15. Speech at the Mukhtar Meeting

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

26 November 2015 · 15th Mukhtar Meeting · Presidential Complex

Context
Erdoğan addressed the 15th Mukhtar Meeting at the Presidential Complex on November 26, 2015, hosting local representatives from ten Turkish provinces to discuss national and regional issues.
Main themes
Syrian crisis, Turkish foreign policy, regional identity and historical ties, mukhtar meetings, Middle East and North Africa, terrorism and separatism, political criticism and opposition, human suffering in conflict zones, Ottoman heritage and civilization, national interest versus partisan politics
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,924
91st percentile
Sentences
276
94th percentile
Readability
55
78th percentile
Grade
9.9
19th percentile
Syntax
2.89
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
48th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 53%50%
  • Institutional 17%16%
  • Social 15%14%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

276 sentences in 62 paragraphs

Dear esteemed mukhtars,

Dear brothers and sisters;

I greet you with my heartfelt affection. Welcome to the Presidential Complex, the house of the nation.

We are together for the 15th meeting of mukhtars that we have been holding since January. Today, we are hosting you, our valuable mukhtars from Diyarbakır, Edirne, Erzurum, Gaziantep, İzmir, Malatya, Mersin, Samsun, Tokat, and Trabzon. We aim to bring together all the mukhtars in our country in this way, to converse and to alleviate our longing.

Our meetings with mukhtars are not merely about alleviating longing; through these gatherings, we consult on the issues of our country and the world with our mukhtars, representing our entire nation. The evaluations we make here are closely followed by all 81 provinces and all 78 million citizens, as well as by the whole world.

Currently, we have the Syrian crisis, which is deepening and gaining new dimensions on our agenda. The issue of Syria is, like Iraq, Egypt, Libya, the Balkans, Crimea, and the Caucasus, one of our fundamental issues. Our perspective on this entire geography can never be like that of other countries. The viewpoints of other countries towards these regions and the people living there can change according to the conditions of the day, their own interests, and the conjuncture.

We must regard every issue in this vast geography, to which we are bound by history, culture, faith, brotherhood, and, in short, a common destiny, as our own issue. In this respect, there are very deep differences between our approach to the Syrian issue and the approaches of other countries. When we look at Syria, we see not only Turkmen, Arabs, Kurds, Sunnis, Alawites, but all the social segments with whom we have lived together for thousands of years, even though our borders have been separate for a century, our hearts remain united.

We feel the destruction and devastation caused by every bomb dropped on Syria in our own hearts. We feel the pain of every innocent child, woman, and man who dies there in our own hearts. With every artifact destroyed in this geography, where the most ancient traces of humanity and civilization lie, a piece of our memory is erased. Just as we feel for what happened in Bosnia and Karabakh, we feel the same for Syria today. We cannot close our eyes or hearts to any issue, any problem, or any segment in our geography.

The Middle East and North Africa may be a quagmire for others. But for us, those places are an inseparable part of our thousand-year-old memories. The Caucasus, the Balkans, Central Asia, and the Fergana Valley may be considered "problematic regions" by others. For us, they are the most valuable elements of our ancient history and civilization. It is the global injustice that humanity has been subjected to that has turned these places into a "quagmire," a "crisis region," or a "conflict zone," and we must see it this way. This issue is about the trampling of human life for the sake of power struggles. That is why we say, "The world is bigger than five."

Those who do not know the deep-rooted history of our nation and geography may not understand our sincerity regarding the problems in our region, especially in Syria. Indeed, they do not understand. You see someone with "professor" in front of their name; but they cannot grasp this nuance, this sensitivity, and they come out and say, "Here is Turkey's situation in the policies being pursued in the Middle East." This is not their job; they do not understand. They are not "fallen from the roof"; they are merely those who look at events with an ideological mindset and logic. They do not calculate where the interests of this country lie, where the interests of this nation lie. They only calculate, "What is the interest of our political party?"

