"When 2021 ends, the amount paid for electricity will be the same as in 2018."

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

6 September 2021 · La Moncloa, Spain

Context
Sánchez gave an interview at La Moncloa on September 6, 2021, addressing the electricity price crisis and outlining government measures to stabilize consumer bills.
Main themes
Electricity prices, consumer protection, structural energy reforms, renewable energy investment, VAT reduction, minimum vital consumption, coalition government stability, electricity market intervention, social shield, CGPJ judicial renewal blockage, PP criticism, just recovery
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,743
84th percentile
Sentences
219
91st percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.77
19th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
45th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 40%39%
  • Economic 27%26%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

219 sentences in 74 paragraphs

To this end, he explains, the Executive has launched structural reforms, suspended taxes, expanded protection for the most vulnerable, and is studying the creation of "a minimum vital consumption." Sánchez is confident in completing the legislature alongside Unidas Podemos and harshly criticizes the PP for the blockage in the renewal of the CGPJ: "The PP has kidnapped the Constitution and the Judiciary. It is undemocratic."

Pedro Sánchez (born in Madrid 49 years ago) arrives at this interview in La Moncloa with his mind on the price of electricity. In his responses, it is evident that he has been focused on this for several days, memorizing data and discussing alternatives to resolve it. It is currently the big black hole for the Government, and the urgency to clarify and repeat a commitment is palpable: that, despite the chaos in the wholesale market, by the end of the year, citizens will have paid on average in their bills the same as in 2018 thanks to the intervention of the Executive. After a radical change of Government, Sánchez is confident in a "just recovery" to turn around the polls and reconnect with the progressive electorate in the next two years.

Question. The Government has given the impression of impotence in recent days in the face of rising electricity prices. Do you really not have any margin to control this increase?

Answer. The Government takes social concern seriously. And we are working on a plan to reach a concrete commitment, which is that by the end of 2021, Spaniards will look back and see that they have paid in their electricity bill an amount similar to what they paid in 2018. That is the objective and the commitment: that all citizens with an average consumption by the end of 2021 pay an amount similar to what they paid in 2018, logically with the CPI discounted.

Q. And how are you going to do it? With what instruments?

A. It is important to clarify the debate that one thing is the evolution of the wholesale price of the energy market and another thing is the electricity bill. We pay the bill monthly. What does not make sense is to raise the debate daily, because we do not pay for electricity daily. What the Government can do is cushion the evolution of that wholesale price. First, with structural reforms, with a firm commitment to renewable energies, not only for climate change reasons but because it is cheaper.

The electric futures markets are already saying that Spain, in 2022 and 2023, thanks to renewables, will have lower prices than France and Germany. In addition, we have reduced VAT from 21% to 10%. This is benefiting 28 million consumers and 2.8 million businesses. It represents a revenue loss effort for the State of 1.4 billion euros. This cushions the evolution of the electricity bill by 12%.

Thirdly, the protection of the most vulnerable consumers with the social shield, the prohibition of cutting off electricity to those who cannot pay, or with the energy voucher. We are protecting 1,100,000 consumers. Moreover, we have a project to define a minimum vital consumption precisely in the field of electricity and energy. And finally, the Government has taken measures in that fourth axis to review the excessive profits that the electricity companies have.

We have deducted 650 million euros that were going to go to the electricity companies to redirect them to consumers. We are going to take measures to guarantee that objective: that Spaniards, when they see what they have paid in 2021 for the electricity bill, find that it is the same or similar to the figure they paid in 2018, with the CPI discounted.

Q. The State takes on the protection of the vulnerable, but does not intervene in the market. You have not reformed the electricity market after three years in Government.

A. We have approved a sustainability fund for the electricity system, which is currently being processed in the Cortes. We are going to extract from the electricity bill a series of costs that citizens are currently paying and that tomorrow, once validated in Congress, will be paid by the generating companies of that energy, nuclear, gas. The Government has done and will continue to do everything possible. With the recovery plan, we are going to allocate 1.2 billion euros to self-consumption.

Q. You are talking to us about what you have done so far, about things that are in Congress for the coming months. But many people, especially your partners in Unidas Podemos, urge you to do something now because there are forecasts that prices will continue to rise until March 2022. Do you have anything in the pipeline right now?

