7. Speech at the Atlantic Council Energy and Economy Summit

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

19 November 2015 · 7th Energy and Economy Summit organized by the Atlantic Council · Istanbul, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed the 7th Atlantic Council Energy and Economy Summit in Istanbul on November 19, 2015, speaking on energy, terrorism, and the refugee crisis.
Main themes
Energy and economy summit, fight against terrorism, Syrian refugee crisis, Turkey's burden of migration, Paris attacks, G-20 Antalya Summit, global security concerns, Islam and terrorism disassociation, international community responsibility, Turkey-US relations
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,933
85th percentile
Sentences
247
93rd percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.71
13th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 44%43%
  • Economic 23%23%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Institutional 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

247 sentences in 69 paragraphs

President of Croatia, Ms. Grabar Kitarović,

Prime Minister of Albania, Mr. Edi Rama,

Esteemed ministers,

Valued participants, dear guests;

I greet you with love and respect. Welcome to Turkey and our Istanbul.

I would like to particularly emphasize my pleasure in participating in the 7th Energy and Economy Summit organized by the Atlantic Council here in Istanbul this year and being together with you.

I also find it significant that this gathering is taking place immediately after the G-20 Antalya Summit. On this occasion, I would like to thank the Atlantic Council, its Istanbul Office, and everyone who contributed to the organization of this meeting.

Since 2010, the Atlantic Council Energy and Economy Summit held in Istanbul has been an important platform that provides an opportunity to address developments in these areas. I believe that the panels to be held under the headings of energy and economy throughout the summit will lead to enlightening and broad evaluations.

I believe that such platforms also provide serious contributions to our official relations with the United States.

Dear guests;

We are in a sensitive period where the whole world is going through historical trials from different perspectives. Economic stagnation, poverty, and injustices in income distribution remain on our agenda. Global issues such as large migration movements stemming from internal conflicts, terrorism, and the depletion of natural resources have begun to come to the forefront more and more. We are obliged to fight all of these swiftly, effectively, and decisively.

No one has the right or luxury to isolate themselves from the crises or humanitarian crises that are occurring. In the face of increasing security concerns, even the most ambitious economies and the most developed countries can find themselves helpless. Today, Turkey is struggling to maintain its stability and development right next to a region that is the focus of security concerns.

Looking back at the history of our fight against terrorism, we have been combating terrorism for about 35 years. The events that began at our southern borders and have complex dimensions have the potential to yield long-term consequences for the entire world. We are facing the heavy consequences of these issues, especially the migrant issue.

Unfortunately, Turkey has been left alone in its honorable struggle against humanitarian crises. For nearly 5 years, we have shouldered the entire economic and social burden caused by 2.5 million migrants coming from Syria and Iraq.

Look, the money we have spent just for the services we provide to the migrants coming from Syria in the camps, I am only talking about the camps, is 8.5 billion dollars. So, how many people live in these camps? 280,000. The others are scattered across various cities in our country. Do you know how many migrants and refugees we have in our Istanbul? Approximately 500,000.

Can you imagine the sociological traumas of this? Can you think about the psychological trauma it creates? Both the trauma experienced by those who come and the trauma it creates in our society… When we think about these, does humanity have the luxury to say, ‘Turkey will manage this anyway’? Do states have such a luxury?

We share this world together. We must all contribute to world peace. None of us actually has the luxury to say, ‘Let them take care of themselves, whatever happens.’ But for 35 years, we have fought against terrorism within our borders, and now we have not closed our doors to these refugees, we have opened our doors. Because we could not close our doors to those people under barrel bombs. Our non-governmental organizations and charitable citizens are currently providing assistance that cannot be compared to money for the migrants living in our cities, just like in Istanbul. In return, the international community, especially European countries, has not only ignored this problem but has also adopted an attitude that will deepen the crisis further.

