CLAUSE 53.—(Provisions as to Instrument of Instructions).

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

20 March 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill (Committee stage) · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons Committee debate on the Government of India Bill in London on March 20, 1935, arguing that the Princes' White Paper broke the Federation scheme and urging the Government to drop the Federal Clauses.
Main themes
Government of India Bill, White Paper on the Princes' position, paramountcy of the Crown over the princely states, breakdown of the Federation scheme, motion to report progress, Lord President of the Council and the Conservative associations, Indian Liberals Congress and Labour opposition, Lord Lothian's 'fresh start' remark, proposal to drop the Federal Clauses, Chelsea Hospital (No. 2) Relief Bill
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,351
80th percentile
Sentences
171
85th percentile
Readability
64
94th percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.83
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 58%54%
  • Geopolitical 31%29%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

171 sentences in 33 paragraphs

This Debate has been remarkable for the unanimity of the criticism and condemnation which have been directed at this stage upon this Government of India Bill as it now presents itself to us. The speeches from every quarter of the Committee have converged and concentrated their fire upon the position now occupied by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State and those who have been associated with him in the long task of promoting this Bill. We have had a notable speech from the Noble Lord the Member for Oxford University (Lord H. Cecil)—a very rare pleasure to us in this House. He brings to us the fruits of profound reflection and of absolute disinterested sincerity. Then we have had the speech delivered by the hon. Member for Caerphilly (Mr. M. Jones) representing His Majesty's Opposition, who has given proofs of his sincerity and is known to be a very strong supporter of what is called advance in India. That speech certainly requires an answer from the Treasury Bench. Certain facts which he adduced and which have been brought forward from every quarter ought to be answered if we are to continue to be a reasonable and reasoning debating assembly.

Sometimes one wonders what is to happen if British Members of Parliament lose all contact with each other by means of reasonable processes. It is very difficult to know how we should get on in such a case, and we are in great danger of it. The Government persist in their policy. The right hon. Gentleman recites at intervals the formulae at which he has arrived. He publishes his despatches and memoranda in a highly specialised and technical jargon which only occasionally forms contact with the English language. For the rest, matters are left to the Patronage Secretary and to a large number of gentlemen who, if they were only giving to this problem the attention which they gave to it a year ago or two years ago, when they began to make up

1262

their minds, would rush this Bill out of the House. Unhappily, they have taken their decision. They are not with us here, but they will be in the Division Lobby. So the machine goes on. That you can roll the Bill forward I do not deny. We cannot doubt that you have the power, during the continued lifetime of this Parliament, to roll this Bill through, in defiance of every fact and every appeal, but the consequences will not be dispersed so easily.

My Noble Friend has moved to report Progress this afternoon because of this White Paper with its unofficial companion the verbatim report of the Princes' speeches—its handmaiden and concomitant. The White Paper undoubtedly presents us, officially, formally and directly with a new situation. No one can deny that it is a new situation. I do not believe that even the hon. Member for Bodmin (Mr. Isaac Foot), who has suffered in political controversy from being at bottom a fair-minded man, would deny that he feels himself in the presence of new facts in the situation produced by this White Paper and the speeches of the Princes. Whether we have a National Government or not is arguable, but evidently there is a National Opposition in the sense of all parties reaching a certain general basis of agreement on the fact that there is a new situation.

This White Paper and its companion represent—what? They represent the Princes' offer. I had not meant to be controversial, but it seems almost a joke. This White Paper is the Princes' offer on which the Government have gone into action for the last four years. This is the Princes' offer which induced the Foreign Secretary to abandon all the conclusions which he and his commission had reached as a result of their study. This is the Princes' offer which my right hon. Friend the Lord President of the Council dwelt on as the ground on which he solemnly advised his party to adopt this policy. I read in the "News-Chronicle," the organ of the Liberal party—I beg pardon, I am not so sure about that, but an organ at any rate of the Liberal and Labour parties— Do not repudiate any support. You may need it all. I read that paper's epitome of this situation—their headline—and what was it?

1263

The Princes reaffirm their faith in Federation.

Can any reasonable person who has read the White Paper and also read the actual text of the Princes' speeches imagine that we are going to make progress in our affairs by taking such nonsensical views as that? What is the moral of this White Paper? It is the final refusal of the Princes to have anything to do with this Federation scheme. I believe we are going to have a reply from the Attorney-General. I am sure that if he were consulted in a legal capacity and if he saw this document, especially if he saw the report of the speeches, he would say that on the correspondence there was a complete breakdown. On the correspondence there appears a total and utter breach. Mind you, it is not only a question of a breach such as might arise between a willing buyer and a willing seller who were still haggling about how the thing should go and who was to get some advantage here or there. Not at all. This is a deliberate decision on the part of the Princes of India to break from this scheme of Federation. Do not delude yourselves. There is no compromise, no alternative possible.

