Speech at the Dokuz Eylul University International Conference on Migration: Projections for the Next Twenty Years and Beyond

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

22 February 2021 · Dokuz Eylul University International Conference on Migration · Dokuz Eylul University

Context
Erdoğan addressed an international academic conference on migration at Dokuz Eylül University in February 2021, marking the 70th anniversary of the Geneva Convention on Refugees.
Main themes
Migration and refugee crisis, Turkey's refugee hosting role, humanitarian failures in Mediterranean and Aegean, Western countries' burden-sharing failures, Geneva Convention 70th anniversary, causes of displacement, pushback incidents and human rights violations, historical Turkish hospitality, global migration statistics, developing countries bearing refugee burden
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,480
67th percentile
Sentences
129
75th percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 42%41%
  • Geopolitical 33%32%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

129 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Esteemed Administrators of Dokuz Eylul University,

Honorable Professors,

Valued Participants,

Dear Students,

I greet you with my warmest feelings and respect. I am very pleased to be with you on the occasion of the International Migration Conference.

I especially wish for the success of the conference organized under the theme of the projection of migration for the next 20 years and beyond. I congratulate Dokuz Eylul University, which brings together distinguished experts in the field of migration, as well as the esteemed Rector and University Senate.

The fact that the conference is held on the 70th anniversary of the Geneva Convention on the Status of Refugees adds a special meaning to this gathering. I believe that the views expressed here will prompt us to rethink the causes of migration and its social, cultural, political, and economic effects. I would like to extend my gratitude, on behalf of myself and my nation, to all the academics and experts participating in the conference from both domestic and international backgrounds for their contributions.

We see that the issue of migration has occupied the global agenda, especially in recent years. We are experiencing the largest human mobility since World War II. Every year, millions of people leave their homes due to reasons such as wars, internal conflicts, instability, famine, terrorism, and poverty. The number of migrants worldwide has reached 272 million, the number of displaced persons has reached 80 million, and the number of refugees is approaching 26 million, meaning that 3% of the world’s population lives as migrants. In this human mobility, we sometimes encounter many heartbreaking scenes. Journeys undertaken in hopes of building a safe future, fleeing from oppression, persecution, and hunger, sometimes end in disaster. In the recent past, nearly 30,000 migrants, most of whom were women and children, lost their lives in the Mediterranean. The scorching sands of the Sahara Desert have become the grave of thousands of hopeful travelers. We just watched on the screen; we have not forgotten, nor can we forget, the humanitarian dramas experienced in the Aegean, especially that of baby Aylan. We remember very well how these oppressed individuals, who challenged the raging waves on their journeys filled with great dreams, had their boats deliberately sunk.

Humanity has failed not only in the Mediterranean but also in the Aegean and the Meriç. The dreams of migrants for a safe life have been buried in the waters of the Aegean by those who push them to death. In 2020 alone, there were nearly 9,000 pushback incidents in the Aegean. The whereabouts of tens of thousands of Syrian children who sought refuge in Europe are unknown, as are the identities of those who have kidnapped them.

While Western states constantly complain about migration, it is the developing countries that bear the main burden of this issue. Approximately 85% of the world’s refugee population is hosted not by wealthy states but by countries with much more limited resources. Those who use a few hundred refugees as a marketing tool do not take responsibility in the face of this crisis, which is directly related to human life. The data from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees clearly reveals this reality. According to the figures from the High Commissioner for Refugees, in 2020, only 39,500 of the 1.44 million refugees waiting to be resettled in third countries were placed in 25 Western countries. Meanwhile, Turkey has hosted over 4 million refugees on its own. Those who advise Turkey to open its borders have closed theirs during this process and turned their backs on refugees. We have even witnessed shameful scenes where Greek security forces openly persecuted refugees at the Turkey-Greece border, and the European Union Agency Frontex has also been complicit in these human rights violations.