The terrorist attacks that took place in Paris last Friday night have brought us to a new crossroads regarding both the fight against terrorism and migrants. We discussed this issue thoroughly at the Leaders' Summit held in Antalya during the G-20. In my bilateral meetings - I had face-to-face meetings with the leaders of 17 countries and we held inter-delegation meetings - we evaluated these in all their details.

At the end of the summit, in addition to the customary declaration, we published a declaration on the fight against terrorism. In this declaration, after condemning the attacks in Paris, Ankara, Gaziantep, Beirut, we emphasized that we are united in the fight against terrorism. We specifically stated that terrorism cannot be associated with any religion, nationality, civilization, or ethnic group.

I say this very clearly and sincerely here: I am a Muslim, Islam is derived from the word ‘salama,’ which means ‘peace’ in Arabic. There is a terrorist organization called ISIS that casts a shadow over Islam, which is a religion of peace. Where did this terrorist organization originate? From Al-Qaeda. In addition, there are terrorist organizations within my country, such as the PKK, and terrorist organizations like the PYD and YPG in northern Syria. You go to Africa, and you see Boko Haram. All of these, regardless of which religion they belong to, dear friends, we must know this well; we cannot and should not judge any religion through the negative, bad types of people of that religion. We cannot show such an approach to the other members of that religion. Just as these come from among Muslims, they can also come from among Christians and Jews. Similarly, there are many who emerge from within sects.

I strongly condemn and denounce these terrorists who emerge from the religion I belong to and take pride in. And at this point, we discussed this at the G-20, while inviting the political leaders of Muslim-majority countries to take a stance, we also invited scholars and even religious leaders to take a stance on this issue. We must do this together. If we cannot, today, those who knock on our door in Ankara, as I said recently, will also knock on your door tomorrow.

Indeed, it knocked on the door in Paris. But did it end with Paris? It will knock on that door somewhere else too. Therefore, we must address this attitude within an international consensus. Our foreign ministries, our interior ministries, all our intelligence agencies must enter into a joint intensive effort. Because world peace is not the issue of one country, two countries, but the common issue, the problem of the entire world.

Valued participants;

As the leaders of countries with Muslim populations attending the summit, we saw that we agree on the need to fight extremism together and decisively. I believe this consensus will also be a consensus that includes other countries with Muslim populations. We will raise this issue in our bilateral contacts and on every platform we will be together, and we will show our determination to the whole world. Indeed, during the G-20 Summit, our Directorate of Religious Affairs also announced its statement on this issue to the world and to the leaders.

Of course, there is also an important task for other countries; we see that especially in Europe, where Muslims are in the minority, there is an increasingly prejudiced, negative, and exclusionary atmosphere spreading against Muslims. Indeed, while we sincerely condemn the Paris attack and share the pain of the French people, we have started to receive news of attacks against Muslims in various countries.

I would like to particularly emphasize this point: The hardening of attitudes towards migrants will only serve to deepen the humanitarian drama experienced. We expect all leaders in the world to call for common sense to their societies on this issue.

As Turkey, we show more sensitivity to this issue than anyone else.

I made a press statement at 1:30 AM in Antalya. And from that moment on, I continuously called Mr. Hollande, and we had our meeting with him in the morning. Why? Because we must show that we are shoulder to shoulder against terrorism. We have 5 million citizens or people of Turkish descent living in Europe. We have painful experiences, such as the Solingen massacre, where five members of a family were burned to death, and the neo-Nazi serial murders where eight of our brothers lost their lives. We have unfortunately lost ambassadors in many places in Europe, and we have lived through all their pains. We have not forgotten the racist act in Norway that claimed the lives of 77 people, among whom one of our citizens unfortunately died.

If the rising racist attacks and fanatic movements in Europe and other countries are not stopped, it is inevitable that new and dangerous tragedies will occur. I believe that all countries and all leaders see the danger that racism, combined with Islamophobia, poses, especially for Europe.

As the leaders of states with Muslim populations, I condemn and denounce all forms of extremism. I believe it is our right to expect a similar approach from other countries for their societies.

