SIXTH SCHEDULE.—(Excluded Areas and Partially Excluded Areas.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

13 May 1935 · House of Commons Committee debate on the Government of India Bill · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons Committee in London on May 13, 1935, during debate on the Government of India Bill, protesting the Government's decision to postpone the excluded areas question to a later Parliament.
Main themes
Postponement of the excluded areas question to another Parliament, fate of 22,000,000 people in excluded and partially excluded areas, withdrawal of the Government's Sixth Schedule, 10,000,000 people left without the vote or Governor's protection, distrust of provincial governments over backward peoples, Order-in-Council procedure, request to defer the Report stage until after Whitsuntide, criticism of the Attorney-General, mockery of the anthropologists, Government of India Bill, loss of Government nerve
Duration
~11 min
40th percentile
Words
1,358
40th percentile
Sentences
57
37th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
3.14
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 69%65%
  • Social 15%14%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

57 sentences in 12 paragraphs

After I have finished the hon. Gentleman will have an opportunity to speak and will not be confined, even, to making it a personal explanation. We are in Committee, and he will certainly be able to explain his point of view and explain the charges which he made against the Under-Secretary. I want the Committee to see where we stand as the result of the concessions which have been announced. The whole of this question of the excluded areas is to be put off to another Parliament. That is the effect. The whole question is to be shelved and put back to another Parliament. I do not think the Government need have taken this very serious step. They tell us that they want to settle this Indian question once and for all, to reach a solution, to give peace and security, to let people know what their fate is to be; yet here are these 22,000,000 people whose fate is involved, all the people in the 30 districts enumerated in the Amendment and the others enumerated in the Government Schedule, and no one is to know which are to be in and which are to be out.

Perhaps the Attorney-General will give me his attention. He complained just now of my prolonged silence. May I not complain of his continued volubility? I certainly should not complain if only we

1429

had the advantage of hearing him, because when he is addressing us it is deeply interesting to study the forensic methods which he so skilfully employs. Out of the 22,000,000 people affected, the Government proposals affect about 10,000,000 or 12,000,000. All those people will remain uncertain what their fate will be, not only during this Parliament but until Provincial Governments are set up sometime during the next Parliament. We have no idea of what the next Parliament will be and what treatment will then be applied to this subject. We have plunged 22,000,000 people in India into absolute uncertainty as to their fate. They will not know which districts are to be in and which out. Look at the admission which is made—that these districts, many of them, must, be excluded, because the new Governments which we are setting up cannot be trusted to administer these backward peoples. These unfortunate people will not know whether they are to be reserved for the protection of the Imperial representative, the Governor, or whether they are to be left to take their chance in one of the provincial administrations.

As between the mover of the Amendment and the Government there is a matter of 10,000,000 souls. The Government agree that 12,000,000 must have protection, but the other 10,000,000, because they are mixed up in particular Provinces, cannot be protected on account of administrative difficulties; though we know that these 10,000,000 are the type of people the Government admit ought to be protected from the inferior administration or exploitation which they will receive at the hands of the bodies which are to be set up. The 10,000,000 are to be left without the vote, because they are all too poor to qualify. They are without the slightest protection given by the vote or by any protection which comes to them through the exercise of the Governor's authority. That is indeed a forlorn position—neither the Imperial Raj nor the vote. Ten million people of the type specially indicated as requiring particular protection are to be relegated to that fate, but the whole 22,000,000 people share the uncertainty, because it will not be known precisely which of them will be in and which will be out.

To leave this over to be settled by an Order-in-Council in another Parliament

1430

is the most extraordinary step to take, and it only shows that if there had been a little more support the Government could have been turned from this misguided policy. Why, even before a handful of anthropologists they run away and withdraw their Schedule and adjourn the matter to the Greek Kalends—to another Parliament. It is an extraordinary situation. I am amazed that the Government should have taken such a step. I had no idea that anything would be promised which would go beyond a promise of reconsideration on the Report stage; but to say you are going to put the other thing off till another Parliament—I never heard of such a process in legislation. It only shows the want of confidence and of conviction which lies behind those who are conducting the Bill. They have made up their minds that on the whole the best thing is to ram it through, and their followers have put their heads down and devoted themselves to this butting process. But now, in this matter, the Government have lost their nerve. They are frightened of the attacks directed upon them, by the attacks of their friends the anthropologists and so they have in this case gone back and passed all this matter over to another Parliament. That is a very far-reaching step to take, and if it were not that I am most anxious not to delay the proceedings I should certainly ask leave to Report Progress.

I do not remember this procedure ever being adopted before, though I have sat on many Bills and have heard concessions promised in Committee to be settled on the Report stage, the Report stage being delayed, if necessary, for another month till the matter was settled. Here we throw 22,000,000 people into the melting pot and leave their fate to a new Parliament. To do that and still press this Bill through is to take up an attitude which is altogether unreasonable. I cannot help thinking that probably the Attorney-General and his colleague took this decision with a little less premeditation than serious Government departures require. I have always understood that it was the desire of the Government to have this Indian question settled as a whole, and surely this is an integral part of the Bill. It is not a, new question. It is true that the Amendment has only just been put down, but the Government have had their Schedules on the Paper

1431

for weeks and weeks, and for months the matter has been in their hands. Why have they only just now discovered these uncertainties which make it necessary for them to put off the solution of this question to another Parliament? How can they leave this aspect of Indian affairs in that complete confusion into which it is now thrown?

I protest against the procedure. The proper course for the Government to adopt is to promise to reconsider the matter upon Report stage; to delay the Report stage until they have made up their minds about it and then to bring it before Parliament in the ordinary way. To say that this Parliament is to jettison large chunks of this Bill and leave them to be dealt with in another Parliament, is, I should have thought, a most incredibly clumsy and improper procedure. I strongly urge that the Attorney-General should reconsider what he has said and promise to make the decision of the Government plain upon the Report stage. Those who dislike these present proposals should have the courage of their convictions and give effect to them by their votes—they have no chance of beating the Government, the Government have 200 or 300 people who are ready to vote for whatever they say or do, so there is no danger. If the anthropological party have the courage to go into the Lobby, which I greatly doubt, for they have been wriggling and twisting for the last quarter of an hour trying to find an excuse to get out of their position, that will be the best way and the only constitutional and Parliamentary way of bringing their influence to bear on the Government and getting the matter dealt with on the Report stage. The Report stage can perfectly well be adjourned until after Whitsuntide, till the Government can confront us with a reasoned, well-thought-out and final proposal upon a matter affecting 22,000,000 people and one which is inherent in the general structure of the Bill.