Foreign Office.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament

10 July 1933 · House of Commons debate · House of Commons, Palace of Westminster, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill, a backbench Member, addressed the House of Commons in London on July 10, 1933, during a Foreign Office debate, welcoming America's departure from gold and urging the Government to organise a sterling bloc and raise prices.
Main themes
United States abandonment of the gold standard, World Monetary and Economic Conference, revaluation of commodity prices to 1928 levels, the sterling convoy, the gold bloc, strength of sterling and London as financial centre, burden of taxation and the Budget, war debts and fixed charges, unemployment, Roosevelt's refusal of currency stabilisation
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,917
85th percentile
Sentences
131
75th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
14.5
72nd percentile
Syntax
3.39
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
39th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 77%73%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

131 sentences in 35 paragraphs

My right hon. Friend the Chancellor of the Exchequer evidently did not feel it right to tell us anything new this afternoon, nor to admit us more closely into the grave problems which are now dominating the minds of the Members of His Majesty's Government. I do not think we could blame him for that because of the immense responsibility which attaches to the action of the representatives of Great Britain at the present time and the possibility that later on—perhaps a little later on—they would see more clearly exactly in what direction to move and would be able to make us a full, or at any rate, a much fuller statement than what we have already received. Therefore, I do not at all take occasion to complain. I merely note the fact that so far we have been

782

told only what I may call the articulations of the conference, and no new light has been thrown upon the purposes of His Majesty's Government. I do not think that the same conditions of silence and reticence are necessarily imposed upon private Members, and, indeed, it is a good thing, I think, that we should ventilate this subject and bring House of Commons opinion into focus upon it when the proper occasion arises, as it has this afternoon. But I speak upon it with the very greatest diffidence because, as the speech of the right hon. Gentleman the Leader of the Opposition has shown, it is a very complicated and difficult subject, and one in which one might easily lose one's way while all the time seeming to proceed along extremely promising and attractive avenues.

A year ago I ventured to suggest to His Majesty's Government that they should call an international conference on the monetary problem with a view to arresting the deflation, and I had in mind, as I said hopefully on another occasion, that the object which we should set before ourselves should be the effective revaluation of commodities up to something like the values of 1928. A year ago the world was divided between gold countries and non-gold countries and the United States led the gold countries. It seemed to me when I made this suggestion that, if the United States could be persuaded to detach herself from the gold countries and embark upon a policy of revaluation, it would become much easier and much safer for Great Britain as the leader of the sterling countries to raise wholesale commodity prices. After all, the great obstacle to price expansion a year ago was the formidable power and authority of the United States ranged behind the Gold Standard, and in that enforcing of deflation inevitably associated with the Gold Standard under the present conditions of gold hoarding. It was very difficult for us to move with any effect while the United States adhered so rigidly, so firmly and so authoritatively to that position. Very large purchases had to be made by us across the exchange every year, and the movement of our exchange in relation to the United States was one of the very serious factors we should have had to consider.

If the United States proved obdurate in her adherence to gold, it seemed a year ago that there was nothing for us but to

783

go with what we then called the sterling convoy and steam at a pace which would encourage the largest number of countries to join the convoy and enable them to keep continuous station in it, and then the world would have ranged itself definitely into two great monetary and trading groups, as it then seemed, of almost equal power. Within each group all transactions would become increasingly easy, but between these two groups all transactions and all payments would become increasingly difficult, and we should have had—there seemed to be no alternative open—the evil of two vast rival monetary and economic worlds each of which believed that it was being ruined by the other—the gold countries believing that they were being defrauded of the debts which were due to them and undercut by the depreciated exchanges of their debtors, and the sterling countries believing that the gold bloc were enforcing a policy of deflation upon the whole world with a view to enhancing the enormous masses of gold which they had hoarded in the unfortunate period preceding these world disturbances. It seemed, therefore, that there was no outcome from such a state of affairs except the wholesale repudiation of debts by sterling countries to gold countries, and the freezing up of all the exports of gold countries to non-gold countries.

