condolences to the victims, families, and friends of the person who died and the injured in the derailment of a Renfe train in the province of Barcelona. And I also want to extend my condolences to my colleagues from Podemos for the four young people who died in a traffic accident in Jaén yesterday.

Mr. President, your separatist partners have repeatedly conditioned their parliamentary support, the parliamentary support for your Government, on the release of prisoners for an alleged crime of rebellion in Catalonia. Mr. Tardá, who is the spokesperson for Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya, is asking you to urge the Attorney General of the State to withdraw the charge of rebellion as a prerequisite for supporting your Budgets.

The Vice President of the Generalitat of Catalonia says that they will not be able to talk about State Budgets if the Spanish Government does not move on the right to self-determination, nor on the issue of the prisoners and the charges set by the Supreme Court. The spokesperson for PDdeCAT in the Congress of Deputies, Mr. Campuzano, has insisted that if there are no changes regarding the Catalan independentist prisoners, it will be difficult for his party to support the Budget Law project.

And in the face of these demands, the first thing you have done, Mr. President, is change your criteria. In the opposition, --we have all seen it--, you saw a clear crime of rebellion in the 'coup plotters' who committed the crime in Catalonia.

Now that you are the President of the Government, you no longer see a crime. You no longer see anything. It is true that the Vice President of the Government has tried to convince us that you were born on the day of your investiture as President, but the truth is that you have a past that you also have to answer for.

Your Minister of Justice, who is sitting to your right, also forced the criteria of the State Attorney's Office. Yes, Mr. President, I am very proud of my past.

But look, President, you have not only changed your criteria on the issue of the crime of rebellion. You have also changed your criteria regarding pardons. In the opposition, you presented a Bill in the Congress of Deputies to try to limit this right. Now, as those limitations would affect the prisoners for this crime, you are trying to delay that modification as much as you can.

Many voices in your party and in the Government have also asked you to grant the pardon; the Secretary General of the Socialist Party of Catalonia, Mr. Iceta, has expressly asked you to pardon the prisoners before they are convicted.

The Minister of Territorial Policy and Public Administrations, Ms. Batet, has hinted that "to normalize Catalonia, it would be better if there were no prisoners." Or the Government delegate in Catalonia has also expressly asked for pardons for the prisoners.

Mr. President, in light of so much back and forth, I believe that the Spanish people have the right to know what your criteria is, and that is why I ask you if you commit to not granting pardons to those prosecuted for serious crimes against the unity of Spain, in the event of being convicted.

Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you, Mr. President.

Mr. Cosidó, let’s see, just to make one thing clear, when you talk about partners, after having listened to the representatives of the PDdeCAT Parliamentary Group in the Senate, it seems evident that partners, partners… I say this because, look, the motion of censure, for you to get an idea, for it to prosper or be rejected, the votes in favor or against from the independentist parliamentary groups were necessary. Well. We agree on that, good.

If they had voted against the motion of censure, would those votes be legitimate because they would have validated Mr. Rajoy's permanence at the head of the Government of Spain? Of course, if they support an illegitimate change of Government, if they support Mr. Rajoy's permanence at the head of the legitimate Government, well, it’s the law of the funnel. It is, in the end, always the same strategy of the Popular Party when they are in opposition. I will tell you one thing, Mr. Cosidó, look, what pardons are you talking about, if there are no sentences? You talk about pardons based on sentences from trials that have not yet been held. Therefore, it is true that it will sound strange for me to say this to you today, precisely after what we read yesterday, but respect the justice.

You have spent seven years judicializing a political crisis like the Catalan one, and now what you intend is to set yourselves up as judges of the case. Therefore, respect the independence of the Judiciary, Mr. Cosidó. Let the judges work, and then, ladies and gentlemen, logically, from the Government of Spain, and also from the representatives of the different parliamentary groups, we will have to do politics. That is what corresponds to us.

Mr. Cosidó.- Yes, thank you very much, Mr. President.

Look, you are the President of the Government thanks to those votes, therefore they are your partners because they voted for you, and because today they continue to support you in Government. And that respect for a decision that has not yet been made by the Supreme Court, well, look, tell it to Ms. Cunillera. Tell it to Mr. Iceta, tell it to Minister Batet. Or tell it to yourself before being President of the Government, but don’t tell it to me.

Look, you are not really answering. And I believe you are not answering because you want to hide from the Spanish people that within the political pact that made you President, the release of these prisoners was included. Via the State Attorney's Office, as we have seen, via the Prosecutor's Office, or via pardon, as a last resort.