We look for the nation, we look for our country, and we make our decisions accordingly. Those who think like others and take stances like others on issues concerning the fate of the country and the nation are rootless and disconnected from their values; know this.

Unfortunately, we see that this group has a treasonous attitude regarding the actions of the separatist terrorist organization. We witness the same group taking a similar stance in the bomb attacks of ISIS. In the recent incident at our Syrian border, this group has once again revealed its character. In fact, we know that they are a handful of minorities among 78 million. I do not evaluate this from the perspective of minority rights; but I want to express that they are in the absurdity of being able to dominate over the majority. Despite all this, we feel sorrow. Thank God, our nation has always given them their lesson with its wisdom, discernment, and understanding.

We will continue to fulfill our responsibilities towards our history and geography within the framework of the authority granted to us by our nation. We will continue to stand by our brothers in their struggle for liberation in Syria. We are of the same lineage with them; we have kinship ties with them. We are not fighting on order.

We know that a scenario played out in Afghanistan is now being implemented under a different name in Iraq and Syria. We are aware that the project carried out under the name of ISIS has been attempted to be turned into a tool for a discriminatory, racist, and Islamophobic campaign against Muslims worldwide. Those who claim to be carrying military power to Syria under the guise of fighting ISIS, but have targeted moderate groups that have fought against the regime without causing almost any harm to ISIS until today, have a clear goal.

Dear friends,

Today, I want to clearly express the issue of ISIS and share it with you. Thus, we will have seen the true faces of those who are pursuing to design the region and implement different projects regarding the region by using this organization as an excuse.

I want to sincerely express that there is almost no country other than Turkey that is seriously fighting against the organization known as ISIS. Turkey recognized this organization as a terrorist organization under its former names in 2005. Since 2013, we have continued our struggle against this structure, which we also recognize as a terrorist organization under its new name, without interruption.

Therefore, Turkey's stance regarding ISIS has been clear from the very beginning; there is no question mark here. Whether from within or outside, no one has the right to make Turkey's fight against ISIS a subject of debate or to put us under suspicion in this regard. As the President of the Republic of Turkey, I said this during my term as Prime Minister, and I say it now: We are the country that has suffered the most and has been victimized in this regard.

Dear brothers and sisters,

We have been subjected to the actions of the ISIS terrorist organization in Niğde, Şanlıurfa, Ankara, Diyarbakır, and Gaziantep. To date, we have lost 140 citizens in ISIS attacks, and we have martyred 7 security personnel. Similarly, there have been clashes between our security forces and members of this organization at our border from time to time. In response, we have conducted an uninterrupted struggle against the organization. Since 2011, approximately 3,000 individuals affiliated with this organization, under both its old and new names, have been detained, and about 800 of them have been arrested.

A total of 33 ready-to-use suicide vests, along with numerous weapons and explosives, have been seized from the members of the organization and the places they stayed. In the context of combating foreign terrorist fighters, entry bans have been imposed on 27,000 individuals into our country. Additionally, 2,600 individuals identified as having come to our country for the same purpose have been captured and deported.

Thanks to the measures we have taken at our borders to prevent fuel smuggling, which is one of the most important sources of income for ISIS, 79 million liters of smuggled fuel were seized in 2014. Fuel smuggling at our borders has almost reached the stage of being eradicated. We are engaged in such an intense struggle against ISIS, both in terms of its actions and its methods of recruitment, as well as its sources of income. Pay attention, some of the countries conducting military operations in Syria under the guise of fighting ISIS have only targeted regime-opposing dissidents.

Now, I say this here, addressing my nation watching us on screens, and at the same time addressing the world media: Dear brothers and sisters, there is no ISIS in the regions of Latakia and northern Latakia, where the Bayırbucak Turkmen are located; let no one deceive us and the world. And as a result of the bombings carried out here by aircraft, more than 300 Bayırbucak Turkmen have died within 1-1.5 months, and now the Bayırbucak Turkmen are trying to seek refuge towards our borders. Some of them have settled in our camps. But some say, "We will be martyred on our land." This morning, I spoke with the President of AFAD, and he said, "They do not want to come. We say our camps are ready, come." "No, we will be martyred here. Provide us with humanitarian aid; that is enough for us, we will continue to live in these tents," they say. And you know, yesterday, two trucks carrying humanitarian aid were unfortunately burned by bombing, and 3 people were martyred, and 7 were injured.

