Announcement by the President of the Nation, Alberto Fernández, alongside the Minister of Public Works, Gabriel Katopodis, from Casa Rosada.

Argentina Alberto Fernández · President of Argentina

14 September 2022 · Announcement with Minister of Public Works Gabriel Katopodis · Casa Rosada

Context
Fernández announced at Casa Rosada the signing of a decree initiating legal action to annul the 2018 highway concession contracts for Buenos Aires' North and West Access routes.
Main themes
Highway concession contract annulment, lesivity action, North Access and West Access highways, Macri-era contract renegotiation, dollarization of contracts, unjustified debt to concessionary companies, extraordinary profitability guarantees, concession extension to 2030, harm to the National State and users, Ministry of Public Works legal action, toll scheme scandal
Duration
~17 min
56th percentile
Words
1,984
56th percentile
Sentences
47
30th percentile
Readability
31
18th percentile
Grade
19.3
97th percentile
Syntax
3.67
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
59th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%45%
  • Economic 38%38%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

47 sentences in 18 paragraphs

PRESIDENT.- Good afternoon everyone; we have come here, with Minister Katopodis, to announce that I have just signed a decree through which I instruct the Ministry of Public Works to initiate an action seeking the annulment of the concession contracts for the North Access and West Access highways. These are contracts that – in our opinion, and the minister will explain clearly – are completely distorting, which have caused enormous economic damage to the National State and fundamentally to the users. The action will be exercised, before the courts and the administrative contentious jurisdiction, by the Ministry of Public Works. I want the minister to explain in detail the reasons that explain this decision and then, in any case, I will resume or close this presentation. It is an action of lesivity because what we are verifying is that the contracts that were signed and authorized in 2018 were signed and ratified through two decrees in 2018, and were clearly disadvantageous for the National State, particularly for the users of the highways, and have caused enormous harm to the State. So I give the floor to the minister and then we will continue.

KATOPODIS.- Thank you very much, Mr. President. Well, basically, during 2018, the previous government, of former President Macri, issued two decrees (608 and 607) that renegotiated the concession and award contracts for two road corridors, the North Access and the West Access, in one case Ausol, and the other GCO Sociedad Anónima. In the framework of that renegotiation, carried out in 2018, a set of decisions, actions, and premises were established in that contract, with several issues that we understand, and after a meticulous legal analysis and the corresponding audits, we established as vices that determine the absolute nullity of that renegotiation.

First, because it established, without any justification, parameters, and without any objective basis, a debt in favor of the concessionary companies; a debt that was established, in the case of AUSOL, at 540 billion dollars and in the case of GCO Sociedad Anónima at 272 billion dollars; a total of 213.143 billion dollars. That debt – as I said – has no element or justification in the file that could be accredited and verified. The second issue we have observed is the dollarization of that contract, which was established in pesos and was so because a legal regulatory framework existed in Argentina that had dollarized all contracts, and also because the companies, in a renegotiation in 2006, had explicitly renounced the dollarization of these agreements, but in that renegotiation in 2018, the government of former President Macri granted them a dollarization of the contract, when there is no component in the contract that justifies that these contracts should be dollarized.

Thirdly, an annual adjustment of 8 percent was determined, which allows both companies to have extraordinary profitability; in any business, in any concession contract of this type, of course, there is no guaranteed profitability and what exists is business risk. Well, here these two companies were granted a privilege with a profitability in dollars, updated at 8 percent per year, which undoubtedly guaranteed them extraordinary profitability. And to complete that framework of decisions that for us constitutes a true scheme of tolls, it was determined that this debt would be paid over ten years with which the contract would be extended.

The concession contract, by law, was established to end in 2020, and in an absolutely arbitrary manner, it was determined to extend that concession contract until 2030, a contract that therefore, based on that, is in force, and that – in that period – what would be privileged was precisely the payment of the debt, the economic financial equation was modified in that 2018 renegotiation, privileging the payment and compensation of the companies' debt and postponing the works, improvements, and everything related to the central object of a concession contract.

In short, what was done was to transform a concession contract into a promissory note, a simple signature, a concession contract with concurrent responsibilities into a true payment agreement, so that was a debt that for us was absolutely unjustified, a dollarization of a contract without any element that justifies or substantiates the need to dollarize that contract, when all contracts in Argentina were dollarized, and the extension of the concession agreement was – in some way – the structure with which the government in 2018 ended up granting these companies an extraordinary privilege, an extraordinary profitability, and for us all this leads, as I said, to a scheme of tolls that is absolutely scandalous and that the President of the Nation has instructed me to initiate legal actions for the action of lesivity in the federal administrative contentious courts, which are the courts that correspond for justice to declare the lesivity and absolute nullity of this contract.

