Speech at the High-Level Event on "Combating Hate Speech"

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

25 September 2019 · High-Level Event on "Combating Hate Speech"

Context
Erdoğan addressed a UN high-level event on combating hate speech on September 25, 2019, co-organized by Pakistan's Prime Minister Imran Khan, on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly.
Main themes
Islamophobia and hate speech, discrimination against Muslims, rising racism and xenophobia, freedom of expression vs. hate speech, terrorist attacks on Muslims, accountability for crimes against humanity, religious freedom and tolerance, international community responsibility, populist politicians normalizing hatred, legislative gaps on hate crimes
Duration
~14 min
50th percentile
Words
1,722
50th percentile
Sentences
93
59th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.1
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 46%45%
  • Geopolitical 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

93 sentences in 23 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I greet you with my heartfelt feelings and respect. I pray that our meeting will be a harbinger of good.

On this occasion, I would like to express my gratitude to the Director of the Alliance of Civilizations for being present at this meeting, as it is very relevant to his area of responsibility.

Dear friends,

The content of our meeting is very meaningful. Of course, I would like to start my remarks by extending my condolences regarding the earthquake that occurred yesterday in the Azad Kashmir region, on the eve of the day we are holding this meeting. I pray for God's mercy on our brothers who lost their lives and wish a speedy recovery to the injured. As Turkey, we are ready to provide any assistance you may need.

I thank my dear friend Imran Khan for organizing this event.

Hate speech is the most common tool of rising Islamophobia, populism, racism, and xenophobia on a global scale. Unfortunately, such rhetoric is being normalized and becoming commonplace in social media, television programs, and the statements of politicians, both domestic and foreign, at all hours of the day. It should not be forgotten that the echoes of hate speech were first heard in the commission of the greatest crimes against humanity, from the Holocaust to Bosnia, from Rwanda to Myanmar. No one has held the West accountable for the massacres in Rwanda. Millions were killed there, yet no one asked the West how they could commit such a massacre, how they did it. Similarly, the international community has not drawn the necessary lessons from these painful experiences, each of which has left a dark stain on history.

As my brother Imran Khan just mentioned, the terrorist attack on two mosques in Christchurch on March 15, 2019, which resulted in the deaths of 51 Muslims, has shown the world the grave dimensions of this issue. Undoubtedly, this incident is an expression of a deep-seated hatred, obsession, and malignant hatred towards Muslims. On this occasion, I once again pray for God's mercy on our martyrs and extend my condolences to their families. I would like to thank the people of New Zealand for their exemplary attitude following the terrorist act. The Christchurch terrorist attack is neither the first nor the last attack targeting Muslims and innocent people. Before this, Muslims and communities of other faiths have been subjected to violence, bullying, and massacres. In 1993, neo-Nazis in Solingen cowardly martyred five of our citizens by setting their homes on fire. In 1994, an Israeli occupier martyred 29 Muslims praying at the Ibrahimi Mosque in Hebron and injured 125 others. In 2011, 77 lives were taken on the island of Utøya near Oslo by a perpetrator who believed in white supremacy. In 2015, three of our young people were shot and killed in their homes in Chapel Hill by a racist. In 2017, six Muslims lost their lives in a mosque attack in Canada.

Today, unfortunately, Muslims are the most affected by hate speech, cultural racism, discrimination, and insults to sacred values. Muslim workplaces, homes, and places of worship are targeted almost every day by racists and fascist groups. Muslim women are harassed in the streets, markets, and workplaces simply for wearing headscarves. As a country with 6.5 million people abroad affected by hate speech and attacks, we cannot turn a blind eye to this issue. I condemn once again the hate speech that is being normalized by populist politicians and the media.

The gaps in legislation must be corrected, and hate speech should never be framed within the context of freedom of expression. Doubts in people's minds about whether hate crimes will go unpunished must be eliminated. Complaints made to the police, judiciary, and other relevant authorities should be recorded and reported transparently, thus preventing the covering up of crimes under various pretexts.

Recently, especially in India, during a period intertwined with the events in Azad Kashmir, how will we defend the Muslim youth there who are whipped, even beaten with machetes, and condemned to death just for eating beef? How will we be able to advocate for their human rights? How can one say, "How can you eat beef?" Is such nonsense acceptable? Can there be such an approach to people? Then, are we also eating beef, what will happen to us? Are we supposed to ask them this? It cannot be expected that everyone is a vegetarian; such a situation is not possible. But the logic and mindset behind this, on one hand, you will talk about freedom of belief, and on the other hand, you will talk about freedom of thought, but this is not a requirement of my belief; it may be a requirement of your belief. I respect your belief; why do you not respect mine? Therefore, it is absolutely impossible to understand this duality.