Now, what do they say to the world with all this? "We are fighting against ISIS." Excuse me, you are not fighting against ISIS; you are unfortunately collaborating with the regime to empty northern Latakia, killing our Turkmen brothers and Syrian citizens. There are also those who fall into the error of supporting other terrorist organizations operating in the country under the guise of fighting ISIS. As Turkey, we express that we oppose ISIS and all other terrorist organizations in the same way, as well as the Assad regime, which applies state terrorism against its own citizens. Because the biggest supporter of ISIS is the Assad regime.

Now they say, "Turkey buys oil from ISIS." Those in the relevant authorities say this. It is very shameful; it is a disgrace. Turkey's sources of oil and natural gas are clear. We make the largest imports from Russia at this point, and secondarily from Iran. We receive natural gas from Azerbaijan and from Northern Iraq as well. In addition, we import LNG from Algeria and Qatar; our sources are clear. Those who claim that we buy oil from ISIS in this way are obliged to prove their claims. Otherwise, no one can slander this country; I would label them as slanderers.

ISIS sells the oil it produces to Assad. Talk to the Assad you support about this; it sells it there, and it gets the money from there. The source of the money is already clear. We would not want to come to this point. If one is to look for the backing of ISIS's arms and financial power, the first place to look should be the Assad regime and the countries that act together with it.

Those who target the opposition groups recognized as the true representatives of the Syrian people by 120 countries are directly supporting ISIS. What struggle is the moderate opposition there fighting? They are fighting to reclaim their lands from the murderer Assad. Assad is a person who instills state terrorism. Those who do not stand against Assad, who has killed 380,000 people, should know that they will not be able to account for this before history. How can you stand alongside this? Can those who stand alongside this talk about the Universal Declaration of Human Rights? Can those who stand alongside this talk about human rights? It is because we stand against these that the interest networks do not like it. But we have always stood with the oppressed against the oppressors, and we will continue to do so.

Let no one forget this; our country has a border of 911 kilometers with crisis-ridden Syria. It shares a border of 384 kilometers with Iraq. The people living on both sides of the border are connected by thousands of years of kinship, friendship, and brotherhood. Antep and Aleppo, Hatay and Idlib, Urfa and Raqqa, Mardin and Hasakah are cities that are parts of a whole, but belong to two different countries. For the people in these regions, the barbed wire drawn at the borders and the passports carried in pockets have a different meaning; the meaning of brotherhood in their hearts is different. Turkey's open-door policy and humanitarian aid efforts across the border are a requirement of our responsibilities towards our brothers.

Similarly, Turkey is a country that hosts 37 million tourists annually. Nevertheless, we are making great efforts to prevent the passage of foreign terrorist fighters. In addition to entry bans and deportation practices, we have established risk analysis units at various airports and bus terminals. In this context, we have subjected over 5,000 foreigners to interviews, and we did not allow the entry of those whose situations were deemed suspicious. However, this issue cannot be solved solely by the measures taken within Turkey's borders. The most important thing is for the source countries to engage in close cooperation with Turkey, sharing information and intelligence.

Now I ask the countries that speak to us and make accusations: Our actions and results in the fight against ISIS are clear; what have you done? I ask those who target the opposition under the pretext of ISIS and those who remain silent about them: Are the ones who killed 1,500 innocents in Ghouta with chemical weapons the opposition? Are the ones who condemned tens of thousands of Palestinians in Yarmouk Camp to starvation the opposition? Are the ones who have killed 380,000 people, regardless of women, children, the elderly, and men, with conventional weapons, barrel bombs, missiles, and heavy weapons the opposition? Are the ones who have forced 12 million people to migrate from their homes the opposition? Who is responsible for the 11,000 victims who were tortured and starved to death, documented with 55,000 photographs? The Assad regime is responsible for all of this.

