Foreign Office.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

2 May 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Foreign Office · House of Commons, Palace of Westminster, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on May 2, 1935, in the Foreign Office debate, arguing that Germany had overtaken Britain in air strength and urging collective security through the League of Nations.
Main themes
German air rearmament and loss of British air parity, failed Government air estimates, responsibility of Prime Minister and Lord President of the Council, Stresa declaration, League of Nations resolution on German treaty violations, French appeal to the League, tardiness of British policy, rejection of isolation, collective security with France and Italy, Treaty of Versailles and disarmament
Duration
~42 min
91st percentile
Words
5,066
91st percentile
Sentences
201
89th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.21
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 69%61%
  • Institutional 15%13%
  • Ceremonial 14%12%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

201 sentences in 57 paragraphs

No. The hon. Gentleman said, what an inconsistent course we had taken—that while Germany was weak we tried to make her strong, and, now that she was getting strong, we were alarmed. That certainly

599

is a reproach against the policy of this country. As a matter of fact, it has been consistent from the time when the peace was signed—an earnest endeavour to make it easy for Germany to resume her full place in the comity of nations. We have been forward, if not foremost, in lending large sums of money to Germany, the repayment of which is extremely doubtful; and was it not upon our initiative that all the economic clauses of the Treaty Which burdened Germany were swept away? I could give a catalogue of a dozen important steps taken, even during the tenure of the present Government, all of a character designed to keep in the most friendly relations with Germany, and designed to help her to reach a position where she will feel at peace with her own dignity without being a danger to other nations.

Neither do I agree with the hon. Gentleman in the doctrine that the Allies have broken the Treaty of Versailles. I do not accept that view. I am not going to argue the question this afternoon, but two years ago a very powerful despatch was written by the present Foreign Secretary upon that subject, with the arguments of which, I think, the hon. Gentleman might refresh his mind. But I should be quite prepared to argue it on a suitable occasion, and to show that there was no breach of the Treaty in what has taken place in France, while certainly, as regards what has taken place in this country, we have seen disarmament carried to extremes which, as I have previously endeavoured to show, have placed us in a position which demands the constant attention of the House. The first step which, as it seems to me, we should take upon this supreme combined issue of foreign affairs and national defence—the first step necessary to the restoration of our affairs—is a proper assignment of responsibility. I am very glad indeed to see the Prime Minister restored in health and able to take a leading part in this Debate. Constitutional usage assigns to the first Minister of the Crown the main direct responsibility for the safety of the country. On the other band, under the present political arrangements, the Lord President of the Council has been accustomed to make the important declarations upon defence matters; and the fact that he is the Leader of the Conservative party,

600

commanding overwhelming majorities in both branches of the Legislature, has invested his words with special responsibility.

There is a danger at the present time, and there has been, I think, for some time, that the responsibility may be confused, that it may fall between two personalities—between the Prime Minister, who is the titular head of the Government, and the Minister who is unquestionably the most powerful politician in the country. I believe that many of the evils of the present situation arise from the fact that one Minister holds the chief office and another holds the chief power. We suffer from the lack of a single commanding mind ranging over the whole field of our affairs; we suffer from the disadvantage of not having a single prime figure who is not merely responsible, but, if I may use a more precise word, accountable, to the nation. However, my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister has been for six years continuously in his present office. He has during that period played a great and a leading part in guiding our foreign policy; and during all that period he has been the Chairman of the Committee of Imperial Defence. He will not, I am sure, dissociate himself in any way from the statements which have been made on behalf of the Government by the Lord President, and he will not divest himself in any way of the responsibility traditionally associated with his office. It is, therefore, to him that I shall principally address myself in any remarks which I shall venture to make this afternoon.

We have before us in the sphere of foreign policy three new and separate documents of much importance. We have the League of Nations' resolution; we have the declarations of the Stresa Conference; and we have the Prime Minister's article in his own organ, the "News-Letter." I find myself—I think in common with the great majority of the House, not in one party but in all parties—in very general agreement with the Prime Minister and His Majesty's Government upon the measures taken by the Government in these three documents. The sentiments expressed in the "News-Letter" about the dangers of German re-armament are akin to those which I myself have ventured, the Committee may remember, to express several times in the last two or three years, beginning in the

601

autumn of 1932. The Stresa declaration, including the statement that the three Powers, Great Britain, Italy and France, will keep in touch with one another, and are pledged to study the maintenance of peace in common—I am not quoting the actual words—seems to be no more than national safety or national survival requires. There remains the Resolution of the Council of the League of Nations complaining of the growth of German armaments and of the unilateral violation of treaties. I have seen a great deal of criticism in quarters where one would least expect it of France for appealing to the League of Nations against Germany, and of the League of Nations for giving a faithful verdict upon the questions submitted for their judgment.