A. Unidas Podemos proposes the establishment of a public company. It is an old debate, but when we agreed on our coalition program, we discussed it and it was left out. It is not part of the coalition agreement. Therefore, the Government does not feel concerned by that proposal. But in Congress, a parliamentary commission is going to be established precisely to see what proposals the actors and political groups make. We will listen. But the important thing is the Government's commitment that, of course, we are going to keep the electricity bill at terms similar to those of 2018.

Q. Why can't Spain do the same as France, for example, set the price of nuclear energy?

A. The energy mix is different in one country than in another. We are making an unequivocal commitment to renewable energies. In addition, not many people know it, but Spain is the country with the largest solar energy source in Europe and one of the most important in wind energy. 90% of the wind farms in our country are made with national manufacturing; 60% of solar farms are made with national manufacturing.

Q. Can this crisis break the Government?

A. We are committed to a coalition program that we formed. We have already fulfilled 34% of the commitments of that coalition Government before we reach the halfway point of the legislature, and we will reach 38% in this semester. This is a Government that is moving forward. In 2008, it took 12 years to recover the employment levels prior to the crisis. We have a shared objective, which is that Spain, in 2023, is a better country than the one we found in 2018, a more advanced, more prosperous country, and ultimately, that emerges from the greatest calamity of the last 100 years. Today we are at employment levels more or less similar to those before COVID, and we have taken a year and a half.

Q. Are you considering finishing the legislature without Unidas Podemos?

A. My commitment is to continue with the coalition Government until the last day. We are two parties with two different political cultures, although we share the progressive space. The PSOE is a party that reflects the feelings of the street, but that has a very consolidated culture of governance. Unidas Podemos, in its genesis, was a movement of social activists who took the step into institutional politics. Governing is reconciling what is desirable with what we can achieve. We are achieving very important things, raising the minimum wage, approving a euthanasia law, reversing cuts that were made in the past, for example, in dependency or education. They are assimilating that transition between social activism and institutional politics. But from the point of view of loyalty, in important votes, Unidas Podemos has always been on the side of the Government. Could the decibels be a little lower? Of course.

Q. We already have 70% of the population vaccinated, but the pandemic is still there. When will we return to pre-pandemic normality? Or will we never recover that life?

A. We have set an example both to Europe and the world of how things can be done well. We are getting closer to recovering our normality. There are several lessons to be learned from this 70%. First, it would not have been possible if we had not had formidable healthcare professionals. Second, this vaccination process has not depended on the bank account or the size of each taxpayer's pocket. And, third, we have had an example of the best patriotism of Spaniards who trust in their national health system and in science and who, therefore, do not give credit to the nonsense or superstitions we have seen in the form of hoaxes.

Q. Does it make sense to give a third dose in rich countries when poor countries are just starting their first?

A. It is not incompatible. Spain has already donated more than six million doses to Latin American countries; our commitment is to reach 7.5 million donated doses before the end of the year. Europe, as a whole, is the continent that is donating the most doses to the rest of the planet. But regarding the third dose, we have to wait for scientific evidence.

Q. Can a country be changed with 72 billion euros?

A. A lot can be done because it is not just 72 billion euros. It is, above all, leveraging private investment based on that public investment. We need to make a recovery as fair as possible, so that the big numbers translate into the daily lives of people, even the most humble, in the form of more jobs, better wages. That is why the debate now about the minimum wage. And also with more dignified pensions. The agreement we have just reached with the unions and employers is the first on pensions since 2011. It took us 10 years to rebuild an agreement that was broken in 2013 under Rajoy's administration.

Q. What guarantees are there that this amount of money that will arrive in Spain from European funds will not be captured only by large companies?

Q. And this great change of country with 72 billion euros, can it be done with this Parliament, with a president who has only 120 seats?

A. The new politics we are in is precisely about being able to articulate and structure the difference. We have 155 seats with Unidas Podemos, but in these 18 months of legislature, almost all the bills, royal decree laws, have been validated in Congress.

We have to make the digital revolution and the ecological revolution as inclusive as possible, from a territorial, generational, and also gender perspective. That these two revolutions are felt by the working middle class as opportunities for progress and job creation for them.

Q. There is no memory of a government reshuffle like the one you made this summer. Now you replace Adriana Lastra as spokesperson in Congress. Does it change almost everything because almost nothing was working?