Those who appear on television screens and try to charge Turkey's administration with only ideological perspectives say that my meetings with Assad during those positive periods were once very good, that they used to come together as families, and that at that time...

"Wasn't he a dictator?" At that time, there was no Assad in front of me who had killed tens of thousands of people. And my advice to him back then was: "Come to democracy as soon as possible, we will provide you with all kinds of support in this regard." And although he sent his men to us, he could not return there. Why couldn't he return? Because returning to a multi-party political life was not in his interest. Later, the Jasmine Revolution that started in Tunisia, its continuation in Egypt, and then its arrival here must have created some hesitations.

My brothers,

What ISIS has done is absolutely unforgivable, this organization can never be tolerated. Not only this, but the PYD, YPG, the PKK in our country, Boko Haram, and Al-Shabaab are the same. Unfortunately, they are currently taking truly unforgivable steps with their actions in the world. And we know very well that ISIS has caused the greatest harm to Islam and Muslims. But it must also be seen that the Assad regime is no different from ISIS; there is no difference between organizational terrorism and state terrorism.

For those killed in Paris, our hearts burned as much as for our losses in Ankara; we showed the same sensitivity in Suruç, we showed it in Gaziantep, and we have constantly voiced these. We also show this for the innocents who are slaughtered by the regime and terrorist organizations on Syrian soil, and we expect this from everyone.

The incident that occurred in Hatay on Tuesday morning needs to be evaluated in this context. I want to express upfront that this is definitely not an event targeting Russia. Turkey, as a country that has experienced similar troubles with elements affiliated with the Assad regime and terrorist organizations, is on alert regarding the security of its land and airspace. In accordance with the engagement rules we announced earlier and reminded Russia of repeatedly, we respond immediately to violations of our country's borders. This is an automatic response that has been pre-authorized; this must be understood. We have experienced similar incidents 1-2-3-4 times before. On Tuesday morning, the rules were applied when an aircraft with an unknown affiliation and nationality persistently violated our border despite all warnings. Two planes were approaching the border, but their nationality was unknown, and 10 warnings were made within 5 minutes. Look, these warnings are now being broadcasted by the Armed Forces on television. The nationality of the aircraft was only understood after the incident. Believe me, like all events in Syria, this incident has saddened us greatly. Because we have been striving from the very beginning to ensure that no one dies in the region, that no one's nose bleeds.

Technical explanations regarding the matter have been made by our General Staff and our Ministry of Foreign Affairs to all relevant countries and institutions, especially Russia. Nevertheless, we are following the statements made by Russia and the reactions expressed in unrelated areas with sadness. We have a strategic partnership with Russia, we have a High-Level Advisory Council called UDIK. But our unity requires solidarity. This unity does not require us to threaten each other in this sense; this has saddened us.

Moreover, the violation of our airspace by aircraft of unknown affiliation and nationality, despite warnings, and the fact that this has been done 3 or 4 times before is, of course, a step taken for security reasons. The situation we are currently in with Syria is evident. We are striving to ensure peace and tranquility, not to create new tensions in the region. There is no reason for us to target Russia without any border violation, given our multifaceted and strong relations.

Disagreeing with Russia on Syria policy is one thing; implementing our engagement rules is another. Our objections to attacks initiated under the pretext of fighting ISIS, but only targeting the opposition, continue. Our decision to establish a humanitarian security zone along our Syrian borders from Cerablus to the west, together with allied countries, is also ongoing. If you pay attention, our efforts are aimed at clearing our Syrian borders of ISIS and other terrorist organizations.

Supporting the opposition elements fighting against the Assad regime is an effort with international legitimacy. Supporting the Assad regime and terrorist organizations is entirely the decision of the relevant country and lacks international legitimacy. I express once again from here; we support the moderate opposition fighting against the Assad regime, the Bayırbucak Turkmen, and we will continue to support them. Because they are the oppressed, they are the victims. They are the rightful owners of the lands there; we are relatives, and they are our compatriots.