When I hear extreme pacifists denouncing this act of the League of Nations, I am left wondering what foundation these gentlemen offer to countries to abandon individual national armaments. We are reminded how in a state of savagery every man is armed and is a law unto himself, but that civilisation means that courts are established, that men lay aside their arms and carry their causes to the tribunal. This presupposes a tribunal to which men, when they are in doubt or anxiety, may freely have recourse. It presupposes a tribunal which can deal with great matters as well as small, and it presupposes a tribunal which is not incapable of giving a verdict. Personally, I admire greatly the self-restraint and courage with which France addressed herself to the League of Nations. It was far better surely than that she should have dealt in ultimatums or should have seized territories as hostages, such as would have been the practice in former generations. She appealed to the tribunal which has been set up, and I also admire the spirit of that tribunal and of these different countries, some great and some small, drawn from different parts of the world, who showed themselves according to their lights prepared to give justice though the Heavens fall. If we are to be told that it is very wrong for France to go to the League of Nations, and how foolish and tactless of them to give their opinion, if that view is to be held by those who have hitherto told us to look to this international procedure, then you have absolutely stultified all your arguments, for never again, if it is the case,

602

will nations be prepared to abandon the security which resides in strong national armaments. All that prospect, and the only prospect which opens itself before our eyes, of establishing a reign of law and building up a great international structure to which all nations will accede—that prospect and hope will dwindle and die away. Therefore, I am in general agreement with His Majesty's Government upon all these three steps which have been taken by them in the last few months in company with other nations.

If I criticise these measures, it is not at all because of their character but because of their tardiness. Why was all this not done two or three years ago? If the Prime Minister two years ago had thought what he now thinks in his "News-Letter" about the German danger, he need perhaps never have published his thoughts to the world. Instead of his lectures to a nation now already so heavily armed, he could have imparted them as wise guidance to the Cabinet. If only the French Government two and a half years ago, when the German process of re-armament began, had laid their much talked of dossier before the League of Nations and demanded justice or protection from the concert of Europe, if only Great Britain, France and Italy had pledged themselves two or three years ago to work in association for maintaining peace and collective security, how different might have been our position. Indeed, it is possible that the dangers into which we are steadily penetrating would never have arisen. But the world, and the Parliaments and public opinion would have none of that in those days two or three years ago. When the situation was managable it was neglected, and now that it is thorughly out of hand, we apply too late the remedies which then might have effected a cure. There is nothing new in the story. It is as old as the Sibylline books. It falls into that immense dismal category of the fruitlessness of experience and the confirmed unteachability of mankind. Want of foresight, unwillingness to act when action would be simple and effective, lack of clear thinking, confusion of counsel until the emergency comes, until self-preservation strikes its jarring gong—these are the features which constitute the endless repetition of history.

603

All this leads me to the gravest matter of all, and the only other matter with which I propose to deal, though I must ask for our indulgence from the Committee, namely, the state of our national defences and their reactions upon foreign policy. Things have got much worse, but they have also got much clearer. It used to be said that armaments depend on policy. It is not always true, but I think that at this juncture it is true to say that policy depends, to a large extent, upon armaments. It is true to say that we have reached a position where the choice of policy is dictated by considerations of defence. During the last three years, not only under the government of Herr Hitler but before him, under the government of Chancellor BrÜning, Germany worked unceasingly upon a vast design of rearmament on a scale which would give that mighty, gifted, scientific, valiant race of 60,000,000 or 70,000,000 such a predominance in Europe as would enable it, if it chose—and why should it not choose?—to reverse the results of the Great War. The method should be noted by the Committee. The method has been to acquire mastery in the air, and, under the protection of that mastery in the air, to develop—and it is fortunately a much longer process—the land and sea forces which, when completed would dominate over all Europe. This design is being completed as fast as possible, and the first part of it—German ascendancy in the air—is already a fact. The military part is far advanced, and the naval part is now coming into view.