That was the situation, and of the two groups I had myself no doubt, although they seemed so evenly balanced, that the sterling group would in the end prove much the stronger, even although the United States was on the other side. The sterling group, comprising as it did then almost the whole of the British Empire, and as it does now the whole of the British Empire, together with many powerful Continental countries, seemed to have the stronger position as between these two great spheres into which the world threatened to divide itself. But great friction and tension lay ahead, and a new arbitrary cleavage was opening in the world to international trade, in addition to all those other cleavages which we have known so far. I thought, therefore, that we should do our best to detach the United States from the gold bloc before we began consciously organising the sterling convoy and reconciled ourselves

784

to the somewhat gloomy prospect I have ventured to outline.

I did not a year ago regard this as hopeless, because it was so evident to anyone who travelled about the United States, as I had recently done, that that great country was strangling itself both in respect to external and internal trade by its rigid adherence to the Gold Standard and to hoarded gold. On the other hand, when we remember how the gold obligation was soldered into the fabric of so many of the greatest American undertakings and how it was enshrined in the domestic law of the United States, with our minds dwelling upon a thousand million pounds worth of gold, including so many of our vanished British sovereigns, which had been solemnly buried in the vaults beneath the Federal Reserve Bank, when we thought of all that, it seemed that the hope that the United States would be induced to detach herself from gold and come and join the freer area outside the Gold Standard, was at any rate rather a forlorn hope. Still there was a possibility of a world conference. There was a possibility of the facts telling their own tale. In that interval there was the possibility of intimate conversations between representatives of Great British—which have taken place—and the United States, and one hoped that that result might be achieved.

But what has happened? The result which I had in my mind as the most hopeful that could be sought for has achieved itself. It achieved itself before the Conference ever met, freely, voluntarily, without pressure from us or bargain with us; the United States has repudiated gold. It has abandoned the leadership of the gold countries, and it is now resolutely and hopefully engaged in that very process of revaluating commodities up to the prices say, of 1926, or, it may be, 1928 or thereabouts. As far as I am concerned, while making every excuse and apology to the House for forming an opinion upon these extraordinarily complicated matters which have, nevertheless, forced themselves upon us, revaluation to the figures of 1928 was a result which I had always regarded as of paramount importance and desirability. I say "1928 or thereabouts," because, although there are many who share hopes, everyone knows also the danger of the experi-

785

ment upon which President Roosevelt has so courageously launched himself and his country.

If anyone had told us a year ago that the United States would join Great Britain in abandoning gold we should have thought him far too sanguine; we should have thought him a builder of air castles whose expectations were his desires and whose wishes were his beliefs. The tremendous event has happened. We get every day in the newspapers headlines of equal size, and therefore we are sometimes apt to overlook the fact that they deal now and again with matters of vast and dominating importance, and at other times with purely frivolous or trivial topics. But the great event of the United States going off gold—a greater event than our departure from that standard—has happened, and I for one frankly rejoice.

Let me submit to the Committee—and I do not intend keeping it long this afternoon—that I really would speak with great trepidation upon these matters, because, without contact with the technical experts and without the great knowledge in possession of the Government, it is very difficult to do more than express a tentative view, and that I intend to do. It seems to me that the following results have followed from the decision of the United States which are all satisfactory and beneficial to us, or may be later. First of all, there is the gold bloc. What is called the gold bloc—we are getting into a new terminology upon this matter very rightly—rests upon American support. Confronted to a certain extent with a measure of American antagonism it becomes incomparably weaker as a world force. We no longer have the two equal forces. The changed use of this enormous power has altered altogether the proportion as between the gold and the non-gold countries. The countries of the gold bloc play nothing like the part in the world's business and production as do the non-gold countries, nor do they possess their vast and varied territory and their immense reserves of raw material. We must certainly do nothing apart from what is in our own interests. We cannot deflect from our own proper policy, but apart from that we must do nothing to embarrass or hamper the countries who decide to remain upon gold and to adhere to that,

786

but I must say that I think it is extremely doubtful, whatever we do, whether they will be able to adhere to this system now that the United States has changed sides. I do not believe that any steps which we could take—and I hope that we shall take no steps which are to our own disadvantage—would alter at all the outcome of events. Let me say parenthetically, but, I hope, in the most inoffensive terms, that these gold countries have really no grounds for reproaching either the United States or Great Britain.

