"Together for a New Constitution" Themed Program Speech

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

28 January 2016 · "Together for a New Constitution" themed program

Context
Erdoğan addressed the Turkey Constitution Platform's 'Together for a New Constitution' themed program on January 28, 2016, calling for a locally-rooted new constitution.
Main themes
New constitution demand, civil society mobilization, national sovereignty, local and national identity, democratic legitimacy, opposition resistance, constitutional reform history, political unity, coup-era constitutional legacy, presidential governance
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,948
85th percentile
Sentences
211
90th percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 74%70%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Geopolitical 8%7%
  • Social 4%3%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

211 sentences in 63 paragraphs

Esteemed members of the Turkey Constitution Platform,

Dear brothers, ladies and gentlemen;

I greet you with my heartfelt feelings, with longing and affection.

Each of our 16 civil society organizations that have come together under the roof of the Turkey Constitution Platform; Anadolu Platformu, ASKON, Birlik Vakfı, Cihannüma Derneği, Ensar Vakfı, HAK-İŞ, HUDER, İHH, İlim Yayma Cemiyeti, İnsan ve Medeniyet Hareketi, MEMUR-SEN, MÜSİAD, ÖNDER, Türkiye Gönüllü Teşekküller Vakfı, TÜMSİAD, and TÜRGEV, deserves every kind of gratitude, appreciation, and recognition with their administrators, members, and hearts.

I have learned that the call of the Turkey Constitution Platform for "Together for a New Constitution" has been supported by approximately 300 civil society organizations so far. I believe this number will rise to much higher figures in a short time. I believe this is a call for the unity of the nation across the country, because this issue is not the concern of any institution or individual, but rather the concern of our nation itself.

The fact that our civil society organizations, which are sensitive to the preservation of our nation's values, are leading the issue of the new constitution is not a random situation or coincidence. The nation is taking ownership of the demand for a new constitution through the civil society organizations that represent it. For this reason, I thank you.

Everyone who believes in democracy must respect the nation's demand. Whoever turns their back on the nation and tries to walk a path against the nation will meet with failure.

Look at how the late Akif expresses the power of the nation in our National Anthem: "I am like a roaring flood, I break through the dam, / I tear apart mountains, I overflow into the vastness." When the nation roars, what dams can stand before it, and what mountains can resist? The issue of the new constitution has thus become a strong demand of our nation.

This meeting shows that the issue has reached a level that cannot be ignored, postponed, pushed aside, or brushed off. Our nation has now taken charge of the issue through civil society organizations.

With such meetings, workshops, and search conferences, the new constitution process, which encompasses all segments and reflects the needs and expectations of all segments, will mature rapidly. I would like to express my gratitude in advance to everyone who has contributed and will contribute to the work on the new constitution.

Because this issue is national, this issue is local. As the President, I am also present in every national and local issue, I say this clearly. All the constitutions established until today are imported, not local. And we have been governed by imported products, imported logics have dominated us; now we must turn to local and national.

Dear brothers,

Of course, every time we mention a new constitution, some people become seriously disturbed by it. Those who are disturbed by the new constitution must be satisfied. However, despite all the amendments made over the years, the current constitution is still a text that embodies the distrust towards the nation, carrying the spirit of the coups of 1960 and 1980.

There is a beautiful saying from the old days, "The reform of what is not practically possible is also not possible." Despite being constantly changed, the current Constitution is in a state of a text that cannot be reformed. In fact, the political and administrative order established by the current Constitution is very beneficial for the party and cadre that has governed this country for 13 years. But if one pays attention, the issue of the new constitution has been brought to the agenda by this cadre since the very beginning, from the early days of my premiership, and is being demanded strongly.

On the other hand, we see that the opposition, which should be the main stakeholder in this matter, is taking a completely opposite stance. As is known, after the 2011 elections, we took a serious step in this regard. Despite having a 60% majority in the Parliament, we ensured the formation of a commission with equal participation from every party that has a group. Our aim was to ensure the emergence of a constitution text with the widest possible participation. However, since other parties acted not to create a constitution text but rather to prevent the formation of a constitution text, the work of this commission was hindered.

So, did this situation deter our nation from the demand for a new constitution? No. Elections were held, on June 7, November 1, and during the presidential elections, when we talked about the new constitution, the squares were roaring. Why? Because the current Constitution or constitutions were too narrow for this body, they could no longer accommodate it. Just like today, the issue of the new constitution is being discussed, debated, and kept on the agenda in every platform that represents our nation.

