Privileges.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

11 July 1938 · House of Commons debate on the Report of the Committee of Privileges · House of Commons, Palace of Westminster, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on July 11, 1938, in the debate on the Committee of Privileges report, supporting its finding of a breach of privilege while doubting the blame placed on the Military Court.
Main themes
Breach of parliamentary privilege, Report of the Committee of Privileges, obstruction and molestation of a Member, summons before a military court, Select Committee inquiry, words disclaiming reflection on the Military Court, responsibility of the War Office, respect of army officers for Parliament, Prime Minister's Motion, precedent in parliamentary history
Duration
~10 min
37th percentile
Words
1,259
37th percentile
Sentences
48
31st percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.14
65th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 90%90%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

48 sentences in 14 paragraphs

I came to the House this afternoon not at all expecting that any controversial matter would be introduced into our discussion. I am still disposed to make a very few observations, mainly of a laudatory character on our Ministers, our institutions and, generally, on the way in which this Privilege affair—I am keeping very strictly within the limits of the topics that we can discuss—has been conducted. Except in one respect, which I shall come to later on, which has newly dawned upon my conscience, I am in hearty accord with the Report of the Committee of Privileges, which I understand it is in order for us to debate. I feel that we owe a debt to our chairman, the Prime Minister, for having led us unanimously to this conclusion. The technical grounds of this breach of Privilege are clear. The hon. Member for Dundee (Mr. Foot) has pointed them out. A Member of this House while preoccupied with the duty to attend before a Select Committee, of which the Prime Minister had already given notice, was summoned to appear before an inferior court upon the same subject or upon matters cognate to that subject. He was, therefore, in a Parliamentary sense obstructed in the performance of his Parliamentary duties.

In the old precedents, resolutions and rulings on this subject which we have had the advantage of having had placed before us by the officers of the House, the word "molestation" occurs several times, and it seems to me that the word "molestation" is very relevant to the issues which have been raised. Obstruction and molestation are the technical grounds upon which this breach of Privilege has been claimed. The Committee of Privileges has declared that a breach has been committed, and if the House accept the Prime Minister's Motion, which I can hardly doubt—it would be a great misfortune if the House were to differ from it—this assertion of Privilege for which, as the Prime Minister said, no exact precedent can be found in the records of several hundreds of years, will become a milestone, or at least a furlong stone, in our Parliamentary history. It is the revival and

977

the reassertion of a basis of custom which lay latent in the Privileges of this House, and which have now been brought out upon a modern instance into active and vigorous effect.

I readily agree, however, with those who think that these technical grounds ought not to have been invoked unless the circumstances of this particular case were both substantial and grievous. It is not every day that Parliament is called upon to take notice of everything that happens. Many things in the ordinary course may take place and Parliament may not take care to notice them, but it was the surrounding facts of this case that made it necessary to assert the technical position. It is not necessary to labour those surrounding facts, because we are agreed upon them; the Committee of Privileges were agreed upon them. There is no question that those facts made the technical breach one which required to be marked. It is enough to say that when the House of Commons has been asked by the Prime Minister to set up a Select Committee to inquire into a particular matter other parallel and simultaneous inquiries are inopportune and objectionable. When a Member of this House has to go before a Select Committee upon a question as to whether he should or should not answer a specific question, it cannot be tolerated that an inferior tribunal should hale him before them and ask him the same question upon the propriety of putting which the House is about to deliberate. I agree entirely with the Prime Minister that we are not laying down a general principle, but we are interpreting a principle lying in the general body of Privilege and interpreting it in relation to the actual facts of this case, which are obviously plain.

Now I come to the only point on which I feel some newly awakened doubts about this report, to which I have agreed. I refer particularly to the words, to which I agreed, without making any reflection upon the Military Court.

It may well be asked, ought we to have agreed to such a statement? Here is a breach of Privilege. Can a breach of Privilege be launched out without any objective upon which it can alight? Therefore, it seems to me that one may be asked, "Why did you agree to writing these words,"

978

without making any reflection upon the Military Court.

I can only say in reply to that question and as some justification that my first reason was that I did not think the Military Court were to blame. It seemed to me that it would be very hard to censure these officers and bring them to the Bar, or take any action against them, as officers of the court, because they were only doing their duty. They were only obeying orders. What a terrible position those officers were placed in. On the one hand they commit a breach of Privilege, on the other hand a breach of discipline. I certainly had no desire or intention to put blame upon the Military Court, and I was surprised to hear that that is the way in which the report was read. I was glad when it was proposed to add the words that we were not making any reflection upon the Military Court.

I have never in my experience, including several years at the War Office, supposed that these courts were responsible bodies in themselves, with no higher body behind. I never supposed that the War Office itself was an automatic machine, which rolled forward blindly, senselessly, without taking any notice of what was going on. I have never for a moment imagined that such a situation could arise that a court of this kind would go forth all on its own, pushing on remorselessly, without the slightest responsibility attaching to anybody else. I must say that some of the statements which have been made to-day do create a new situation in respect of military courts, a situation not at all foreseen and certainly a situation which very few people imagined existed up to the present time. One always expected that these courts, not of course in the opinions they express upon matters, but in the dates of their sitting, the times of their sitting, were controlled and regulated for the public interest and convenience and in accordance with decorum, by the military authorities, at the head of whom there ranks a politician to whom it is not in order to refer to-day. Later on, perhaps, we may have an opportunity of doing so.

I am bound to say that I feel great misgiving about throwing the blame, as we are now told we have thrown the blame, upon this Military Court. The Court had no choice. These military men are, in my opinion, the last people who would wish to show disrespect to the House.

979

Ever since the days of Lord Wolseley and Sir Evelyn Wood, I have known, intimately high officers of the Army, and I have known officers of the class from whom the officers of this particular Court come, and I can assure the House that there is no set of men anywhere more respectful to Parliamentary authority and who would be less likely to set themselves up against the House of Commons, or wish to affront it in any way.