I am tired of hearing these claims to superior virtue and integrity attached to the Gold Standard countries; to countries which have already like France devalued to the extent of four-fifths of their indebtedness, or countries like Germany which has destroyed its entire rentier class, relieved itself of all fixed charges and is not paying either its public or private debts. I am unfeignedly glad that there is no danger now, or very much less danger, of the creation of a crystallisation of two economic and monetary worlds. There is no danger—to borrow a word from a much more thorny controversy—of a monetary diarchy in the world as between two equally established and equally large parties. The liberation of all currencies from gold is a possibility which must certainly be taken into account for the future. That is a great event, a prodigious event, if we look back to the position where we stood last year. Hitherto, we have had to consider the case of particular countries one at a time quitting the Gold Standard, or to groups of countries departing from it, but if all the countries depart from gold for the time being—I say only for the time being—an entirely new and by no means necessarily unhopeful situation will be created. Through the period of general flux we might reach the solution, or a solution, a far better solution of this problem than anything that has been in our power so far.

It is in relation to this possibility of the non-gold area being enlarged until it is almost universal that the second beneficial effect of what has taken place arises. In such circumstances it seems to me, looking at it from the British point of view, that the prestige and influence of sterling must become enormously enhanced and that consequently the position of London as the

787

financial centre of the world will become even more secure. We in this island have shown, both before and after the abandonment of the Gold Standard, that we can manage a currency detached from gold, and manage it with sober and sedate self-control. The United States have yet to prove that, having escaped from the gold hoarder, they may not fall a victim to the paper speculator. I trust that they will succeed. Every one of us must hope and pray that this valiant experiment will succeed. They are pioneers, they are in a pioneer position, and the consequence of their failure will strike a note of despair throughout the world. I hope that they will succeed, but, succeed or fail, it seems to me very likely that once gold has been dethroned, sterling will become the world's most trustworthy measure. Already in these circumstances, for one year we have had two rival systems at work, and we have heard the expression: "It was not sterling that went off gold, but it was gold that went off sterling," and there was some considerable measure of truth behind it. How much more will the strength and solidity of sterling be apparent when gold is nowhere set up as an anchor in any part of the world. It is a great responsibility for us that this should happen, but it is also a very great opportunity, and it is an opportunity which has come to us in conditions when we have a stable Government in this country possessed of enormous powers to deal with any situation which may arise. I hope that it will not be found unequal to that opportunity should it arise.

The third result of what has happened in the United States has been to remove a barrier which has hitherto prevented us from carrying out the declared policy of the Chancellor of the Exchequer of raising the wholesale price level. I hope the removal of that barrier means an endeavour on his part to raise the prices up to at least the level of 1928. We have been told hitherto that we could not do this because other nations, especially the United States, were wedded to gold, but now that divorce has become so common, almost universal, it may be found that we in these islands have regained our freedom too. For all these reasons, I rejoice—and I do not think the right hon. Gentle-

788

man would shed many tears over it—in the action of the United States in quitting the Gold Standard. I am sorry for the World Conference because no doubt it has lost a very great part of its original purpose. The biggest thing it could do had been done before it met. But there is plenty more work, as my right hon. Friend has shown, of the utmost importance for the World Conference to do. Anyhow, conferences exist for men and not men for conferences. I trust that the Government will keep the Conference in being. It is of the utmost importance that it should be continued in existence during the unforeseeable and not by any means unhopeful conditions which the next few months may bring about. If some nations go I hope, and I gathered so from my right hon. Friend, that His Majesty's Government will remain with others, keeping the others together. So long as the United States representatives remain in this country very few countries in the world can afford to absent themselves permanently from deliberations which at any time may assume the most decisive character.

I do not at all share, as an outsider, the naive astonishment with which some Members of the Government received the refusal of the United States to agree to a temporary price stabilisation of currency. I agree with the quotation read from President Roosevelt's speech during May, but how anyone watching the changes that had occurred in the interval could have imagined that Mr. Roosevelt, on the morrow of taking his tremendous plunge, and in the full tide of his successful experiment, having just severed his country from gold and launched himself on a revaluation of commodities, would agree to tie it all up again to gold, out of love for France, is quite beyond human comprehension. I agree with Professor Gustav Cassel, whose extraordinarily pregnant and suggestive statements have appeared from time to time during the last few years, that merely to tie up currencies even temporarily to hoarded gold--it is not gold, remember, but it is hoarded gold that you are invited to tie yourselves to at various ratios—would be no solution of the world's difficulties and certainly should not be attempted until the desired revaluation of commodities has actually been achieved.