We are to have a Debate, as we have been promised, in 10 days or so upon the Defence Services and I shall, therefore, enter into no technical details this afternoon, but confine myself solely to the broad, outstanding realities which dictate the course of our foreign policy. For the last two years some of us have been endeavouring to convince His Majesty's Government of the scale and pace at which German aviation was proceeding. We debated it in March, 1933, on the Air Estimates of 1934, in August, 1934, in November, 1934, and quite recently, in March, 1935. On all these occasions the most serious warnings were given by Private Members who spoke on this subject, of whom I was one. The alarm bells were set ringing, and even jangling, in

604

good time if only they had been listened to. This afternoon I am not concerned with what Private Members said in giving their warning, but I am bound to address myself to the main statements and promises which were elicited on these occasions from His Majesty's Government. In. March, 1934, we had the first declaration of the Lord President:

Any Government of this country—a National Government more than any, and this Government—will see to it that in air strength and air power this country shall no longer be in a position inferior to any country within striking distance of our shores."—[OFFICIAL REPORT, 8th March, 1934; col. 2078, Vol. 286.]

That declaration was considered of enormous importance. That was in March, but nothing happened until August, when, under the pressure not indeed of those hon. Gentlemen in this House who were raising this matter, for their pressure could easily have been disdained, but under pressure of events, the Government produced a five-years' programme for increasing the home defence portion of the Royal Air Force to 75 squadrons, comprising 880 machines, by 1939. Anyone could see that that was utterly inadequate, and that it bore no relation whatever to the pace at which German aviation was developing and to the military character which it was assuming. At that time, nine months ago, I urged that without a day's delay measures should be taken, first, to double, and then to re-double the Royal Air Force. My right hon. Friend the Member for Darwen (Sir H. Samuel) made a speech to-day very different in its note. I am most grateful to him for the change of note from that in the speeches which he delivered a few months ago on the subject, and he indicated that the future measures which may be proposed by the Government would be received in a spirit of most earnest consideration by the party of which he is the spokesman. But when he spoke in August last he spoke very harshly of the proposal that I made and, as the Committee will remember, described me as a "Malay run amok." Anyone can see now, and most of all the Ministers responsible, that the kind of policy of doubling and re-doubling the Air Force which I then proposed was the least which should have been set on foot. If nine months ago these measures had been begun you would to-day have been be-

605

ginning to reap the harvest and beginning to obtain results, and very different would have been the position. In November some of us moved an Amendment to the Address, and I took the responsibility then of making some definite statements, or rather understatements, about the German air menace. In order that the Government should have an opportunity of consulting their expert adviser, I supplied the right hon. Gentleman the Lord President with a précis in advance, and upon this he made a series of strong declarations, the last of which has been endorsed and confirmed by the Prime Minister to-day. I must read these to the House:

It is not the case that Germany is rapidly approaching equality with us. … Her real strength is not 50 per cent. of our strength in Europe to-day.

As for the position this time next year,"—

That is, November of this year—

…. so far from the German military air force being at least as strong as and probably stronger than our own, we estimate that we shall still have in Europe alone a margin of nearly 50 per cent.

It is quite true that my right hon. Friend in that second statement said:

provided that there is no acceleration in Germany.

But it is very difficult to know what is acceleration when the original speed at which the German air force has been constructed is not known nor when the final limit at which they are aiming is not known. Then came this declaration, the most important that we have had—the Prime Minister has repeated it to-day—

His Majesty's Government are determined in no conditions to accept any position of inferiority with regard to what air force may be raised in Germany in the future."—[OFFICIAL REPORT, 28th November, 1934; cols.882–83, Vol. 295.]

Here we have a assertion that the Government, with all its sources of information, was convinced that they had, and would continue to have for many months, a large air superiority over Germany, and that in no case would they fail to maintain what has been called air parity with Germany. These assurances were accepted. My right hon. Friend the Member for Carnarvon Boroughs (Mr. Lloyd George) spoke in that debate. I remember his speech well. He declared himself completely reassured. He declared himself in agreement with the principle

606

that we should maintain our parity, and said that he was completely reassured by the fact that we still had this air superiority, and that the Government intended to maintain it unbroken in the future. My right hon. and gallant Friend the Member for Caithness (Sir A. Sinclair), who is not here this afternoon, also accepted it on behalf of his party, and he too rapidly decided in his own mind that the Government statement was right and that mine was wrong.

