CLAUSE 251.—(Power by Order in Council to transfer certain powers of Secretary of State.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

8 April 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill · House of Commons, Palace of Westminster, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on April 8, 1935, during debate on the Government of India Bill, welcoming the withdrawal of Clause 251 while warning against a replacement clause.
Main themes
Withdrawal of Clause 251, morale of the Indian Civil Service, quality of Indian Civil Service recruits, uncertainty over civil service careers, Secretary of State's concession, alternative clause to be introduced later, Orders in Council versus Bills, Clause 286 procedure, burden on the House of Lords, Parliament Act, Government of India Bill
Duration
~5 min
17th percentile
Words
616
17th percentile
Sentences
17
9th percentile
Readability
44
44th percentile
Grade
16.1
84th percentile
Syntax
3.62
97th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
22nd percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 71%71%
  • Social 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

17 sentences in 5 paragraphs

I should have said since the operation of the Bill has been brought under review. I think I could give the Noble Lord and the Secretary of State, if they are in any doubt, some figures which are very disconcerting indeed. However, if to the already great despondency which hangs over the Indian Civil Service you are going to add the uncertainty that their careers may be placed on an entirely different basis in future years you will undoubtedly increase the deterioration in the character and quality of those who come forward. I do not suppose that you will fail to find people who will come forward, but they will not have the educational qualities or the high character which has enabled the Civil Service in the past to do such remarkable work in India.. Remembering how few there are of the Indian Civil Service compared with the enormous masses of people whose affairs they regulate and guide, it seems to me a serious thing indeed to lower the class of candidates coming forward or cast any uncertainty over the future of the Service. Both from the point of view that the evil effects on Indian public opinion need not deter him and that to some extent he will be undoing the harm done to the future of the Indian Civil Service by removing this additional cause of unsettlement, I feel that we ought to acknowledge that the Secretary of State

837

has taken a wise step in deferring to the opinion expressed from so many quarters of the Committee.

However, I must enter my caveat about what the Secretary of State said on the subject of introducing other words in some other part of the Bill. I hope that he is not going to take away with one hand what he is giving with the other. I hope that we shall not encounter at a later stage, on Report, the ghost of Clause 251 risen from the grave in which we are now by general consent interring it, with all the grisly marks of its sojourn there. I trust that we have seen the last of this quite needless cause of disturbance to the already harassed Indian Civil Service. For my part, while I welcome the concession given and the gracious way in which it came, I shall certainly exercise the most constant vigilance in an examination of the alternative Clause, or verbiage, which he proposes to introduce at a later stage.

I must also say, on the general Parliamentary point of view, that there is all the difference between a Bill which passes through all its stages in this House, and an Order-in-Council which acquires validity by a single division. Moreover, it seems to me that the procedure under this Clause, and Clause 286 which governs it, throws upon the House of Lords the burden of giving a veto to a proposal, to a policy, put forward by the responsible Government of the day. To throw the burden on the House of Lords of imposing a veto, apart from the regulating and mitigating procedure of the Parliament Act, is to expose that Chamber to a constitutional burden which in its present unreformed condition it is unable to bear. From that point of view, we may rejoice that this Clause has been withdrawn, and, although we cannot yet say in what form the proposal will again come before us, I feel that the Debates on the subject, the careful examination which the matter has received, have been fully justified, and the care and attention which hon. Members are paying to this Bill in its various stages is another unsolicited tribute to the Secretary of State.