- Context
- Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on May 24, 1937, during the Civil List debate, defending support for the new sovereigns and urging the Opposition not to force a Division on its Amendment.
- Main themes
- Civil List provision for the new sovereigns, abdication of King Edward VIII, proposed committee of inquiry into court ceremonial, practical importance of Monarchy ceremonial to the people, constitutional Monarchy as barrier against dictatorship, Disraeli on force and tradition, tradition and democratic freedom, Labour Amendment and call to avoid a Division, unity of present with past
- Duration
- ~5 min
- Words
- 608
- Sentences
- 17
- Readability
- 45
- Grade
- 15.4
- Syntax
- 3.29
- Vocabulary
- 2.13
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other17 sentences in 7 paragraphs
If it is said that the circumstances attending the abdication of King Edward VIII have introduced a new factor, I say that that new factor only tells in one direction, namely, that there should be added help to sustain and assist the new sovereigns who have come forward in the difficult circumstances that were created, and they should not be confronted at the outset of their reign with a prolonged committee of inquiry into the manner in which the hitherto traditionally observed ceremonial of the court has been conducted. At this time of all others it seems to me that the ceremonial attaching
48
to the Monarchy is of high practical importance to the masses of the people, and no one realises that with more assurance than the masses of the people themselves. We do not require a minority to tell us of the feelings which are evident in our fellow-countrymen.
The right hon. Gentleman talked of the false idea of the importance of the Throne. For my part, I consider that the ancient constitutional Monarchy of this country is the most effectual barrier against one-man power or dictatorship arising whether from the Right or from the Left. It has never been more valid and precious to democracy than it is at the present time. One of the most pregnant sentences of Mr. Disraeli, and one of those sayings which most deserve prolonged and repeated reflection and consideration, was when he said that nations are driven by force or by tradition. Here in this country we have seen tradition and custom giving us a decency and a security in our national life which no iron law, however brutally enforced, has been able to give to other countries. Long may it be the function of the Monarchy, sustained as it will be by Parliament and by the masses of the nation, to give that element of unity, of the present with the past, which, when all is said and done, is the greatest hope of our freedom in the future.
I did not rise at all to magnify the differences, because although the right hon. Gentleman has had to make this speech—I am sorry he has had to do so—and may still have to move his Amendment, yet it would be a great mistake if it were thought that there was any very deep, profound or large practical difference in the proceedings Upstairs upon the Civil List Committee, or that there is any real widespread right of opinion throughout this country as to the provision which should be made. The hon. Gentleman opposite laughs but he is in a minority of a minority, and we have to deal with majorities in this country, and we have a right to speak on behalf of the whole great mass of the nation. I hope, indeed, that the right hon. Gentleman, having made his protest in a dignified and moderate manner, though in a manner which could not avoid making a good many statements which are painful to some of us and excite controversy—I think that these remarks about the false importance of the Crown as a British
49
institution are painful to many people—I hope and trust that, having made his statement, he will let the action of his party rest upon that statement in its moderation, and will not force this matter to the test of a Division. I hope this for much wider reasons than purely party reasons; for such a line to be drawn as that of a Division is certainly one which could only conduce to further misfortune overtaking the party of which he is the leader.