It is essential to correctly understand the primary causes of the humanitarian dramas and terrorism activities occurring in our region. The main culprit of the humanitarian crises and terrorist incidents we are experiencing today is the Assad regime, which has killed 380,000 of its own people. Assad is perpetrating state terrorism. I say very clearly and unequivocally; those who stand behind this person, who is perpetrating state terrorism, are as guilty as he is. The 380,000 Syrians who have been slaughtered with barrel bombs, chemical and conventional weapons are not just a statistic; each one is a life, a human being. And we must evaluate very well what kind of message the ongoing debate of ‘should he go or should he stay’ sends not only to the Syrian people but to humanity as a whole. The regime is trying to maintain its power through sectarian conflict and the activities of terrorist organizations.

Not long ago, at the G-20 Summit we held in St. Petersburg, it was interesting to discuss what? Of course, I opposed it; the issue being discussed was whether chemical weapons were used or not. ‘Okay, chemical weapons were used, but how many people died from chemical weapons?’ 1,500 people. Well, how many people died from conventional weapons? Then 120,000 people. Now, we set aside those killed by conventional weapons; we are saying that for the 1,500 people killed by chemical weapons, ‘there is a law about this, therefore we must punish based on this.’ Okay, but while 120,000 people are killed by conventional weapons, why are we not focusing on who provided these conventional weapons to Syria, who sent them? What is important for us is the cause-effect relationship. If the result is death, regardless of what the cause is, all are responsible for that result, and we need to focus on this.

Today, all terrorist organizations in the region serve the Assad regime directly or indirectly. ISIS is supported by Assad. Assad is currently taking ISIS's oil and converting it into money. You have to be blind not to see this; it is clearly evident.

In this respect, there is no difference between ISIS and the PYD, YPG. The PYD is supported by Assad. But until yesterday, Assad was an enemy to the Kurds there. During the times when our negotiations were good, he was not giving identity cards to the Kurds living in Syria, he was not giving them residency papers. We were saying, ‘What are you doing? Give it, they are your citizens.’ He was not giving them. He was not giving passports; on the contrary, we were pressuring him.

But now they have become quite friendly, they have come to this state. Anyone who does not look at these two organizations, which support the PYD under the pretext of fighting ISIS, with the same lens is, in a way, showing tolerance towards terrorism. Especially those who insult Islam and Muslims through ISIS are definitely in a great mistake.

In fact, all terrorist organizations that exploit Islam, such as Al-Qaeda and Boko Haram, predominantly kill Muslims and harm Muslims. None of these organizations have the slightest relationship with Islam; they cannot. The blood of every innocent person they kill is also stained with the hands of the powers behind them. I believe that by spreading the stance we agreed upon as countries with Muslim populations at the G-20 Summit to the entire Islamic world, we have taken an important step towards drying up these sources of discord.

Valued guests;

The influx of migrants heading to Europe from troubled regions, especially Syria and Iraq, has once again highlighted the importance of Turkey-European Union relations. This reality needs to be seen by everyone: The effective cooperation between Turkey and the European Union will have deep impacts in various areas concerning Eurasia and the Middle East. Just like everyone who establishes positive relations with Turkey, the European Union will also benefit from this. In this respect, the relations between our country and the European Union need to be strengthened. Turkey's value as an actor, a partner, both regionally and globally, is evident. Turkey is the only country that can bring the economic and social dynamism that Europe needs most today if it becomes a member.

Despite all the problems in our close geography, we look to the future with hope with our strong democracy and stable economy. We want to see all the friendly and brotherly societies we cooperate with, along with our own country, in prosperity and development.

In the last 13 years, our relations at the economic, social, cultural, and humanitarian levels have increased exponentially across a wide geography. We have pioneered the establishment of numerous dialogue and cooperation mechanisms at bilateral and regional levels. We have made special efforts to contribute to the development efforts of particularly underdeveloped countries. Look, in 2014, with our humanitarian aid reaching 4.5 billion dollars, we became the country that increased development aid the most among OECD countries. We will continue to intensify our efforts in this direction.