A. There are months that are worth years. We have lived through a terrible pandemic. We have had two or three Council of Ministers a week, with very tough decisions. That also has a personal cost.

Politics is made by people who have to give up their family life to defend what they love most, which is their country. I am very grateful for what all the ministers have done. Many of them have accompanied me even before I became president.

It is also important that in this new stage of economic recovery, teams are renewed, that new blood comes in. The PSOE has a lot of talent, and the best talent it has is municipal, and that is precisely where I have turned to make that recovery.

In parliamentary terms, Adriana Lastra has done an extraordinary job. Starting from the federal congress in October, as deputy general secretary, she will have a 100% dedication to the party because we have municipal and regional elections in 2023, and then the general elections at the end of 2023.

Q. Do you think that some courts are politically opposing the Government?

A. If you ask me about the blockage of the renewal...

Q. I am asking you about judicial rulings that correct some political decisions.

A. I respect the decisions that are made, although I do not agree with the ruling of the Constitutional Court. And, of course, I feel more identified with the dissenting vote even of the president himself on the state of alarm.

Q. Have you resigned yourself to ending the legislature with the democratic anomaly that represents having a General Council of the Judiciary with a mandate expired for almost three years, the Court of Auditors not renewed, the Constitutional Court also?

A. I have never resigned myself. We have tried on four occasions to reach an agreement with the PP. The PP has been outside the Constitution for a thousand days. Why do they hold the Government hostage to the judges? The PP has not accepted the electoral result of 2019. Not only their defeat but the parliamentary composition of the Cortes.

That behavior must be called by all its names: it is undemocratic. But there is a second reason that also seems very serious to me. The PP claims ownership of everything: Spain, the flag, the Constitution must be read as I want... There is a clear kidnapping of the Spanish Constitution. That Vox does it is concerning, but that the PP does it is alarming.

Q. Could the members of the CGPJ unblock the situation by resigning?

A. I cannot enter that debate because we are talking about a power independent of the Executive. The PP has given many pretexts during these thousand days; today it is the election system, yesterday it was that Podemos is in the Government, the day before it was that they did not want a judge who ruled in one of the PP's corruption cases. In short, pretexts. I hear the PP say "the Government's interventionism regarding the judges," but is there greater interventionism than blocking and kidnapping the renewal of the judges' government?

Q. Has the Government ever put the reform of the judges' election system on the negotiation table, even if only for the future?

R. This debate can be substantial, but it is nothing more than a pretext. If you want to change the law, the first thing you have to do is win the elections. Secondly, you must have a parliamentary majority, which does not exist today in Congress, to modify that electoral system, which, by the way, has been in place for 30 years.

P. Would you be willing to offer it to unblock?

R. That is not the debate. It is much deeper and more serious. It is about democracy. The Constitution, as far as I know, and I may be mistaken, does not state in its articles that it should be upheld when the PP wins and, when it does not win, then it should not be upheld. The Constitution tells us that every five years we must renew the governing body of judges.

P. The Supreme Prosecutor is investigating the former king for allegedly receiving illegal commissions. Should he return to Spain and provide an explanation?

R. Regarding King Juan Carlos, I believe I have clearly positioned myself in previous statements. For the peace of mind of citizens, the rule of law is functioning, the Tax Agency is working, the Prosecutor's Office is also active, and the media are reporting on the progress. Therefore, the most important thing is that it is known that any conduct, any investigation that may be opened in this area will not face any hindrance. I also think it is important to reaffirm that my commitment is total to the Constitution and to the parliamentary monarchy. Here, we are not judging an institution; we may be judging a person from the public debate.

P. But it harms the institution...

P. This debate does not contribute. But I also tell you with the same firmness with which I have expressed myself regarding King Juan Carlos, that I recognize the efforts and advances being made by the current head of state and the Royal House in terms of transparency and exemplary conduct.

P. Can the institution and the person be separated in a hereditary institution? What image does it give of Spain?

R. That does not contribute to the good reputation of our country. To say otherwise would be a falsehood. It is also true that, just as we have seen cases that we have liked more or less in other bodies, whether in politics, in the media, or in other institutions, we are not stigmatizing the profession or the institution with that.