Let me point out that it is a question of paramountcy. Paramountcy, the Secretary of State says, is not in the Bill. "I rejoice," he says, "that our differences are narrowed by the fact that I need not discuss paramountcy." But why do the Princes raise this question of paramountcy? I must say it astonishes me that my right hon. Friend, with all his ability, does not seem to be in touch with the actual way in which the forces in India are working. Why do you suppose the Princes have raised this question of paramountcy and dragged it in by the heels? Not because they expect the Government to grant their wishes, but because they wish to put up a barrier against being involved in this scheme of Federation. It may be said that there are 30 points of difference, and the lawyers may discuss them and write them out in great detail and make proposals for compromise, for arrangements and for accommodations. But the Princes were not going to trust only to that. No, they raise the question of paramountcy, and they now say "Before we come into this Federation you have to define paramountcy and deal with us on that subject." They twice use the expression

1264

that this is a "condition precedent" to their joining the Federation.

What does the right hon. Gentleman say? He says what any Secretary of State would say, the only thing which any Secretary of State could say. "I am not prepared to entertain a discussion at this time with the Princes of India upon their relations with the King Emperor." Could you possibly have a more complete and absolute breach than is disclosed by that position? On the one hand, the Princes say, "We will not enter the Federation until, as a condition precedent, our wishes about paramountcy are met." On the other hand, you have the right hon. Gentleman saying, as it was his duty to say, "We are not prepared to discuss the high relationship of these princely States with the sovereign Power." There is a complete breach. I do not think there can be any doubt about it. You may work for several months, you may spend a lot of time, trouble and money with the lawyers in trying to work out a compromise but this means that the Princes have definitely decided not to come into this Bill.

Why they have so decided it would take a long time to tell, but there is one reason that the right hon. Gentleman ought to appreciate because I think it is the dominant, the actuating reason, the motor muscle of their position. It is because their compatriots in the political classes of India have told them not to come in. It is because from all over India they have received appeals, protests, even threats, all with the object of inducing them to stop out. It is because they are making common cause with the rest of Indian educated intelligentsia and public opinion against this Measure, and therefore the Princes have withdrawn from it. There may be many other reasons, such as their position and their sovereign rights, and many of them have never liked the idea of Federation; but the decisive fact undoubtedly is that the Princes have refused to come into Federation because those forces in British India which asked them five years ago to come in have now in the most explicit and earnest manner begged them, urged them, exhorted them to stay out. Therefore, they have erected this insuperable obstacle of paramountcy.

That is the position. It is a very serious position. I really must ask my

1265

right hon. Friend the Lord President of the Council—I am always having to ask him questions—to think over very carefully what he said to the National Union of Conservative Associations. I am absolutely sure that the last thing in the world my right hon. Friend would do is to obtain support, to get round a difficult corner by anything in the nature of false pretences. I am sure that when he sees that the facts on which he presented his case to the Conservative associations are not borne out and have actually fallen from beneath his feet, he will take the earliest effective opportunity of either detaching himself from the policy or of explaining that new circumstances have arisen which induce him to base his advocacy of the Measure on different grounds from those he then put forward.

I am glad to see the Prime Minister back. It gives me great satisfaction, and I hope he will not mind my pointing out to him how different the situation is now from what it was in 1931. In those days he had the offer of the Princes; there was an offer then. In those days he had the assent and agreement of British Indian politicians. In those days he had a large amount of support among Indian Liberals—active support from that great body of central opinion of which we have heard. In those days also he had hopes of obtaining the Congress party and Mr. Gandhi—" My Dear Mahatma "we had then. In those days he had the official support of the Conservative party and Liberal support, and he was himself the head of a Socialist Government. In those days four or five years ago he had every expectation, as it seemed at the moment—although I did not share it—of being able to make a great settlement for India with an equally broad basis of public assent here. Every one of those factors has been swept away; not one vestige of that structure remains. You may say that you will continue with the Bill, but every man who has studied the matter knows that the situation has no resemblance in any way to what occurred at that time.

What do the Government say should happen now? They say, "It is quite all right, it makes no difference." The Indian Liberals will not have it. Congress will not have it, the Princes will

1266

not have it, and the Labour party will not have it. It is not an agreed Measure here, it is not a Measure which can be said to be, as it were, high and dry above the ebb and flow of party conflict. All that has vanished. Still, the Government say, "It is all right, wait until the Division bell rings, and we will get them through the Lobbies, and it will be all right." Their newspapers—they still have some in their support—their devoted newspapers will read to-morrow, "The House of Commons decided by an overwhelming majority that there was no substance whatever in those ridiculous and obstructive tactics put forward against the Bill." All this, and a reference to the fine speech of the Secretary of State, in which he depicted himself in action on behalf of a cause which has got into a somewhat ramshackle condition, will be, no doubt, admirably portrayed.

