CLAUSE 231.—(Application of preceding section to railway services, and officials of courts.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

4 April 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on April 4, 1935, during debate on Clause 231 of the Government of India Bill, criticising the Government's vague undertaking on Anglo-Indian railway employment.
Main themes
Employment of Anglo-Indians on the railways, Government of India Bill, vague undertaking of careful attention, Montagu-Chelmsford reforms, unemployment of the Anglo-Indian community, tribute to Anglo-Indian war service, Secretary of State for India, Colonel Sir Henry Gidney, Isaac Foot's intervention, Parliament's duty towards India, military communications and defence of British India
Duration
~9 min
31st percentile
Words
1,054
31st percentile
Sentences
37
23rd percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.37
87th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 41%41%
  • Ceremonial 32%32%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

37 sentences in 12 paragraphs

In order to remove any unnecessary suspicion, but not because he considers it necessary. On this showing, the latest version, he is ready to cumber his Bill with otiose provisions in order to remove unnecessary suspicions, which he does not himself share and which he thinks are not at all valid. I think my right hon. Friend must not rest himself upon such a very insecure and abnormal foundation as that: otherwise, his Bill will very quickly be encrusted with a host of meaningless provisions. No, I take it that when the Under-Secretary of State was instructed and authorised to state that the matter would have further consideration and to give the new undertaking, it was because a point of substance had been raised of which the Government felt conscious and against which they wished to provide. I think, at any rate, that that really would be the best way for us to look at it.

I am not clear what is the new undertaking that has been given. If the new undertaking is simply to give, as I think the Under-Secretary said, careful and

560

serious attention to this matter, that is what is called common form. I hope there is no part of this extended Bill to which careful and serious attention has not been given. I trust there is no point that is raised in these debates which, if it strikes a new chord in the breast of the Administration, will not win from it sympathetic consideration. But what does it all amount to? I was impressed with the tribute which the Under-Secretary paid to this community of Anglo-Indians, or Eurasians, as they used to be called in former years, to their great services and to the prowess of some of their young men, the brilliant prowess in deathless feats of arms to which he referred. He spoke of the service they had rendered, but we must be careful that their service is not repaid by the Under-Secretary's lip service. I do not see what the Anglo-Indians have got out of all these tributes, except this vague undertaking to do something or other, to give careful attention to the matter, and that only given to us, as the Secretary of State has said, in order to allay suspicion, not because the Government think it necessary. Therefore, the Government are contented with the existing proposals so far as the Anglo-Indians are concerned.

What are those existing proposals? Their highest aim is to stereotype the disastrous position to which the Anglo-Indian community has descended since the Montagu-Chelmsford reforms. A terrible blow has been struck at these men during the 15 or 16 years since those reforms were passed. Just at the moment when, after the Great War, 80 per cent. of them having volunteered, they had rendered these extraordinary services, which no one can deny and to which the Government have afforded a verbal, oratorical tribute, just at that very moment began these disasters, and whereas they were obtaining employment on the railways, for which they were well fitted and which fitted in so well with our schemes for maintaining peace and order in India, and military communications, just at that very moment, when they were looking forward to this employment, when they had rendered service in the hour of need, down through the Montagu-Chelmsford reforms fell this continued succession of blows.

It may be said that I was a Member of the Government which passed the

561

Montagu-Chelmsford reforms. That is true; and what a lesson that has been to all of us, that a Parliament should not neglect its duties in regard to India and should not be easily gulled by a lot of tame magnates brought home from India to assure us that it will be all right, but that Parliament should go into the matter itself in great detail, because there is no doubt that the working of the Montagu-Chelmsford reforms inflicted horrid injury upon the Anglo-Indian community and was in effect an instance of base ingratitude on the part of the Imperial power to those who had so newly served them, and served them well. But the highest aim which His Majesty's Government have in view, according to the accounts which are now laid before us, is to stereotype this poor remnant, this fragment, of their previous employment. I am told that over 20,000 adult males of this community in India are now without employment, without the means of educating their children, invited to compete with coolie labour, which has entirely different requirements from the point of view of maintaining their standard of life.

The hon. Member for Bodmin (Mr. Isaac Foot) presents himself to help the Government out of its difficulties. He is so afraid that something more may be done for the Anglo-Indian that he gives him a good, Liberal whack on the head. It astounds me that an hon. Member with such warm-hearted sympathies in some directions should have the knack of putting up certain shutters in his moral and mental house and thereupon excluding all rays of light which might reach him from those quarters. No one can be harder than the hon. Member on causes which do not stir his imagination at the moment. But I hope the Secretary of State will not harden his heart because of the support which reaches him from almost the only other Member in this House besides himself who is enthusiastic about this Bill. I hope he will still continue to examine this question of the Anglo-Indians with patience and with care, not with perfunctory assurances. Something should be done to assure this community that in the present transference of sovereignty they are not merely to be stereotyped at the position which they now hold, but are to have an opportunity of expansion, because of their merits, in these services for which

562

they are so peculiarly fitted and in which their collaboration is an 'essential part of the defensive arrangements of the British power in India.

The right hon. Gentleman spoke of Colonel Sir Henry Gidney. I have had the pleasure of making his acquaintance and of having some conversation with him on several occasions, and I must say that when I looked into Sir Henry Gidney's eyes I saw fear, and grief, and almost despair