What I want is for you to be aware, Mr. Sánchez, that if as President of the Government of Spain you grant pardons to those who acted against our country, those pardons have a name, they will be the pardons of shame. If you yield, know that you are giving the coup plotters just the wrong message. The message of weakness, the message that it is free to violate the law, the message that you are inciting them to give a new coup d'état. If you grant those pardons, Mr. President, you will be yielding to blackmail, demonstrating that you, in order to remain in La Moncloa, are capable of doing or paying any price, a pardon, a referendum, or whatever it may be.

And if you, Mr. President, grant those pardons, and I sincerely hope you do not, you will be betraying a majority of Catalans who feel Spanish, who are being harassed daily by separatism, as happened with the President of the Popular Party in Catalonia, Mr. Alejandro Fernández, who had people enter his home, who painted a swastika on his car, and who feel absolutely helpless due to the lack of authority of this Government. And, look, I tell you sincerely, that is something that the Spanish people would not forgive you.

Look, in the motion of censure, the one that your separatist partners voted for, you committed to call elections immediately. Once you were in La Moncloa, you entrenched yourself and announced that your intention was to exhaust the legislature.

Now some of your ministers have talked about an early election for May. What I want to tell you, Mr. President, on behalf of the popular group, is that there are prices that cannot be paid. The pardon to the coup plotters is one of those prices. So I ask you to call elections and the sooner, the better, Mr. President.

President.- Thank you, Mr. President.

Let me see if I get it, Mr. Cosidó, so then I was supported because I agreed to the pardons to be able to be President of the Government, but, on the other hand, the separatists do not support the Budgets because I do not yield to the Prosecutor's Office changing its opinion and, therefore, what you are asking me is to call elections.

What I tell you is, well, that you clarify yourselves, that you clarify yourselves, that, really, that you make a calm reflection, on what is happening with the Popular Party, on the decomposition that the Popular Party is currently in, on the lack of a sense of State, on the lack of a sense of government, ladies and gentlemen. And that you are, moreover, a little humble, because we have been seven years, seven years, supporting the Government of Mariano Rajoy, precisely, in the face of the Catalan challenge, for you to come here now to tell us that, well, that we have sold ourselves to the Catalan separatists. A little humility, Mr. Cosidó, humility. Learn from mistakes. Learn from mistakes, Mr. Cosidó.

Look, there is one thing that I cannot buy from you. There are many differences between you and me, but there is one, there is one that I would like to underline. I believe in the independence of the Judiciary and I do not tolerate interference in the functioning of the Judiciary, Mr. Cosidó. Yes, sir, yes, sir.

Look, the more it is necessary to strengthen the institutions in this country, the more you contribute to weakening them. The election of the General Council of the Judiciary, Mr. Cosidó, is something that pertains to the Legislative Power, to the Legislative Power. We can, ladies and gentlemen from the different parliamentary groups, change the methodology, we are open to it. But right now, as of today, the way to renew the governing body of the General Council of the Judiciary is through the Legislative Power, through the Congress of Deputies and the Senate, ladies and gentlemen. Therefore, that is what we have to do.

And you, Mr. Cosidó, said serious things yesterday about the agreement that we had reached between the Socialist Party and the Popular Party. You have seriously offended the honorability of an impeccable judge, like Judge Marchena, when you wrote to 120 senators assuming that the Supreme Court can be politically controlled by the Popular Party because you will control the Second Chamber from behind. You have damaged the general credibility of justice by subordinating it, Mr. Cosidó, and, consequently, the popular parliamentary group, to the interests of your party, when you state, and I quote, "we were playing for the future renewals of two-thirds of the Supreme Court and hundreds of vital appointments in the Judiciary for the Popular Party, and for the future of Spain," end quote.

You have distorted the pact by interpreting some appointments as beneficial for the corruption of the Popular Party, saying verbatim, Mr. Cosidó, "removing De Prada from the National Court is good, better as a member than issuing sentences against the Popular Party," end quote. This is what the spokesperson for the Popular Parliamentary Group in the Senate has written to 120 senators.

Look, the scandal, ladies and gentlemen, is not that it is the Legislative Power, neither the Congress nor the Senate, who choose the members of the plenary of the General Council of the Judiciary. The scandal is the patrimonialist sense that the Popular Party has of justice. We reached an agreement that I ask you to respect. You are a party of your word, you must respect the agreements, because fundamentally what we have to do is renew a fundamental governing body, such as the General Council of the Judiciary.

Have institutional sense, have a sense of State. Oppose the Government, but not at the cost of deteriorating the public institutions of this country, Mr. Cosidó. And look, ladies and gentlemen of the Popular Parliamentary Group, I tell you one thing very clearly: today someone has resigned, but it has not been precisely who the Spanish people expect to resign, which is you, Mr. Cosidó.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Jon Iñarritu, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Iñarritu.- Yes, good afternoon, Mr. President, good afternoon Mr. President of the Government.