Turkey, dear friends, is a country that is not at all foreign to the phenomenon of migration, located at the crossroads of continents and cultures. For centuries, we have been at the center of human mobility between east and west, north and south. We have opened our doors to millions of people who have suffered persecution, oppression, and discrimination due to their faith, color, or culture, including Jews fleeing the Inquisition. We have a state tradition that says, "I will give my throne, I will give my crown, but I will never give up the oppressed who seek refuge in my state."

Our brothers in the Caucasus and our compatriots in the Balkans have always sought refuge in our lands when they faced difficulties. Hundreds of scientists persecuted by the Nazis found refuge in our universities in the 1930s. During World War II, Turkish diplomats in Europe risked everything to save hundreds of refugees from genocide with Turkish passports. We opened our doors to hundreds of thousands of Kurdish brothers fleeing Iraq after the Halabja massacre and during the First Gulf War. We embraced our compatriots who had to migrate from Crimea, Ahıska, Turkistan, and Bulgaria. Throughout history, we have been a safe haven and a compassionate home for all those who have faced oppression and genocide.

We have never turned away anyone who came to our borders due to their ethnic identity, religion, culture, sect, or denomination.

Since the onset of the conflict in Syria, we have once again fulfilled this historical responsibility by providing shelter to millions of migrants. While countries with far greater resources than ours confine refugees to camps, we have shared our bread with these people. Just as we have supported Syrian Turkmen, we have also stood by our Kurdish brothers from Kobani. I remember a night when President Obama called me while he was in office and said that the Kurds in Kobani were in a difficult situation and asked for our support in opening our doors. I asked him, "How will this happen?" His response was, "These people are facing death right now. So, what will you do?" I received the answer: "If necessary, we will drop all kinds of ammunition here by plane." I cannot participate in this operation because I see what lies beyond it. Beyond that operation, there was a serious war at stake. And indeed, it turned out to be so, and thousands of our Kurdish brothers lost their lives in that operation. Nevertheless, we opened our doors, and tens of thousands of Kurdish people from Kobani are still in our country. We did not close our doors to them. We also supported our Arab brothers in Aleppo. We opened our doors wide to Christians, Yazidis, Assyrians, and many others of different faiths alongside Muslims.

Now, look at the new developments; in northern Syria, an American general interestingly says, "We are currently with the PKK-YPG-PYD." What kind of alliance is this between two countries in NATO? They have no concern for supporting refugees; their concerns are different. They are still with terrorists. Of course, we continue our fight against terrorism and terrorists everywhere, and we will continue to do so. Friends, as long as they act as friends, we will open our hearts, but if they do not, we will continue to do what we have done until now. We have provided the same services to these suffering people that we provide to our own citizens, without expecting anything in return.

In the regions we have cleared of terrorism in northern Syria, we have also prevented a major migration crisis. We have done all this not for profit or publicity, but as a requirement of our faith, belief, and culture. In fact, during this process, we have seen that many of the promises made to our country have not been kept. I will not name names; these are leaders you all know very well. And these leaders said here, in Idlib, in northern Syria, "Let’s build brick houses, let’s take a step," and when we asked how many of these brick houses could be built, they said, "How many shall we build?" We said we wanted to build about 50,000 or 100,000 houses, and that you should take on part of this. Can you believe it? They did not keep their promise; they brought us water from 50 rivers in 50 different ways. But now, there in Suleyman Bey, has it reached 50,000? 52,000. We have built 52,000 brick houses. We wanted these people not to live in tents anymore; at least as humanely as refugees, we wanted them to live in these 50,000 brick houses, not in tents. Meanwhile, for example, even in this earthquake, we are hosting earthquake victims in 500-600 containers.

The European Union provided 3 billion euros in support for 100,000 refugees in Greece, which is very important; these are documented. However, it has not put its hand under the stone for the 4 million refugees in Turkey. When we come together and talk, it is always lies, lies, lies. "We gave this much, we gave that much," but where did you give it? You are not speaking the truth. Despite the time that has passed since the March 18 Agreement, the 6 billion euros promised to us have still not been fully sent. Even international media organizations have begun to see and acknowledge this reality. According to a recent report published in the international media, Turkey is the only state that has supported Syrian refugees. The only barrier to potential massacres is Turkey's military presence in this region. If we did not have our soldiers, it is clear what they would do. Because we are people who believe in the blessing of sharing and the power of solidarity, who believe that the world will change for the better and that the world stands on goodness; that is our difference.

