Clause 28.—(TRANSACTIONS DESIGNED TO AVOID LIABILITY TO THE PROFITS TAX.)
Winston Churchill · Leader of the Opposition of the United Kingdom
- Context
- Churchill addressed the House of Commons Committee in London on June 11, 1951, during debate on Clause 28, urging the Leader of the House to accept a motion for a break in proceedings.
- Main themes
- Request for a break in the sitting, loss of Tuesday as a parliamentary day, Government handling of business, Leader of the House's proposal, Clause 31 timetable, welfare of the servants of the House, 1914 battleship readiness analogy, Opposition and Government voting strength, importance of Clause 28, public reporting of the debate, motion to adjourn the Committee
- Duration
- ~6 min
- Words
- 683
- Sentences
- 28
- Readability
- 62
- Grade
- 10.4
- Syntax
- 3.03
- Vocabulary
- 1.82
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other28 sentences in 9 paragraphs
Yes, Thursday—very good. I am sure that that would be the best way for the Committee.
I have been asking myself what good the Government get out of going on indefinitely and killing the Tuesday as a Parliamentary day. One does not see that they gain anything, because, obviously, they will not succeed in making any more rapid progress with the course of business and they will have killed a day. If we are to be released, as some have suggested, at an earlyish hour tonight, in order to catch up arrears of sleep and to balance the human budget in a satisfactory manner, then this arrangement would be very convenient and I suggest it to the right hon. Gentleman—not that I expect him to agree, because he is paying off a grudge because he did not get to the end of Clause 31 by a quarter to midnight last night.
The more one has considered the proceedings of the Committee and what has happened since, and the many complicated matters that have to be disposed of, the more one perceives what an unfair and absurd proposal he made. If it were any man but he, I should use the word "dishonest," but in his case I shall simply say that it was grossly out of relation to anything that could be considered as fair play.
Then there is the question, which has been mentioned, of the servants of the House. A break is very valuable to them now. From now until 2.30 would allow over three hours, which would have highly beneficial effects and enable the preparations to be made for the renewal of our discussions. The Government gain nothing by going on continuously. They are not going to weary us or exhaust us on this side. We are not called upon to produce any given number of votes at any given moment.
2051
I remember—and I should like the Committee to consider this carefully—that before the 1914 war, when I was First Lord of the Admiralty, we had 16 battleships which had to be always ready to meet 10 of the potential enemy—the Germans. One would have no idea how difficult it is to maintain an average of 16 to meet the selected moment of only 10. All sorts of things happen. They have to undergo refits; sometimes they collide with one another, and injuries are done. Generally speaking, it is a very great strain, which cannot possibly be measured.
The Government seem to have the idea that they have the advantage in this matter. I do not think that that is so, because nothing happens to us if we turn up 100 short in any Division—we should be having a needed rest by what I am suggesting—whereas much would happen to the party opposite if they turned up only 10 short; they might get an even longer rest.
I hope, therefore, that the Government will consider very carefully this well-meant suggestion of mine, and that when he replies the Leader of the House will be able to tell us, so that we can understand the manner in which his mind is working what advantage he gains by not having a break now. I do not see what advantage he gains by cutting out all the Questions and by continuing until a late hour tonight or whenever he chooses to release us. I should have thought it would be very much better to break now and to begin where we leave off after Questions are over. That is the course, I suggest, which would be in every way most convenient.
There is another great advantage which we would gain. The present Clause, Clause 28, is an extremely important one, and owing to the fact that we have had all the morning to discuss it and will have all the afternoon also, whatever is done, the arguments which are set forth can be fully reported and meditated upon by those whose servants and representatives we are. I therefore ask the Leader of the House to accept the Motion which I now move.