Yesterday we learned about that famous whatsapp from Mr. Cosidó, in which he indicated that after the agreement that you had reached, the Socialist Party and they, the Popular Party, they would control -as you have well indicated-, the Second Chamber of the Supreme Court, and likewise, Chamber 61 of that same Court. Something that is very serious, that we found out through the press, and that breaks that theory of the independence of justice, which many of us studied here today, in college.

But it is not only that. A week ago we learned the name of who was going to be the president of the General Council of the Judiciary before that of the 20 independent members who were to elect him. And that also breaks the separation of Powers that Montesquieu, or John Locke, spoke to us about. It is that in Spain the judicial independence, the independence of justice, the separation of Powers is a tale. And today, another chapter has occurred: the one who was going to be the president has resigned before being proposed and before being elected. And the gentlemen of the Popular Party, they have gotten angry and it seems they want to break that pact. To me, Mr. Sánchez, the whatsapp from the illustrious one seems serious, but what seems much more serious to me is that what is said in that whatsapp is true. It is that you and they share the control of the judicial leadership of this country. That is how it is, and that is the shame. They share the control of justice. That is why I wanted to ask you what assessment do you make of judicial independence and the separation of Powers in the State? Thank you very much.

President.- Yes, thank you, Mr. President.

Ladies and gentlemen, hold me responsible for everything, but for me to be held responsible for the whatsapp of the Popular Parliamentary Group and the messages from Mr. Cosidó seems too much.

Look, I believe that precisely the resignation of Judge Marchena, with whom I had the opportunity to speak this morning, --I was unaware that he had resigned last night from being able to run for the Presidency of the General Council of the Judiciary and the Supreme Court--, I believe that precisely his resignation demonstrates the independence of criteria, the independence of the Judiciary and, above all, of magistrates like Mr. Marchena. I believe it is just the opposite.

But regarding your question, I will tell you that the assessment made by the Government of Spain and the one I make about the independence of the Judiciary is very positive, it is excellent. I will tell you the following, Mr. Iñarritu: look, in Spain and around, I will be corrected by the judges in retirement, who are members of the Government, there are around 5,500 judges in our country. Each year, I believe that around three million judgments are issued in our country, and these are judgments that during these last ten years of economic crisis have been very positive, especially for those who were suffering the most. The Judiciary has issued very important rulings regarding evictions, regarding floor clauses. In Social matters, for example, they have issued very important rulings against the labor reform approved by the Popular Party; they have issued rulings, for example, that made it possible for a new Government to be formed in Spain as a result of a motion of censure, the Gürtel ruling.

In short, corruption, evictions, the defense of labor rights. I believe that they demonstrate that the work of judges in our country is worthy of praise. And, probably, the only caveat that I can attribute to myself as president of the Government and also to my own Government is that we need to invest many more material and economic resources in the Judiciary so that they can carry out their duties within the Judiciary with greater guarantees, greater independence, and greater effectiveness.

Mr. Iñarritu.- Thank you very much, Mr. President.

First of all, I wanted to reflect that this format of response, turning your back, reminds me of the Tridentine Masses, those pre-Vatican II ones. I would ask that the format be changed, at least to be able to see you when you respond to me.

I continue with the issue. Regarding Mr. Cosidó's WhatsApp, what he said is that he did not hold you responsible, if the serious thing is not the WhatsApp. The most serious thing is that what Mr. Cosidó says is true, that they and you share power, the control of the judicial leadership. And speaking of WhatsApp, four years ago you wrote on a social network a message that said that your commitment was to regenerate democratic life and for that it was necessary to create a truly independent General Council of the Judiciary, independent of the Government.

What has changed, Mr. Sánchez? What has changed for you to change your criteria? It is that this very year, in the so-called Greco, from the Council of Europe, we saw how in that unsatisfactory report, because the Kingdom of Spain did not comply with most of the recommendations made by the Council of Europe, there was one of those recommendations that was to eliminate the participation of the General Courts in the election of the members, of the members of the Judiciary. Are you going to heed this recommendation that I believe you shared four years ago?

And it is true that the majority of the leadership, let’s say, or of the judicial elites are contaminated. There is a continuous political contamination. Not only, recently we have seen that scandal that occurred with the ruling on mortgage taxes, we see how there is also a contamination from those factual or economic powers.

But returning to the political, it is especially in everything that has to do with what Machiavelli called "L' Arte dello Stato," that has occurred as "the reason of State." In everything that has to do with Euskalerría, with the Basque Country, with Catalonia, we see how there is always a double fixation, and how those barriers of judicial independence are erased very easily.

And I could talk here about that exceptional court of the National Court where we have seen that thousands and thousands of Basques were judged under the excuse of everything is ETA, people, many of whom had nothing to do with violence: journalists, members of associations, political representatives, and we saw how the reports of torture were not seen in those courts, on many occasions, by judges decorated at the same time by the State Security Forces and Corps. And this lack of independence and exceptionality is corroborated by several rulings of the European Court of Human Rights, which you said last week, "of course, there are not many." Of course, they go to the essential, when they have to do with Euskalerría.