Valued guests;

Energy is one of the foremost issues in our development efforts. We see and know that the world energy map is changing, and new actors are emerging in the energy sector. Of course, diversification of energy is essential. Thirteen years ago, Turkey was very, very poor in this regard, let me be clear. It was not due to a lack of resources, but rather because, despite having them, they were not being utilized or could not be utilized. Being located at the crossroads of energy-producing and consuming countries places a great responsibility on our country. We believe that effective cooperation among producer, transit, and consumer countries—what I call the 3T—is crucial for ensuring energy security; that is, supply, transit, and consumption. Energy, which should be a tool for peace, stability, and prosperity, should promote cooperation instead of conflicts.

The transportation of natural gas from Central Asia and the Caspian Basin to Europe through our country will contribute to Europe's energy supply security. For this purpose, with the support of the United States, we have signed major projects together with Azerbaijan and Georgia, and we continue to do so.

We successfully realized the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan and Baku-Tbilisi-Erzurum projects, which were seen as a dream by some circles in the past. They said it wouldn't happen, but here we are, it happened. The whole issue is about believing, being determined, and taking the step...

In 2007, we facilitated the export of Azerbaijani gas to Europe through an alternative route with the Turkey-Greece Interconnector. The Kirkuk-Ceyhan, Iran-Turkey, and Blue Stream pipelines are other pipelines we have implemented.

The Trans-Anatolian Natural Gas Pipeline Project (TANAP), which we developed together with Azerbaijan, will be the longest pipeline built on our territory. We have laid the foundation, and construction is currently progressing intensively. Thus, the transportation of Azerbaijani gas to both our country and Europe will be ensured.

Now, I am addressing the Europeans, I am addressing the European Union; we also signed Nabucco with you. It has been six years since we signed Nabucco. Look, why haven't we taken a step? If you don't provide the money, if the supply doesn't resolve this, it won't work. Then where do they cut the bill? To Turkey. Why are you billing us? We say that everything is ready, we are here. But what is our duty? Transit, we are ready for that. We have another feature, we are consumers, we are ready for that too. But did you supply it, did you bring the money? Look, Azerbaijan took the step, and we partnered with Azerbaijan. And now, as partners, we joined hands, laid the foundation, and the tenders have been held, construction is rapidly continuing. We are also currently working to include alternative sources, especially Turkmen natural gas, into this pipeline, TANAP. There are developments that will strengthen our country's energy center role regarding the Eastern Mediterranean, Iraq, Iran, and the Caspian region.

Distinguished participants;

During our term presidency, we were the first to bring the issue of energy to the forefront within the G-20 framework. And we held an energy meeting here, in this hall. Why? We said let's address the energy issue strongly in the G-20. The discussions held during the Antalya Summit and the declaration adopted at the end of the summit are important in this regard.

As you know, we defined our priorities as three fundamental concepts; inclusiveness, implementation, and investments. And where does the importance of inclusiveness come from among these priorities? For the first time, we brought the issue of women to the agenda as a headline at this summit, Women-20, and similarly, Youth-20 took its place at this summit. But we emphasized the theme of justice. By highlighting SMEs, we said, 'let's make inclusiveness one of the main topics here.' And now, inclusiveness is also taking its place at the China Summit.

Secondly, implementation. What is implementation? Okay, you are taking all these steps, but are they being implemented, are they ongoing, is there follow-up on whether they are continuing or not; this is very important.

Thirdly, investments. And the target for 2030 is to achieve investments between 80-100 trillion dollars in underdeveloped, least developed, and developing countries... How will this happen? For this, the secret is public-private partnership. With the existence of public-private partnership, it is possible to realize these infrastructure investments; Turkey is full of examples of this. We have brought these issues to the agenda.