What needs to be done here is to replace the delaying, evasive attitudes that turn a deaf ear to calls for a new constitution with sincere proposals. The more broadly representative the structure that builds the new constitution is, the stronger and more realistic its implementation will be.

For this reason, we especially expect the other parties represented in the Parliament, as well as you civil society organizations that voice different views and thoughts, to be included in the new constitution process. There is a saying, "The light of truth emerges from the clash of ideas"; that is, the light of truth, the light of reality, emerges from the clash of different ideas. Now you are doing this; we desire the preparation of the new constitution with a pluralistic understanding, not a majoritarian one.

Constitution texts are a social contract, and they should be so. However, the constitution texts we have are impositions, prepared as coup directives. Everyone here has lived their lives under the constitutions prepared by the coup makers since 1960; we have lived our lives under them. Let us gift a constitution made not by the coup makers but by this nation itself, by its representatives, to the generations that come after us. This new constitution should be a text that reflects the accumulation, culture, history, and aspirations of our nation with its spirit, language, and method. When we look at this constitution, the nation should see itself, its traditions, and its history.

In law, procedure is as important as substance; in science, method is as important as content. For this reason, we must determine the procedure in the making of the new constitution very well. We saw that the method used in 2011 did not yield results. It is so interesting that you give three representatives from four parties, and then consensus is reached on 47 articles. And the leader of the main opposition says, "At least let’s pass these through the Parliament." And I tell my friends, "Go discuss, let’s resolve this immediately." They go, and they say, "All four parties must approve this." "Here are the approvals of the four party representatives, look, they have initialed these parts," our friends say. "No, the party leaders must also approve this," they say.

Dear brothers,

Believing, being honest, is something else; it is very important. They start again, and they reach 60 articles; this time I tell my friends, "Go around again, if they are going to say yes to this, let them say yes, let’s take out these 60 articles, and then we can continue." The same answer comes back, "The other parties must also say yes to this." Our friends say, "Here, the four party representatives have approved these 60 articles, who are these representatives here for? They are here on behalf of those parties, and they say they have approved this by initialing." They say, "No, the party leaders must say yes to this." And again, it does not happen. Right now, these 60 articles remain as they are. In terms of learning who is honest and who is different in the evening and different in the morning, this work of 60 articles is actually a very important proof.

Now we must carry out a constitution writing process that will include all segments of our nation through our civil society organizations. We can only produce such a constitution text that is inclusive, not elitist, in this way. You know, sometimes I say Turkish-style presidency, we used to say this… We must be able to demonstrate the success of preparing a Turkish model constitution in this regard. Hasn’t the cadre that can write a constitution from within this nation been able to prepare one until now?

The nation is ready, but those who pretend to be elite, the politicians are not fully ready for this; that is where the problem lies. Otherwise, the nation is ready; the nation is already roaring in the squares, waiting for this. In our view, a constitution that expresses the principle of putting the nation at the center, "Live the people so the state lives," is the Turkish-style constitution.

Dear brothers;

One of the issues that will be most debated in the new constitution studies will undoubtedly be the issue of the separation of powers. In fact, our legislative body, the Parliament, is a heroic assembly, a founding assembly. We must ensure that the legislative body, the Parliament, focuses on its primary area. Therefore, I do not think we will experience too much difficulty in this regard.

None of us can object to the rule of law. If you say the supremacy of laws, there may be objections there, let me say that, but no one can object to the rule of law. The fundamental problem between the judiciary and the legislative and executive branches has been the understanding of the current constitution, which is based on conflict rather than the harmony of powers. When the spirit of the new constitution is created with the logic of support rather than mutual destruction, and with harmony and balance instead of conflict, this problem will naturally disappear.

I believe the issue of the executive will constitute the knot of the new constitution studies. We believe that the parliamentary system has fulfilled its term in our country. We think that there is a need for a new constitution and a presidential system to be implemented alongside the construction of the New Turkey.

I especially address my dear nation watching us on their screens; I want to correct this mistake upfront: The presidential system is not Tayyip Erdoğan's personal issue, let’s be clear about this. I have discussed this system during my presidency, I discussed it during my premiership, and I discussed it when I was the Mayor of Istanbul; I did not just start this now. We are studying this issue well. My bringing this issue to the agenda stems from my sincere belief that Turkey needs such a governance system to achieve its goals. Anyone who reduces the discussion of the presidential system to my person, rather than filtering it through reason, falls into this simplicity and incurs a great burden on our country and our nation. The issue is not about the person; it is about the future of the country.

