CLAUSE 196.—(Power of Federal Legislature to enlarge appellate jurisdiction.)
Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping
- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on April 1, 1935, in the Committee debate on Clause 196 of the India Bill, attacking the 50,000 rupee threshold for appeals as favouring the rich over the poor.
- Main themes
- 50,000 rupee threshold for appeals, one law for rich and poor, Clause 196 of the Government of India Bill, appellate jurisdiction of the Federal Court, Augustus and attention to small cases, poor widows and agricultural labourers, tenant farmers and rack-renting landlords, De minimis non curat lex, wealthy advocates and unequal attention, Attorney-General and the 10,000 rupee figure, Ahmedabad millowners and Bombay corporations
- Duration
- ~7 min
- Words
- 846
- Sentences
- 33
- Readability
- 62
- Grade
- 10.6
- Syntax
- 3.13
- Vocabulary
- 2.10
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other33 sentences in 7 paragraphs
We ought to dwell on this point a moment. I should really have thought that it was a matter that appealed enormously to the Opposition, for obviously, in this Clause we are laying down in the most naked and blatent terms that there is one law for the rich and another law for the poor. It does not at all follow that cases over 50,000 rupees are more important than cases under 50,000 rupees. It was a maxim in Roman times, and the great Augustus is stated to have said, that magistrates should always make a point of attending to the small cases, because the small cases revealed the life of the people who bore upon their shoulders the pressing weight, the necessarily inevitable pressing weight, of an elaborate social organisation. Why should the Committee be ready to pass in a casual manner a Clause such as this? Why are the representatives of Labour, the broad proletarian masses, dumb when these things come up? They seem to say, "It is a matter involving 50,000 rupees; what do we care for that? "It may be that a poor widow is asserting her right to live—rather difficult, I believe, in some cases in India. There may be a case of a humble agricultural labourer who has been paid a wage which does not give him even the daily subsistence which is necessary to support body and soul. "Oh, well," they say, "this is nothing." It may be some small tenant farmer, oppressed by some rich landlord, who has rack-rented him and ill treated him very much, taking perhaps the whole value of his poor holding, with all the improvements which he has put into it. That is not a matter of 10,000 rupees, let alone 50,000 rupees.
I am not saying that some arrangement of this kind may not be necessary. There is a maxim, De minimis non curat lex, but I have never, known that de minimis was regarded as having a pecuniary standard, or that there was any idea that wealth and wealth alone is to be the test by which the course of justice is to be regulated. I know that this may easily strike a rather unexpected and perhaps uncomfortable chord in the breast of the right hon. and learned Gentleman. Among the hierarchy of the
149
law there are wealthy and famous and skilful advocates, and a litigant does get very well attended to when such a one puts his case. There are a lot of people who might manage to put a case effectively, and it would go through in the ordinary way, but with nothing like the careful and considerate attention to detail with which it is handled when eminent K.Cs. appear on one side or the other. That may be one of the practices which grow up irresistibly in the ordinary workings of a complicated civilisation, but there is all the difference between that and putting principles into the cold lead of an Act of Parliament. I am bound to say that I think this is a little characteristic—though I am sorry to have to say so—of the kind of outlook and view, and temper and touch and mood in which this Bill has been shaped and framed by His Majesty's Government. There is nothing like a careful procedure reserved for the appeals, the cries for justice, which arise from people whose case does not involve 50,000 rupees, none of the elaborate precautions which are available in cases above that mystic figure.
How does the right hon. and learned Gentleman arrive at his figure of 50,000 rupees? The Attorney-General, in an audible aside which I think we may fairly say has become the common property of the Committee, mentioned that the present figure was 10,000 rupees. Now it has to be 50,000 rupees before a man can get the full and careful consideration of the courts. That is very typical of the Bill; it is the exact measure of the Bill. In the future it is to be five times as difficult for poor people to get their affairs attended to in India as it was before this Bill was passed. I wish I had a legal training which would enable me to do justice to these matters, but, lacking that, I must study the text of the Bill as best I can in bringing these points forward. It is a bad thing for a great Empire when it definitely draws the line in this cold, cynical and brutal manner between the rich and the poor, especially in a population which, as my hon. Friend has reminded us, is miserably poor, brushing aside the poor and selecting only the affairs of the wealthy, of the Ahmedabad millowners, the wealthy corporations of Bombay, the enormous landowners and others. I think something
150
should be done to make it clear that money is not to be the test. I am delighted to hear my right hon. and gallant Friend laughing, because, generally speaking, he seems to be oppressed by a melancholy disposition.