These priorities have been accepted and supported by the G-20 countries. Our common goal as the G-20 is to ensure strong, sustainable, balanced, and now, with this year, inclusive global growth.

The slow recovery in the global economy and uncertainties in financial markets indicate new risks. In this regard, the implementation of the growth strategies we adopted last year and restoring confidence in global markets is of great importance.

Of course, we must not waste anything related to energy. Look, obtaining energy from the wind is important. The sun should not only warm us, but we must also utilize the energy it provides in every field.

If the translation is done well by my friends, I will say a word: Actually, we do not have much water. But despite this, the waters used to flow and meet the sea, and at that time, a saying was produced among us. Do you know what this saying was? 'Water flows, the Turk watches.' We said, this cannot be the case.

Now we have changed it; we said, 'Water flows, the Turk makes it.' We transformed it. And we immediately entered into hydroelectric power plants intensively. And along with hydroelectric power plants, you know, it is a heavy investment, but it is a cheap operation, we evaluated this.

And similarly, we focused on wind energy plants. Now we are focusing on solar energy plants. Natural gas is good, nice; but if you do not produce it yourself, if you do not have it, the cost is high... These are also important due to being renewable energy, thus having an additional beauty. By multiplying all of these in these areas, we have reached a much different position.

At our summit meeting, we also agreed that the growth strategies should be effectively implemented in Antalya. Now we have a mechanism to monitor the implementation of the commitments made to achieve the additional growth target of 2.1% by 2018. And regarding global infrastructure investments, as I just mentioned, we will take these steps and will intensively pursue them. Calculations are being made that could reach up to 100 trillion dollars.

The International Energy Agency also estimates the energy investment need until 2035 to be 48 trillion dollars. At the summit, we addressed the comprehensive investment strategies prepared by the G-20 countries in all their dimensions. I was pleased to see that there is a consensus on the need to revitalize investments to achieve our G-20 growth target. Of course, it is not possible to meet the investment need solely by using public resources. Therefore, establishing effective cooperation between the public and private sectors is extremely important in this regard.

During our country's term presidency, for the first time in G-20 history, we took an important step alongside the energy ministers regarding agricultural issues, which was very significant in terms of development goals.

We placed special emphasis throughout the year on the issue of access to energy, which is a principle among the sustainable development goals of G-20 energy cooperation countries. Especially due to its urgency, we focused our efforts more on Sub-Saharan Africa.

Because 1 billion 100 million people live in energy poverty in Africa. Can we remain silent against this, are there no steps we need to take? We organized the Africa Energy Access Conference, which brought together G-20 energy ministers and representatives of the private sector with African energy ministers for this purpose.

Due to the critical nature of 2015 in terms of climate change negotiations, we prioritized increasing renewable energy and energy efficiency among our key issues. Indeed, we had many discussions regarding climate change at the summit as well. And on November 30, we will hold a meeting in Paris, which we can call the final, and we hope to participate in this meeting.

Valued guests;

In 2015, in addition to the G-20 Term Presidency, Turkey also held the term presidencies of organizations such as the Global Migration and Development Forum and D-8, and we hosted the 12th Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification. In the upcoming period, we will host many events in Istanbul and various cities, such as the 13th Islamic Summit of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, the 23rd World Energy Congress in 2016, and the World Petroleum Congress in 2017. We place great importance on the 2016 World Humanitarian Summit, which will be a first in the world.

These developments are not coincidental. They are a result of the active foreign policy approach we have pursued decisively and consistently over the past 13 years. In the upcoming period, we will continue our efforts to contribute to the humanitarian development, growth, and stability of our country, our region, and the entire world.

With these sentiments, I conclude my remarks by thanking everyone who contributed to the organization of this meeting. I extend my condolences to the families of all those who have fallen victim to terrorism in Paris, Ankara, Gaziantep, Beirut, and various parts of the world, wishing healing to the injured.

I greet you all with love and respect. Stay healthy.