SIXTH SCHEDULE.—(Excluded Areas and Partially Excluded Areas.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

13 May 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on May 13, 1935, during debate on the Government of India Bill, supporting an Amendment to exclude 22,500,000 people in primitive areas from the new system and mocking the Government's inconsistencies.
Main themes
Exclusion of primitive tribes from the India Bill, 22,000,000 people in excluded areas, Amendment to the Sixth Schedule, Under-Secretary's smaller list of exclusions, admitted deterioration of administration under new Indian bodies, Provincial and Federal Governments, inconsistency of the Government's case, jealousy of non-excluded Indians, franchise and parliamentary institutions for India, law and order and police under Indian control, retrogression in standards of administration
Duration
~10 min
35th percentile
Words
1,203
35th percentile
Sentences
46
30th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
3.25
78th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 74%63%
  • Social 18%15%
  • Ceremonial 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 3%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 15%

46 sentences in 11 paragraphs

While I gave way to my hon. and gallant Friend I must point out again that I was making no charge at all and that he has in fact sought to reply to my speech in controversial fashion before I have been able to complete it. However, unabashed by his warnings and unmoved by his appeal I continue, if I may, to continue to put these necessary points. There are, we are told, 22,000,000 people involved in this proposal. We are assured that these people are too primitive to be allowed to share in the advantages and boons of liberty, of responsibility, of the franchise and of the Parliamentary and legislative institutions which you are going to confer on the rest of that vast population. The speeches which we have heard seem to indicate that if these people were included in the ordinary scope of the functions of the Provincial Governments or of the Federal Government their lot would be worse than it will be if they are left outside the scheme. That statement very much disquiets me.

My hon. and gallant Friend the Member for Wellingborough spoke of the disaster of leaving these 22,000,000 people in unscrupulous Indian hands. Apparently, he contemplates that when the new bodies which we are calling into being have come into existence there will be a far lower range of government and administration in operation than is attained at the present time. My hon. and gallant Friend takes a warm and philanthropic interest in the affairs of these primitive tribes with whom he has come in contact and wishes to save them from the evils which apparently he apprehends. But, on the other hand, we are told of all the blessings which this Bill has to offer and I really do not see how any logical argument can be held on the basis of such a contradiction. It is clear however that there is general agreement, in principle though not in detail, between the Government and the hon. and gallant Gentleman and his friends. The Government too, by their own exclusions, admit that there are large areas and large populations whose fortunes they will not entrust to these new bodies which they are creating.

The speech of the Under-Secretary seemed to me to admit that these people or some of them at any rate would be better off if they were excluded. He

1410

agreed, partly, with my hon. and gallant Friend that some of them would be much better off if they were left outside this great liberating Measure. One thing which the Under-Secretary said struck me very much. He said that one of the difficulties of leaving out all these classes and districts enumerated in the Amendment was that it would alienate the opinion of the rest of the people of India. I suppose that means that those other people will be jealous at seeing all these districts and all these 22,000,000 people being allowed to continue in their present condition—which is admitted to be better than the condition into which they would be forced under the new system. Apparently it is feared that the people who are not excluded will say, "This is not fair. We are to have all these boons of democratic and modern Western institutions and here are these other people who are to be free from them." Naturally, the people who are in that position will envy the people who are being left alone and who are not to be subjected to the species of ingenious modern mental torments which constitute the higher forms of political thought at the present time.

We ought to know clearly from the Government and the supporters of the Bill whether they consider that the probable condition of these people, as they will be under the operation of the Bill, is worse or is better than their present condition. If their probable future condition under the Bill is regarded as worse than their present condition, then it is quite right to exclude these areas, and I hope that the Under-Secretary will not reject the Amendment. I shall certainly vote to exclude them. I am convinced from the admissions which have been made—and the fact that they are unconscious admissions makes them much more impressive—that the condition of these people will deteriorate under the proposed new system. I am satisfied that the more we can exclude from the operation of the Bill the better. I like this longer list. I like it much better than the Under-Secretary's list. The Under-Secretary proposes to exclude some millions but the Amendment would exclude no fewer than 22,500,000 people. If you have this feeling that you cannot trust the fortunes of these people in the hands of the new administration—to

1411

which you are going to entrust law and order, and every kind of vital function such as those connected with the police and the most difficult tasks of administration—if you think you cannot even trust them with administering the affairs of these primitive people surely you ought to pause. It might be argued that those to whom it is proposed to entrust the administration of these other matters know more about the primitive people than we do. Was not the whole idea of these proposals that Indian opinion was to be brought to bear on such problems? Did we not, hear the Lord President of the Council say how Indians would much prefer people of their own race and creed to white administrators?

I am at a loss to know on which ground the Government stand. Anyhow I know clearly that, for myself, the doubts which I have had all along are more than confirmed by the admissions which we are getting from people supporting the Bill, showing that they know that it will bring a worse form of government to India, and a less reliable form of administration and that they cannot trust these primitive tribes to the care of the new Indian bodies. The great issue of the government of a mighty land and such subjects as irrigation and police and revenue and so forth—all that we are told may be handed over to these new bodies. We are told that they can discharge those functions with perfect security. But when it comes to the administration of the primitive tribes, then sentimental reasons are advanced for taking another course and admissions are made which show that you know that the whole process in which you are engaged, means a great retrogression and decadence in the standard of administration in India to which you have reluctantly consented. I should be very glad indeed if the Under-Secretary were to accept the Amendment, and, even if my hon. and gallant Friend cared to add other districts to it, I should not object. I should not object indeed to including in it the entire scope of the great Indian peninsula. I am certain that the blessings which would be spread thereby would be gratefully received from one end of the continent to the other and really it would be the most happy exit we could find, after all

1412

this trouble and labour from the inconsistencies and contradictions of this Measure.