- Context
- Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on July 19, 1938, during a debate on privilege, arguing that a mistaken reference to the Committee of Privileges had produced a miscarriage of censure against a Military Court.
- Main themes
- Breach of privilege against Duncan Sandys, erroneous reference to the Committee of Privileges, Motion of 29 June 1938, summoning of a Member before a Military Court, Speaker's statement on procedural discrepancy, Committee of Privileges report, responsibility of the Secretary of State for War, injustice to the Military Court of Inquiry, Speaker's ruling of 11 July, accuracy of Sandys's complaint
- Duration
- ~7 min
- Words
- 899
- Sentences
- 34
- Readability
- 53
- Grade
- 12.2
- Syntax
- 3.07
- Vocabulary
- 2.22
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other34 sentences in 10 paragraphs
I share the wish and the hope of the Prime Minister that we shall be able to continue to act unitedly as a House of Commons in the further stages of this affair. Nevertheless a certain number of serious points have emerged up to the present time, which in my opinion should be very clearly in the minds of the House and should be brought to their minds upon this occasion. In your statement yesterday, Mr. Speaker, you spoke of a discrepancy upon technical points of procedure for which you assumed responsibility. I need scarcely say that it is with the utmost respect and in no spirit of criticism that
2027
I feel obliged to point out that these discrepancies in technical procedure led to very important and inconvenient consequences. It is, therefore, necessary for us to understand exactly what they were. Originally the Motion of the Prime Minister which was passed by the House on 29th June was:
That the matter of the complaint be referred to the Committee of Privileges.
I have no doubt with the best will in the world that Motion was altered in the sense of being defined at the Table, or in the OFFICIAL REPORT. In defining the reference, no doubt a process which, as it were, claimed attention, the reference ceased to be general. It became precise, it became limited and it became wrong. I am very glad there is a general agreement that my hon. Friend the Member for Norwood (Mr. Sandys) in no way misstated his case to the Chair and to the House. As the Leader of the Liberal party has pointed out, he did not complain of any order from or by a Military Court, but only of orders to appear before such Courts. It was not, as anyone can see, in the power of my hon. Friend, or of anyone not intimately acquainted with military procedure, to know whether those orders were on behalf of the Court or on behalf of a higher authority. His statement to the House was couched in terms which were strictly accurate, correct and complete in so far as they were needed to form the basis of the claim that a breach of Privilege had been committed. As you, Sir, observed yesterday:
The essence of the breach of Privilege was the summoning of a Member of this House before a Military Court in the circumstances detailed in the Report of the Committee of Privileges. Whether he was summoned by the officers composing the Court, or by another officer making the preliminary arrangements for the holding of the Court, is immaterial from the standpoint of Privilege."—[OFFICIAL. REPORT, 18th July, 1938; cols. 1816–17, Vol. 338.]
There has been, as hon. Members must know, a great deal of talk and discussion about this affair, and I think it is only bare justice to my hon. Friend that the House, at this point in the proceedings, should recognise that his statement was accurate and was complete in all that was relevant to the issue. However, when the Committee of Privileges met an hour later we found ourselves in the presence of the precise and mistaken definition of the complaint, which attributed the order to
2028
the Military Court. As may be seen from our Report—which is all that I am entitled to go upon here and was all that you Sir, were able to go upon—this new and erroneous reference governed all our proceedings. In fact the Prime Minister said as much to-day. The proceedings of the Committee of Privileges are, of course, confidential, but it is clear from this Report that all of us, Ministers and Private Members alike, accepted the basis of the new reference, and were not led to inquire beyond it, or to call evidence about it or correct it in any way. Hence the Report which we presented was vitiated throughout by the original error which came in as I have described.
When the Report came to be debated on 11th July, you, Sir, were forced to give a Ruling on it—I say "forced," in the sense of being confined within the limits of the Report which we had submitted and by the Rules of which you are the guardian and interpreter. You had nothing to go on but that Report, and in consequence you ruled—and I am certainly not challenging your Ruling in any way—that no reference could be made in the Debate to the responsibility of the Secretary of State for War and that the Committee of Privileges had, with whatever reservations they might make, "put the blame upon the Military Court of Inquiry." It was in those circumstances that the Debate was paralysed and that the House had no power either to correct the initial mistake or lay the breach of Privilege on the appropriate shoulders and, in fact, we were led—we must face the fact—into a miscarriage of censure which has done injustice to the Military Court who were literally, at that time, as innocent as a babe unborn. Against the injustice of this decision which we have taken, a protest has been made, the source of which has not been revealed to us, and that has been sufficient for you, Sir, to say conclusively, that no blame of any kind rests upon the Military Court. Now, Mr. Speaker, this is a very unfortunate catenation of events——
