CLAUSE 148.—(Remission of States contributions.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

21 May 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill (Report stage) · House of Commons, Palace of Westminster, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on May 21, 1935, during the debate on Clause 148 of the Government of India Bill, arguing that so-called drafting amendments were concessions to the Princes.
Main themes
Government amendments described as drafting changes, concessions to the Indian Princes, sea customs and untaxed salt in the States, salt tax revenue of the Princes, Federal and Imperial taxation, bargaining with the Princes' legal advisers, scrutiny of legislation at Report stage, Secretary of State for India, eighteenth century diplomacy
Duration
~7 min
25th percentile
Words
851
25th percentile
Sentences
34
21st percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 65%59%
  • Economic 35%32%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Ceremonial 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

34 sentences in 7 paragraphs

But surely it is part of the general series of Amendments which are now being inserted. They are intended as being drafting Amendments, but what is their cumulative effect? It is to make or to endeavour to make this Clause more acceptable to the Princes concerned. Far from being a drafting Amendment it is part of the attempt to make what one might describe as a new deal with the Princes. It may be a small part but, at any rate, it is a part, and to pretend that it is simply a case of the draftsman looking over the Clause in retrospect and coming to the conclusion that he had put down something that was wrong and that he wanted half a page of the Order Paper in order to make the Clause more word perfect, is surely falling short of the actual truth. I have of ten seen, especially after Questions have come to an end early, the Government endeavouring to sweep through a whole set of Amendments by the mere suggestion that they are really drafting Amendments, or purely consequential on what we have already done. Therefore, the House ought always to look rather narrowly at the legislation which is passing through the House; otherwise, some parts of the Bill may slip through with out receiving that meticulous attention which it requires.

With regard to the proposed change, I have read and re-read the existing words and the words which it is pro posed to substitute for them, and it is clear that a greater assertion is to be made of the power of levying sea customs

958

and of producing and selling untaxed salt. I suppose that untaxed salt means salt which is immune from Federal taxation by the Government of India, but it does not mean that a Prince having produced this salt which is immune from the taxation of the Government of India, cannot tax it himself for his own revenue. He can. Is that not so 7 I gather from the Chancellor of the Duchy that that is so. The object is to make sure that the Prince has a more assured facility for imposing a salt tax upon his subjects. Whereas the Federal Government, the Imperial Government have a tax which runs over the whole country and whereas some of the States have, as it were, the right to produce salt without its being taxed now, the proposed wording will give a greater right and a greater facility for the Princes to impose a salt tax. That may be very desirable. No doubt it is very desirable when you want to win the assent of the Princes, but it is perfectly clear that the whole purpose of these Amendments is to secure to the native Prince a greater privilege, a more assured application for the purposes of imposing a salt tax upon his subjects. That is the intention. No doubt he has that right at the present time, but this Amendment is to make his right far more secure than it was. I have no doubt that what is called a mere drafting Amendment is the result of a long process of haggling between the advisers of the Secretary of State and the legal advisers of the Princes. Did I say the legal advisers of the Princes? There is, I should say, one legal adviser who is carrying on negotiations at the present time. I have no doubt that prolonged discussion has gone on with regard to this point, which is represented to us as a mere drafting Amendment.

I do not see why the draftsman should have made any move if the Amendment were not the result of a bargain. I do not remember that this point was discussed in Committee. It is new to me. When our discussions reached this part of the Bill nothing was said about this matter. Therefore, it is not a question of the draftsman going through the Bill between the Committee stage and the Report stage and saying: "Let me look at the Bill; let me take note of the pledges given by Ministers; let me note the weak points which have been ex

959

posed; let me tighten up the armour in these respects, and let me prune away excrescencies." What has moved my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State and his right hon. colleague the Chancellor of the Duchy to bring forward this Amendment? It is, as I say, part of an attempt to sugar the pill for the Princes. I do not at all blame the right hon. Gentleman for doing that. Much of the fortunes of his Bill rest upon his being able topersuade—I will confine myself to the word "persuade," because I do not wish to get on to controversialgrounds—the Princes to accept it, but what I object to is that after he has engaged in this elaborate piece of eighteenth century diplomacy he should come down to the House and pretend that the whole series of Amendments which he has presented to us are merely drafting and con sequential.