That was in November. Only six weeks ago my right hon. Friend the Under-Secretary of State for Air, on whom I would not lay any responsibilities beyond those which are proper to his position as an Under-Secretary in a Department, was put up to say that at that date, in March, 1935—that is to say, last March—we had a substantial superiority over Germany, and that in November of this year we should still have superiority. Only six weeks have passed since then, and surely we are entitled to ask what has happened to bring about the extraordinary change in the whole colour and configuration of the landscape? We are told that Herr Hitler made a statement to the Foreign Secretary at Berlin in the conversations, which it now seems were most fortunately undertaken, otherwise I suppose we should never have known. We have not always been accustomed to depend for our information upon statements, however frank and friendly, that may be made by Rulers of other States. My point is that all these statements that were made by the Lord President of the Council, and later, on behalf of the Government and under instructions from the Government, by the Under-Secretary for Air, are admitted to be untrue. I do not say that they were made in bad faith, but they were utterly wrong. They were the reverse of the truth, and more than the reverse of the truth. Certainly. If the Government statement was that we should be 50 per cent. stronger than Germany at a certain date and we find that they are 50 per cent. stronger than we are, it would be the reverse of the truth, and far worse than that. Is there a Member of the Government who will get up now and say that in November next we shall still have a 50 per cent. superiority over Germany? Is there a Member of the Government who will still

607

assert that in March last, six weeks ago, we had a substantial superiority, or that we have a superiority to-day? No, Sir. The whole of these assertions, made in the most sweeping manner and on the highest authority, are now admitted to be entirely wrong. We have had a confession from the Prime Minister to-day that the then estimates have been found to be below what is now understood to be the truth.

Look at the Press which supports the Government, great newspapers like the "Daily Telegraph" and the "Times," which are now making statements much more definite than I ventured to commit myself to six months ago. Let anyone who chooses read the statement in the "Times" to-day—a paper devoted to the cause of peace and particularly friendly to Germany, a strong supporter of the Government. It says:

German strength in first-line aircraft is assumed at present to be not less than 1,020, which is double the first-line strength of the Royal Air Force' including 171 aeroplanes of the Fleet Air Arm and 264 in units overseas. The strength of the British home defence force is 500 aeroplanes.

That is a very formidable assertion, and, as far as I know, it is quite correct. There is no doubt that to-day—I do not think it will be challenged at all from the Treasury Bench—the strength and scale of the German Air Force, whether judged by military machines or by first-line strength, as the saying goes, is at present already substantially superior in numbers to ours.

There is a second unpleasant chapter in this subject upon which I will merely, as it were, indicate the title and the contents. The German military machines have all been produced within the last 2½ years. Therefore they are of the latest design. An hon. Gentleman has just placed in my hands a telegram which has arrived and is published in one of the evening newspapers, in which General Goering says:

We have no old machines. Our planes are the most up-to-date in existence.

That statement has been newly printed in the evening Press. Many of our designs, on the other hand, are seven or eight years old. The average of our machines—these facts are perfectly well known; there is nothing in them that is not known, or I would not say it—is

608

certainly double in age to the designs which have been created in Germany. We are to have a debate on defence questions, and I hope that my hon. and gallant Friend the Member for the Isle of Thanet (Captain H. Balfour), who takes a great interest in this matter, and who spoke in the last Debate with much authority, and my hon. and gallant Friend the Member for Wallasey (Lieut.-Colonel Moore-Brabazon), who has made a study of this question, will illustrate the point, because it is one of very great gravity and interest. But I do not propose to go into it, as it is too technical for our Debate to-day. I do, however, say this to the Committee, and there is no dispute about it, it cannot be disputed, that both in numbers and in quality Germany has already obtained a marked superiority over our home defence Air Force.

But it is the third chapter of this story which is the most grievous. The rate and volume which the output of German military aeroplanes has attained is many times superior to our own. The Under-Secretary told us six weeks ago that the additions that would be made to our first line air strength, which was then thought sufficient, would be 151. There is reason to believe, as I said on that occasion, that the comparable German output of military machines is between, at least, 100 and 150 per month. Many people would put it much higher. The German air industry is therefore turning out military machines at perhaps ten times the rate at which ours are turned out, and those machines are being formed into squadrons for which long-trained, ardent personnel are already assembled, and for which an ample number of aerodromes are already prepared. Therefore, at the end of this year, when we were to have had a 50 per cent. superiority over Germany, they will be, at least, between three and four times as strong as we are.