As the security environment in northern Syria improves, the safe and voluntary return of Syrians in our country to their homeland is also accelerating. So far, 420,000 refugees have returned to the areas we have cleared of terrorism. As progress is made in the political solution efforts in Syria, and as stability and peace are strengthened, these returns will increase even more. We see that the separatist terrorist organization, which feeds off the instability in Syria, has increased its terrorist actions against safe zones, especially in recent days. Due to the treacherous attacks of the PKK-YPG, dozens of innocent civilians and children have lost their lives in just one month. We will not allow terrorists to disrupt the peace and security environment established by our country. Just as we have previously destroyed terrorist nests without looking at anyone when necessary, we will not hesitate to take the necessary steps towards other regions if attacks continue.

Valued Friends;

It is a great contradiction for societies that are established through migration, whose ancestors were migrants, to approach the issue of migration solely from a security-focused perspective. The phenomenon of migration, which has existed throughout history and will continue to exist, needs to be viewed from a broader perspective.

What is happening in the context of Syria has shown us that raising walls, surrounding borders with barbed wire, and even sinking migrants' boats is not the solution. It is not a moral stance to promote brain drain by taking the qualified individuals raised by the limited resources of underdeveloped countries and closing the door to those in need. Such policies will deepen the problems that lead to migration and cause new waves of migration. It is a great delusion to think that the issue of migration can be addressed by fueling xenophobia and Islamophobia. In an economic order where income inequality is so sharp, it is impossible to completely eliminate migration.

The coronavirus pandemic has exacerbated the difficulties faced by migrants, making the situation of these people, who already live in a fragile climate, even more difficult. The real issues that need to be confronted are those that feed migration, the reasons that force millions of people to leave their homes and homelands every year. We can begin this confrontation by acknowledging that the issue of migration, while it certainly has a security dimension, is primarily a humanitarian, political, and social issue.

As I have stated before, every migration is also a new encounter. It is the embrace of people with different ethnic identities, religions, languages, and cultures. We need to set aside our prejudices about migration and recognize the contributions of migrants to the countries and societies they go to. Among our brothers who have migrated from our country and continue their lives elsewhere, there are many individuals who have made significant contributions to their communities and humanity in every field, from science to art, technology to business. Similarly, there are those among the refugees who have settled in our country who have provided us with very important contributions through their efforts and expertise. Among them are engineers, lawyers, midwives, doctors, architects, and many others, and we benefit from many of them in various places.

As a country that has received migration for centuries and has also been a country of emigration since 1960, we are taking steps by considering both dimensions of the issue. While we do not compromise on our security, we do not view the phenomenon of migration solely through a security lens. While strengthening the capacity of our institutions that work on migration, we are also trying to benefit from good and successful examples around the world. We are aware that we can build a great and strong Turkey of tomorrow not by closing ourselves off but by opening up. Just as we mobilize all kinds of opportunities for foreigners who want to invest in Turkey, we will also provide the necessary facilitation for those who want to contribute to this country in education, science, art, and trade.

In particular, we will take different steps towards those who have received education in our country, developed a bond with our nation, and have a heartfelt connection with Turkey. We will continue to positively renew our policies regarding migration and migrants according to changing conditions and the needs of our country.

I believe that the discussions you will have within the framework of the conference and the ideas you will present will open new horizons for us in this regard. I must say this very clearly; you surely know as well as I do how those boats are inflated by the Greek police and the coast guard, and how those defenseless people die in the waters of that sea. We have told the world these truths, we are telling them, I have presented them visually, we are telling them. No matter what you say, it goes in one ear and out the other. But we will continue to tell.

As I conclude my remarks with these thoughts, I wish for the conference to be successful, and I congratulate Dokuz Eylul University once again.

I greet you with my warmest feelings and extend my thanks to everyone.

Stay safe.