Clause 24.—(RATES OF PROFITS TAX, ETC.)
Winston Churchill · Leader of the Opposition of the United Kingdom
- Context
- Churchill, as Leader of the Opposition, addressed the House of Commons in London on June 11, 1951, during Committee debate on the Finance Bill, rejecting deals on timetabling through the usual channels and asking the Government for its plans.
- Main themes
- Arrangements for Budget debate timing, conduct of business through the usual channels, role of the Leader of the House, rights of the Opposition to oppose, use of the Closure, Government majority in Committee, Finance Bill proceedings, parliamentary tradition and democracy, Patronage Secretary's proposals, request for the business plan for the evening
- Duration
- ~6 min
- Words
- 692
- Sentences
- 28
- Readability
- 63
- Grade
- 9.5
- Syntax
- 2.93
- Vocabulary
- 2.01
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other28 sentences in 9 paragraphs
I should like to pay my tribute, not for the first time, to the careful, patient and conciliatory manner in which the right hon. Gentleman the Home Secretary discharges his duties as Leader of the House. We all appreciate his good feeling and his desire to have everything go through as smoothly as possible—to the advantage of the Government. Also, we are always a little bit influenced by the agreeable nature of his personality. I was sorry that he marred the somewhat serious arguments which he laid forward—and which I shall refer to in a minute—by referring to matters which apparently concern not the House but the turf. We all know the right hon. Gentleman's addiction to that pursuit, and this momentary lapse will, I am sure, be pardoned on both sides of the Committee.
The right hon. Gentleman naturally wishes to get his business through as quickly as possible. We wish to make as severe a test as we can of the proposals in the Budget and to bring them to issue in the Committee. When he spoke about discussions which had taken place through the usual channels I was very much obliged to him, because anything that happens through the usual channels is, of course, entirely confidential—until it is made public. That seems to be the rule followed in regard to most of our secrets nowadays.
10.0 p.m.
The right hon. Gentleman has made a series of proposals through the Patronage Secretary, who I see in the corner, which were denounced immediately they had been uttered from below the Gangway as being too generous. We have never asked for the generosity of hon. Members opposite. All we ask for is fair play and that they should rule in accordance with the principles of democracy when supported by
1802
the will of the people. When I began, I was talking to every quarter of the House and not to the hon. Gentleman whose acquaintance I have not the pleasure to enjoy. I do not feel that this is a matter upon which bargains can be made through the usual channels. The discussion of the Budget should proceed, as it does, in accordance with the rights of Members of Parliament and of the Opposition to oppose and so forth, and with the use of the Closure governed, as it is, when demanded, by the long tradition of the House.
I have seen many Budgets carried through the House—I have even carried five myself—and I know well how lengthy the discussions may be. It is all part of the process in which our way of life is sustained that great consideration should be shown, not in the interests of generosity to the Opposition, but as an Act of Parliament—an affirmation which is one of the great foundations on which our ancient civilisation rests. Therefore, we were not able to come to any agreement about details and so forth and say, "It is all wound up and settled." It is not settled. The right hon. Gentleman must decide what hours he chooses to sit. He has a Government majority—What was it last time?—in these matters, and I think that he had much better conduct the Bill—he and the Chancellor of the Exchequer—with the ability, discretion and good feeling which animates on other occasions and let us do our part, as we are called upon to do, as we think fit.
We certainly do not wish to have further discussions on this Bill governed by some detailed good faith arrangement between the Patronage Secretary and my hon. Friends on this side. We think it much better that they should flow out in the normal course and Parliament should take its stake and fortunes as they come, confident that it has a right to do so as one of the great elements and sources of British national life.
I want to point out to the right hon. Gentleman that he did not tell us what he was going to do or what he wished even for tonight on the basis that there is not an agreement or deal between parties. Would he kindly do so now?