Responses from the President of the Government in the plenary session of the Congress of Deputies during the parliamentary control session.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

21 November 2018 · Parliamentary control session (plenary session of the Congress of Deputies) · Congress of Deputies

Context
Sánchez responded to opposition questions during a congressional plenary control session on November 21, 2018, addressing Andalusia elections, judicial renewal, and Bankia's future.
Main themes
Andalusia regional election campaign, judicial independence and General Council of the Judiciary, Bankia nationalization and public banking, separation of powers, Popular Party criticism, government accountability, banking rescue and public funds recovery, progressive governance
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,091
59th percentile
Sentences
111
68th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 44%41%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Environmental 10%9%
  • Social 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

111 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Mr. Sánchez, our commitment to defending the separation of powers and judicial independence is unequivocal. Now it is your turn to rise to the occasion of the State, to meet the expectations of the Spanish people. And if you do not do so, you will be delegitimized to continue governing, by the way, held hostage by the separatists, who attack the homes of deputies, police officers, and judges.

Listen to Mr. Ábalos and call for elections as soon as possible, and head towards the opposition, like Susana Díaz, before ruining Spain and Andalusia.

President.- Thank you, Madam President.

I can see that you care nothing about Andalusia, Mr. Casado, nothing at all. The problem you have when you talk about Andalusia, as do many of your deputies, is that you always look down on it. And you cannot aspire to govern Andalusia while despising it, Mr. Casado.

Look, all your criticisms, all your criticisms, the entire electoral campaign you are deploying in Andalusia is a collection of clichés. You started by denigrating the education system in Andalusia, -there is Ms. Tejerina to remind us of that-, you have continued with the photos, the drone photos with the Spanish flag. The candidate for the Junta from the Popular Party, wearing a vest like Bolsonaro, taking pictures… look, there are great restaurants in Andalusia, but you go to a fast food restaurant. In short, Mr. Casado, who advises you electorally? Who is directing the electoral campaign in Andalusia? Stop making a fool of yourselves; propose something for the people of Andalusia. Stop insulting, despising, and denigrating Andalusia.

Look, I am going to say something that, well, I find it even curious to have to explain. I never thought I would say this, Mr. Casado, but next to you, Mr. Rajoy is a moderate. And I will tell you more, I will tell you more, Mr. Casado, I will tell you more, and more serious than you. Because you, to cover up your shame for not taking responsibility for what Mr. Cosidó did, what you do is break the renewal of the Council of the Judiciary, a fundamental body for our democratic system.

What I ask Mr. Casado is to reflect. Look, the drift of the Popular Party cannot imply the drift of the institutions, fulfill your pact and allow the renewal of such an important body as the General Council of the Judiciary.

Mr. Iglesias.- Thank you, Madam President.

Mr. President of the Government, what plans do you have for Bankia?

President.- Thank you, Madam President.

Thank you, Mr. Iglesias. Our main objective is to recover the more than 22 billion euros that the Spanish people put in to rescue the entity that have not yet been returned, and that is our priority. And, in that sense, let’s be clear: at this moment, the stock price does not allow for this objective, therefore, at this time, the Government is not considering selling its stake in Bankia.

And I believe this should not surprise anyone. You know very well that this is what this Government and the party that supports it have always defended, which is to protect the interests of all citizens and the small savers who had and have their deposits in the entity.

Mr. Iglesias.- Thank you.

Mr. President, you said that you are going to work to recover the 22 billion euros that we citizens spent on Bankia. Allow me to remind you that we spent 120 billion euros more in indirect aid.

Allow me to remind you of a resolution from the 39th Congress of the Socialist Party, which you happily won against Susana Díaz, in which your Secretary of Economy, Manuel Escudero, coordinator of your economic project, introduced a resolution in Congress, in my opinion, very sensible, the resolution says -I quote literally-: "If we do not remedy this, we will advance towards a system of strong banking concentration. To do this, it is necessary to reverse that trend as a guarantee of a productive economy that has resources, investment, and credit through the creation of a public banking sector."

Mr. Escudero was more right than a saint. Citizens had to spend a lot of money on Bankia. The Government of the Popular Party nationalized Bankia. The question is: Now that we have spent the money to sanitize Bankia and it is already nationalized, because the Popular Party did it, what sense does it make to allow Bankia to be privatized again?

Eduardo Galeano said bankruptcies are socialized, and yet profits are privatized. That is to be expected in a government of these people; in a progressive government, I believe it would be sensible to have a public bank.

Is it eccentric to have a public bank? Well, I don’t think so. Germany, Italy, Switzerland, or the Netherlands have a public bank. What is a public bank for? For several things. The first, so that working people, small and medium-sized enterprises can have guaranteed and secured lines of credit from the public sector.

Not long ago, you said, with the famous mortgage tax, that banks can ultimately pass this tax on to the people. Well, if there is a public bank that competes with an increasingly concentrated banking market, it turns out that now we can compete and they do not have to pass it on to the customers. Moreover, public banks are much more solvent than private ones. I am not saying this. The European Banking Authority says that, after stress tests on the 48 most important financial entities in Europe, the two best are public: one, German, and one, Dutch. I ask for some coherence. Let’s not go back to that time when the Socialist Party says one thing in opposition and does another in government.

President.- Yes, thank you, Madam President.