When one reviews in more detail the entirety of what was reestablished in that renegotiation, what one really finds is a renegotiation tailored to the companies, as it displaced the natural justice, the original court, which is the administrative contentious jurisdiction, and established that an arbitration court would define any situation of controversy. In addition, the obligation that any private entity contracting with the State has to exhaust administrative avenues in any claim was eliminated. And in that case, that obligation was also eliminated for the companies, allowing them to directly initiate and resolve those controversies in these arbitration courts.

We have clearly identified that throughout this operation and throughout this process, in the Ministry of Public Works and in National Highway Administration, there were officials who were on both sides of the counter, officials who held managerial positions in the private sector, in the concessionary companies, who then held important positions in National Highway Administration and then returned to those companies, clearly functioning in detail according to the instructions that, from the companies and from their former employers, were determining for them. The debt, which ultimately fell on the State and is now the responsibility of the State, had the bright idea that it would be all Argentines and all users who daily pass through the North Access and West Access highways who would pay the toll to meet that debt.

That is why the ten-year extension, that is why the dollarization of the contract, and that is also why a permanent request we received from the companies for a tariff increase, which this government, at the President's instruction, did not grant. They wanted the users of the tolls, the Argentines, to pay that debt that had been established daily. And in addition, the contract established that this compensation should be made by effect of the tariff framework or by effect of any administrative decision that aimed to complete the cancellation of that debt, that is, if the tariff increase was not sufficient, if the tariff framework was not sufficient, there should be administrative and budgetary decisions that could compensate, cancel, and comply with that situation. And in general, this renegotiation was presented at the time as imperative and urgent in the face of a complaint that supposedly the concessionaries had made in international courts, in the CIADI, and that a possible CIADI ruling could condemn Argentina and that, in any case, this was the remedy and the path that had to be taken to avoid greater evils or greater harm.

Well, the reality is that nowhere in the file, in none of the administrative proceedings is it accredited that there was a possible condemning sentence for the Argentine State; we have no doubt that this was a formal argument to justify and to be able to advance with a dark process, which was absolutely arbitrary and that generated and is generating a patrimonial harm for all Argentines.

PRESIDENT.- Thank you very much, Gabriel. You know that there is a case in the Federal Criminal Justice investigating, among other things, these contracts, which is the so-called toll case. I want to highlight and thank the enormous work done by the Ministry of Public Works and National Highway Administration over these two years, trying to verify whether what we are stating is correct. Indeed, it was correct. It is true, to this day we do not know what the amount of the debt was, we do not know why that debt was paid, we do not know why there was talk of an imminent outcome in the CIADI, of an incipient claim, which was at that time, what the concessionaries were making; The only thing we do know is that from all this resulted two contracts, two renegotiations of contracts, significantly advantageous for the concessionary companies and highly detrimental to the National State and particularly to the users.

As Gabriel rightly said, from day one we have pursued a policy aimed at ordering the system of the concessioned highways. We have recovered for the State 7,000 kilometers that were concessioned and are now managed by the State, with good results.

In these two cases, if we had allowed the contract in 2018 to be approved by the then National Executive, applied, just to give you an idea, someone who is currently a user of the Autopista del Sol, of the Panamericana, who pays around 100 pesos for the toll, would be paying 1,800 pesos, that is what would have happened if that contract had been applied as it was signed and ratified by the National Executive. We are talking about this dimension.

We have a clear perspective on two aspects, the first: that we are here to safeguard the interests of the users, in this case, of services subsidized by the State; and what we will not allow are abuses. It is not the first time we have taken this path, we did it with the Post Office, we did it with the public-private partnership contract; which were particularly onerous contracts for the State and which we were able to deactivate through a long negotiation, which cost the State nothing, but if executed would have been very harmful. Many of the works that were awarded to the public-private partnership were taken by the State and what we verified is that the State could do them with a 70% lower advantage, that is, the prices of the TTP were 70% more expensive, more onerous than what the State ended up doing the works for. We believe that this is a way to conduct the State.

The second aspect that we want to highlight is that we have to put a turning point and not allow more people to be on both sides of the counter, that in truth, we are here as public servants to defend the interests of the State and the people; and for that reason, we are asking the Justice to annul these contracts and we will surely ask them to provisionally return the administration of these roads to us, to continue, to prevent what are clearly leonine contracts to the detriment of the State from being perfected.

In truth, the best State is the one that is not foolish, the best State is the State that protects the heritage of all; the best State is the State that does not give advantages and allows someone to win a lot to the detriment of, in this case, the users of the highways.

In the coming days, we have already worked. I want to congratulate Gabriel for the work he did; It has been two careful years of pending audits to verify everything we are affirming today. Surely the lawsuit we present will be submitted as evidence to the criminal case, where it seems that they did not find the evidence that we found quite easily and what we will demand is that these things stop happening once and for all in the Argentine State.

We thank you for the time you have given us. Thank you very much.