There is no direct military intervention against either Russia or any other country. We expect everyone to respect our sovereign rights and show sensitivity to these rights. We do not find it appropriate to expand a situation that the whole world acknowledges we are right about to include our political and economic relations. If the same violation were to happen today, Turkey would have to respond in the same way. In this regard, it is the country that commits the violation that must question itself, take measures to prevent the recurrence of the incident.

Dear brothers,

As you know, Turkey experienced a historically significant election on November 1. The picture that emerged after the June 7 elections, threatening the stability and security environment of our country, completely changed on November 1.

Can a statement be made like this? "There is an effort by the administration, the administrators to Islamize Turkey"? So, I, the government, we are trying to Islamize Turkey. Ninety-nine percent of Turkey is Muslim; how can you say this? How can such a statement be used? Can I say about Russia, "The administration is trying to Christianize Russia"? There are 30 million Muslims there as well. What a wrong approach this is! Tayyip Erdoğan is a Muslim, ninety-nine percent of this country's population is Muslim; then what am I trying to do? We are just trying to fulfill the requirements of our religion, that's all; this is what we do, but look at the assertion, look at this mistake.

Is the stoning of our embassy, the breaking of its windows and frames, a correct approach? We have always opposed such actions by extremists and fanatics with our security forces; we have always prevented them.

Are these important? We do not care much about them. But we are strategic partners. Do these approaches suit politicians? Are these things that should happen? First, politicians need to sit down and discuss where the mistake was made, our military needs to sit down and discuss, and then these mistakes need to be mutually corrected; we need to look at this. If we do not look at this and make emotional statements like this, it would not be right. Just the other day, we sat down beautifully at the G-20, held inter-delegation meetings, had face-to-face discussions, and discussed the Syrian issue repeatedly among us, but then for something like this to happen has saddened us.

Look, on Tuesday, November 17, when the Parliament convened, without wasting any time, I gave the task of forming the government to the Chairman of the AK Party, Mr. Ahmet Davutoğlu, and on Tuesday, November 24, we officially started government work by approving the Cabinet list presented to me by Mr. Davutoğlu. Yesterday, Mr. Prime Minister presented the Government Program to the Parliament. On Saturday, discussions on the Government Program will take place in the Parliament. On Monday, a confidence vote will be held, and this process will be completed. Thus, Turkey will continue on its way with a government that has the support of 49.5% of the people after a break of about 6 months. Once again, I pray to God that the results of the elections and the new government will be beneficial for our country, our nation, and our citizens.

Since March 2014, Turkey has been under the heavy burden of four consecutive elections. Although the negative impact on the economy has been very limited, we must also acknowledge that this series of elections has left us behind our targets in investments, growth, employment, and interest rate reductions.

Especially the results of June 7 have made everyone very anxious. We all experienced and saw that in a country that has been accustomed to being governed by strong single-party governments for over 12 years, no one was willing to accept the possibility of a coalition. We need to leave this anxious period behind and refocus on our 2023 targets. I see the fact that the government has largely been formed in a way that will ensure the continuity of the past 13 years as a gain for Turkey. This means that ongoing efforts will be carried out with determination, that projects on the agenda will be rapidly implemented, and that strength will be gathered for new projects.

As you know, there is a new airport being built in Istanbul, with a capacity of 150 to 200 million passengers, which will be completed in its first phase in 2018 and hopefully fully completed in 2024, and will perhaps be the number one in the world. There is a Yavuz Sultan Selim Bridge that will connect Asia and Europe, with 4 departures, 4 arrivals, and a high-speed train passing through the middle, and it will also pass next to this third airport.

