- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on July 19, 1938, in a debate on privileges, criticising the handling of the Court of Inquiry and welcoming referral of the matter to a Select Committee.
- Main themes
- Court of Inquiry and War Office instructions, ministerial responsibility of the Secretary of State for War, Manual of Military Law, Committee of Privileges, Speaker's ruling and free debate, Prime Minister's statement on the Court of Inquiry, accountability of the House of Commons, referral to the Select Committee, rearmament, press and public interest in the affair
- Duration
- ~9 min
- Words
- 1,094
- Sentences
- 42
- Readability
- 57
- Grade
- 11.6
- Syntax
- 3.15
- Vocabulary
- 2.07
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other42 sentences in 14 paragraphs
I say exactly what the Prime Minister said on that matter. We all accepted the general point of view when it was put before us, and no doubt we are blameworthy for accepting that point of view, but, as my hon. and gallant Friend has challenged me on this matter, I must say that it is inconceivable to me that the facts should not have been known at the time. Take the Prime Minister's statement:
The Leader of the Opposition appears to think that the proceedings of this Court of Inquiry are somehow connected directly with instructions given to it by this Government. If so, that is a misunderstanding.
Why, Sir, the Manual of Military Law, on page 688, says distinctly:
2031
The Court will be guided by the written instructions of the authority who assembled the Court. The instructions will be full and specific, and will state the general character of the information required.
Are we to assume that a letter of instruction was issued from the War Office, through the various military commands, for the guidance of this Court of Inquiry, without my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State ever having been made aware of it, and, that, in a matter of this Parliamentary importance, he did not know of it? If it was never brought to his attention, it appears that he has been ill-served, and if it was brought to his attention, I think the Prime Minister has been ill-served, and we also. The House will remember that I protested in the last Debate, as far as I possibly could, against the view that the War Office was a blind, automatic machine in matters of this kind, and I argued that a real and effective responsibility rested upon the higher authorities and suggested that this real responsibility was implied by exhaustion in the words of our Report without making any reflection upon the Military Court.
All that I got for that was a tart insinuation from the Chancellor of the Exchequer that I was making "a covert slap" at the Secretary of State for War. I assure the House there is nothing covert about my methods. They are perfectly open. It has also been said, I think by the Prime Minister now, that if the Secretary of State had risen, he would have been out of order, but I have yet to learn that, if a Minister of the Crown wished to make a personal explanation of this character, when the House was evidently going wrong and when the House was evidently being led to throw blame on innocent parties, such an intervention would not have been permitted by the Chair, or that the House would not have granted the indulgence which would have been asked of it; and I must say that in these 11 days that followed it seems to me that it was due to you, Sir, that the facts should be placed before you. I have no doubt the Prime Minister would have done so if he had known.
In my view, the Chair has received ill usage in this matter, all of which could have been avoided, and very easily avoided. The precedents for the Chair waiving a Ruling which it has given about what is or is not in order in a Debate,
2032
in response to the general wish of the House, are numberless, and I am certain that if the Prime Minister had only known the facts, he would have joined with the Leaders of the two Opposition parties in asking that the House should be perfectly free to debate this matter. This would have saved a great deal of time, the Debate would have been a natural and a normal Debate, the blame would have been put where it may be thought to reside, the House would not have been misled, and we should not have to be debating this matter again to-day. Free debate is a cleansing process, and I believe it is also a process which curtails discussion.
We hear a great deal about the time that is being wasted upon this affair, but that is certainly not our fault. I do not know whether it is being wasted, provided that it inculcates valuable lessons for the future. We are told that the House and still more the country are sick and tired of this matter. As to the country, we have to take that from the Press, some of whose organs have a necessity for providing new topics at least every few days, but the House of Commons must not be wearied in pursuing its themes. It must persevere and persist, and it must enforce accountability, as was done in days of old. Anyone looking around the House can see how utterly bored and sick and deficient in interest the Members are in the whole of this matter, how they are all longing to get away from it to more important topics—great issues of agriculture or of unemployment—on which during long hours this Chamber will be lamentably empty. I do not agree with those who say, "Cut the cackle and get on with the job." Why, Sir, it was about trying to make people get on with the job of rearming that all this cackle started, and it is about that that the cackle will proceed.
I must say that I, personally, rather regret that my right hon. Friend has not himself proposed to refer this matter back to the Committee of Privileges. That, I believe, would have been the best, the most natural, and the shortest course. I am sure, as a member of the Committee, that my right hon. Friend owed it to his colleagues on that Committee to secure for themselves an opportunity of putting themselves right with the House and with its records. Nevertheless, I welcome what was said by the Leader of the Opposition. I think it would be a disaster and
2033
an unfortunate incident if this Motion were pressed to a Division. It might almost seem as if some Members would be voting against the guidence which you have given us from the Chair. I myself should certainly not be able to vote against that guidance. The Debate has clarified matters. We now have for the first time a definite instruction to the Select Committee to examine these matters in detail, and I am content, with other Members, to await the Report of that Committee before attempting to form a final judgment upon the behaviour of the various parties concerned.