If the presidential system is the right choice for the future of Turkey, it must be discussed and implemented without any complexes or prejudices.

In fact, discussions about the presidential system in our country are not new; this issue has been discussed and addressed in various aspects throughout the nearly 93 years of our Republic. In the last 56 years, which have passed under the shadow of coup constitutions, this discussion has never been absent. Almost all of our political leaders, whom we remember with mercy, including Turgut Özal, Süleyman Demirel, the late Erbakan, and the late Türkeş, have expressed positive views on the presidential system. Now those who come after them are making statements or applications that are completely contrary to them.

Today, for the first time in Turkey's history, it is not as an imposition of an extraordinary period, but as the nation's own choice, its own demand, that we can discuss the new constitution and the presidential system as a form of governance; this is our greatest advantage. Just this climate alone is a significant gain for our country.

What do we need to do? First; our people need to be further informed about the new constitution or the presidential system… Second; the explanation of this in televisions, newspapers, and the importance of informing our nation as soon as possible is crucial. Civil society organizations have already taken this step. This will not stop; our universities, especially law faculties, as well as international relations, economics, and economics faculties, have reached a point where these issues are now being discussed, and panels and symposiums are starting and will start there.

Another important advantage we have regarding the presidential system is that as of August 10, 2014, the president has begun to be elected directly by the nation; a step has been taken, this is in progress. It is inconceivable for any president elected with this system in our country to be in a purely symbolic position, isolated from the political agenda.

Dear brothers,

In fact, we cannot say that the presidents elected by the Parliament have completely remained outside the political agenda and used their powers impartially. Let’s not deceive ourselves; such a thing cannot happen. We experienced this reality ourselves between 2003 and 2007.

Dear brothers,

With the direct election of the president by the people, we are faced with a new and very important reality that goes beyond this de facto situation. This reality is that presidents will now carry out their duties as a political power. A president who comes to office by making many evaluations and commitments in the fields of domestic and foreign policy during the election process must, excuse me, stand behind their words. A president who expects to sit aside after coming out of the ballot box does not know this nation and does not understand politics; that is the truth. There can be no regression in the election system of Turkey's president. Our nation will not allow such a situation; the nation I know will not allow it; this is how I know this nation.

The important step that will complete this significant but unfinished move forward is our transition to the presidential system. Our current system is an abnormality; it is extraordinarily difficult for both an elected prime minister and an elected president to operate within this system. Today, as the President and Prime Minister, coming from the same political tradition and having worked together for many years, we are working in harmony. But I have also worked with a president who did not come from the same political tradition; I know what it brings and what it takes away. I have fallen from the roof; I know.

What will happen if the president and the prime minister have different priorities and come from different political understandings tomorrow? Did we not see this with the late Özal and the late Demirel? We did. Did we not witness the attacks they made on each other? We did.

Are we not going to learn from these experiences? We need to learn.

Our nation is well aware of how even the presidents elected by the Parliament in the past have caused difficulties for governments in such situations. The presidents emerging from the ballot box will be much more effective and courageous in every matter from now on.

Therefore, what we need to do is to take precautions today to prevent this crisis situation from arising and to complete the unfinished work, that is, to transition to a presidential system.

It is most appropriate for the new constitution to be prepared with this understanding. It is also clear that a new constitution process that completely disregards this need will be flawed from the outset. My proposal is to leave the decision to our nation. The Parliament should make a decision at this point, but after the Parliament's decision, the nation should be consulted, and the final decision should be made not by the representatives, but by the nation itself.

The issue of what the presidential system is and how it will be implemented is indeed a very broad area of discussion. There are many different applications of this system around the world. We should examine all of them and create a new and realistic system that suits our needs and culture, while also benefiting maximally from our existing knowledge.

Of course, this situation requires the restructuring of the entire system, from local governance to national governance. Turkey's need for this restructuring is already at a critical level. Based on my 40 years of political experience, I see and know that a system dominated by elected officials who are accountable to the people is what our nation demands, and I believe we have the knowledge and foresight to achieve this.

Dear brothers and sisters,

We have a beautiful proverb: "The horse neighs according to its owner." Undoubtedly, the people who will operate every system are those who will take responsibility there. A good manager can achieve beautiful results even with an average system; however, a good system can ensure that things do not fall below a certain level even with average managers. Unfortunately, our existing system is very open to fluctuations, instabilities, and crises. We are paying the price for this individually and as a society, as a nation.