The condemnation of Spain because Mr. Otegui and his companions from Bateragune did not have a fair trial is not unique; last year we saw another one about the 'Atutxa case,' but there are also several about the failure to investigate torture. And we have also seen, regarding freedom of expression, and what do you say about all this? Because now, when fortunately violence has disappeared, people are being judged for public disorder, for bar fights, in this exceptional court, which if they were from another place would not be judged there.

We see how members of the CDR, tweeters, rappers are taken to this exceptional court, but the same medicine is being applied by these politically contaminated exceptional courts against the Catalan case. We see how at this moment all members of a legitimate, peaceful, and democratic government are in prison or in exile. And, at the same time, Spanish justice when it looks in the mirror, because we see that there are four other European justices, as Mr. Cleries mentioned earlier, have entered the matter and none see what that Supreme Court sees.

Do you think that that Second Chamber, presided over by their candidate, from the Popular Party, is going to act with a criterion of impartiality, - excuse me, - of neutrality? And what I say is so obvious that if you do not believe me, I encourage you to take a look at the state press today, or to go to the reports of the Council of Europe, of the European Commission, talking about the perception of justice in Spain, placing the independence of the judiciary of this State at the tail of the European Union. Or the report from 'The Economist' that I mentioned last week, and today I was in a forum, I was surprised that it was mentioned because curiously that report did not speak well of Spain. It said that Spain runs the risk of becoming an imperfect democracy due to the Catalan issue, and I conclude, Mr. President, due to the issue of October 1, due to 155, by the way, against the vast majority of Catalan society. Or because they have political prisoners, which makes it a country closer to Turkey than to another country. And to finish, Mr. President, you know that if one day, God forbid, you are judged, you will be judged by the Second Chamber of the Supreme Court to be privileged, the chamber they control. That is why I wish you luck, a lot of luck.

President.- I thank you for the luck.

In any case, I will also tell you that this Government has proposed a constitutional reform to limit the privileges concerning public office holders. I hope that the different parliamentary groups present here, and, in particular, the Popular Parliamentary Group, along with the Ciudadanos parliamentary group and Unidos Podemos support that constitutional reform.

Look, in relation to the legitimacy, with the way of electing the magistrates, the jurists who can make up the General Council of the Judiciary, I defend, and I have always done so, from the very first moment, publicly, and also in the meetings I have had with the Associations of judges and also of prosecutors to their dismay, that it must be the Legislative Power that decides who the members of the General Council of the Judiciary are.

The agreement that the Socialist Party and the Popular Party had reached and that inexplicably I do not understand why the Popular Party unilaterally breaks, what it does is represent 210 deputies of the General Courts. That is to say, if there is sufficient legitimacy to represent a broad social majority of that country, it is represented in those 210 out of 350 deputies. Therefore, I will certainly defend that it is the Legislative Power and not, precisely, the Associations of Judges and Prosecutors who decide how to govern themselves.

Secondly, we - you have said so many things... - look, of course, you talk about democratic quality, and I have to repeat to you, sir, the indices, because I think it is important that you know them. Last week I mentioned, for example, the Freedom House report from 2018, the democratic index from the magazine "The Economist," and also data on the scarce condemnatory sentences of Spain in the European Court of Human Rights. Therefore, do not lie, sir.

I add another piece of data, the Institute of Quality of Government rates Spanish democracy with a 95 out of 100, placing it in its quality above established democracies like France or Italy.

And let me also remind you of one thing, sir, and that is that the Strasbourg Court is an instance that reinforces the guarantee of Human Rights for 800 million Europeans in the 47 member states of the Council of Europe, which have ratified the European Convention on Human Rights. That is to say, it is an additional guarantee belt to the Rule of Law.

You want to convey the idea that Spanish justice is partial due to a ruling that has been favorable to your interests, but I have not seen you speak about the rejection of the European Court of Human Rights regarding the issue raised a few weeks ago about the compliance of sentences for ETA prisoners? Justice cannot be qualified according to what suits each one, according to their sentences. So, in this sense, sir, what I demand from you is coherence.

Look, in recent years, from 2013 to 2017, our country has recorded an average of six sentences per year in the European Court of Human Rights. Do you know how many sentences a Supreme Court judge issues on average per year in Criminal matters? 43.7. That can give us an idea of the scarce violation of the European Convention on Human Rights by our country. Sir, judicial sentences are complied with, whether we like them more or less. This Government complies with the sentences of the European Court of Human Rights because it is part of our legal system, something you tend to forget.

And, regarding, Mr. President, my inability to address him while the microphone is here, I leave it to the discretion of the Table.