In our country, there are those who eat pork; we have never intervened in this and do not intervene. Why? That is a requirement of their belief; they can eat it, and it does not concern us much. But it is impossible to understand their freedom of belief.

And right now, the situation in Azad Kashmir is indescribable, incomprehensible. It is as if Azad Kashmir has been turned into an open-air prison. The people here are practically imprisoned in this open-air prison, with entry and exit almost banned, and I cannot even imagine what kind of bloody actions will take place in that region tomorrow; I do not want to understand or explain it.

Valued friends,

The first step in combating hate speech, which feeds on ignorance, is education. And in light of these developments, the Indian Foreign Minister says that they do not find Turkey's approach to Azad Kashmir correct. So, are we going to determine our policy by asking the leaders of those countries about developments in any country or by obtaining their permission? Is there such a thing? It is absolutely impossible to understand or explain such a thing in world politics.

And all state institutions have important responsibilities in this regard; concrete initiatives carried out at the level of both inter-state and regional and global international organizations should be made more effective. Here, Mr. Director is present; we established the Alliance of Civilizations to eliminate these wrongs and to resist the clash of civilizations, and we said that if we succeed in this Alliance of Civilizations, we will prevent and cut off their paths. Of course, the point we have reached now is not a good sign with the developments in Azad Kashmir. We must concretize our initiatives under the umbrellas of organizations such as the United Nations, the Council of Europe, and the Organization of Islamic Cooperation and adopt a results-oriented approach.

The Secretary-General has announced the action plan for the protection of religious sites prepared by the Alliance of Civilizations. We support the idea of creating a database on hate speech at the United Nations. We also emphasize the importance of establishing a platform within the United Nations where those exposed to hate speech can quickly submit their complaints and follow up on them.

As Turkey, we will continue to lead efforts to combat rising Islamophobia, racism, and hate speech effectively. During our presidency of the Islamic Cooperation Organization Summit, we carried out significant work for cooperation on these issues. As my brother Imran just expressed, the West has constantly insulted our beloved Prophet in many ways, both in writing and visually, and we have always faced all of this with patience. However, we have never spoken ill of Jesus Christ, Moses, or David; they are all sacred to us, and we have always maintained that respect and opposed any insults directed at them because all prophets have maintained their place within that respect for us. Now we expect the same from the world.

Moreover, no one can label our religion as Islamist terrorism or Islamic terrorism. I always say that Islam comes from the Arabic word "slm," which means peace; therefore, Islam is a religion of peace. To associate the religion of peace, Islam, with terrorism is, excuse me, a very great slander, an immorality; such a thing is unacceptable and cannot be. Despite saying this everywhere, every faith has its terrorists; I just gave examples earlier, and these terrorists are evident, and there are those from different religions among them. Can we tarnish the religion they belong to for this? That is one thing; a terrorist is another. And we are fighting this in the same way, and we will continue to do so.

After the terrorist attack in New Zealand, we carried out significant initiatives in the Organization of Islamic Cooperation and the United Nations. To eradicate the root of the problem, we must take necessary steps together as states, international organizations, technology companies, educational institutions, media, and civil society organizations. Therefore, our determination right now is to quickly establish these steps in Jammu and Kashmir, to fully protect the rights of the Muslims living there, and to ensure their freedom of movement.

Do you know what I compare this to? I compare it to what is happening in Palestine right now. Can those in Palestine leave? No, they are also subject to the permission of the Israeli state.

Let me give one last example and conclude my remarks. As Prime Minister, I went to Israel, and while crossing from Israel to the Palestinian side, I was kept at the border with my wife for half an hour; I could not understand why I was being kept. I was in Tel Aviv for an official visit, and this incident happened to me while crossing from there. I have always told this story, I am telling it, and I will continue to tell it. This is the approach of the leaders of the Israeli state; if they like someone, the doors are open for them, but if they do not like someone, then the doors are closed. When it comes to words, they defend all freedoms; they appear to be in favor of them, but they are never sincere. Thank you very much.

As I conclude my remarks with these thoughts, I would like to thank the valuable friends who organized such an event that serves this purpose and all the participants.