Behind all this rapid peace time production lies the industry of Germany, fully organised for war manufacture and steadily tending in its character into the condition of war manufacture. This can be drawn upon at any time gradually and to any extent which they may choose. Where, then, is this pledge of air parity and that we would not accept any inferiority to whatever the German Air Force might be? The Prime Minister said

609

to-day that the Lord President's declaration stands. It stands only as a declaration. The facts do not support that assertion. It is absolutely certain that we have lost air parity already both in the number of machines and in their quality. It is certain that at the end of this year we shall be far worse off relatively than we are now. Our home defence force will be for a long period ahead a rapidly diminishing fraction of the German air force. It may reasonably be urged that the units of the German Air Force, having been prepared in conditions of secrecy, have not at the present time acquired the efficiency of our squadrons in air tactics and in formation flying. It is very dangerous to underrate German efficiency in any military matters. All my experience has taught me to think that any such supposition would be most imprudent. Anyhow, now that the Germans are openly marshalling and exercising their squadrons and forming them with great rapidity, we may take it that six months of this summer and autumn will amply give them the combined training which they require, having regard to the long, careful individual preparations which have been made, therefore any superiority which we may at this moment possess in personnel and in formation flying and in air manoeuvring is a wasting asset, and will be gone by the end of the autumn, having regard to the enormously increased German air strength and the superiority of their machines.

The Prime Minister in his article in the "News-Letter" used the word "ambush." The word must have sprung from the anxieties of his heart, for it is an ambush into which, in spite of every warning, we have fallen. I have stated the position in general terms and I have tried to state it not only moderately but quite frigidly. Here I pause to ask the Committee to consider what these facts mean and what their consequence impose. I confess that words fail me. In the year 1708 Mr. Secretary St. John, by a calculated Ministerial indiscretion, revealed to the House the fact that the battle of Almanza had been lost in the previous summer because only 8,000 English troops were actually in Spain out of the 29,000 that had been voted by the House of Commons for this service. When he made that revelation it is recorded that the House sat in silence for half an hour, no Member

610

caring to speak or wishing to make a comment upon so staggering an announcement, and yet how incomparably small that event was to what we have now to face. That was merely a frustration of policy. Nothing that could happen to Spain in that war could possibly have contained in it any form of dangers which were potentially mortal.

But what is our position to-day? For many months, perhaps for several years, most critical for the peace of Europe, we are inexorably condemned to be in a position of frightful weakness. If Germany were the only Power with which we were concerned, if we stood alone compared with Germany, and if there were no other great countries in Europe who share our anxieties and dangers and our point of view, and if air warfare were the only kind of warfare by which the destinies of nations was decided, we should then have to recognise that this country, which seemed so safe and strong a few years ago, which bore with unconquerable strength all the strains and shocks of the great War, which has guarded its homeland and its independence for so many centuries, would lie at the discretion of men now governing a foriegn country. There are, however, friendly nations with whom we may concert our measures of air defence, and there are other factors, military and naval, of which in combination we can dispose. Under the grim panoply which Germany has so rapidly assumed there may be all kinds of stresses and weaknesses, economic, political and social which are not apparent, but upon which we should not rest ourselves.

It seems undoubted that there is an effective policy open to us at the present time by which we may preserve both our safety and our freedom. Never must we despair, never must we give in, but we must face facts and draw true conclusions from them. The policy of detachment or isolation about which we have heard so much and which in many ways is so attractive, is no longer open. If we were to turn our backs upon Europe thereby alienating every friend, we should by disinteresting ourselves in their fate invite them to disinterest themselves in ours. Is it then expected that we can go off with a wallet full of German Colonies gathered in the last war and a world-wide collection of territories and

611

trade interests gathered in the past, when the greatness of our country was being built up, when all the time we should in this vital matter of air defence be condemned to protracted, indefinite and agonising inferiority? Such a plan has only to be stated to be rejected.

There is a wide measure of agreement in the House to-night, and our foreign policy has made it so. We are bound to act in concert with France and Italy and other Powers, great and small, who are anxious to preserve peace. I would not refuse the co-operation of any Government which plainly conformed to that test as long as they were willing to work under the authority and sanction of the League of Nations. Such a policy is not to close the door upon a revision of the Treaty, but it does procure a sense of responsibility and stability, an adequate gathering together of all reasonable Powers for self-defence, which must be assembled before any inquiry of that character can be entered upon. In this august association for collective security we must build up defence forces of all kinds and combine air action with those of friendly Powers, so that we may be allowed to live in quiet ourselves and retrieve the woeful miscalculations of which we are at present the dupes and of which, unless we are warned in time, we may some day be the victims.