It is true that the, let’s say, presence of the public sector in the functioning of the financial sector has always been one of the debates of the left. I will tell you one thing, something that you have left, let’s say, unsaid in your speech, and that has to do with regulation.

This Government, Sir, is doing a lot to enhance regulation. We have already announced the creation, for example, of a macroprudential authority that will be called the National Authority for Financial Stability, which I believe is fundamental, to avoid repeating the mistakes that occurred in the past as a result of the 2008 crisis.

Secondly, we are accelerating the transposition of European Directives that, in my opinion, are important: there is the one on mortgage credit, which I hope this Chamber will approve as soon as possible, as we are very behind. And it is true that the news that has appeared today in the media, as a result of parliamentary debates, in my opinion, is positive.

And, thirdly, we have also announced the creation of the Authority for the Protection of Financial Customers, in line with what is being requested from Europe, and which will undoubtedly serve to improve the functioning of our financial markets and better protect users.

And, regarding the last of the issues, I will tell you, Mr. Iglesias, that we are not closed to having a public bank. The debate that has always existed in the Socialist Party and on the left is whether the State should have a commercial bank or an investment bank. We believe there should be an investment bank. There cannot be a commercial bank, which makes no sense for the State to have deposits. Therefore, what we are doing, and there is the Minister of Economy promoting it, is to greatly enhance the ICO as that investment bank, precisely, for small and medium-sized businesses in our country.

Mr. Campuzano.- Thank you, Madam President.

Mr. President, the automotive sector has lived with astonishment and concern the announcement of your Government to prohibit the sale and circulation of combustion cars.

The issue is not so much the objective, which we can share, but the terms in which you made that announcement, without proposing a concerted and agreed plan with the automotive sector to transition towards sustainable mobility, based on autonomous, connected, low-emission, and electric cars.

And, Mr. President, in the face of this challenge, what is the policy? What is the plan that the Government has foreseen to address that regulation and guarantee competitiveness and employment in the automotive sector?

Thank you.

President.- Yes, thank you, Madam President.

The truth is that I appreciate this question very much, because I think it is important that we talk about the automotive sector, which represents and creates around 300,000 direct jobs in our country. Two million indirect jobs in our country, but look, and I think this is important. Eight out of ten cars manufactured in our country are exported. If one looks at where the calendars being proposed by competing countries are or where we are selling our cars: Belgium, France, Germany, the United Kingdom… for the prohibition of combustion cars, a period of around 2030 to 2040 is being marked.

We are proposing to the automotive sector, 2040, as a medium-term goal; 2050 as a long-term goal. The question would be: if we do not make an orderly ecological transition in the automotive sector, who is going to buy the cars outside of Spain? I remind you, eight out of ten vehicles are sold outside our country. Therefore, I believe that what is important is to convey, first, certainty to investors, to the automotive sector. A firm commitment to ecological transition, not just from the Government, but from all public institutions. And, in that, the Government is engaged in dialogue with the automotive sector. There is the strategic agreement we are preparing and developing with them. And, undoubtedly, providing certainty to such an important sector for the economy of our country.

Mr. Campuzano.- Mr. President, we share the importance of the sector in terms of wealth, GDP, and industrial employment. But what I reproach is that you made that announcement precisely without that plan. That plan to make that transition possible to achieve those climate change objectives, to combat pollution in large cities, and to guarantee competitiveness and that industrial employment. And those countries have made plans. They have made plans with measures in the field of infrastructure, in tax incentives, in research, in innovation, and in development. And agreed with the sector.

Look, last week, the manufacturers did not attend the meeting called by your Government, nor did the representatives of the workers. We have no record of any agreement with the Autonomous Communities, which have key competencies in this matter. And, moreover, Mr. President, in the terms that the prohibition has been announced, it generates uncertainty among consumers, among international investors, indeed, Mr. President.

And you know that in such a competitive and globalized industry, where the decision-making centers of manufacturers are neither in Madrid nor in Barcelona, it is essential to set that shared roadmap, and, moreover, in the short term.

Look, there is an aging fleet. We need a new Plan Renove for those cars that pollute and emit CO2. For Catalonia, this policy is essential in terms of competitiveness and in terms of employment.

Mr. President, in these months that you have been governing, issues of economic policy and the competitiveness of our economy have not been your priority. In this matter, we demand it from you.

Thank you.

President.- Thank you, Madam President.

Approve the Budgets, Mr. Campuzano. Look, it is not clear to me whether you agree or not with the horizon of 2040-2050 that the Government of Spain has proposed. One thing is certain, we are providing certainty to investors because we are proposing a horizon of more than 20 years, to be able to work on this orderly ecological transition that we are proclaiming from the Government.

Look, I am aware that currently, demand is scarce, for example, regarding electric vehicles, autonomous vehicles, but that is why we are carrying out a series of measures to stimulate it.

The first, a new support aid program for mobility, based on the use of alternative energies. Secondly, we have eliminated the figure of the charging manager, with Royal Decree 15/2018, of October 5, on Urgent Measures for the Energy Transition and Consumer Protection.

Thirdly, we will maintain a specific electricity tariff, with time discrimination to favor recharges produced during the super valley hours of the electrical system.

Fourthly, we are transposing several Directives related to the energy efficiency of buildings to incorporate…

Thank you very much.