Privileges.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament

19 July 1938 · House of Commons debate · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on July 19, 1938, in a debate on privileges, criticising an altered Committee of Privileges reference and ministers' failure to correct the Prime Minister's misapprehension.
Main themes
Committee of Privileges reference, altered terms of reference, procedural gap in formulating complaints, need for a general Ruling, Prime Minister's statement of 29 June 1938, Court of Inquiry and the Secretary of State for War, ministers' failure to correct the mistake, 11-day delay in informing the House, remittal to a Select Committee
Duration
~6 min
18th percentile
Words
661
18th percentile
Sentences
19
10th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
16.1
84th percentile
Syntax
3.70
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 79%79%
  • Ceremonial 21%21%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

19 sentences in 8 paragraphs

I hope there will be no attempt to interfere with discussion, otherwise my remarks may become more protracted and more controversial. This, as I say, is a very unfortunate chain of events, and it has led us all to absurd

2029

and wrong conclusions from which I fear, as far as the Committee of Privileges is concerned, we shall not ever be enabled to extricate ourselves. One must hope that such misfortunes will not occur again. I have been astonished, after a lifetime in this House, to find that it is possible for a reference to the Committee of Privileges, which has been approved of by the House, to be presented in a different form, which the House has not heard of and which subsequently governed the action of the Committee, and I hope that measures will be taken to make sure that no similar misunderstanding can arise in the future. It is a serious point of procedure, extending far beyond the limits of the present case, on which it seems to me, with very great respect, a further Ruling of a general character will be found necessary at a later stage.

I should like to direct the attention of the House to the fact that there is a gap between the general statement that a complaint should be referred to the Committee of Privileges and the process of formulating in intelligible and accurate terms what that complaint is, and there appears to be no machinery at present for doing it. But I agree with the Leader of the Opposition that an even more serious point arises from the failure of His Majesty's Ministers to put the mistake right. We were not allowed to discuss the matter freely on the former occasion, but we are entitled to press and submit this point to the House on the present occasion, and I think that is a more serious aspect than this accidental alteration of the reference. My right hon. Friend the Prime Minister was clearly under a complete misapprehension when he made the statement on 29th June, which has been partly quoted by the Leader of the Opposition and by the Leader of the Liberal party, as follows:

The Leader of the Opposition appears to think that the proceedings of this Court of Inquiry are somehow connected directly with instructions given to it by this Government. If so, that is a misunderstanding. I assume that for the setting up of the Court of Inquiry the Secretary of State for War is technically responsible, but in a case of this kind, w here there has been divulgence of information … it would be an automatic proceeding to set up a Court of Inquiry."—[OFFICIAL REPORT, 29th June, 1938; col. 1919, Vol. 337.]

One would not expect the Prime Minister himself to know the details of the military procedure, but one would expect the Department of State and the Secretary of

2030

State for War, with the resources of the War Office at his disposal, and the Attorney-General, who was studying the case with the closest attention, or other officers serving under them to lay the actual facts before the Prime Minister without delay, because, after all, 11 days, as has been pointed out, intervened between this Report of the Committee of Privileges being presented to the House and the Debate which took place in this House, and 12 days intervened between the statement which the Prime Minister made, in perfect good faith, and the matter being debated in the House. I must say that I consider that the House is bound to take cognisance of this matter at this stage. We are remitting these matters to the inquiry by a Select Committee, but we are entitled, in broad general terms, to say that we do not understand at the present time how it was that the Prime Minister, the House, and the Chair were left in ignorance of the facts for 11 long days.