But what is the Government's policy? It is to place this Bill on the Statute Book, no matter what happens and whether they have agreement of all parties or not. They wish to place the Bill upon the Statute Book. What will happen then? I see that Lord Lothian made a speech the other day. He is a very important person and has a great influence in our relations with Germany and in our relations with India. I quote from the report of his speech in the "Times" of the 8th March:

Lord Lothian, discussing the Indian Bill, said they had nothing to do to-day but to put the Bill on to the Statute Book and make a fresh start from that position.

I ask the Conservative party, I ask the Government and their faithful supporters, if that is the position they take up? I ask particularly my Noble Friend the Member for Horsham (Earl Winterton). If faith holds between man and man, we are entitled to know where we stand in a matter of this kind. This Bill has been represented as the most that we can give and the furthest we can go. All its safeguards have been drawn carefully in order to salve the consciences of members of the Conservative party and to make it easy for the great mass of that party to do what without their support would never have been done in this country. Now, when it is to be put on the Statute Book, what is it to be? A settlement? No, it is to be the point from which a fresh start is to be made. The Attorney-

1267

General is a Conservative. He is a sincere patriot. Has he any bottom to his convictions in this matter? Is there any point where we shall reach finality? He is going to force the Bill through, but is he prepared to take it as a starting point for some great new lurch, some downward slurge? We ought to know. Of course, you can vote us down, but if there is no sort of attempt to meet propositions of this kind, you cannot blame us if we try to fight not only in this House, but elsewhere, by every method open to us, because, once all contact is lost on a basis of reason and argument, then the only thing people can do is to organise and to endeavour to express their opinions as effectively as they can. I hope that we shall have some answer upon that point—how far do you mean to go?

This Bill is now to be placed on the sideboard like a ham from which anyone can come and cut a slice if they feel inclined before it gets mouldy and rotten. There is your Bill, there is your settlement of India, and of course it will be the starting point for any further legislation if it is passed. Every concession you have made, the most extreme point which you have reached, will be the starting point for new legislation. The Attorney-General made a speech in the country the other day. He usually indulges himself at week-ends in the country by giving us orations which are most interesting and nearly always afford food for controversial comment. He made a speech in which he said that it ought to be five or ten years before the policy of this Bill could be carried out. In five or ten years there will be a change of Government in this country. However sanguine may be the hopes that are entertained, one cannot imagine that in such a period there will not be a change. But when you have passed this Bill of 400 or 500 Clauses and put it on the Statute Book, it will not be difficult to pass a Bill of 20 Clauses. It will be quite a manageable matter. It will slip through this structure and completely transform it; it will completely prune out, excise, eliminate and excavate every one of the particular points upon which the Conservative party have been induced to carry this policy so far.

Why press this matter further? It is not any longer a great measure of Indian constitutional reform. The right hon.

1268

Gentleman has no doubt to introduce a great many Amendments to meet the objections of the Princes. I suggest that at the same time he should change the title of the Bill. He should no longer call it the Government of India Bill, but the Chelsea Hospital (No. 2) Relief Bill. He should call it by the name which far more accurately delineates its purpose, namely, to enable a number of officials and powerful people to escape from a difficult situation without undue loss and countenance and face. This Bill has nothing whatever to do with India. India will have nothing whatever to do with the Bill. The whole position has now become one of will power, of clash of opinions and wills here at the centre. Why can we not relax this position? The right hon. Gentleman spoke of the temptation of abandoning this Bill in the face of the universal opposition which it has excited among those for whom it was designed. Why can he not yield to that temptation? Temptation which is a natural instinct is not necessarily wrong. You beg the question when you say that all that reason and all that convenience and all that public interest urge is temptation. You ought to yield to these things, and this is the time to yield. This is the time when the Government ought to lay aside every impediment. There is great need of simplifying our policy here and abroad. There is great need of uniting forces which are harmoniously blended and must act together. Surely this is the time to take a reasonable step.

It is little that we ask, and how very little it is now that we have reached the point when, as far as arguments and facts are concerned, it is admitted by all parties in the House that the case has been made out. Surely it is not much to ask that the Federal Clauses should be dropped, that they should not be placed on the Statute Book until or unless the Princes have concurred in them, that they should, as my Noble Friend has suggested, be brought to the Third Beading and then be left out with any other ancillary parts as may be required. Then we could go forward. If that were done, very useful legislation would still rest in the hands of the Government, but, if they persist in the course which they have adopted, if they simply go forward using the dull brute force that they can demand. The right

1269

hon. Gentleman the Member for West Birmingham (Sir A. Chamberlain) has taken very great responsibility in this matter, and I hope he will not be left high and dry when the subject is concluded. If the Government go forward, using their force, they must not suppose the trouble will end with the passage of the Bill. That is not possible. While this Bill remains on the Statute Book it claims from all those who disapprove of such policies and principles a consistent and persistent effort to establish forces, continuing and organised forces, which will resist the repetition of such Measures in the future, and will endeavour, as far as possible, to repair the mischances of the past.