There is Marmaray, where trains go back and forth, and a double-deck Eurasia Tunnel, where cars will pass, a little further south. We laid the foundation; now, hopefully, it will be completed next year. The drilling process has now finished, and the scorpion has emerged from Ahırkapı. These show one thing. What is that? It shows the New Turkey. New Turkey cannot be achieved with words; this is how New Turkey is achieved.

Look now, there are very important transportation projects like the Izmit Gulf crossing, which connects Istanbul to Izmir and reduces the travel time to 2.5-3 hours, and hopefully, projects like Kanal Istanbul and high-speed train lines. The construction and commencement process of these is rapidly continuing, hopefully.

We have an important project that we have set as a target ahead of us. What is that? The Çanakkale Strait crossing bridge... As you know, the passage of car ferries there becomes very problematic when the weather is bad. When this bridge is built, that problem will be eliminated. Projects like new high-speed train lines are continuing.

We attach great importance to the Akkuyu and Sinop nuclear power plants in terms of energy supply security, and hopefully, a step will also be taken regarding the third one.

Similarly, in the upcoming period, with the physical renewal of education and culture policies, as I mentioned in the teacher meeting the other evening, we have a problem with the content, meaning we need to strengthen the inside of the envelope. Therefore, we need to implement a strong national curriculum in national education; perhaps this has been the area where we have been the weakest in the 12-year process.

In our cultural policies, we need to reach a much stronger point with an intensive step, an intensive program, both nationally and internationally. I know that our government is seriously preparing in this regard. Thank God, as Turkey completes its infrastructure deficiencies, it has risen to a very different level in terms of increasing its capabilities.

Of course, the most important thing is the new Constitution. Despite my great efforts and hard work during my premiership, I am saddened that we could not provide Turkey with a new constitution. Because four political parties came together and said, "We do not look at our numbers; each party should send 3 members, let’s establish a constitutional monitoring committee here and do this with 3 members." Of course, commissions are not formed like this; in Parliament, commissions are formed according to the number of your members. But we gave up on the number here and said, "Come on, let’s just do this." And it reached up to 60 articles, but it got stuck there. Demands came, and I sent my friends. They discussed, but no, all four signatures must be there. The others do not agree. We said to the main opposition party, "Come, let’s finish this together," but they did not come. I hope that now our political parties will sit down on the new constitution, which is a very important expectation of our people, and if the four of them do it together, it would be magnificent. If they do not, the government and the main opposition should actually carry this out. During this period, I sincerely wish for Turkey to attain its new constitution. As President, there should be no doubt that I will be in a position to encourage and pave the way for this.

No one should be disturbed by the discussion of the presidential system within the scope of new constitution preparations. Whether it is a partisan presidency or a presidential system, why should we be disturbed by this? We held the G-20 here, right? Almost all of the leading G-20 countries are governed by a presidential system, and they came to these positions that way. Look at the world; most developed countries have either a presidential system or a semi-presidential system. Due to the distribution of deputies in the Parliament, the new constitution must be prepared with the consensus of more than one party. Similarly, the prepared constitution will ultimately be submitted to the approval and appreciation of the nation. Therefore, the preparations for the new constitution need to be carried out courageously. Why are we afraid of the nation? Let’s prepare it, let’s go to the nation, and let the nation decide. Let them say yes or no.

Our nation has truly deserved the new constitution with its strong struggle for democracy over the past 13 years. At the point we have reached, this cannot go on with the coup constitution. No matter how much we change it, it has turned into a patched-up quilt. Therefore, dear brothers, insisting on continuing with the current constitution is of no benefit to anyone. I believe that common sense will prevail in the 26th Term Parliament, and the voice of our nation will be heard. With these thoughts, I once again wish success to the 64th Government of our Republic, to our Prime Minister, and to the ministers in the Government.

I express my gratitude to you, esteemed muhtars, for your interest in the issues of our country and our nation. I thank each of you separately for honoring the Presidential Complex, the house of the nation.

I kindly ask you to convey my greetings, respect, and affection to my brother.

We will be together again shortly for dinner; for now, I greet you all with love and respect, and I say may God be our helper and supporter.