P. Does King Juan Carlos owe an explanation to the Spanish people?

R. First, let's see how everything develops. It is important, at least as the President of the Government, to maintain the presumption of innocence. Depending on what we see, we will be able to respond to your question much more clearly.

P. You plan to present a budget this year. We are recovering some institutional normality. Can you guarantee that this will be the case until the end of the legislature?

R. That stability of having four-year legislatures is my commitment. It was said that we would not reach 70% vaccinated by August. That we would not be able to approve the first budget, and we are going for the second. I appeal to all parliamentary forces. The state must emerge strengthened from this challenge; we must strengthen our healthcare, our education, and our science and research system.

P. But taxes are not being touched for now...

R. I believe we must emerge with a much stronger welfare state, without a doubt. The first thing to do to achieve this is for the economy to grow. And from there, the Government has launched a commission of experts for a tax reform that needs to be done; we have committed to developing it over the next six years. We will work with that horizon.

P. Esquerra talks about an independence referendum in 2030. Do you see any future for the dialogue table starting from a base like this?

R. Catalonia needs a government that emerges from the self-absorption it has been in for the last 15 years, talking about issues that, perhaps for them, legitimately, are very important, but that today, after the pandemic and the social, economic, and health consequences, have probably been reduced.

P. But at the dialogue table that is meeting now, they are going to bring that referendum for 2030. What will you bring?

R. What I will bring is something public, which is the agenda of reconnection, where there is a set of financing investments, which is in the interest of Catalonia and the whole country to take advantage of this stage of recovery and modernization. Spain has no problem with Catalonia; the problem lies with the independence movement itself regarding the plural conception of Catalan society.

P. Will you preside over the meeting?

R. I have always stated that my willingness to dialogue is total. I have met with the President of the Generalitat [Quim] Torra, with President [Pere] Aragonés, I met in this room with the delegation of the Generalitat's government at that time. The most important thing is not whether I go or not; the important thing is whether there are advances at that table, and that is something we all need to strive for.

P. Are you satisfied with how the minors from Ceuta were returned to Morocco?

R. In May, 9,000 people entered Ceuta in two days. The territorial integrity of our country was called into question. Fortunately, that is in the past. We have an extraordinary opportunity to redefine our relationship with Morocco, which is a strategic partner. Therefore, it is a problem we need to resolve, with the utmost guarantees for the minors who entered, but also being aware that we have a delicate balance of coexistence in Ceuta, which was broken by the massive entry of Moroccans. I can only express my gratitude to Ceuta, to its government, and also to Morocco because in this new phase we have opened, we believe we will be able to provide a solution with their utmost collaboration.

P. What or who has failed in Afghanistan for the Taliban to return to power 20 years later?

R. It is a failure of the international community. There is no need to sugarcoat it. But both in Afghanistan and with the 70% vaccination, Spain has exercised the best of patriotism. The President of the European Commission said that Spain represents the soul of Europe. We are there in tough times and in good times. Our country is a formidable country, with very high values. The other day I read a survey [by YouGov, a British polling company, conducted in eight countries] that said 91% of Spaniards expressed that they would see it as completely normal for any of their relatives to come out of the closet and acknowledge their homosexuality. In the US, it is 66%. In France, 57%. Our country embraces the achievements in rights and freedoms. With Afghanistan and vaccination, we have given ourselves and the world a lesson. The opposition says: "What do you have to celebrate about Afghanistan?" As a collective success, we have saved the lives of 2,000 people. They are few, probably, but we should ask each of them if that exercise was not worth it.

P. How do you imagine post-Merkel Europe? The SPD is doing very well in the polls.

R. I know the candidate, Olaf Scholz, very well, and I participated in the electoral campaign in July with him in Berlin. If there is that change in Germany, both Spain and Germany can be two engines of a new conception of progressivism that I believe will suit Europe very well.

P. What has this hard year and a half taught you?

R. Humility, it is the great lesson for politics and for the West: we are not safe, we are not immune. And also being aware that, beyond the noise, this is a great country that, when called to that unity, can move forward. Now we have the most extraordinary conditions to carry out a new modernization of the country like the one that took place during the Transition. This moment for Spain is one of a crossroads: whether we want to advance or whether we want to stay at the back of this process of change and revolution that the world is experiencing.

NOTE: Article published with the authorization of El País.