Look, the crises of 1994 and 2001 were crises that arose in our country due to our internal dynamics during periods when there were no problems in the world and everything was going well everywhere. In contrast, the financial crisis that began in the world in 2008 continues to affect many countries, including developed ones. The same crisis, however, just grazed Turkey, in my words. Do you know why? Because Turkey was a country where stability and security prevailed. If we did not have a strong single-party government, I do not even want to think about what kind of situation the global financial crisis would have put us in. Turkey has paid the price for the political instabilities it has been subjected to in the past by facing economic and social crises.

Again, Turkey has achieved services equivalent to the previous 79 years of the Republic, and in many areas, even surpassing them, in the 13 years since November 2002. One of the most important factors behind this success is the uninterrupted maintenance of the stability and security environment. And I must also say that the personnel involved are of great importance. If we had tried to run this with the bureaucracy, we would have failed. We succeeded because we adapted it to ourselves. We succeeded because we did not say yes to its binding nature. We succeeded because we thought, "What does this bring me or where does it take me?" But some people, whom I always refer to as the bureaucratic oligarchy, bring the regulations and laws before you, and you cannot cope with them. Especially if you are a politician, you are doomed; this job cannot be accomplished.

Did we experience a hesitation for which we are still paying the price between the June 7 and November 1 elections last year? We did. Did every place turn into a pool of blood? It did. Why? The reason is clear; a coalition ground immediately emerged, and those who took advantage of this turned our country into a pool of blood. The presidential system has the ability to protect Turkey from such troubles and risks with the absolute stability it provides; its insurance systems are much stronger.

Since there will be no government crisis, election, or sudden change of course during the term of the president elected by the people, it will be easier to implement medium and long-term programs with determination. The executive, which will operate entirely under the president's responsibility, will also enable the legislative and judicial bodies, which will be relieved of the burden of this executive, to carry out their duties much more meticulously.

Dear brothers and sisters,

Discussions about the new constitution and the presidential system are being deliberately linked by certain groups to our unitary structure, our national integrity, and our national unity. However, what do we say? We say one nation. Regardless of their roots and beliefs—thank God our population is now close to 79 million—we are one nation... Then what do we say? One flag... We say that no other flag can wave in these skies except for our flag, which takes its color from the blood of our martyrs. Thirdly, one homeland... We say that we cannot allow any operation or surgery on our 780,000 square kilometers of homeland. Fourthly, what do we say? One state... Regardless of its name and rhetoric, we will not allow any state, parallel state, or parallel structure; we cannot allow it.

Just as we make the world a difficult place for those who want to create a parallel structure within the state under the guise of a so-called community, we will also bring down those who try to establish a state within a state under the guise of autonomy or self-governance; this must be understood.

Dear brothers and sisters,

While we say one nation, one flag, one homeland, one state, those who approach the issue with the rhetoric of division and fragmentation are, I say openly, definitely malicious, and they are the foremost of the separatists; know this.

We are the community of a Prophet who said, "There is mercy in unity, and there is torment in separation." We can only strive to make our country greater and our nation stronger. Our nation, that is, you, are witnesses to the fact that we have acted this way until today.

Everything that is national and local in these lands, whoever it may be, has a place above our heads. Likewise, it is our moral duty to fight against anyone or anything that stands against our country and our nation; I want this to be understood.

Because this country is not ownerless. This state, pay attention, I emphasize, is not rootless. This nation does not have a short memory. We know the value of the values we are entrusted with very well. What does Arif Nihat Asya say? "The hill of martyrs is not empty; heroes are waiting for its soil. / And a flag is waiting for the wind to wave. / The epic of the orphan, the silence of the unknown soldier. / His tomb is fitting for this blessed hill. / The soil he lies on is known, the flag he holds is known; who said unknown soldier?"

The soil where our ancestors lie is known, the flag we hold is known. With God's permission, we will not leave our flag waiting for the wind to wave. We will honor the sacrifices of our martyrs and veterans, we will bring our country to the 2023 targets, and we will realize our visions for 2053 and 2071.

With these feelings, I once again express my gratitude on behalf of myself and my nation to the Turkey Constitution Platform and all the civil society organizations that formed and supported the platform. I believe that millions will respond to your call for a new constitution, where the common value is human dignity and the common goal is a strong and great Turkey; do not have any doubt about this.

I thank each of you individually for your love, friendship, and loyalty to your promises; may God be your helper, and I say stay healthy.