789

I have indicated, I hope in language which is sufficiently vague not to fall into technical inaccuracies—we must all be particularly careful—my view, which I have sincerely held during the last 18 months while we have been compelled to address ourselves to this awful topic. Let me ask the Government what is the alternative to a real effort to revalue commodities. Now that the United States has joined the Latin countries and Germany in post-War devalorisation of their currency, we shall if we do nothing—I admit that we have done something—be the only Power which has not written off or written down past obligations at least to the level at which they were contracted, and we shall find ourselves alone in a competitive world crushed under a unique burden of debt and fixed charges, of which our rivals have freed themselves, burdens which will increase with every effort we make to reduce them and with every failure to arrest the fall in prices, while all the time our rivals will have relieved themselves in varying degrees. We shall be the only country where, above all others, the new wealth produced each year by the enterprise and toil of man is penalised to an unfair and destructive extent in comparison with the old wealth of past accumulations. We shall be the only country to assert and enforce the rights of creditors far beyond their original contractual equities, and by so doing if we go on indefinitely upon such a course with a falling price level, we may well bring about the ruin of that very rentier class who have been made usurers against their will, and without their knowledge to a very large extent, by the movement of monetary affairs, and whose lawful rights can only he guarded and guaranteed when founded upon justice, reason and public advantage.

Let the Government consider also the paralysing burden of taxation and the precarious balance of the Budget. We are incomparably the heaviest taxed people in the world. How can we expect a real revival—I rejoice in the signs of improvement which are shown, and it is no good part to minimise them—while we remain with a burden of taxation unparalleled in the past and crushing in its actual effect? While we proceed on the present lines I see absolutely no hope of any mitigation of the burdens of taxation. My right hon. Friend the Chan-

790

cellor of the Exchequer has used up every conceivable resource merely to pay his way, and it is even doubtful whether he will succeed in paying his way. Very severe and much resented economies have been enforced and no others of a substantial character are now in prospect. All the yield of the tariff, the enormous yield, which has come to our aid, has been absorbed. All the savings of the skilful conversion, £20,000,000 or £30,000,000, have been absorbed. All the saving in not providing for the payment of the American Debt has been absorbed, because it was not included. All the relief of raising the entire Sinking Fund has been swallowed up, and still the balance trembles doubtfully. The explanations are only too plain. The burden of providing more than £120,000,000 a year, as we are bound to do, for 2,000,000 or 3,000,000 unemployed, has cut down the revenue at the same time that excessive taxation is drying up its sources. If a successful policy of price raising and wage raising, at the moment when the price raising had been effected, were adopted, the new wealth would he replaced in fair relation to the old.

You cannot measure by what unseen channels stimulus will come to your industries throughout the land. The burden of debt in relation to new production and to figures of revenue would also be reduced. Lighter taxation would liberate enterprise. Thousands of businesses which now make no profits at all, although they are still carrying on—a matter which was brought before me when I was Chancellor of the Exchequer—which are at present withdrawn from the tax collecting area, would come again into the revenue production area to the relief of the Chancellor of the Exchequer. You may get from lower rates of taxation, I will not say the same yield but, proportionately, a much higher yield than you get from destructive rates of taxation. Lastly, there would be a further reduction in unemployment, the most blessed economy of all, from which future Chancellors of the Exchequer alone can expect to have effective relief.

It seems to me that the course of His Majesty's Government is clear. Although they are absolutely right in not being precipitate and in watching carefully the moment at which to act, no doubt, they are justified in keeping their own counsel,

791

as they certainly have done, I trust that this course, which is clear, is one upon which they will resolutely set forth. It seems to me that they should now proceed, or at the best moment proceed, to organise and guide a sterling convoy, in the centre of which lies the whole of the British Empire, upon a set plan of controlled revaluation; endeavour to raise prices in relation to sterling as far and as much as they can without losing touch with the Dominions and foreign countries who are keeping company with us. It is safe enough. The American navy has come over, as they did in the Great War, and although separate from us is steaming along the same course. It may be that it is steaming at undue speed considering the unchartered seas through which we are all passing, but there is no more risk of a direct monetary collision or confict between sterling and the United States of America. We ought, I think, to follow their general movement at a prudent distance, with every possible precaution which is open to experienced navigators, and with that thought for the common interest imperative on those who move in large associations. It may well be that the whole armada will be united at no distant date, and will move forward together in one majestic array and at one uniform speed.